Highlights Portfolio Strategy The financials sector's fortunes are linked to the path of 10-year Treasury yields. BCA's view of a selloff in the bond market bodes well for this interest rate-sensitive sector. The S&P banks index is on the cusp of flexing its earnings power muscle. Higher profits will serve as a catalyst for a valuation rerating in this key financials sub-sector. The still unloved S&P asset management & custody banks index has significant catch-up potential. We reiterate our high-conviction overweight status. Recent Changes There are no changes to our portfolio this week. Table 1
Later Cycle Dynamics
Later Cycle Dynamics
Feature The S&P 500 ended last week on a high note, cheering significant progress on the tax bill front and digesting early earnings beats. Given the equity market's lofty valuation starting point, substantial positive profit surprises are now necessary to move the needle in stocks. Encouragingly, IBM's mention of the fall in the U.S. dollar boosting EPS1 may morph into a broad-based theme this earnings season given the currency's mysterious absence we have been flagging in Q2. Beneath the surface, easy fiscal policy prospects coupled with synchronized global growth will likely continue to underpin equities. Importantly, later stages of the business cycle are synonymous with impressive gains in the S&P 500. The unemployment gap, defined as the unemployment rate minus the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU), is an excellent leading indicator of the yield curve. Granted, NAIRU is an estimate and we are using the CBO's long-term NAIRU quarterly forecast as an input to the unemployment gap indicator. When the unemployment gap disappears, inflation should start rearing its ugly head, eventually leading the Fed to tighten monetary policy to the point where the yield curve inverts and predicts the end of the business cycle. Empirical evidence suggests that first the unemployment gap closes then the yield curve inverts and the business cycle subsequently ends (Chart 1). However, this indicator has had one miss since the early-1970s, during the second leg of the early-1980s double dip recession. Chart 1Eliminated Unemployment Gap Is Bullish For Equities
Eliminated Unemployment Gap Is Bullish For Equities
Eliminated Unemployment Gap Is Bullish For Equities
Table 2 shows the S&P 500 performance from when the unemployment gap clearly closes until the business cycle ends. In all five iterations that lasted, on average, 28 months, the broad market has risen, on average, by 29%. The unemployment gap has been eliminated since February 2017 and if history at least rhymes the next U.S. recession will arrive some time in 2019 as the SPX hits our peak cycle 3,000 target.2 Another later cycle phenomenon is the disappearance of volatility and the plunge in stock correlations as the Fed tightens monetary policy. While large institutional investors aggressively selling volatility this cycle is dampening vol across asset classes, there is another explanation of the non-existence of vol: synchronized global growth. Chart 2 shows that leading up to the prior three recessions, volatility was drifting lower and remained low, and the common denominator was simultaneous global growth in the late-1980s, late-1990s and mid-2000s. BCA's global (40 country) industrial production composite was expanding during the later stages of the business cycle. Similarly, our global (44 country) global EPS diffusion index and the global synchronicity indicator also depict concurrent global growth. Table 2S&P 500 Returns When##br## The Unemployment Gap Closes
Later Cycle Dynamics
Later Cycle Dynamics
Chart 2Linking Low Vol To ##br##Synchronized Global Growth
Linking Low Vol To Synchronized Global Growth
Linking Low Vol To Synchronized Global Growth
During the later stages of the cycle, equity sector correlations also collapse as earnings fundamentals are key performance drivers and sector differentiation generates alpha, as the broad market enters the last stage of the bull market. As we mentioned in our "SPX 3,000?" Weekly Report on July 10th, this does not mean the S&P 500's path is a linear straight line up until the next recession hits. There are high odds of a 5-10% garden variety pullback materializing which we deem a healthy development and our strategy would be to buy the dip, ceteris paribus. This week we update an early cyclical sector and two key sub-components. Financials: In The Shadows Of The Bond Market While financials stocks have cheered the prospects of a tax bill passage sometime in early 2018 (Chart 3), sell-side analysts have been brutally downgrading financials sector EPS estimates, dealing a blow to most sub-indexes net earnings revisions (Chart 4). True, hurricane-related losses may be the culprit, but such indiscriminate downgrades are unwarranted, and we would lean against such pessimism. Recent profit results corroborate our positive sector bias, but we are still early in the earnings season. Chart 3Dissecting Financials Performance
Dissecting Financials Performance
Dissecting Financials Performance
Chart 4Extreme EPS Pessimism
Extreme EPS Pessimism
Extreme EPS Pessimism
This early cyclical sector is a core overweight portfolio holding and there are high odds of significant relative gains in the coming quarters. Historically, financials stocks had been almost 100% positively correlated with the yield curve slope (Chart 5): a steepening yield curve gooses financials profits, while a flattening one eats into earnings via narrowing net interest margins. This rang true up until the Great Recession. Since then, unconventional monetary policies likely rendered this multi-decade correlation ineffective. In particular, the fed funds rate's zero lower bound caused a shift in the correlation from the yield curve to the 10-year Treasury yield (Chart 6). In fact, changes in the 10-year Treasury yield are now a carbon copy of relative share price momentum (Chart 6). Chart 5Shifting Correlations
Shifting Correlations
Shifting Correlations
Chart 6Financials And UST Yield Are Joined At The Hip
Financials And UST Yield Are Joined At The Hip
Financials And UST Yield Are Joined At The Hip
Thus, accurately forecasting long term interest rates should also dictate the direction of relative share prices, especially given the still historically low fed funds rate. On that front, the Treasury market is priced for the 10-year yield to hit 2.57% in October 2018 from roughly 2.38% currently. We expect the 10-year yield will rise more quickly than is discounted in the forward curve. Our U.S. bond strategists think core inflation will soon resume its modest cyclical uptrend. A parallel recovery in the cost of inflation protection will impart 50-60 basis points of upside to the 10-year Treasury yield by the time core inflation reaches the Fed's 2% target.3 Chart 7 plots the path of the 10-year Treasury yield discounted in the forward curve alongside a path consistent with BCA's view that inflation is poised to head higher. It also shows what this would mean for the 10-year breakeven inflation rate. If core inflation resumes its uptrend, as BCA expects, then financials will have a stellar return year in 2018, all else equal. Chart 7Lots Of Upside
Lots Of Upside
Lots Of Upside
Meanwhile, market participants typically value financials on a price-to-book basis during calamitous times and are very slow in changing metrics once the tremors are behind the sector. We are likely on the cusp of a switch away from P/B and toward forward P/E as a key valuation metric for financials. The current 20% forward P/E discount to the broad market is highly punitive (bottom panel, Chart 5). If the key S&P banks sub-index successfully flexes its earnings power muscle, as we expect, then a valuation rerating phase looms for both banks and financials equities. Banks Hold The Key We remain constructive on the S&P banks index as all three key drivers of bank profits, namely loan growth, price of credit and credit quality, are simultaneously moving in the right direction. Tack on the increasing likelihood of a tax bill becoming law in early 2018, the continued push of the Trump administration to relax bank regulations and pent up demand for shareholder friendly activities including net share retirement and higher dividend payments/payouts, and bank stocks are well positioned to generate impressive returns in the coming quarters. Lower corporate tax rates will boost bank profits directly and indirectly. Fiscal stimulus typically translates into an economic fillip. If small and medium businesses (SME) benefit the most from lower taxes then higher SME profits will lead to a more expansionary mindset and small business owners will likely tap their bankers to finance capital spending plans. As tax certainty increases, so will animal spirits, aiding in kick-starting a virtuous economic cycle. Thus, loan growth is on an upward trajectory. Leading indicators of loan demand are also painting a bright picture for bank profits. C&I and consumer loans, two large credit categories, are both forecast to reaccelerate in the coming months. The ISM manufacturing survey has been on fire lately and consumer confidence has been following closely behind (third & fourth panels, Chart 8). Our credit growth model captures these positive forces and is sending an unambiguously positive message for loan reacceleration in the coming months (Chart 8). Moreover, residential real estate loan origination (the second largest credit category in U.S. dollar terms) should gain steam, underpinned by solid housing market's foundations: house prices are still expanding at a healthy clip (top panel, Chart 9), household formation is running higher than housing starts and mortgage rates are not prohibitive. Chart 8Bright Business And Consumer Credit Outlooks
Bright Business And Consumer Credit Outlooks
Bright Business And Consumer Credit Outlooks
Chart 9Ongoing Valuation Rerating
Ongoing Valuation Rerating
Ongoing Valuation Rerating
The V-shaped recovery in our U.S. credit impulse corroborates this fertile loan backdrop and is heralding an earnings outperformance phase (Chart 10). On the price of credit front, if BCA's bond view pans out in the next year and the 10-year Treasury yield veers closer to 2.8-3% range with rising inflation expectations in the driver's seat (Chart 11), then bank profits should continue to accelerate. Granted, the Fed will also raise rates next year and, at the margin, push up funding costs for the banking sector. However, our working assumption is that banks will remain linked to the 10-year UST yield's fortunes next year. At some point later in the Fed tightening cycle, the yield curve and bank correlation will likely get re-established. But, a flattening yield curve denting NIMs is a 2019 narrative. Finally, credit quality remains pristine despite some pockets of weakness in, subprime especially, auto loans. At this stage of the cycle, near or at full employment, NPLs will remain muted. Importantly, loan loss reserves have recently crossed above non-current loans in Q2 according to the FDIC, for the first time since 2007. Historically, a rising reserve coverage ratio has been synonymous with increasing valuations and the current message is that the banks rerating phase is in the early innings (Chart 12). Chart 10Heed The Positive Credit Impulse Signal
Heed The Positive Credit Impulse Signal
Heed The Positive Credit Impulse Signal
Chart 11Price Of Credit Should Recover
Price Of Credit Should Recover
Price Of Credit Should Recover
Chart 12Pristine Credit Quality
Pristine Credit Quality
Pristine Credit Quality
Bottom Line: We reiterate our early-May overweight stance in the S&P financials sector and continue to overweight the heavyweight S&P banks sub-index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5BANKX - WFC, JPM, BAC, C, USB, PNC, BBT, STI, MTB, FITB, CFG, RF, KEY, HBAN, CMA, ZION, PBCT. A Few Words On Asset Management & Custody Banks The S&P asset management & custody banks (AMCB) index sits atop of our high-conviction return table (see page 15), outperforming the broad market by 7.2% since inception. While it is tempting to monetize some of these profits, we choose to remain patient. Likely more gains are in store in the coming months as this financials sub sector maintains its leadership position. If BCA's bond view of a selloff in the 10-year Treasury market transpires in 2018, then the budding rotation out of bond and into equity products will further accelerate. The stock-to-bond ratio captures this shift and it is currently flashing green (Chart 13). Overall assets under management are also rising and are a boon for the AMCB group's profit prospects, on the back of higher equity prices and also higher flows into stocks in general (bottom panel, Chart 13). Vibrant global economic sentiment, as measured by the IFO's World Economic Survey (top panel, Chart 14), and domestic (and global) manufacturing resurgence should continue to underpin M&A activity and sustain the high levels of margin debt. Both of these factors suggest that AMCB profit drivers are accelerating and will likely serve as a catalyst to unlock excellent value in this still unloved financials sub-group (middle panel, Chart 14). Chart 13Increasing AUMs...
Increasing AUMs...
Increasing AUMs...
Chart 14...And Rising Animal Spirits Are Bullish For AMCB
...And Rising Animal Spirits Are Bullish For AMCB
...And Rising Animal Spirits Are Bullish For AMCB
Adding it up, the still undervalued AMCB index has sizable catch-up potential, especially if the equity risk premium (ERP) continues to narrow in the coming quarters, as we expect (ERP shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 14). Bottom Line: The S&P AMCB index remains a high-conviction overweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5AMGT-BK, BLK, STT, AMP, NTRS, TROW, BEN, IVZ, AMG. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy & Global Alpha Sector Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report,"Dollar The Great Reflator" dated September 18, 2017, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report,"SPX 3,000?" dated July 10, 2017, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report,"Living With The Carry Trade" dated October 17, 2017, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor small over large caps and stay neutral growth over value.