Currencies

Highlights Oil prices are up strongly from their lows, but conditions for a durable bottom may not yet be in place. The main hiccup is that an air pocket will likely remain under global oil demand until most social-distancing measures are lifted. That said, most petrocurrencies offer a significant valuation cushion, making them attractive for longer-term investors. We will look to buy a basket of petrocurrencies on further weakness. The Asian economies that were closer to the epicenter of the epidemic are likely to recover faster than the West. Transport and electricity energy demand should pick up in these economies faster. AUD/CAD and AUD/EUR should benefit from this dynamic. CAD/USD is likely to weaken in the short term as Canadian crude remains trapped in Alberta, but then strengthen as the global economy recovers. Feature Chart I-1Massive Liquidation In Crude Oil Just over a decade ago, the price of crude oil was firmly above $100 per barrel. Fast forward to today and many blends are trading south of $20 (Chart I-1). The extraordinary drop has sent many petrocurrencies, including the Norwegian krone, Mexican peso, and Canadian dollar, into freefall. The oil industry has been hit by multiple tectonic shocks, including a sudden stop in economic activity, a fallout from the OPEC cartel, divestment from ESG funds, and falling oil intensity in many economies. Meanwhile, the trading of petrocurrencies is also complicated by a shifting production landscape among many oil producers. For investors, three key questions will determine whether petrocurrencies are a buy: Have we approached capitulation lows in oil prices? If so, what will be the velocity and magnitude of the demand recovery? Will the correlation between oil and petrocurrencies still hold once the dust settles? Have We Approached Capitulation Lows? In terms of magnitude and duration, yes. Over the last two decades, oil price drawdowns have tended to last between 8 and 20 months before a durable rally ensues. The oil price collapse from July 2008 to February 2009 lasted around 8 months. The decline from June 2014 to February 2016 was much longer, around 20 months. Given the October 2018 peak in oil prices, we should be very close to the bottom in terms of duration. Remarkably, in all episodes, the peak-to-trough decline in the West Texas Intermediate (WTI) blend has been around 75% (Chart I-2).   However, since the 1970s, oil has moved in a well-defined pattern of a 10-year bull market, followed by a 20-year bear market (Chart I-3). Assuming the bear market in oil began just after the global financial crisis, it does suggest that even if prices do recover, it will most likely be a bear-market rally. That said, history also suggests that these bear market rallies in oil can be quite powerful, with prices often doubling or trebling. As we go to press, oil prices are up a remarkable 18% from their lows Chart I-2Similar In Magnitude To Prior Oil Crashes Chart I-3Oil Prices Are Close To Capitulation Lows What is different this time? Aside from a breakdown in OPEC+, a few other factors are in play. This alters the timing and duration of an intermediate-term bottom: Any coordinated supply response will need to involve the US to be viable.1 The OPEC+ cartel, specifically the alliance between Russia and Saudi Arabia, is broken. Chart I-4 illustrates why. While being the stewards of global oil production discipline, there has been one sole benefactor – the US. In 2010, only about 6% of global crude output came from the US. Collectively, Canada, Norway and Mexico shared about 10% of the oil market. Meanwhile, OPEC’s market share sat just north of 40%. Fast forward to today and the US produces around 15% of global crude, having grabbed market share from many other countries. Chart I-4US Is The Big Winner From OPEC Cuts As we go to press, there are reports that Saudi Arabia and Russia have come to an agreement. However, the history of OPEC alliances suggests that it is fraught with broken promises.  Oil still trades above cash costs for many producing countries, meaning the incentive to boost production in times of a demand shock is quite strong (Chart I-5). Ditto if oil prices are recovering. Oil futures are in a massive contango, with WTI trading close to $40 per barrel two years out. This incentivizes players with strong balance sheets to keep the taps open. The oil curve needs to shift significantly lower, probably pushing some blends into negative spot territory, in order to force production discipline on some players.   Chart I-5Oil Still Trading Above Cost Of Production The dollar has been strong, meaning the local-currency revenues of oil producers have been cushioning part of the downdraft in oil prices. This could sustain production longer than would otherwise be the case, especially in a liquidation phase. The New York Fed’s model suggests that most of the downdraft in oil prices since 2010 has been due to rising supply (Chart I-6). Chart I-6Oil Downdraft Driven By Supply Both Saudi Arabia and Russia have low public debt and ample foreign exchange reserves. This buys them time in terms of dealing with a prolonged period of low prices. We know there will be massive economic pain from the oil price collapse (Chart I-7). The good news is that with the economic slowdown already in place, it may well be the catalyst needed to enforce any agreement put into effect. Chart I-7The Coming Economic Pain For Oil Producers While the positive correlation between oil prices and petrocurrencies has weakened in recent years, it has been re-established during the current downturn. More importantly, should production cuts be led by US shale producers, this will redistribute market share to OPEC and other non-OPEC members, allowing their currencies to benefit. Should production cuts be led by US shale producers, this will redistribute market share to OPEC and other non-OPEC members, allowing their currencies to benefit.  In statistical terms, petrocurrencies had a near-perfect positive correlation with oil around the time US production was about to take off (Chart I-8). Since then, that correlation has fallen from around 0.9 to about 0.3. Chart I-8Falling Correlation Between Petrocurrencies And The US Dollar Take the Mexican peso as an example. Since 2013, Mexico has become a net importer of oil, as the US moves towards becoming a net exporter (Chart I-9). This explains why the positive correlation between the peso and oil prices has weakened significantly in recent years. Put another way, rising oil prices benefit the US industrial base much more than in the past, while the benefits for countries like Canada and Mexico are slowly fading. Chart I-9A Shifting Export Landscape That said, in the case of Canada and Norway, petroleum still represents over 20% and 50% of total exports. For Russia, Saudi Arabia, Iran or Venezuela, the number is much higher. Therefore, it is easy to see why a big fluctuation in the price of oil can have deep repercussions for their external balances. Historically, getting the price of oil right was usually the most important step in any petrocurrency forecast. Bottom Line: Both the CAD and NOK remain positively correlated with oil. So do the Russian ruble and the Colombian peso. This correlation should remain in place if oil prices put in a definitive bottom, and it should strengthen if production cuts are led by the US. When Will Oil Demand Recover? Oil demand tends to follow the ebb and flow of the business cycle, with demand having slowed sharply on the back of a sudden stop in economic activity. Transport constitutes the largest share of global petroleum demand. Ergo the economic lockdowns have brought a lot of freighters, bulk ships, large crude carriers and heavy trucks to a halt. Encouragingly, passenger traffic in China has started to pick up as the number of new Covid-19 cases flattens, and the country is gradually reopening for business. There has also been an improvement in the manufacturing data. All eyes will be watching if the relaxation of measures in China lead to a second wave of infections. Otherwise, should the Western economies follow the Chinese recovery path, then the world will be open for business by the end of the summer (Chart I-10). One way to play an early restart in Asia relative to the West is to go long the Australian dollar, relative to a basket of the Canadian dollar and the euro.  Part of the slowdown in global demand is being reflected through elevated oil inventories. However, part of the inventory building has also been a function of refinery maintenance (Chart I-11). Chinese oil imports continue to hold up well, and should easier financial conditions continue to put a floor under the manufacturing cycle, overall consumption will follow suit. Chart I-10Some Optimism For The West Chart I-11Watch For A Peak In Inventories One way to play an early restart in Asia relative to the West is to go long the Australian dollar, relative to a basket of the Canadian dollar and the euro. There are three key reasons which support this trade: Liquefied natural gas will become the most important component of Australia’s export mix in the next few years (Chart I-12). As Beijing restarts its economy and electricity production picks up, Aussie exports will benefit. Beijing has a clear environmental push to shift its economy away from coal electricity generation and towards natural gas. The massive drop in pollution resulting from the shutdown will all but assure that this push occurs sooner rather than later. Chart I-12LNG Will Be A Game-Changer For Australia There was already pent-up demand in the Australian economy going into the crisis, given the destruction of the capital stock from the fires. With an economy that was already running well below capacity, construction activity should see a V-shaped rebound once social distancing measures are relaxed. As the currency of the now largest oil producer in the world, the US dollar is becoming a petrocurrency itself. In this new paradigm, a better strategy for playing oil upside is to be long a basket of energy producers versus energy consumers. AUD/EUR benefits from this. Chart I-13 shows that a currency basket of oil producers versus consumers has both had a strong positive correlation with the oil price and has outperformed a traditional petrocurrency basket. Rising oil prices are a terms-of-trade boost for oil exporters but lead to demand destruction for oil importers. Chart I-13Buy Oil Producers Versus Oil Consumers Eventually, a pickup in manufacturing activity will be a global phenomenon rather than localized within Asia. When this happens, other petrocurrencies will begin to benefit. This will especially be the case for producers where production is more landlocked. Bottom Line: A recovery in global transport will help revive oil demand. This should be positive for oil prices in general and petrocurrencies in particular. One way to play the recovery in Asia relative to the West for now is to go long AUD/CAD and AUD/EUR. On CAD, NOK, MXN, RUB And COP Chart I-14NOK Will Outperform CAD While Canadian crude is likely to remain trapped in the oil sands, North Sea crude will face less transportation bottlenecks in the near term. This suggests the path of least resistance for CAD/NOK is down (Chart I-14). We were stopped out of our short CAD/NOK trade, but still recommend this position as a play on this dynamic. We are already long the Norwegian krone versus a basket of the euro and dollar. CAD/USD has been displaying a series of higher lows since the March 18 bottom, but the double-top formation in place since then suggests we could see some weakness in the near term. Should CAD/USD retest its recent lows, driven by a relapse in oil prices, we will be buyers.  Many petrocurrencies, including the Mexican and Colombian pesos, have become quite cheap and are attractive on a longer-term basis (Chart I-15). Given the uncertainty surrounding the nearer-term outlook, we a placing a limit buy on a broad basket of these currencies at -5%. Should oil prices retest the lows in the coming weeks/months, it will imply an 18% drop. Given the correlation between petrocurrencies and oil of 0.3, this suggests a 5.3% move lower.  Chart I-15ASome Petrocurrencies Are Very Cheap Chart I-15BSome Petrocurrencies Are Very Cheap Bottom Line: Place a limit buy on a petrocurrency basket at -5%.    Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report, “The Birth Of WOPEC,” dated April 9, 2020, available at ces.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been negative: The unemployment rate soared from 3.5% to 4.4% in March. Nonfarm payrolls recorded a total loss of 701K jobs, the first decline in payrolls since September 2010. The NFIB business optimism index plunged from 104.5 to 96.4 in March. Initial jobless claims surged by 6.6 million last week, higher than the expected 5.3 million. Michigan consumer sentiment declined to 71 from 89.1 in April. The DXY index fell by 0.7% this week. Risk assets have recovered, fueled by an extra USD $2.3 trillion stimulus from the Federal Reserve. The lesson we are learning is that the deeper the perceived slowdown, the more the Fed will do to assuage any economic damage. As for currencies, what matters is relative monetary policies. The key variable to stem the rise in the USD is that the liquidity crisis does not morph into a solvency one. Report Links: Capitulation? - April 3, 2020 The Dollar Funding Crisis - March 19, 2020 Are Competitive Devaluations Next? - March 6, 2020 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been mostly negative: Markit services PMI fell further to 26.4 in March from 28.4 the previous month. The Sentix investor confidence dived to -42.9 from -17.1 in April. Moreover, the Sentix current situation index fell from -15 to -66 in April, while the outlook index moved up slightly from -20 to -15. EUR/USD appreciated by 0.5% this week. The euro zone members failed to reach an agreement on the joint EU debt issuance. On the other hand, the ECB adopted an unprecedented set of collateral measures to mitigate the negative impacts from COVID-19 across the euro area, including easing collateral conditions for credit claims, reduction of collateral valuation haircut, and waiver to accept Greek sovereign debt instruments as collateral.  Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 On Money Velocity, EUR/USD And Silver - October 11, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been negative: Consumer confidence fell to 30.9 from 38.4 in March. Labor cash earnings grew by 1% year-on-year in February, but slowed from 1.2% in January. The Eco Watchers Survey current index fell from 27.4 to 14.2 in March. The outlook index also declined from 24.6 to 18.8. The Japanese yen fell by 1% against the US dollar this week. On Wednesday, the BoJ announced that it would scale back some non-urgent operations such as long-term research and studies for academic papers, following the government’s decision to declare a state of emergency. The Reuters poll forecasted the Q1 GDP to shrink by 3.7% quarter-on-quarter and Q2 by 6.1%. Report Links: The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the UK have been dismal: Markit construction PMI plunged to 39.3 from 52.6 in March. GfK consumer confidence crashed to -34 from -9 in March. Total trade balance (including EU) shifted to a deficit of £2.8 billion from a surplus of £2.4 billion in February. The goods trade deficit widened from £5.8 billion to £11.5 billion. GBP/USD rose by 0.6% this week. After being told to cut dividends last week, the UK banks are now pressuring the BoE on fresh capital relief to help fight the COVID-19. The BoE has also agreed to temporarily lend the government money, funded through money printing. The details suggest the operations are temporary, but the BoE might be the first central bank to formally step closer to MMT. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 United Kingdom: Cyclical Slowdown Or Structural Malaise? - Sept. 20, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been negative: The AiG services performance index fell from 47 to 38.7 in March. Imports and exports both slumped 4% and 5% month-on-month respectively in February. The trade surplus narrowed from A$5.2 billion to A$4.4 billion.  The Australian dollar surged by 3.8% against the US dollar, making it the best performing G10 currency this week. The RBA held interest rate steady at 0.25% on Tuesday, while warning the country is in for a “very large” economic contraction. Lowe also suggested that the economy will “much depend on the success of the efforts to contain the virus and how long the social distancing measures need to remain in place”. Report Links: On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been dismal: NZIER business confidence survey reported that a net 70% of firms expect general business conditions to deteriorate in Q1, compared to 21% in the previous quarter. Electronic card retail sales contracted by 1.8% year-on-year in March, down from 8.6% growth the previous month. The New Zealand dollar recovered by 1.7% against the US dollar this week. In addition to the NZ$30 billion purchases of central government bonds, the RBNZ is stepping up the QE program by offering to buy up to NZ$3 billion of local government bonds to support liquidity. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been dismal: Bloomberg Nanos confidence fell further from 46.9 to 42.7 the week ended April 3. Housing starts increased by 195K year-on-year in March, down from 211K in February. Building permits contracted by 7.3% month-on-month in February. On the labor market front, the pandemic has caused the unemployment rate to rise sharply from 5.6% to 7.8% in March, higher than the expected 7.2%. Employment fell by more than one million (-1,011,000 or -5.3%). The Canadian dollar rose by 1.2% against the US dollar this week, supported by the tentative rebound in oil prices. The BoC spring Business Outlook Survey shows that business sentiment had softened even before COVID-19 concerns intensified in Canada. The overall survey indicator fell below 0 to -0.68 in Q1. Businesses tied to the energy sector were hit the most due to falling oil prices. Report Links: The Loonie: Upside Versus The Dollar, But Downside At The Crosses Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Making Money With Petrocurrencies - November 8, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been negative: Total sight deposits were little changed at CHF 627 billion for the week ended April 3. The unemployment rate jumped from 2.5% to 2.9% in March, above expectations of 2.8%. The number of total unemployed increased by 15%, now reaching 136K. The Swiss franc appreciated by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. The Swiss government forecasted the output to slump 10% this year under the worst-case scenario, given the incoming data proved worse than expected. On the positive side, the government said it would gradually relax restriction measures later this month should the current situation improve. Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been negative: The unemployment rate surged to 10.7% in March from 2.3%. Manufacturing output fell by 0.5% month-on-month in February. Headline inflation fell from 0.9% to 0.7% year-on-year in March, while core inflation remained unchanged at 2.1%.  The Norwegian krone rose by 2.8% against the US dollar this week, up 18% from its recent low three weeks ago. Norway will likely relax some restrictions later this month while the ban on public gatherings will still remain in place. The loosening of COVID-19 measures, together with oil prices recovering and cheap valuations all underpin the Norwegian krone in the long run. Please refer to our front section this week for more detailed analysis. Report Links: Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1   Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2   Recent data in Sweden have been mixed: Industrial production fell by 0.2% year-on-year in February. Manufacturing new orders increased by 6% year-on-year in February. Household consumption increased by 2.3% year-on-year in February, up from 1.6% the previous month. The Swedish krona increased by 1% against the US dollar this week. The recent efforts in buying up bonds by the Riksbank to increase liquidity amid COVID-19 is likely to increase the debt burden in Sweden. The stock of Swedish Treasury bills held by the Riksbank is estimated to be SEK 300 billion by the end of this year, compared to only 55 billion in February. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

Highlights Please note that we are publishing an analysis on Vietnam below. The unprecedented depth of this recession entails that many businesses will likely be operating below their break-evens for a while, even after the confinement measures are eased. Consequently, the process of bottoming in this bear market will be drawn out, and share prices will gyrate substantially in the interim. Elevated foreign currency debt levels among some EM corporations, plunging revenues and local currency depreciation combine for a perfect storm in EM corporate credit. Continue underweighting EM stocks and credit within global equity and credit portfolios, respectively. Take profits on the long EM currency volatility trade. Feature If history is any guide, the speed of the rebound in global equities is more consistent with a bear market rally than the beginning of a new bull market. Typically, for a new durable bull market to emerge after a vicious bear market, a consolidation period or a base-building phase is needed. As of now, share prices have not formed such a base. Playing bear market rallies is all about timing, in which fundamental analysis is not useful. Rebounds die as abruptly as they begin. Hence, it is all about chasing momentum on either side. The unprecedented depth of this recession heralds that many businesses will likely be operating below their break-evens for a while, even after the confinement measures are eased. We closed our absolute short position in EM equities on March 19 but we have continued shorting EM currencies versus the US dollar. Even though EM share prices have become cheap based on their cyclically-adjusted P/E ratio (Chart I-1), valuation is not a good timing tool. This is especially true for this structural valuation indicator. Chart I-1EM Equities Are As Cheap As In Previous Bottoms Why The Rebound? After the massive selloff, investor sentiment on risk assets in general, and cyclicals specifically, has become very depressed. In particular: Sentiment of traders and investment advisors on US stocks has plummeted (Chart I-2). That said, net long positions in US equity futures are still above their 2016 and 2011 lows, as we noted last week. Traders’ sentiment on cyclical currencies such as the CAD and AUD as well as on copper and oil has dropped to their previous lows (Chart I-3).  Chart I-2Investor Sentiment On US Equities Is Poor Chart I-3Investor Sentiment On Copper And Oil Is Depressed   Consistently, net long positions of investors in both copper and oil have been trimmed substantially (Chart I-4A and I-4B). Chart I-4AInvestors’ Net Long Positions In Copper... Chart I-4B…And Oil   On the whole, it should not be surprising that after having become very oversold, risk assets rebounded in the past two weeks. Nevertheless, depressed investor sentiment is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a major bear market bottom. As illustrated in Chart I-3, sentiment on oil and copper was extremely depressed in late 2014. Yet with the exception of brief rebounds, both oil and copper prices continued to plunge for about a year before bottoming in January 2016. The necessary and sufficient condition for a durable bottom in global cyclical assets is an improvement in global demand. Chart I-5The S&P 500 And VIX In The Last Two Bear Markets Given the US and Europe are still in strict confinement and the Chinese economy remains quite weak (please see our more detailed discussion on this below), the global recession is still deepening. Further, while the enormous amounts of stimulus injected by policymakers is certainly positive, it is not yet clear whether these efforts are sufficient to entirely offset the collapse in the level of economic activity and its second round effects. Nevertheless, the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank have probably contained the acute phase of the financial market crisis by buying financial assets and providing credit to the real economy. Odds are that the VIX and other volatility measures will not retest their recent highs. However, this does not mean that risk assets cannot retest their lows or make fresh ones. For example, in the previous 2001-2002 and 2008 bear markets, the S&P 500 re-tested its low in early 2003 and made a deeper trough in early 2009 even though the VIX drifted lower (Chart I-5). Finally, as we discuss below, a unique feature of this recession makes it unlikely that a definite equity market bottom has been established so quickly. How This Recession Is Distinct From an investor viewpoint, this global recession stands out from others in a particularly distinct way: In an average recession, nominal output levels do not contract. In the US, since 1960 it was only during 2008 that the level of nominal GDP contracted (Chart I-6). Presently, we are experiencing the gravest collapse in nominal output/sales since the 1930s – much worse than what transpired in 2008. Chart I-6US Nominal GDP And Corporate Profits Growth When a company’s sales shrink, a critical threshold for sustainability is the level of its revenues relative to its break-even point. The latter is the level of sales where total revenue is equal to total cost – i.e., where profits are nil. Break-even points have ramifications for share prices and the shape of a potential recovery. In an average recession, break-even points for the majority of companies are not breached – i.e., they remain profitable. As a result, a moderate and sequential revival in sales boosts profits, often exponentially. Share prices react positively to even modest sequential growth. Besides, when profits are expanding, managers and owners of these businesses are often quick to augment their capital spending and hiring. A marginal and sequential recovery from this very low point is not sufficient to produce a durable bull market for stocks or corporate credit. When a company’s sales drop below its break-even level, a moderate sequential recovery in sales could be insufficient to make the company profitable. In such a case, the share price may not rally vigorously unless they had priced in a much worse outcome – i.e., a bankruptcy. Crucially, a moderate sequential revival in activity may not lead to more capital spending and hiring. Given US and global nominal GDP are presently contracting at an unprecedented double-digit pace, the revenue of a majority of companies has fallen below costs – i.e., they are presently operating below their break-evens (experiencing losses). This makes this recession distinct from others. On the whole, the loosening of confinement measures and the resumption of business operations may not be sufficient reasons to turn bullish on equities. So long as a company operates below its break-even, its share price may not rally much in response to marginal sequential growth. In short, the pace of recovery will be crucial. Yet, there is considerable uncertainty with respect to these dynamics. Such uncertainty also warrants a high equity risk premium. A U-shaped recovery is most likely, but the latter assumes that many companies will be operating with losses for some time. Consequently, odds are that the process of bottoming in this bear market will be drawn out, and share prices will gyrate substantially in the interim. Taking Pulse Of The Global Economy In our March 19 report, we argued that this global recession is much worse than the one in 2008. High-frequency data are confirming our view: The weekly US economic index from the New York Fed has plunged more than it did in 2008 (Chart I-7). Capital spending plans have been shelved around the world. Odds are many businesses will be operating below their break-evens even after confinement measures are eased. Therefore, they will not rush to invest in new capacity and equipment, or rush to hire. China is a case in point. Commodities prices on the mainland remain in a downtrend, despite the resumption of business activity (Chart I-8). This is a sign of lingering weakness in construction/capital spending. Chart I-7An Unprecedented Plunge In Economic Activity Chart I-8Commodities Prices In China Are Drifting Lower   The world’s oil consumption is presently probably down by more than 35%.  According to INRIX, US car traffic last week was 47% below its level in late February before the confinement measures were introduced. Plus, airline travel has literally ground to a halt worldwide. In China’s major cities, traffic during rush hour is re-approaching its pre-pandemic levels. However, automobile congestion data from TomTom shows that in the afternoons and evenings, traffic remains well below where it was before the lockdown. This reveals that people go to work, spend most of their time at the office, and then quickly return home. They do not go out during lunch time or in the evenings. Hence, we infer that China’s service sector remains in recession.  Chart I-9EM ex-China, Korea And Taiwan: Nominal Growth Was Very Weak Before The Pandemic  The Chinese manufacturing and service PMI indexes registered 51 and 47 respectively in March, revealing that their economic recoveries are very subdued. As per our discussion above, we suspect revenues for many businesses in February dropped below break-even levels. The fact that only about a half of both manufacturing and service sector companies said their March activity improved from February is rather underwhelming. EM ex-China, Korea and Taiwan nominal GDP and core consumer price inflation were at very low levels before the pandemic (Chart I-9). The ongoing plunge in economic activity will produce the worst nominal output recession for many developing economies. Consequently, corporate profits of companies exposed to domestic demand will crash in local currency terms. Bottom Line: The unprecedented depth of this recession heralds that many businesses will likely be operating below their break-evens for a while, even after the confinement measures are eased. Thus, a marginal and sequential recovery from this very low point is not sufficient to produce a durable bull market for stocks or corporate credit. Credit Markets Hold The Key Solvency concerns for companies become acute and doubt about their debt sustainability persist when their revenues drop below their break-evens. Thus, a marginal improvement in revenue – as lockdowns worldwide are relaxed – may not suffice to produce a material tightening in EM corporate credit spreads. Playing bear market rallies is all about timing, in which fundamental analysis is not useful. Rebounds die as abruptly as they begin. Interestingly, equity markets often take their cues from credit markets. Chart I-10 demonstrates that EM US dollar corporate bond yields (inverted on the chart) correlate with equity prices. This chart unambiguously expounds that what matters for EM share prices is not US Treasurys yields but rather their own borrowing costs in US dollars. Chart I-10EM US Dollar Corporate Bond Yields And Stock Prices Presently, there are no substantive signs that US dollar borrowing costs for EM companies or sovereigns are declining. Chart I-11 illustrates that investment and high-yield corporate bond yields for aggregate EM and emerging Asia remain elevated. Remarkably, bank bond yields in overall EM and emerging Asia have not eased much (Chart I-12). The latter is crucial as banks’ external high borrowing costs will dampen their appetite to originate credit domestically. Chart I-11EM US Dollar Corporate Bond Yields Chart I-12EM Banks US Dollar Bond Yields Chart I-13EM Credit Spreads, Currencies And Commodities In turn, the direction of EM corporate and sovereign credit spreads is contingent on EM exchange rates and commodities prices, as demonstrated in Chart I-13. Credit spreads are shown inverted in both panels of this chart. We remain negative on both EM currencies and commodities prices, and argue for a cautious approach to EM credit markets.  Bottom Line: Elevated foreign currency debt levels among some EM corporations, plunging revenues and local currency depreciation combine for a perfect storm in EM corporate credit. To make matters worse, this asset class as well as EM sovereign credit were extremely overbought before this selloff. Therefore, there could be more outflows from these markets as adverse fundamentals persist.  Investment Strategy And Positions We continue to recommend underweighting EM stocks and credit versus their DM counterparts. Importantly, the EM equity index has been underperforming the global equity benchmark in the recent rebound (Chart I-14). Aggressive policy stimulus in the US and Europe have improved investor sentiment towards their credit and equity markets. Yet, the Chinese stimulus has so far been less aggressive than in the past. This will weigh on the growth outlook for emerging Asia and Latin America. The outlook for oil prices is currently a coin toss. Price volatility will remain enormous and it is not worth betting on either the long or short side of crude. Apart from oil, industrial metal prices remain at risk due to subdued demand from China. In general, this is consistent with lower EM currencies (Chart I-15).   Chart I-14Continue Underweighting EM Stocks Versus The Global Benchmark Chart I-15EM Currencies Correlate With Industrial Metals Prices Chart I-16Book Profits On Long EM Currency Volatility Trade In accordance with our discussion above that the most acute phase of this crisis might be over, we are booking profits on our long EM currency volatility trade. We recommended this trade on January 23, 2020 and the JP Morgan EM currency implied volatility measure has risen from 6% to 12% (Chart I-16). While EM currencies could still sell off, we doubt this volatility measure will make a new high. Arthur Budaghyan Chief Emerging Markets Strategist arthurb@bcaresearch.com   Vietnamese Stocks: Stay Overweight Like many EM bourses, Vietnamese stocks have plunged 35% over the past two months in US dollar terms. How should investors now position themselves with regard to Vietnamese equities, in both absolute and relative terms? In absolute terms, there are near-term risks to Vietnamese equities: Vietnam’s economy is highly dependent on exports, which amount to more than 100% of the country’s GDP. The deepening global recession entails that overseas demand for Vietnamese exports will be decimated. Chart II-1 illustrates how share prices often swing along with export cycles. Customers from the US and EU, which together account for 40% of Vietnamese exports, have been cancelling their orders. In addition, the number of visitor arrivals has already dropped significantly, and tourism revenue – which amounts to about 14% of GDP – will continue to contract (Chart II-2). Chart II-1Vietnamese Stocks: Risks Are External Chart II-2Tourism Has Crashed   Nevertheless, we expect Vietnamese stocks to outperform the EM benchmark, in USD terms, both cyclically and structurally. First, Vietnam has solid macro fundamentals. The country’s annualized trade surplus has ballooned, reaching $12 billion in March (Chart II-3). Even as exports contract, the current account balance is unlikely to turn negative. Notably, Vietnam imports many of the materials required to produce its exported goods. As such, its imports will shrink along with its exports, which will support its current account balance. Meanwhile, the year-on-year growth of domestic nominal retail sales of goods has slowed down, but remains at 8% as of March, which is quite remarkable (Chart II-4). Chart II-3Vietnam Has Large Trade Surplus Chart II-4Consumer Spending To Slow But Not Contract   Second, the government has announced a sizable policy stimulus package. On March 16, the State Bank of Vietnam cut its policy rate by 50bps, from 4% to 3.5%, and its refinancing rate by 100bps, from 6% to 5%. On April 3, Vietnam's Ministry of Finance passed a fiscal stimulus package worth VND180 trillion (equal to US$7.64 billion, or 2.9% of its GDP). Third, Vietnam has contained the COVID-19 outbreak better than many other countries. With aggressive testing and isolation, the country has so far limited the infection rate to only three out of one million citizens, and reported zero deaths. This reduces the probability that Vietnam will be forced to adopt severe confinement measures that would derail its economy. This nation’s success also contrasts with the difficulties that many emerging and frontier economies are having in their struggle with COVID-19 containment.  We continue to overweight Vietnamese stocks relative to EM due to healthy fundamentals, attractive valuations, a large current account balance and a successful economic and health response to the COVID-19 outbreak. Fourth, the country remains quite competitive in global trade. For some time, multinational companies have been moving their supply chains to Vietnam in order to take advantage of its cheap and productive labor, inexpensive land and supportive government policies. As a result, Vietnamese exports have been outpacing those of China across many industries (Chart II-5). Given the geopolitical confrontation between the US and China is likely to persist over many years, more manufacturing will shift from China to Vietnam. Investment Recommendations In absolute terms, we believe Vietnamese stocks are still at risk. Stock prices falling to their 2016 low is possible over the coming weeks and months, which corresponds to a 10-15% downslide from current levels (Chart II-6, top panel). Chart II-5Vietnam Continues Gaining Export Market Share Chart II-6Vietnamese Stocks: Absolute & Relative Performance   Relative to the EM equity benchmark, however, we continue overweighting Vietnam equities, both cyclically and structurally. Technically, this bourse’s relative performance has declined to a major support line and it could be bottoming at current levels (Chart II-6, bottom panel). Ellen JingYuan He Associate Vice President ellenj@bcaresearch.com     Footnotes   Equities Recommendations Currencies, Credit And Fixed-Income Recommendations

Highlights The Federal Reserve’s temporary FIMA repo facility will go a long way in helping ease dollar-funding stress outside the US. However, with the duration of the lockdown highly uncertain, a liquidity crisis could rapidly evolve into a solvency one. If the containment measures prove successful by summer, then the global economy will be awash with much stimulus, which will be fertile ground for pro-cyclical currencies. However, in the event that we receive indications of a more malignant outcome, we could retest and break above the recent highs in the DXY. We assign a one-third probability to this outcome. For now, a barbell strategy is warranted. Hold a basket of the cheapest currencies, along with some safe-havens. Crude oil has approached capitulation lows, but conditions are not yet in place for a durable bottom. Stand aside on petrocurrencies for now. Feature Chart I-1The Fed's Liquidity Injections Are Working The DXY index has once again broken above the psychological 100 level. This has occurred alongside the backdrop of very generous swap lines offered by the Federal Reserve to foreign central banks, as well as a temporary repo facility for foreign and international monetary authorities (FIMA). In fact, the euro-dollar cross-currency basis swap is now in positive territory, suggesting that a key funnel for offshore dollar liquidity has now significantly widened (Chart I-1). Why then has the dollar continued to strengthen, despite a concerted effort by the Fed to flood the global system with dollars? We offer and explore three reasons: The Fed’s actions are still insufficient. The dollar crisis is evolving from a liquidity one to a solvency one. The liquidity-to-growth transmission mechanism needs time. The Fed’s Actions Are Still Insufficient The Fed’s actions so far to ease the offshore dollar funding stress have been to: Offer unlimited funding through swap lines to five major central banks at the overnight index swap + 25 basis points.1  This was effective the week of March 16. Extend the swap lines to nine more central banks, with a cap of US$60 billion and a maturity of 84 days.2 This was announced March 19. Allow FIMA account holders to temporarily exchange their Treasury securities held with the Fed for US dollars. This was announced on Tuesday. Have these actions been sufficient? For most developed market currencies, yes. Chart I-2 shows that the currencies that have been most hit in the first quarter were of the countries initially excluded from the swap agreement such as Australia, Norway and New Zealand. Since the March 19 agreement, these currencies have staged significant rallies. Chart I-2Very Few Winners In Q1 However, there are three reasons why the Fed’s actions are still insufficient. First, they are limited to only 14 central banks, and need to be expanded further. While currencies such as the Brazilian real and Mexican peso have stabilized, others like the Turkish lira or South African rand continue their freefall. In short, many emerging market central banks do not have swap agreements with the US. These are countries with huge dollar liabilities that could continue to see their currencies fall, pushing up the  aggregate dollar index. Developed market commodity currencies tend to be highly correlated to emerging market currencies (Chart I-3). There is a huge pool within the financial architecture unable to access funding through central bank swap lines.  The second reason is that the pool of Treasury securities available to swap for US dollars has shrunk significantly. This has been on the back of slowing global trade, which sapped the current account surpluses of many countries, dampening their foreign exchange reserves. Thus, while the Fed’s latest actions may prevent an international dumping of US Treasurys, it may be insufficient to completely assuage funding stresses (Chart I-4). Chart I-3Commodity Currencies Still At Risk Chart I-4A Smaller Pool Of Treasurys To Sell Finally, a recent report by the Bank of International Settlements3 showed that of the US$86 trillion in outstanding foreign exchange swaps/forwards, about 60% is among non-bank financial and other institutions. This suggests there is a huge pool within the financial architecture unable to access funding through central bank swap lines. Given that hedge funds are included in this group, this category entails a lot more credit risk than any central bank will be willing to bear (Chart I-5). Chart I-5Can The Fed Bail Out Non-Banks? Bottom Line: While the Fed’s injection of dollar liquidity has been massive and significant, access to these funds may be limited to entities that have significant credit risk. There is not much the Fed can do about this. But at the same time, it also suggests the Fed’s actions have been insufficient to quench the global thirst for dollar liquidity. From A Liquidity To A Solvency Crisis If the containment measures prove successful by summer, then the global economy will be awash with much stimulus, which will be fertile ground for pro-cyclical currencies. As a counter-cyclical currency, the dollar will buckle, lighting a fire under our favorites such as the Norwegian krone and the Swedish krona. The euro will be the most liquid beneficiary of this move. However, the DXY index has effortlessly broken above the psychological 100 level, suggesting we could catapult to new highs. When massive amounts of stimulus are injected into markets but prices keep falling (and the dollar keeps rallying), this portends a liquidity crisis morphing into a solvency one. What ensues is a liquidation phase where the only guiding signposts are technical indicators and valuation extremes. There are a few indications we could be stepping into this phase: During recessions, the dollar rally has tended to occur in two phases. The first phase prompts the US authorities to act, usually by dropping interest rates, which dampens the rally. The next phase epitomizes indiscriminate liquidation by financial markets (Chart I-6). Enter 2008. The US first introduced swap lines with a few central banks in December 2007. But from March to October 2008, the dollar soared by about 25%. This prompted the Fed to expand its swap lines to include even some emerging markets. Despite the knee-jerk fall in the dollar of 11%, we eventually made new highs by rallying 15%. While the Fed’s injection of dollar liquidity has been massive and significant, access to these funds may be limited. As the dollar rises, it takes time for economies to implode due to strong monetary and fiscal frameworks. The implosion of the euro area economy only surfaced well after the 2008 crisis. Specifically, there has been an epic rise in global nonfinancial corporate debt. As a result, credit default swaps across many countries are surging (Chart I-7). High-yield spreads are blowing out. Our bond strategists believe that even though there is value in investment-grade debt, high-yield paper remains at risk.4  Historically, whenever the default rate has breached 4% (as is the case now), a self-reinforcing feedback loop of higher refinancing rates and defaults ensues (Chart I-8). With a recovery rate that is going to be much lower than historical standards due to bloated balance sheets, this is worrisome. Chart I-6The Dollar Rally Occurs In Two Phases Chart I-7CDS Spreads Are Widening Significantly Chart I-8Large Defaults Are Ahead It is difficult to pinpoint where the epicenter of the potential default wave will be. The energy sector looks like a prime candidate, putting many commodity currencies at risk. Bottom Line: There is a non-negligible risk that the liquidity crisis evolves into a solvency one. Though this is not our base case, we assign a one-third probability to this outcome. Liquidity To Growth Transmission Channel Monetary stimulus only affects the economy with a lag, and fiscal stimulus is so far unlikely to completely plug the hole from economic disruption. This leaves currency technicals and valuation as among the only few guiding signposts towards a peak in the DXY. There is usually a significant lag between easing in offshore dollar funding costs and a respective bottom in the domestic currency (Chart I-1). The AUD/JPY cross has broken below the key support zone of 70-72. This defensive line held notably during the European debt crisis, China’s industrial recession and, more recently, the global trade war. This pins the next level of support in the 55-57 zone, on par with the recessions of 2001 and 2008. The USD/JPY is weakening again and will likely hit 100. A rising yen is usually accompanied by a dollar rally against other procyclical currencies. Outside of the Fukushima crisis, this has been a key indicator that the investment environment is becoming precarious (Chart I-9). Chart I-9The Yen Could Touch 100 Some high-beta currencies such as the USD/TRY, USD/ZAR, and USD/IDR are still in freefall. These currencies are usually good at sniffing out a change in the investment landscape, specifically one becoming perilous for carry trades. Similarly, the USD/CNY has tested and has failed to break above 7.12. This will be a key level to watch since a break above will send Asian currencies into the abyss. “Doctor” copper has failed to stage a meaningful rebound. In fact, the copper-to-gold and oil-to-gold ratios continue to head lower from oversold levels.  Whenever cyclical sectors are underperforming defensives at the same time as non-US markets underperforming US ones, this has signaled that the marginal dollar is rotating towards the US. This is usually dollar bullish (Chart I-10A and Chart I-10B). “Doctor” copper has failed to stage a meaningful rebound. In fact, the copper-to-gold and oil-to-gold ratios continue to head lower from oversold levels. This signifies impairment in the liquidity-to-growth transmission mechanism (Chart I-11). Earnings revisions continue to head lower across all markets. Chart I-10ACyclical Markets Are Not Confirming A Dollar Top Chart I-10BCyclical Markets Are Not Confirming A Dollar Top   Chart I-11Dr Copper Is Sick Bottom Line: Historically, signs of capitulation can usually be observed by paying close attention to market internals and currency technicals. While we have had some marginal improvement, we are not out of the woods yet. Portfolio Strategy Chart I-12Go Short CAD/NOK We recommend maintaining a barbell strategy – a basket of the cheapest currencies, along with some safe-havens such as the yen and Swiss franc. Overall, investors should maintain a small upward bias in the dollar in the near term. Meanwhile, short USD/JPY positions make sense. Oil plays are becoming attractive, but conditions for a durable bottom are not yet in place. The strong rebound in the NOK/SEK cross is just an unwinding of the flash crash. If the dollar and oil have been at the epicenter of these moves, then the cross is still at risk of relapsing in the near term. We were stopped out of a long position in this cross, and will discuss oil and petrocurrencies next week. That said, a short CAD/NOK position is a much safer way to express a longer-term bearish view on the dollar (Chart I-12). We are going short this cross today with a stop-loss at 7.5. Finally, the pound remains extremely cheap versus the dollar, but the rally in recent days has eroded the potential for tactical upside. We will await better opportunities to own sterling.   Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 These include the Bank Of Canada, Bank Of Japan, Bank Of England, European Central Bank, and the Swiss National Bank. 2 These include the Reserve Bank of Australia, the Banco Central do Brasil, the Danmarks Nationalbank (Denmark), the Bank of Korea, the Banco de Mexico, the Norges Bank, the Reserve Bank of New Zealand, the Monetary Authority of Singapore, and the Sveriges Riksbank. 3  Stefan Avdjiev, Egemen Eren and Patrick McGuire, “Dollar Funding Costs during the Covid-19 Crisis through the Lens of the FX Swap Market,” BIS Bulletin, dated April 1, 2020. 4 Please see US Bond Strategy and Global Fixed Income Strategy Joint Special Report, “Trading The US Corporate Bond Market In A Time Of Crisis,” dated March 31, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been negative: The University of Michigan's consumer sentiment index plunged to 89.1 in March from 101 the previous month, the fourth largest monthly decline over the past half a century. ADP employment recorded a loss of 27K jobs in total nonfarm private sector, including a 90K decrease in small businesses payroll which was offset by the 48K increase in healthcare. Initial jobless claims surged to 6.6 million for the week ended March 27. The ISM manufacturing index came in at a relatively benign 49.1, but this was boosted by supplier deliveries. The DXY index appreciated by 1.1% this week amid growing concerns over COVID-19 and disappointing data releases. Shortly after the $2 trillion coronavirus rescue package last week, President Trump is now calling for another "very big and bold" $2 trillion "Phase 4" package on infrastructure spending. Report Links: The Dollar Funding Crisis - March 19, 2020 Are Competitive Devaluations Next? - March 6, 2020 The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been negative: The business climate indicator dropped to -0.28 from -0.06 in March, as the COVID-19 crisis deepens. The March consumer price inflation fell across the euro area: headline inflation fell from 1.2% to 0.7% year-on-year and core inflation decreased from 1.2% to 1%.  EUR/USD depreciated by 1.1% this week. Euro zone countries have until April 9 to design another stimulus package to support the economy which might consist of financial loans and a short-term work scheme. The biggest challenge being faced is that while some member countries (including France, Italy and Spain) are calling for joint debt issuance, others (including Germany and Austria) are fiercely against it. Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 On Money Velocity, EUR/USD And Silver - October 11, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been negative: The jobs-to-applicants ratio dropped from 1.49 to 1.45 in February. Industrial production contracted by 4.7% year-on-year in February, down from -2.3% the previous month. Housing starts fell by 12.3% year-on-year in February.  The Japanese yen appreciated by 1.6% against the US dollar this week, supported by growing concerns over COVID-19 and a global recession. The quarterly Tankan Survey shows that the sentiment index fell to a 7-year low of -8 in Q1 among large manufacturers, and dived to 8 from 20 among non-manufacturers. Besides, the survey points to a further deterioration of confidence over the next three months. Report Links: The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the UK have been negative, despite some positive releases for Q4: Consumer confidence dropped from -7 to -9 in March. Markit manufacturing PMI slipped from 48 to 47.8 in March. The current account deficit narrowed from £15.9 billion to £5.6 billion in Q4. Annualized GDP growth was unchanged at 1.1% year-on-year in Q4. The British pound soared by 2% against the US dollar this week. To preserve cash during the pandemic, the BoE's Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) suggested commercial banks to suspend dividends and buybacks until the end of this year in addition to cancelling outstanding 2019 dividends. Moreover, the PRA also expects banks not to pay any cash bonuses to senior staff. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 United Kingdom: Cyclical Slowdown Or Structural Malaise? - Sept. 20, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been mixed: Consumer confidence dropped from 72.2 to 65.3 in March. Manufacturing PMI slipped from 50.1 to 49.7 in March. New home sales increased by 6.2% month-on-month in February, up from 5.7% the previous month. Building permits grew by 20% month-on-month in February. However, we expect housing activities to slow down in March. The Australian dollar fell further by 0.4% against the US dollar this week. In the minutes released this Wednesday, the RBA warned that a "very material contraction" in economic activity was ahead. While the RBA said it was not possible to provide an update of the macro forecast given the "fluidity of the situation", it also expressed concerns that the contraction might linger beyond the June quarter. Report Links: On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been negative: Building permits grew by 4.7% month-on-month in February. However, business confidence plunged from -19.4 to -63.5 in March. The activity outlook index also dived from 12 to -26.7 in March. The New Zealand dollar fell by 0.8% against the US dollar this week. Similar to the BoE, the RBNZ is now restricting all locally-incorporated banks from paying dividends on ordinary shares until the economy has sufficiently recovered in order to preserve cash and support the stability of the financial system. The RBNZ is also taking measures to help support banks to lend to businesses. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been negative: Bloomberg Nanos confidence dropped from 51.3 to 46.9 for the week ended March 27. Markit manufacturing PMI fell below 50 for the first time since last September to 46.1 in March. The Canadian dollar fell by 1.2% against the US dollar this week, weighed down by the sharp decline in oil prices. The BoC lowered the overnight target rate by another 50 bps in an emergency meeting last Friday. It also joined the QE club by launching the Commercial Paper Purchase Program (CPPP) which aims to ease short-term funding stress. Report Links: The Loonie: Upside Versus The Dollar, But Downside At The Crosses Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Making Money With Petrocurrencies - November 8, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been negative: KOF leading indicator dropped from 100.9 to 92.9 in March. Total sight deposits increased from CHF 609 billion to CHF 621 billion for the week ended March 27. The manufacturing PMI plunged from 49.5 to 43.7 in March. Headline consumer prices fell by 0.5% year-on-year in March, further down from the 0.1% decline in February. The Swiss franc fell by 1.5% against the US dollar this week. The SNB is not only battling a weaker economic backdrop, but also strong demand for safe-haven currencies. While the SNB has less room to further lower interest rates, it is taking part in easing funding stress from the pandemic. Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been negative: Retail sales increased by 2% month-on-month in February, up from 0.5% the previous month. Manufacturing PMI fell to 41.9 from 51.6 in March, the lowest since the Great Financial Crisis. The new orders, production and employment components all plunged below 40, while suppliers' delivery index soared to 74. The Norwegian krone rebounded by 2% against the US dollar this week, following the brutal selloff in recent weeks weighed by the sharp decline in oil prices. The Norges Bank is stepping up in currency intervention to reduce volatility including buying the krone in exchange for the US dollar. We believe there is now tremendous value in the krone once oil prices stabilize. Report Links: Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been negative: Retail sales grew by 2.8% year-on-year in February. Manufacturing PMI crashed to 43.2 in March from 52.7. The Swedish krona fell by 0.5% against the US dollar this week. In the Swedish Economy Report released on Wednesday, the NIER (Swedish National Institute of Economic Research) estimates that Sweden's GDP will fall by just over 6% in the second quarter. While the NIER believes that the current central bank measures are appropriate in supporting the economy in a wave of bankruptcies and mass unemployment, Sweden has more room to act with relatively lower government debt to its advantage. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

Highlights Extreme global economic uncertainty has pushed demand for USD higher, and forced investors to liquidate gold holdings to raise cash for margin calls and to provide precautionary balances. Gold endured a succession of down moves that elected our stop, leaving us with a 24% gain on the long-standing portfolio-hedge recommendation. Gold failed to deliver on portfolio protection at the onset of the market drop, but we believe this is largely a result of liquidation of positions in the wake of the record price volatility in commodities generally that has attended the COVID-19 pandemic. In the run-up to the GFC in 2008 and the COVID-19 crises, gold reached cyclical highs and was amongst the best performing assets. Once these crises hit and liquidity collapsed, investors were forced to book gains on their winners – including gold – to cover losses elsewhere. Additionally, the yellow metal provided a liquid source of US dollars to foreign investors and sovereigns with large dollar debts and expanding holes in their budgets. We remain constructive toward gold and will be re-opening our long position at tonight’s close. Feature The US dollar is essential to the global economy due to its dominant use in international trade invoicing and to a massive – $12 Trillion – foreign dollar-denominated pile of debt.1 As extreme global economic stress pushed up the demand for dollars, a market risk-off period has been transformed into a broad-based asset liquidation. In this report, we revisit our tactical and strategic stance on gold considering the global COVID-19-induced selloff and ongoing monetary and fiscal policy responses to it. COVID-19-Induced Uncertainty Upends Asset Correlations As investors rushed for liquid dollar assets amid rising worries re the length of the pause in global economic activity, past cross-asset correlations were disrupted and traditional safe-assets contributed to portfolio volatility. The recent equity selloff dragged gold and other safe assets in its wake. As investors rushed for liquid dollar assets amid rising worries re the length of the pause in global economic activity, past cross-asset correlations were disrupted and traditional safe-assets contributed to portfolio volatility (Chart of the Week).2 Gold prices, in particular, experienced a succession of rapid shifts in value since the beginning of this year: Up 10% from Jan 1 to Feb 24, down 12% from Feb 24 to Mar 19, and up 10% since Mar 19 (Chart 2, panel 1). These massive moves pushed gold’s implied volatility to its highest level since 2008. Chart of the WeekVolatility In Safe Assets Chart 2Large Moves In Gold Prices YTD A $1,575/oz stop to our long-standing gold recommendation was triggered on March 13, leaving us with a 24% gain, ahead of gold’s decline to $1,475/oz. We argued in previous reports the probability of a technical pullback remained elevated based on our Tactical Composite Indicator (Chart 2, panel 2). The dollar’s appreciation – driven by heightened uncertainty and pronounced illiquidity in offshore dollar markets – acted as a catalyst to the gold correction. A continued dollar shortage remains a chief risk to both our bullish gold and 2H20 EM activity rebound views. Global non-US banks’ reliance on US dollar and wholesale funding has greatly expanded since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) (Chart 3, panel 1). This increases bank’s reliance on foreign exchange swap markets to secure marginal funding, which pushes up financing costs when demand for dollar asset spikes (Chart 3, panel 2). Chart 3Greater Non-US Banks’ Funding Fragility Chart 4USD Gains From Rising Market-Wide Risk Aversion Generally, when USD supply ex-US expands in the so-called Eurodollar market, the global trade and banking systems function properly. In periods of low systematic volatility – an indication of low market-wide risk aversion – capital flows from safe US assets to stocks, high-yield bonds, and foreign markets in the search for stronger returns. In times of stress, however, risk-aversion spikes and demand for dollar surges as foreigners pile into liquid assets (Chart 4). Since global banks are highly interdependent, a troubled non-US bank unable to cover its dollar liabilities will be forced to dump assets to acquire USD at any price, creating additional stress amongst banks and increasing the convenience yield of holding on to dollar assets (Chart 5). Chart 5USD shortage Forces Foreign Banks To Sell Dollar Assets The USD As A Momentum Currency The global dominance of the US dollar in trade, funding and invoicing can create a vicious feedback loop. The global dominance of the US dollar in trade, funding and invoicing can create a vicious feedback loop (Diagram 1). Diagram 1Dollar Strength And Weak Global Growth Loop This makes the dollar a momentum and counter-cyclical currency (Chart 6). It also explains gold’s recent price movements. The recent global liquidation of financial assets for USD is the result of the most severe liquidity crunch since the onset of the GFC in 2008 (Chart 7). Again, gold failed to provide much-needed portfolio protection at the onset of the market drop, since gold holdings often were liquidated to meet margin calls or by sovereigns to fill budget gaps (Chart 8). Chart 6A Weaker Dollar Bodes Well For Commodities The Dollar Is A Counter-Cyclical Currency Chart 7Liquidity Proxies To Watch A dearth of collateral in repo markets – proxied by rapid increases in primary dealers’ repo fails – typically leads to short-term plunges in gold prices, as the metal is used as an alternative source of loan collateral. Still, we do not interpret this liquidation as a sign that gold’s safe-haven status is fading. In the run-up to both crises, gold was reaching cyclical highs and was amongst the best performing assets. Once the crisis hit and liquidity collapsed, investors were forced to book gains on their winners – including gold – to cover losses elsewhere. Additionally, the yellow metal provided a liquid source of US dollars to foreign investors and sovereigns with large dollar debts and expanding (unfunded) budget obligations. These pressures were particularly acute among EM commodity-exporting countries, which saw revenues compress during the severe drop in cyclical commodities. Chart 8Gold Plunges At the Onset Of Severe Crisis Chart 9Gold Provides Liquidity During Crisis Lastly, scarce high-quality collateral in wholesale markets makes gold swaps a liquid funding source. A dearth of collateral in repo markets – proxied by rapid increases in primary dealers’ repo fails – typically leads to short-term plunges in gold prices, as the metal is used as an alternative source of loan and swap collateral (Chart 9). Swaps effectively release gold previously held in storage to markets, increasing its supply. Gauging The Recovery In Gold Prices Calling the bottom in gold prices depends on how the Fed responds to dollar-funding stress abroad and banks’ reluctance to lend. In the current circumstances, we believe the plunge in gold will be limited compared to the GFC. First, the latest shocks to markets globally come from outside the financial system. There are no pronounced quality concerns in high-quality collateral. Current disruptions are mainly a result of low capital deployment to market-making activities by the financial system. Importantly, banks are now more capitalized, due to tighter post-GFC regulations limiting bank risk-taking. Second, the Fed responded much more rapidly to the current market disruptions. It is taking steps to alleviate liquidity concerns by filling the role of market maker – acting as a dealer of last resort – and encouraging banks to use their available capital to conduct market-making activities. The Fed also acts as the global dollar lender of last resort by providing liquidity globally via swap lines (Chart 10). When the world is short of dollars, funding costs can increase drastically (Chart 11). Swap lines will ease oversea funding pressures, and we expect these will be expanded to more countries if needed. Chart 10Swap Lines Alleviate Funding Stress Chart 11A Rising USD Increases Funding Cost Abroad A few indicators are signaling some liquidity and dollar funding stress remains in the system. We believe the rapid intervention by global central banks over the course of the current market stress will keep any liquidity squeeze from becoming a solvency and collateral quality crisis (Chart 12). However, it is difficult to know the exact level central banks are targeting, and given the nature of the shock, a lot will depend on the fiscal policy response. We believe gold prices – along with the indicators shown in Chart 7 – provide valuable information on the effectiveness of central banks’ actions. Thus, gold’s recent recovery is a prescient signal. Still, a few indicators are signaling some liquidity and dollar funding stress remains in the system. With prices back at $1580/oz, it is possible gold prices would be liquidated in a renewed equity selloff. However, our tactical composite indicator is slightly better positioned now and with US treasury yields now close to zero, gold’s ability to hedge market risk will increase relative to bonds. This inclines us to think the move would be less severe compared to the early March 11% plunge. Chart 12Fiscal And Monetary Actions Will Ease Credit Shock Given these considerations, we recommend going long gold at tonight’s close. Longer-Term, Gold’s Upside Potential Is Attractive The expanding fiscal deficit also tackles the lack of collateral by increasing the issuance of Treasury Notes and Bills. Strategically, gold’s appeal has increased sharply following the unprecedented monetary and fiscal responses to the COVID-19 shock. Over the next 6-12 months, we expect the US dollar will weaken and respond to interest rate differentials as uncertainty dissipates – presuming, of course, the COVID-19 shock is controlled and contained in most countries (Chart 13). The global supply of US dollars will increase from the Fed’s balance sheet expansion, swap lines to foreign banks, and a deepening US current account deficit following the unprecedented $2 trillion fiscal-stimulus package approved by the US Congress. Importantly, the expanding fiscal deficit also tackles the lack of collateral by increasing the issuance of Treasury Notes and Bills. Chart 13The USD Is Diverging From Rates Differentials Longer-term, the odds of higher inflation have risen. Consequently, we expect the vicious circle illustrated above will work in reverse (Diagram 2). EM Asia economic growth – led by a recovery in China – will outpace that of the US. This will generate capital outflows from the US to riskier emerging markets, forcing the dollar down until the Fed moves to raise rates – something we do not expect over the next 12 months. Thus, the opportunity cost of holding gold likely will remain low for an extended period (Chart 14). Diagram 2A Virtuous Cycle Will Start In 2H20 Longer-term, the odds of higher inflation have risen. However, our base case is the inflationary scenario is more likely to develop over the next 2 years. Low and falling inflation expectations can be expected for an extended period – the result of the global shut-down and collapsed commodity prices, particularly oil. This would suggest fixed-income markets will be pricing in low rates for the foreseeable future until an actual inflation threat is apparent. Still, if our call on oil is correct – i.e., our expectation Brent crude oil will be trading at $45/bbl by year-end, and clear $60/bbl by 2Q21 as the global economy recovers from the COVID-19 pandemic and the OPEC 2.0 market-share war ceases – markets could be pricing to higher inflation expectations next year, which would benefit gold.3 In addition, the massive fiscal and monetary stimulus being deployed globally will remain in the system for an extended period, which could stoke inflationary pressures. Chart 14Gold's Opportunity Cost Will Remain Low Chart 15Gold Will Be Supported In A Savings Glut Conversely, there is a non-negligible deflation risk stemming from a semi-permanent increase in precautionary savings as a result of the traumatic pandemic episode.4 Even so, gold can benefit from an increasing pool of savings (Chart 15). Bottom Line: We are going long gold at tonight’s close. The tactical (easing in dollar-funding crisis), cyclical (weakening US dollar and low real interest rates), and strategic (policy-induced inflationary pressure) horizons are all supportive for adding gold positions to a diversified portfolio.   Hugo Bélanger Associate Editor Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com   Commodities Round-Up Energy: Overweight The makings of a deal among the three largest oil producers in the world – the US, Russia and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) continue to fall into place. Russia earlier this week leaked it would not be increasing output after the OPEC 2.0 1Q20 production cuts expired March 31, saying such an increase would be unprofitable. US President Donald Trump is offering to broker talks between KSA and Russia, with the Texas Railroad Commission – the historical regulator of output in the Lone Star State – indicating it would be willing to resume its prior role provided other states and countries got on board. For its part, KSA has made it clear it will not bear the burden of re-balancing global markets unless this burden is shared by all producers – including the US (Chart 16). Base Metals: Neutral Copper prices remain relatively well supported, even as other commodities are pressured lower. COVID-19-induced shipping delays at South African, particularly out of Durban, could tighten copper markets, just as major economies begin recovering from lockdowns and ramp infrastructure projects. Fastmarkets MB noted refining charges are weakening as supply contracts due to shipping delays. Precious Metals: Neutral We are leaving a standing buy order for spot Palladium if it trades to $2,000/oz. Once the COVID-19 pandemic has bee contained and economies begin returning to normal, the fundamental tightness we outlined in our February 27 report our February 27 report – falling supplies exacerbated by a derelict South African power-grid trying to cover steadily increasing demand and more stringent pollution restrictions – will re-assert itself (Chart 17). Ags/Softs:  Underweight CBOT Corn futures hedged lower on Tuesday after the USDA predicted corn acreage will reach 97mm in 2020, the largest in eight years and well above market expectations of 94mm. This comes at a time when numerous American ethanol plants – which account for 40% of corn usage – are closing in response to the diminished demand for biofuels used for gasoline, due to the COVID-19 outbreak. Corn futures ended the month down 7.1%, the largest decline since August. The USDA sees soybeans acres planted rising 10% in 2020, below average expectations and wheat acres planted slipping 1% to 44.7mm, the lowest since 1919. Wheat was down 0.75¢, while soybeans were up 3.75¢ at Tuesday’s close. Chart 16Oil Prices Collapsed After the Market-Share War Chart 17Palladium Deficit To Widen This Year     Footnotes 1     Please see our weekly report titled OPEC 2.0 Cuts, Fed Rate Cuts Will Support Oil Prices published March 5, 2020. 2     Following our US Bond strategist, the liquidity shock discussed in this report means investors are finding it more expensive or difficult to transact in certain markets because of scares amount of capital being deployed to those areas. This does not necessarily imply a lack of buyers of credit risk. Please see BCA Research’s US Bond Strategy report entitled Life At The Zero Bound published by BCA Research’s US Bond Strategy March 24, 2020. 3    Please see the Special Report we published with BCA Research’s Geopolitical Strategy March 30, 2020, entitled OPEC 3.0 In the Offing? It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 4    Please see BCA Research’s Global Investment Strategy report entitled Second Quarter 2020 Strategy Outlook: World War V published March 27, 2020.     Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades TRADE RECOMMENDATION PERFORMANCE IN 2019 Q4 Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2020 Summary of Closed Trades