Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.
Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Consumer Staples

Overweight The S&P household products index got a solid lift last week on the back of upbeat earnings from sector heavyweight Procter & Gamble (PG), though this was also part of a greater rotation into consumer staples. PG noted volume increases across all of their consumer staples segments with the global consumer remaining remarkably resilient. Despite a clearly healthy quarter, the company maintained their guidance for the next three quarters, suggesting the positive trend has some longevity. This broadly matches the macro signal, with exports of consumer goods staging a multi-year recovery, which should further underpin recent earnings outperformance (second panel). One minor negative anecdote, however, was the reference to the rising greenback that should eat into margins especially in early 2019, but rising volumes on the back of resilient demand should provide an offset. An appreciating U.S. dollar is an earnings risk we have been flagging in recent research for SPX exporters, especially if an EM accident materializes. Still, sector valuations remain depressed, implying bargains are still to be found in household products. We reiterate our overweight recommendation. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: PG, CL, CLX, KMB. Restock On Household Products Restock On Household Products
However, the S&P packaged foods sub-index has not participated in the rebound. These exports-oriented stocks have been held back by trade and currency headwinds. Still, we remain constructive on the index as those handicaps could evaporate as suddenly as…
Consumer staples stocks have been staging a recovery late in the year, buoyed by an exceptionally strong consumer. However, the S&P packaged foods sub-index has not participated in the rebound, held back by trade and currency headwinds in this export market-exposed sector. Still, we remain constructive on the index as those headwinds could evaporate as suddenly as they came, leaving a very solid domestic demand backdrop to lift the stocks into outperformance territory. Indeed, the environment looks exceptionally healthy; food retailers have been riding a five-year rising tide of sales (second panel). Further, consumers have been boosting their food consumption, which has historically been a good leading indicator of top line growth (third panel). In the context of a strong dollar providing a meaningful offset to packaging and raw food commodity prices, margin expansion looks particularly potent. Despite the bright outlook, the S&P packaged foods index remains deeply discounted, trading well below its eight-year average earnings multiple as well as the market multiple (bottom panel). We think investors should pick this one out of the bargain bin; stay overweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5PACK - MDLZ, KHC, GIS, TSN, K, MKC, HSY, CAG, SJM, HRL, CPB. Digging In To Packaged Foods Digging In To Packaged Foods
Following up from our inaugural U.S. Equity Market Indicators Report in early-August 2017, this week we introduce the second part in our Indicators series. In this Special Report we have drilled down to the ten GICS1 S&P 500 sectors (excluding the real estate sector) and have compiled the most important Indicators in four broad categories: earnings, financial statement reported, valuations and technicals. Once again this is by no means exhaustive, but contains a plethora of Indicators - roughly thirty Indicators per sector condensed in seven charts per sector - we deem significant in aiding us in our decision making process of setting/changing a view on a certain sector. The way we have structured this Special Report is by sector and we start with the early cyclicals continue with the deep cyclicals and finish with the defensives. Within each sector we then show the four broad categories. In more detail, the first three charts depict earnings Indicators including our EPS growth model, EPS breadth, profit margins, relative forward EPS and EBITDA growth forecasts and ROE and its deconstruction into its components. The following two charts relate to financial statement Indicators including indebtedness, cash flow growth and capital expenditures. And conclude with one valuation and one technical chart. As a reminder, the charts in this Special Report are also made available through BCA's Analytics platform for seamless continual updates. Due to length constraints, Part III of our Indicators series, expected in mid-October, will introduce a style and size flavor along with cyclicals versus defensives and end with the S&P 500, again highlighting Indicators in these four broad categories. Finally, likely before the end of 2018, we aim to conclude our Indicators series with Part IV that would feature our most sought after Macro Indicators per the ten GICS1 S&P 500 sectors, along with value/growth, small/large and cyclicals/defensives. We trust you will find this comprehensive Indicator chartbook useful and insightful. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com Dulce Cruz, Senior Analyst dulce@bcaresearch.com Consumer Discretionary Chart 1Consumer Discretionary: Earnings Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Earnings Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Earnings Indicators Chart 2Consumer Discretionary: Earnings Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Earnings Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Earnings Indicators Chart 3Consumer Discretionary: ROE And Its Components Consumer Discretionary: ROE And Its Components Consumer Discretionary: ROE And Its Components Chart 4Consumer Discretionary: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 5Consumer Discretionary: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 6Consumer Discretionary: Valuation Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Valuation Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Valuation Indicators Chart 7Consumer Discretionary: Technical Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Technical Indicators Consumer Discretionary: Technical Indicators Financials Chart 8Financials: Earnings Indicators Financials: Earnings Indicators Financials: Earnings Indicators Chart 9Financials: Earnings Indicators Financials: Earnings Indicators Financials: Earnings Indicators Chart 10Financials: ROE And Its Components Financials: ROE And Its Components Financials: ROE And Its Components Chart 11Financials: Financial Statement Indicators Financials: Financial Statement Indicators Financials: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 12Financials: Financial Statement Indicators Financials: Financial Statement Indicators Financials: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 13Financials: Valuation Indicators Financials: Valuation Indicators Financials: Valuation Indicators Chart 14Financials: Technical Indicators Financials: Technical Indicators Financials: Technical Indicators Energy Chart 15Energy: Earnings Indicators Energy: Earnings Indicators Energy: Earnings Indicators Chart 16Energy: Earnings Indicators Energy: Earnings Indicators Energy: Earnings Indicators Chart 17Energy: ROE And Its Components Energy: ROE And Its Components Energy: ROE And Its Components Chart 18Energy: Financial Statement Indicators Energy: Financial Statement Indicators Energy: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 19Energy: Financial Statement Indicators Energy: Financial Statement Indicators Energy: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 20Energy: Valuation Indicators Energy: Valuation Indicators Energy: Valuation Indicators Chart 21Energy: Technical Indicators Energy: Technical Indicators Energy: Technical Indicators Industrials Chart 22Industrials: Earnings Indicators Industrials: Earnings Indicators Industrials: Earnings Indicators Chart 23Industrials: Earnings Indicators Industrials: Earnings Indicators Industrials: Earnings Indicators Chart 24Industrials: ROE And Its Components Industrials: ROE And Its Components Industrials: ROE And Its Components Chart 25Industrials: Financial Statement Indicators Industrials: Financial Statement Indicators Industrials: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 26Industrials: Financial Statement Indicators Industrials: Financial Statement Indicators Industrials: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 27S&P Industrials: Valuation Indicators S&P Industrials: Valuation Indicators S&P Industrials: Valuation Indicators Chart 28S&P Industrials: Technical Indicators S&P Industrials: Technical Indicators S&P Industrials: Technical Indicators Materials Chart 29Materials: Earnings Indicators Materials: Earnings Indicators Materials: Earnings Indicators Chart 30Materials: Earnings Indicators Materials: Earnings Indicators Materials: Earnings Indicators Chart 31Materials: ROE And Its Components Materials: ROE And Its Components Materials: ROE And Its Components Chart 32Materials: Financial Statement Indicators Materials: Financial Statement Indicators Materials: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 33Materials: Financial Statement Indicators Materials: Financial Statement Indicators Materials: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 34Materials: Valuation Indicators Materials: Valuation Indicators Materials: Valuation Indicators Chart 35Materials: Technical Indicators Materials: Technical Indicators Materials: Technical Indicators Tech Chart 36Technology: Earnings Indicators Technology: Earnings Indicators Technology: Earnings Indicators Chart 37Technology: Earnings Indicators Technology: Earnings Indicators Technology: Earnings Indicators Chart 38ROE And Its Components ROE And Its Components ROE And Its Components Chart 39Technology: Financial Statement Indicators Technology: Financial Statement Indicators Technology: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 40Technology: Financial Statement Indicators Technology: Financial Statement Indicators Technology: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 41Technology: Valuation Indicators Technology: Valuation Indicators Technology: Valuation Indicators Chart 42Technology: Technical Indicators Technology: Technical Indicators Technology: Technical Indicators Health Care Chart 43Health Care: Earnings Indicators Health Care: Earnings Indicators Health Care: Earnings Indicators Chart 44Health Care: Earnings Indicators Health Care: Earnings Indicators Health Care: Earnings Indicators Chart 45Health Care: ROE And Its Components Health Care: ROE And Its Components Health Care: ROE And Its Components Chart 46Health Care: Financial Statement Indicators Health Care: Financial Statement Indicators Health Care: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 47Health Care: Financial Statement Indicators Health Care: Financial Statement Indicators Health Care: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 48Health Care: Valuation Indicators Health Care: Valuation Indicators Health Care: Valuation Indicators Chart 49Health Care: Technical Indicators Health Care: Technical Indicators Health Care: Technical Indicators Consumer Staples Chart 50Consumer Staples: Earnings Indicators Consumer Staples: Earnings Indicators Consumer Staples: Earnings Indicators Chart 51Consumer Staples: Earnings Indicators Consumer Staples: Earnings Indicators Consumer Staples: Earnings Indicators Chart 52Consumer Staples: ROE And Its Components Consumer Staples: ROE And Its Components Consumer Staples: ROE And Its Components Chart 53Consumer Staples: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Staples: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Staples: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 54Consumer Staples: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Staples: Financial Statement Indicators Consumer Staples: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 55Consumer Staples: Valuation Indicators Consumer Staples: Valuation Indicators Consumer Staples: Valuation Indicators Chart 56Consumer Staples: Technical Indicators Consumer Staples: Technical Indicators Consumer Staples: Technical Indicators Telecom Services Chart 57Telecom Services: Earnings Indicators Telecom Services: Earnings Indicators Telecom Services: Earnings Indicators Chart 58Telecom Services: Earnings Indicators Telecom Services: Earnings Indicators Telecom Services: Earnings Indicators Chart 59Telecom Services: ROE And Its Components Telecom Services: ROE And Its Components Telecom Services: ROE And Its Components Chart 60Telecom Services: Financial Statement Indicators Telecom Services: Financial Statement Indicators Telecom Services: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 61Telecom Services: Financial Statement Indicators Telecom Services: Financial Statement Indicators Telecom Services: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 62Telecom Services: Valuation Indicators Telecom Services: Valuation Indicators Telecom Services: Valuation Indicators Chart 63Telecom Services: Technical Indicators Telecom Services: Technical Indicators Telecom Services: Technical Indicators Utilities Chart 64Utilities: Earnings Indicators Utilities: Earnings Indicators Utilities: Earnings Indicators Chart 65Utilities: Earnings Indicators Utilities: Earnings Indicators Utilities: Earnings Indicators Chart 66Utilities: ROE And Its Components Utilities: ROE And Its Components Utilities: ROE And Its Components Chart 67Utilities: Financial Statement Indicators Utilities: Financial Statement Indicators Utilities: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 68Utilities: Financial Statement Indicators Utilities: Financial Statement Indicators Utilities: Financial Statement Indicators Chart 69Utilities: Valuation Indicator Utilities: Valuation Indicator Utilities: Valuation Indicator Chart 70Utilities: Technical Indicator Utilities: Technical Indicator Utilities: Technical Indicator
  Neutral U.S retailers have been surging recently as customers have been piling in faster than they have in a long time. Walmart reported results last week showing a 4.5% increase in same-store sales and a 40% increase in online sales; the stock responded by rising more than 9%. Target too reported exceptional results with the CEO commenting that the consumer environment was the strongest he had seen in his career. Overall, things are looking up for retailers as the consumer has been spending at an expanding pace for several years. Considering the savings rate remains elevated (second panel), the consumer probably has significant dry powder to maintain the trend. However, we remain nervous about margins; transportation costs are clearly rising and an economy at full capacity means increasing employment costs, which tend to hurt retailers earlier than most other sectors. This likely underlies why S&P hypermarkets EPS has fallen further behind the broad market (bottom panel). Tack on much higher volatility in Walmart's share price as investors whipsaw the stock based on the online sales performance and we see strong rationale to remain on the sidelines; stay neutral. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HYPC - WMT, COST.   The Return Of Retail The Return Of Retail  
Please note that our next publication will be a joint special report with BCA’s Geopolitical Service that will be published on Wednesday, August 1st instead of our usual Monday publishing schedule. Further, there will be no publication on Monday, August 6th. We will be returning to our normal publishing schedule thereafter. Highlights We continue to explore a cyclical over defensive portfolio bent, and the capex upcycle along with higher interest rates are our key investment themes for the remainder of the year. A number of sentiment indicators have broken out (Chart 1), and our sense is that the SPX will also hit fresh all-time highs in the coming quarters. While buybacks vaulted to uncharted territory in Q1/2018 (Chart 2), our profit growth model suggests that EPS will continue to expand at a healthy clip for the rest of the year (Chart 3) and 10% EPS growth is achievable in calendar 2019. Positive macro forces remain in place with the ISM - manufacturing and non-manufacturing - surveys reaccelerating. Beneath the surface, the new-orders-to-inventories ratio is gaining traction and even the trade-related subcomponents (new export orders and imports) are ticking higher. High backlogs also suggest that SPX revenue growth will remain upbeat (Chart 4). Non-farm payrolls are expanding on a month-over-month basis for 93 consecutive months, a record (Chart 5), at a time when the real fed funds rate remains near the zero line (Chart 6). As a result, the economy is overheating. Corporate selling price inflation is skyrocketing, according to our gauge, with our diffusion index catapulting to multi-decade highs. This represents a positive margin backdrop as wage inflation remains muted (Chart 7). While at first sight, valuations appear dear, a simple thought experiment suggests that soon they will deflate1 (Chart 8). And, on a forward price-to-earnings-to-growth (PEG) basis, valuations have sunk to one standard deviation below the historical mean (Chart 9). Two key risks that we are closely monitoring that can put our cyclically positive equity market view offside are: a sustained rise in the U.S. dollar infiltrating profit growth (Chart 10), and corporate balance sheet degradation short-circuiting the broad equity market (Chart 11). Chart 1Sentiment Is Breaking Out Sentiment Is Breaking Out Sentiment Is Breaking Out Chart 2Buybacks Are Soaring Buybacks Are Soaring Buybacks Are Soaring Chart 3Earnings Growth Hasnt Slowed... Earnings Growth Hasnt Slowed... Earnings Growth Hasnt Slowed... Chart 4...And Backlogs Suggest They Wont ...And Backlogs Suggest They Wont ...And Backlogs Suggest They Wont Chart 5Record Jobs Growth... Record Jobs Growth... Record Jobs Growth... Chart 6...And Still-Loose Monetary Policy ...And Still-Loose Monetary Policy ...And Still-Loose Monetary Policy Chart 7Wage Growth Is Trailing Pricing Power Flexing Its Muscles Wage Growth Is Trailing Pricing Power Flexing Its Muscles Wage Growth Is Trailing Chart 8The Market Is Not That Expensive... The Market Is Not That Expensive... The Market Is Not That Expensive... Chart 9...By Several Measures ...By Several Measures ...By Several Measures Chart 10A Strong Dollar Is A Risk A Strong Dollar Is A Risk A Strong Dollar Is A Risk Chart 11Corporate Sector Leverage Is Too High Corporate Sector Leverage Is Too High Corporate Sector Leverage Is Too High Feature S&P Industrials (Overweight) While our industrials CMI remains very near 20-year highs, it has lost its upward momentum this year due almost entirely to the strength of the U.S. dollar, though sliding global PMI surveys have also started to weigh (second panel, Chart 13). Combined with heightened fears of a trade war, the internationally geared S&P industrials have come under pressure. Chart 12S&P Industrials (Overweight) S&P Industrials S&P Industrials Chart 13Positive Industrial Growth Backdrop Positive Industrial Growth Backdrop Positive Industrial Growth Backdrop Still, demand growth has been resilient and continues to soar as the capex upcycle has not yet run its course and the implications for top line and profit growth are unambiguously positive (third and bottom panels, Chart 13). Should some let up emerge from the current break down of international trade, we would expect earnings to resume their role as the fundamental driver for industrials. Our valuation gauge has rapidly declined this year as extreme bearishness is not reflected by the strong profit backdrop. From a technical perspective, S&P industrials have been the most oversold since the Great Recession. S&P Energy (Overweight, High-Conviction) Our energy CMI has continued to push higher from the extremely depressed levels of 2016 and 2017. Still, the much better cyclical environment has started to get reflected in relative share prices with the S&P energy index besting all other GICS1 sectors in Q2. We recently refined our energy sector sub-surface positioning that sustains the broad energy complex in the overweight column, and we reiterated its high-conviction status. We believe the steep recovery in underlying commodity prices, which the market has thus far failed to show much confidence in, has started to restore some semblance of normality in the exploration & production (E&P) stocks space (top panel, Chart 15). Chart 14S&P Energy (Overweight, High Conviction) S&P Energy S&P Energy Chart 15A Capex Boom As Oil Reignites A Capex Boom As Oil Reignites A Capex Boom As Oil Reignites Similar to the broad energy complex that integrateds dominate, oil & gas E&P producers are a capital expenditure upcycle play, which remains a key BCA theme for the year (second panel, Chart 15). Accordingly, we raised the S&P oil & gas E&P index to an overweight stance. Simultaneously, weakening crack spreads (third panel, Chart 15) and rising gasoline inventories (bottom panel, Chart 15) have given us cause for concern for refiners. As a result, we trimmed the S&P oil & gas refining & marketing index to underweight, though this did not shake our high-conviction overweight position on the broad S&P energy index. Our Valuation Indicator (VI) remains near deeply undervalued territory, and indicates an attractive entry point for fresh capital. Our Technical Indicator (TI) has fully recovered from oversold levels and now sends a neutral message. S&P Financials (Overweight) The pace of improvement in our financials cyclical macro indicator (CMI) has not abated. However, the usual tight correlation between the CMI and the relative performance of the S&P financials index has broken down. An important culprit has been the heavyweight S&P banks sub-index and its transition from a correlation with the 10-year UST yield and toward the 10/2 yield curve slope earlier this year (top and second panels, Chart 17). While the former is still up year-over-year, the latter has continued to flatten and the result is likely a squeeze on banks' net interest margins, a key profit driver; we recently booked gains of 6% and removed it from the high-conviction overweight list, and the S&P banks index is currently on downgrade watch. Chart 16S&P Financials (Overweight) S&P Financials S&P Financials Chart 17Growth And Credit Quality Offset A Flat Yield Curve Growth And Credit Quality Offset A Flat Yield Curve Growth And Credit Quality Offset A Flat Yield Curve Still, our key three reasons for being overweight the S&P financials index remain unchanged. Rising yields and the accompanying higher price of credit are a boon to financials and a core BCA theme for 2018 remains higher interest rates. The global capex upcycle, another of BCA's key themes for 2018, has paused for breath, though it has been replaced by soaring U.S. demand. This exceptional willingness of U.S. CEOs to expand their balance sheets should mean capital formation will proceed at well above-trend pace, and further underpin C&I loan growth (third panel, Chart 17). Lastly, a low unemployment rate drives both expanding consumer credit and much better credit quality. At present, the unemployment rate is testing all-time lows, sending an unambiguously positive message for financials profitability (bottom panel, Chart 17). Market bearishness has more than offset the positive fundamentals and the S&P financials index has underperformed in 2018; the result has been a steep fall in our VI to nearly one standard deviation below normal. The bearishness is also reflected in our TI which has recently collapsed into oversold territory. S&P Consumer Staples (Overweight) Our consumer staples CMI has moved sideways since our last update, near a depressed level. This is reflected in the share price performance; defensives in general and staples in particular have been woefully unloved this year. However, we believe positive macro undercurrents have made bargain basement prices in consumer staples an exceptional deal, particularly for investors willing to withstand short term volatility for a long-term investment gain. We recently pointed out that, while non-discretionary demand is losing share versus overall outlays, spending on essentials as a percentage of disposable income is gaining steam. The bearish read on this would be that this could be a pre-cursor to recession, but our interpretation is that latent staples-related buying power may make a comeback from a still very depressed level and kick-start industry sales growth (top panel, Chart 19). Chart 18S&P Consumer Staples (Overweight) S&P Consumer Staples S&P Consumer Staples Chart 19Staples Are Poised For A Recovery Staples Are Poised For A Recovery Staples Are Poised For A Recovery Meanwhile consumer staples exports are flying in the face of a rising U.S. dollar, which has typically presaged relative earnings gains (second panel, Chart 19). Considering the already-strong industry return on equity, any relative earnings gains should result in a valuation rerating (third panel, Chart 19). Both our VI and TI concur; as they are both more than a standard deviation below fair value. S&P Health Care (Neutral) Earlier this month, we lifted the S&P pharma and biotech indexes to neutral and, given that these sectors command roughly a 50% weighting in the S&P health care sector, these upgrades also lifted the health care sector to a neutral portfolio weighting. Sentiment has moved squarely against the sector and the bar for upward surprises has been lowered enough to create fertile ground for upside surprises. As shown in the second panel of Chart 21, health care long-term EPS growth expectations have never been lower in the history of the I/B/E/S/ data. This is contrarily positive, particularly given how our VI has remained under pressure and our TI has sunk. Chart 20S&P Health Care (Neutral) S&P Health Care S&P Health Care Chart 21Peak Pessimism In Health Care Peak Pessimism In Health Care Peak Pessimism In Health Care Still, our health care CMI has been treading water at relatively low levels, but our S&P health care earnings model suggests that at least a bottom in profit growth has formed (bottom panel, Chart 21). S&P Technology (Neutral) We lifted the S&P technology index to neutral earlier this year to capitalize on one of BCA's key themes for 2018: synchronized global capex upcycle, of which the broad tech sector is a core beneficiary (second panel, Chart 23).2 Software and tech hardware & peripherals are the two key sub-indexes we prefer and have also put on our high-conviction overweight list. Chart 22S&P Technology (Neutral) S&P Technology S&P Technology Chart 23A Capex Upcycle Should Sustain High Valuations A Capex Upcycle Should Sustain High Valuations A Capex Upcycle Should Sustain High Valuations There is still pent up demand for tech spending that is being unleashed following over a decade of severe underinvestment. In addition, consumer spending on tech goods is also at the highest level since the history of the data, underscoring that end demand is upbeat (third panel, Chart 23). On the global demand front, EM Asian exports are climbing at the fastest clip in ten years; tech sales and EM Asian exports are historically joined at the hip and the current message is positive (bottom panel, Chart 23). The technology CMI has also turned positive this year after falling for the previous three, though an appreciating dollar and higher interest rates continue to suppress an otherwise exceptionally robust macro environment. Valuations, while still in the neutral zone, have reached their highest level in a decade. This may prove risky should inflation mount faster than expected; a de-rating phase in technology would likely follow. Our TI is in overbought territory, though it has been at this high level for several years. S&P Utilities (Neutral) Our utilities CMI appears to have found a bottom, arresting the linear downtrend of the previous decade. Declining earnings have steadied out as the industry has found some discipline; new investment has declined and turbine & generator inventories have ticked up (second panel, Chart 25). The result of declining investment has been a slight improvement in capacity utilization, albeit still at a relatively low level (third panel, Chart 25). Chart 24S&P Utilities (Neutral) S&P Utilities S&P Utilities Chart 25Earnings Are Looking For A Bottom Earnings Are Looking For A Bottom Earnings Are Looking For A Bottom The uptick in capacity utilization has driven a surge in industry pricing power, despite flat natural gas prices which have historically been the industry price setter; this could be the precursor to a recovery in sector earnings (bottom panel, Chart 25). Still, as with other defensive sectors, utilities have underperformed cyclical sectors in the last year; this has been exacerbated by utilities trading as fixed income proxies. Our VI does not provide much direction as it has been in the neutral zone for the past year, underscoring our benchmark allocation recommendation. Our TI fell steeply earlier this year, though it has recovered and offers a neutral reading. S&P Materials (Neutral) The materials CMI has come under pressure as the Fed has continued to tighten monetary policy. A further selloff in bonds remains the BCA view for 2018, implying rising real rates will weigh on the sector for at least the remainder of the year. The heavyweight chemicals component of the materials index typically sees earnings (and hence stock prices) underperform as real interest rates are moving higher (real rates shown inverted, top panel, Chart 27). Chart 26S&P Materials (Neutral) S&P Materials S&P Materials Chart 27This Time Is Different For Chemicals This Time Is Different For Chemicals This Time Is Different For Chemicals On the operating front, chemicals sector productivity has made solid gains over the past year and the sell-side bearishness for much of the past decade has finally reversed (second panel, Chart 27). Further, overcapacity, the usual death knell of the chemicals cycle, seems to be a thing of the past as the industry has massively scaled back on capital deployment on the heels of a mega global M&A cycle (third panel, Chart 27). Net, operating improvements might offset macro headwinds. Our VI echoes this neutral message and sits on the fair value line. Our TI is somewhat more bullish and is edging toward an oversold position. S&P Real Estate (Underweight) Our real estate CMI looks to have found a bottom earlier this year, though the only time it has been worse was during the Great Financial Crisis. Real estate stocks are continuing to behave like fixed income proxies, as they have since the overhang from the GFC gave way to a yield focus (top panel, Chart 29). In the context of a tightening monetary backdrop, we would need compelling operating or valuation reasons to maintain even a benchmark allocation in the sector; these are both absent. Chart 28S&P Real Estate (Underweight) S&P Real Estate S&P Real Estate Chart 29Dark Clouds Forming Dark Clouds Forming Dark Clouds Forming On the operating front, the commercial real estate (CRE) sector is waving a red flag. The occupancy rate has clearly crested and rents are headed down with it, warning of declining sector cash flows (second panel, Chart 29). While CRE credit quality shows no signs of deterioration, at this stage of the cycle and given weak industry profit fundamentals we would caution against extrapolating such good times far into the future (third panel, Chart 29). We recently initiated a trade to capitalize on relative CRE weakness by going long the S&P homebuilding index/short the S&P REITs index.3 Such overwhelming bearishness would suggest the sector would be relatively cheap, but our VI suggests that REITs are fairly valued. Our TI is has been unwinding an oversold position and is now in neutral territory. S&P Consumer Discretionary (Underweight) In early March, we identified three key factors that we expected to weigh on the consumer discretionary sector: a rising fed funds rate, quantitative tightening and higher prices at the pump. As highlighted in Chart 31, all of these factors remain intact and underlie the two-year decline in the consumer discretionary CMI. Chart 30S&P Consumer Discretionary (Underweight) S&P Consumer Discretionary S&P Consumer Discretionary Chart 31The Amazon Effect The Amazon Effect The Amazon Effect Further, were we to exclude AMZN from the day the S&P included it in the SPX and the S&P 500 consumer discretionary index (November 21st, 2005), then the vast majority of consumer discretionary stocks are actually following the typical historical relationship with the Fed's tightening cycle (fed funds rates shown inverted, top panel, Chart 31). Put differently, the equal weighted S&P consumer discretionary relative share price ratio is indeed following the Fed's historical tightening path (bottom panel, Chart 31). Meanwhile, our VI has broken out to nearly its highest level ever which we believe is largely a function of the decreasing diversification of the S&P consumer discretionary index as AMZN now represents nearly a quarter of its market value, and about to get even larger in the upcoming introduction of the Communications Services GICS1 sector, but only comprises 3% of this sector's net income. Our TI agrees with our VI and is well into overbought territory. S&P Telecommunication Services (Underweight) Our telecom services CMI, bounced off its 30-year low earlier this year, but not nearly enough for a bullish position to be established. Rather, our bearish thesis remains unchanged: A combination of still-tepid pricing power weighing on earnings (second panel, Chart 33), weak consumer spending (bottom panel, Chart 33) and higher Treasury yields (which are negatively correlated with high-dividend yielding telecom services stocks, top panel, Chart 33), should all keep relative performance suppressed. Chart 32S&P Telecommunication Services (Underweight) S&P Telecommunication Services S&P Telecommunication Services Chart 33Pricing Power Is Still On Hold Pricing Power Is Still On Hold Pricing Power Is Still On Hold Valuations have fallen significantly - our VI continues to touch new lows - and our TI has been indicating a persistently oversold position, but we think the industry is in a de-rating phase, implying the new valuation paradigm has a degree of permanence. Size Indicator (Favor Large Vs. Small Caps) Our size CMI has fallen back to the boom/bust line. Keep in mind that this CMI is not designed as a directional trend predictor, but rather as a buy/sell oscillator; the current message is neutral. Despite the neutral CMI reading, we downgraded small caps earlier this year,4 and moved to a large cap preference, based on the diverging (and unsustainable) debt levels of small caps vs. their large cap peers (top and second panels, Chart 35). We expect the divergence in leverage and stock price to be rationalized as it usually has: via a fall in the latter. Chart 34Size Indicator (Favor Large Vs. Small Caps) Style View Style View Chart 35Small Cap Leverage Is Critical Small Cap Leverage Is Critical Small Cap Leverage Is Critical Our call has thus far been slightly offside as small caps have been outperforming: investors have sought the trade-friction free shelter that small caps offer compared with internationally exposed large caps. Extreme optimism also reigns throughout the small cap world (third panel, Chart 35). However, we continue to think a turn is merely a matter of time; the NFIB's "good time to expand" reading is at its highest level in the history of the survey (bottom panel, Chart 35) which means small cap CEOs are more likely to push their already-stretched balance sheets closer to the breaking point. Our TI is telling us that small caps are overbought, but the VI continues to offer a neutral message. Chris Bowes, Associate Editor chrisb@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Insight Report, "How Expensive Is The SPX?" dated July 6, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Buying Opportunity," dated April 9, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Special Report, "UnReal Estate Opportunity," dated July 9, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Special Report, "UnReal Estate Opportunity," dated July 9, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com.
Underweight The S&P soft drinks index has been rallying for the past month after finding its decade low in mid-May. The rally appears to be driven by eroding fears of margin impacts from aluminum tariffs, demand destruction from higher prices to protect profits and general global trade barriers. We would caution that all of these threats are still very much in play. Still, we prefer to focus on other industry fundamentals which remain persistently bearish for the soft drinks industry. Beverage shipments remain deep in contractionary territory while inventories continue to pile up (second power). This unpleasant divergence is corroborated by the recent steep slide in pricing power (third panel), which is now back into decline as beverage makers try to clear backlogs by sharpening their pencils. Meanwhile valuations have been mostly treading water (bottom panel), which to us appears to significantly underappreciate the industry risks. Stay underweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5SOFD - PEP, KO, DPS, MNST. A Relief Rally Should Fizzle A Relief Rally Should Fizzle
Overweight Investors have deserted consumer staples stocks at a dizzying speed as this safe haven sector has lost its allure. Our sense is that this consumer staples wholesale liquidation provides a great buying opportunity, especially for longer-term oriented capital with a time horizon of at least 2-3 years. While non-discretionary demand is losing share versus overall outlays, spending on essentials as a percentage of disposable income is gaining steam. True, this could be a pre-cursor to recession, but our interpretation is that latent staples-related buying power may make a comeback from a still very depressed level and kick-start industry sales growth (top panel). Other industry green-shoots are also surfacing. Consumer staples exports are on a slingshot recovery path, expanding by a low double digit growth rate, defying the year-to-date trade-weighted U.S. dollar appreciation (second panel). Adding it up, a rare buying opportunity has emerged in the S&P consumer staples index, especially for long-term oriented capital. The bearish story is already baked into current valuations, and industry green-shoots are flying under the radar. Tack on impressive industry return on equity and this index appears extremely undervalued (third and bottom panel). Bottom Line: Were we not already overweight the S&P consumer staples index, we would not hesitate to lift exposure to above benchmark. What To Do With Staples What To Do With Staples
Overweight Not only have investors shunned consumer staples stocks in general, but the S&P packaged foods sub-index has also suffered, even trailing the broad staples sector. We are not willing to throw in the towel in this staples sub-index that offers hidden value. A number of leading industry demand indicators are firming and suggest that a top line growth period is in the cards. Food and beverage exports are rising at a healthy clip, despite the U.S. dollar's year-to-date appreciation, and so are domestic consumer outlays (second panel). Importantly, relative to overall spending, real (volume) food and beverage spending is expanding smartly (third panel). Add on tame raw food commodity costs, especially compared with broad commodity price inflation and relative EPS will overwhelm extremely depressed analysts' expectations (relative grain prices shown inverted, bottom panel). Bottom Line: Stay overweight the S&P packaged foods index; please see Monday's Weekly Report for more details. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5PACK - MDLZ, KHC, GIS, TSN, K, CAG, HSY, MKC, SJM, HRL, CPB. Appetizing Packaged Foods Appetizing Packaged Foods
Highlights Portfolio Strategy A rare buying opportunity has emerged in the S&P consumer staples index, especially for long-term oriented capital. The bearish story is already baked into current valuations, and industry green-shoots are flying under the radar. Similarly, the bearish packaged foods narrative is well ingrained in depressed relative valuations, whereas the budding recovery in industry final demand is severely underappreciated. This offers investors a compelling entry point to this unloved and under-owned consumer products subgroup. Recent Changes There are no changes to our portfolio this week Table 1 Girding For A Breakout? Girding For A Breakout? Feature The S&P 500 digested receding geopolitical risks last week, and continued to consolidate recent gains. Stocks are poking at the upper end of the 10% trading range in place since early-February, and internal equity dynamics suggest that a breakout in a bullish fashion is in store for later in the summer, as we first posited in late April.1 Chart 1 shows our Equity Market Internal Dynamics Indicator (EMIDI) that does an excellent job capturing the shifting internal forces that drive market returns. This coincident-to-leading market Indicator comprising economically sensitive sectors and portfolio biases is signaling that the path of least resistance is higher for the SPX. Similar to the EMIDI, the Value Line Arithmetic Index (an equal weighted broad-based stock market index) broke out to fresh all-time highs and the Value Line Geometric Index (a gauge of median stock prices) is following closely behind (third & fourth panels, Chart 2). Market darling AAPL is making a run at a $1tn valuation, spearheading the tech-laden NASDAQ Composite that remains on a pattern of hitting higher highs (top panel, Chart 2). Equity buying power is also evident in the breakout of Thomson/Reuters' "Most Shorted Stocks Index" (second panel, Chart 2). All of this suggests that before long the SPX will follow the uptrend and vault to all-time highs, a message corroborated by the record highs in the broad market's advance/decline (A/D) line (bottom panel, Chart 2). Chart 1Breakout... Breakout... Breakout... Chart 2...Looming ...Looming ...Looming An enticing macro backdrop continues to underpin equities. The latest ISM manufacturing report confirmed the IHS Markit U.S. manufacturing PMI release that we highlighted in our Report two weeks ago2: the U.S. is firing on all cylinders and has the potential to pull global growth out of its recent lull. In particular, the reacceleration in the ISM new orders-to-inventories ratio suggests that equities will gain steam in the coming months (second panel, Chart 3). Another source of upbeat news was the backlog subcomponent of the May ISM manufacturing survey. Unfilled orders hit a 14-year high, just shy of the all-time record. Historically, backlogs have been an excellent leading indicator of SPX revenue growth and the current message is that S&P 500 top line growth is on a solid footing (bottom panel, Chart 3). The Fed acknowledged this mini economic overheating last week, and the FOMC slightly bumped its median expectation to a total of four hikes in calendar 2018. Moreover, fiscal easing will continue to gain thrust as the year progresses and the cash repatriation will also provide an assist to the stock market. We are modeling between $650bn-to-$800bn in equity retirement for calendar 2018. Chart 4 depicts our estimates and if the historical correlation between share buybacks and equity prices holds, then there is more upside to stocks in the back half of the year. Nevertheless, retail investors are replenishing cash coffers according to the American Association of Individual Investors (AAII), rather than actively participating in the latest market run up. At the margin, this beefing up of retail investor dry powder represents a headwind to additional equity market gains. We heed the message from this traditionally leading Indicator and in order for our cyclical (9-12 month horizon) sanguine equity market view to pan out, individual investors will have to drawdown their cash balances (AAII cash shown inverted, Chart 5). Chart 3Macro Tailwinds Macro Tailwinds Macro Tailwinds Chart 4Corporate Underpinnings... Corporate Underpinnings... Corporate Underpinnings... Chart 5...But Retail Investor Has To Participate ...But Retail Investor Has To Participate ...But Retail Investor Has To Participate This week we are revisiting a broad defensive sector and one of its key subcomponents. What To Do With Staples Investors have deserted consumer staples stocks at a dizzying speed, and valuations have cratered to a multi-decade low, according to our composite Valuation Indicator (Chart 6). Technicals are also as washed out as can be, as staples equities have been sold off indiscriminately. Other sentiment and breadth measures confirm that this safe haven sector has lost its allure: the A/D line is probing multi-year lows, EPS breadth is waning and groups with a positive 52-week rate of change and trading above the 40-week moving average have all but disappeared (Chart 7). Chart 6Buy Into Weakness Buy Into Weakness Buy Into Weakness Chart 7Bombed Out Sentiment Bombed Out Sentiment Bombed Out Sentiment Our sense is that this consumer staples wholesale liquidation provides a great buying opportunity, especially for longer-term oriented capital with a time horizon of at least 2-3 years. Even on a shorter-term outlook, a bounce seems likely from extremely depressed levels, as relative share prices may find support close to the pre-Great Recession trough (top panel, Chart 7). From a cyclical perspective we continue to view this defensive sector as a hedge to our overall portfolio position that sustains a pro-cyclical bent. Importantly, the bearish consumer staples case is well discounted in bombed out valuations. The stock-to-bond ratio is weighing on this fixed income proxy sector that sports a dividend yield on a par with the 10-year Treasury (top & second panels, Chart 8). Moreover, subsiding volatility bodes ill for relative share prices; the opposite is also true (bottom panel, Chart 8). On the demand front, once again the uninspiring non-cyclical spending backdrop is well entrenched in sinking relative share prices. Relative staples retail sales - both compared to discretionary and to total sales - are deflating as is typical in the late stages of the business cycle (top & second panels, Chart 9). Chart 8Bearish Narrative Baked In Bearish Narrative Baked In Bearish Narrative Baked In Chart 9Lack Of Demand... Lack Of Demand... Lack Of Demand... Such waning demand has weighed on industry selling prices at a time when executives are making labor additions, blowing out our wage bill proxy. As a result, profits margins are suffering a squeeze (Chart 10). However, there are some pockets of strength hidden beneath the surface. While non-discretionary demand is losing share versus overall outlays, spending on essentials as a percentage of disposable income is gaining steam. True, this could be a pre-cursor to recession, but our interpretation is that latent staples-related buying power may make a comeback from a still very depressed level and kick-start industry sales growth (bottom panel, Chart 9). Other industry green-shoots are also surfacing. Consumer staples exports are on a slingshot recovery path, expanding by a low double digit growth rate, defying the year-to-date trade-weighted U.S. dollar appreciation (second panel, Chart 11). In fact, given the defensive stature of this index, any additional greenback gains will boost relative profits especially in the first half of 2019 (third panel, Chart 11). Chart 10...Weighing On Margins... ...Weighing On Margins... ...Weighing On Margins... Chart 11...But Green-Shoots Surfacing ...But Green-Shoots Surfacing ...But Green-Shoots Surfacing Finally, CEO confidence of non-durable industries is far outpacing the broad animal spirit recovery according to The Conference Board, and this relative Chief Executive euphoria has historically been positively correlated with share price momentum, underscoring that better times lie ahead for consumer staples stocks (bottom panel, Chart 11). Adding it up, a rare buying opportunity has emerged in the S&P consumer staples index, especially for long-term oriented capital. The bearish story is already baked into current valuations, and industry green-shoots are flying under the radar. Tack on impressive industry return on equity and this index appears extremely undervalued (bottom panel, Chart 6). Bottom Line: Were we not already overweight the S&P consumer staples index, we would not hesitate to lift exposure to above benchmark. Appetizing Packaged Foods Not only have investors shunned consumer staples stocks in general, but the S&P packaged foods sub-index has also suffered, even trailing the broad staples sector. As a reminder, within consumer products we are overweight packaged foods and household products but maintain a below-benchmark allocation to soft drinks. Packaged foods relative share prices have returned to the mid-2000s level offering a compelling entry point for fresh capital, especially longer-term oriented money (top panel, Chart 12). Part of the reason that these stocks are under-owned boils down to their defensive characteristics. These safe-haven equities pay handsome, steadily growing and secure dividends. Thus, when the bond market's selloff gains steam, investors flock to deep cyclical stocks and trim fixed income proxied equities, and vice versa. Moreover, the Warren Buffett induced M&A premia have now fully reversed from this group, with the base effect weighing on relative performance (bottom panel, Chart 12). Nevertheless, we are not willing to throw in the towel in this staples sub-index that offers hidden value. A number of leading industry demand indicators are firming and suggest that a top line growth period is in the cards. Food and beverage exports are rising at a healthy clip, despite the U.S. dollar's year-to-date appreciation, and so are domestic consumer outlays (second panel, Chart 12). The industry's shipments-to-inventories ratio is sending a similar message, jumping to a level last seen four years ago (third panel, Chart 12. Importantly, relative to overall spending, real (volume) food and beverage spending is expanding smartly. Add on tame raw food commodity costs, especially compared with broad commodity price inflation and relative EPS will overwhelm extremely depressed analysts' expectations (relative grain prices shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 13). Chart 12Budding Demand Recovery... Budding Demand Recovery... Budding Demand Recovery... Chart 13...Should Aid Top Line Growth ...Should Aid Top Line Growth ...Should Aid Top Line Growth This encouraging demand backdrop is showing up in industry pricing power. Rising food manufacturing shipments are underpinning food producers' selling prices (second panel, Chart 14), and coupled with the contained crude food input costs suggest that packaged foods margins will continue to expand (middle panel, Chart 14). Even down the supply chain, food manufacturers' appear to be making significant headway, a harbinger at least of a profit margin relief phase. While channel captains food retailers have been dictating pricing terms to food suppliers for the better part of the past five years, industry producer prices are now on an even keel with CPI foods, a good proxy of what super markets are charging the consumer (fourth panel, Chart 14). Any additional pricing power gains will represent a boost to industry margins and, thus, profitability. Finally, firming demand is also showing up on industry operating metrics: factory activity is running red hot with resource utilization rates vaulting to multi-decade highs and industry hours worked picking up momentum (third panel, Chart 15). While CEOs have expanded the labor footprint and wage inflation is a cause for concern (bottom panel, Chart 15), a simple industry productivity proxy (industrial production divided by employment) shows that profits should enjoy a lift in the coming quarters. Chart 14Margins Can Expand Further Margins Can Expand Further Margins Can Expand Further Chart 15Brisk Factory Activity Brisk Factory Activity Brisk Factory Activity Netting it out, the bearish packaged foods narrative is well ingrained in depressed relative valuations (bottom panel, Chart 14), whereas the budding recovery in industry final demand is severely underappreciated, offering investors a compelling entry point to this unloved and under-owned consumer products subgroup. Bottom Line: Stay overweight the S&P packaged foods index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5PACK - MDLZ, KHC, GIS, TSN, K, CAG, HSY, MKC, SJM, HRL, CPB. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Lifting SPX Target," dated April 30, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Unwavering," dated June 4, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps