Debt Trends

Long-term deflationary forces in Japan are weakening, setting the stage for inflation to make a comeback over the remainder of the decade. Investors should prepare to structurally reduce exposure to Japanese bonds starting early next year. Higher Japanese bond yields will lift an extremely undervalued yen. To the extent that global growth should surprise on the upside over the next 12 months, Japanese equities could see some modest outperformance.

What is the outlook for the European housing market amid rising mortgage rates and the energy crisis? Does housing represent a systemic risk? Can households weather the storm? And what are the opportunities, if any?

We continue to anticipate that the Fed won’t pause its tightening cycle until Q1 or Q2 of 2023, and current labor market trends certainly give no indication that a Fed pause (or “pivot”) is imminent.

Listen to a short summary of this report.     Executive Summary A Beacon Of Hope For AUD A Beacon Of Hope For AUD A Beacon Of Hope For AUD Along with the Canadian dollar, the Aussie has been one of the best performing currencies during a broad-based dollar rally. Rising interest rates are part of the story, but there is more to Aussie strength than meets the eye. Aussie’s resilience is a conundrum worth exploring. First, it is a favorite short play for an imploding economic scenario in China, which suggests it should be a lot weaker. Second, the Aussie should be in the bottom quartile of FX returns in a risk-off currency scenario. Aussie strength can be attributed to strong commodity prices that are providing a terms-of trade-tailwind. Moreover, there is marginal evidence that demand for Australian-sourced commodities could be becoming a tad more inelastic. Chinese economic growth continues to disappoint, but upside surprises will be a welcome fillip for the AUD (Feature chart). On a terms-of-trade basis, the Australian dollar is very cheap. Falling commodity prices are a handicap, but the margin of safety on the valuation makes the AUD a safer bet. Go long AUD/USD if it touches 0.665 cents. AUD/NZD bets are also attractive. However, we will stay on the sidelines on AUD/JPY bets. RECOMMENDATIONS INCEPTION LEVEL inception date RETURN LONG AUD/USD 0.665 2022-08-26 - Bottom Line: The Aussie dollar could go on a fire sale in the coming weeks. We would be buyers of AUD/USD at 0.665 cents. Feature The Australian dollar has been relatively resilient amidst broad-based dollar strength. Year-to-date, AUD is down 3.7% versus a 13.0% rally in the DXY (Chart 1). This is a remarkable development since historically, the AUD has been a very pro-cyclical currency, bearing the heavy lifting of any dollar rally. AUD/JPY, a key barometer for a risk-on/risk-off environment is up 13.4% year to date, despite a broad-based selloff in many risk assets. Chart 1The AUD Has Outperformed The AUD Has Outperformed The AUD Has Outperformed The Aussie’s resilience is a conundrum worth exploring. First, it is a favorite short play for an imploding economic scenario in China, which suggests it should be a lot weaker. Second, the Aussie should be in the bottom quartile of FX returns in a risk-off currency scenario. In this report, we explore base case scenarios for the Australian dollar, with recommendations for both short-term and longer-term trades, as well as plays at the crosses. Technical Indicators Technical indicators suggest the AUD could be ripe for a rebound. Our intermediate-term indicator bottomed at 5.55 and has usually been associated with non-negligible rallies in the AUD (Chart 2). This indicator is volatile and our expectation is that it could relapse in the near term. However, that will be good news for investors that have a constructive view on AUD prospects. Consistently, speculators are very short the Australian dollar. China’s zero COVID-19 policy, along with property market troubles have made the AUD a favorite short play (Chart 3). Given AUD’s resilience, this suggests that speculators are being overwhelmed by a tidal wave of fundamental currency inflows, through commodity purchases, bond market investors and Aussie equity sector bulls. Chart 2Technicals Point To A Coiled-Spring Rebound In The Coming Months Technicals Point To A Coiled-Spring Rebound In The Coming Months Technicals Point To A Coiled-Spring Rebound In The Coming Months Chart 3Investors Have Been Shorting ##br##AUD Investors Have Been Shorting AUD Investors Have Been Shorting AUD Australian Commodity Demand Chart 4A Beacon Of Hope For The AUD A Beacon Of Hope For The AUD A Beacon Of Hope For The AUD Weakness in China is well known and discounted by financial market participants. The latest selloff in the RMB is a case in point. Yet positive economic surprises in China have been improving relative to peers in the developed market (Chart 4). There are two simple reasons for this. First, the Chinese government is easing domestic financial conditions. Contrary to popular belief, lower rates and higher stimulus in China are positive for the AUD since it boosts Australian exports via higher domestic demand (Chart 5). With the Chinese bond market becoming more and more liberalized, it is also becoming a good proxy for monetary conditions in China. As such, lower bond yields in China have tended to lead imports. This is good news for Aussie exports in the coming months. Chart 5AStimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD Stimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD Stimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD Chart 5BStimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD Stimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD Stimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD Second, the Australian capital account could also be on the mend as foreigners are more willing to re-rate Aussie shares (Chart 6). The Chinese credit cycle has often led to a re-rating in Aussie shares. Our China and Emerging Market strategists argue that stimulus measures might not be sufficient to turn around Chinese domestic demand. In our view, that is well priced into the Aussie, which could potentially experience another selloff in the coming weeks. However, any upside surprises in Chinese growth will be a welcome fillip for the Australian dollar. Chart 6China And Australia Are Tied To The Hip China And Australia Are Tied To The Hip China And Australia Are Tied To The Hip A Few Moats Around The AUD Infrastructure spending is a huge chunk of Chinese fixed asset investment. So, while the housing downturn will impact commodity demand, infrastructure could provide a welcome offset. This could be a big moat that investors should pay attention to. Infrastructure is 24.5% of fixed asset investment in China and 18.0% of steel demand (Chart 7). Chart 7AStimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD A Small Beacon Of Optimism In Australia A Small Beacon Of Optimism In Australia Chart 7BStimulus In China Is Historically Positive For AUD A Small Beacon Of Optimism In Australia A Small Beacon Of Optimism In Australia On a relative basis, Australian terms-of-trade have outperformed other commodity-producing nations. This is some evidence that the external demand for Aussie commodities could be becoming a tad more inelastic. Among Australia’s exports, liquified natural gas has been increasing both in price and as a share of total volume (Chart 8). This is following a natural tailwind. China has an imperative to become greener, which has led to a rise in the share of renewables and natural gas electricity generation (Chart 9). Australia is in the top three biggest exporters of liquified natural gas in the world and exports world class clean coal that China depends on. The result has been a tremendous gain in terms of trade (Chart 10).  Chart 8Some Aussie Exports Could Be Relatively Demand Inelastic Some Aussie Exports Could Be Relatively Demand Inelastic Some Aussie Exports Could Be Relatively Demand Inelastic Chart 9A Tailwind For Australia A Tailwind For Australia A Tailwind For Australia Chart 10Terms Of Trade Are Favorable In Australia Terms Of Trade Are Favorable In Australia Terms Of Trade Are Favorable In Australia Amidst this moat around the AUD is also a valuation cushion. As a result of strong export prices, the Australian dollar is undervalued on a terms of trade basis. While true that the AUD is vulnerable to a correction in commodity prices, the margin of safety on the valuation is sufficient for investors willing to ride out near term volatility (Chart 11). Remarkably, the 10-year government bond yield in Australia is 56.8 basis points above that in the US. This will have two profound opposing effects. First, from an interest rate perspective, it will cushion the drawdown in the Aussie, as interest-rate differentials matter for currency returns (Chart 12). On the other hand, it puts interest-rate sensitive parts of the economy, such as housing, at risk. Chart 11AUD Is Cheap On A Terms Of Trade Basis AUD Is Cheap On A Terms Of Trade Basis AUD Is Cheap On A Terms Of Trade Basis Chart 12AUD Is Cheap On A Fundamental Basis AUD Is Cheap On A Fundamental Basis AUD Is Cheap On A Fundamental Basis The Risks For The AUD The first risk for the AUD is a downturn in commodity prices. Chinese demand is genuinely slowing. This could lead to an undershoot in the AUD, as a terms-of-trade undershoot (Chart 13). That is why our recommended entry point is lower than today’s level at 0.665 cents. Chart 13A Commodity Correction Is A Risk For AUD A Commodity Correction Is A Risk For AUD A Commodity Correction Is A Risk For AUD Chart 14Housing Is A Big Risk For Australia Housing Is A Big Risk For Australia Housing Is A Big Risk For Australia The second consideration is housing prices. Real estate is experiencing a meaningful roll over in Australia. This has been led by Sydney and Melbourne, where prices were clearly overvalued, but the phenomenon is more broad based (Chart 14). Related Report  Foreign Exchange StrategyTwo Decades After The Creation Of The Euro The impact for financial markets and the AUD is two-fold. First, if the RBA continues to tighten and as this flattens the Aussie yield curve further, it will not be a welcome development for bank net interest margins and profits (Chart 15). Second, the market has already priced in interest rates higher in Australia compared to the US (Chart 16). A slowdown in housing construction activity, that makes the Aussie consumer more cautious could temper the pace of RBA rate hikes and put pressure on the AUD. Chart 15Watch The Relative Performance Of Bank Shares Watch The Relative Performance Of Bank Shares Watch The Relative Performance Of Bank Shares Chart 16The RBA Might Be Relatively Dovish in 2023 The RBA Might Be Relatively Dovish in 2023 The RBA Might Be Relatively Dovish in 2023 A Few Trades Ideas Australia provides a lot of the commodities countries need and want in today’s paradigm. That is bullish. Yet exposure to China is a clear risk that investors need to factor into investment decisions. Our trading strategy is as follows: We would buy AUD/USD at 0.665 cents. In our view, it could undershoot this level but will be an attractive longer-term buy. The risks to the housing market are higher in New Zealand compared to Australia (Chart 17). Terms of trade also likely to favor the Aussie versus the kiwi (Chart 18). As such, bet on long AUD/NZD trades. Chart 17AUD Can Withstand Higher Rates Relative To NZD AUD/NZD Is Attractive AUD/NZD Is Attractive Chart 18Terms Of Trade Will Drive AUD Higher Relative To NZD AUD/NZD Is Attractive AUD/NZD Is Attractive AUD/JPY will benefit from a rally in risk assets but is stretched. Thus, from a sentiment perspective, we are only neutral (Chart 19). Economic surprises could also likely underwhelm in Australia relative to the unloved Japanese market (Chart 20). Chart 19AUD/JPY Is Stretched AUD/JPY Is Stretched AUD/JPY Is Stretched Chart 20AUD/JPY Is Stretched AUD/JPY Is Stretched AUD/JPY Is Stretched   Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary

Listen to a short summary of this report.     Executive Summary Housing Activity Should Start To Stabilize By The End Of The Year Housing Activity Should Start To Stabilize By The End Of The Year Housing Activity Should Start To Stabilize By The End Of The Year Home prices in the US are set to decline, almost certainly in real terms and probably in nominal terms as well. Unlike in past episodes, the impact on construction from a drop in home prices should be limited, given that the US has not seen pervasive overbuilding. The drag on US consumption should also be somewhat muted. In contrast to what happened during the mid-2000s, outstanding balances on home equity lines of credit declined during the pandemic housing boom. US banks are on a strong footing today. This should limit the collateral damage from falling home prices on the financial system. Outside the US, the housing outlook is more challenging. This is especially the case in smaller developed economies such as Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Sweden. It is also the case in China, where the property market may be on the verge of a Japanese-style multi-decade slide. ​​​​​ Bottom Line: Softening housing markets around the world will weigh on growth. However, against the backdrop of high inflation, that may not be an unambiguously bad thing. We expect global equities to rise into year end, and then retreat in 2023. The Canary in the Coalmine On the eve of the Global Financial Crisis, Ed Leamer delivered a paper at Jackson Hole with the prescient title “Housing IS the Business Cycle.” Leamer convincingly argued that monetary policy primarily operates through the housing market, and that a decline in residential investment is by far the best warning sign of a recession. Table 1 provides supporting evidence for Leamer’s conclusion. It shows that residential investment is not a particularly important driver of GDP growth during non-recessionary quarters but is the only main expenditure component that regularly turns down in the lead-up to recessions. Table 1A Decline In Residential Investment Typically Precedes Recessions The Risks From Housing The Risks From Housing US real residential investment was essentially flat in Q1 but then contracted at an annualized pace of 16% in Q2, shaving 0.83 percentage points off Q2 GDP growth in the process. The Atlanta Fed GDPNow model forecasts that real residential investment will shrink by 22% in Q3, largely reflecting the steep drop in housing starts and home sales observed over the past few months. Chart 1Housing Activity Should Start To Stabilize By The End Of The Year Housing Activity Should Start To Stabilize By The End Of The Year Housing Activity Should Start To Stabilize By The End Of The Year The recent decline in construction activity is a worrying indicator. Nevertheless, there are several reasons to think that the downturn in housing may not herald an imminent recession. First, the lag between when housing begins to weaken and when the economy falls into recession can be quite long. For example, residential investment hit a high of 6.7% of GDP in Q4 of 2005. However, the Great Recession did not start until Q4 of 2007, when residential investment had already receded to 4.2% of GDP. The S&P 500 peaked during the same quarter. Second, recent weakness in housing activity largely reflects the lagged effects of the spike in mortgage rates earlier this year. To the extent that mortgage rates have been broadly flat since April, history suggests that housing activity should start to stabilize by the end of this year (Chart 1). Third, unlike in the mid-2000s, there is no glut of homes in the US today: Residential investment reached 4.8% of GDP last year, about where it was during the late 1990s, prior to the start of the housing bubble (Chart 2). The construction of new homes has failed to keep up with household formation for the past 15 years (Chart 3). As a result, the homeowner vacancy rate stands at 0.8%, the lowest on record (Chart 4). Chart 2Residential Investment Is Well Below Levels Seen During The Housing Bubble Residential Investment Is Well Below Levels Seen During The Housing Bubble Residential Investment Is Well Below Levels Seen During The Housing Bubble Chart 3Home Construction Has Fallen Short Of Household Formation For The Past 15 Years Home Construction Has Fallen Short Of Household Formation For The Past 15 Years Home Construction Has Fallen Short Of Household Formation For The Past 15 Years Chart 4The Homeowner Vacancy Rate Is At Record Lows The Homeowner Vacancy Rate Is At Record Lows The Homeowner Vacancy Rate Is At Record Lows While new home inventories have risen, this mainly reflects an increase in the number of homes under construction. The inventory of finished homes is still 40% below pre-pandemic levels (Chart 5). The inventory of existing homes available for sale is also quite low, which suggests that a rising supply of new homes could be depleted more quickly than in the past. Chart 5While The Number Of Homes Under Construction Increased, The Inventory Of Newly Built And Existing Homes Remains Low While The Number Of Homes Under Construction Increased, The Inventory Of Newly Built And Existing Homes Remains Low While The Number Of Homes Under Construction Increased, The Inventory Of Newly Built And Existing Homes Remains Low Why Was Housing Supply Slow to Rise? In real terms, the Case-Shiller index is now 5% above its 2006 peak (Chart 6). Why didn’t housing construction respond more strongly to rising home prices during the pandemic? Part of the answer is that the memory of the housing bust curtailed the homebuilders’ willingness to expand operations. Supply shortages also limited the ability of homebuilders to construct new homes in a timely fashion. Chart 7 shows that the producer price index for construction materials increased by nearly 50% between January 2020 and July 2022, outstripping the rise in the overall PPI index. Chart 6Real House Prices Are Above Their 2006 Peak Real House Prices Are Above Their 2006 Peak Real House Prices Are Above Their 2006 Peak Chart 7Producer Prices For Construction Materials Shot Up During The Pandemic Producer Prices For Construction Materials Shot Up During The Pandemic Producer Prices For Construction Materials Shot Up During The Pandemic Chart 8Constraints On Home Building Caused The Housing Market To Clear Mainly Through Higher Prices Rather Than Increased Construction The Risks From Housing The Risks From Housing The lack of building materials and qualified construction workers caused the supply curve for housing to become increasingly steep (or, in the parlance of economics, inelastic). To make matters worse, pandemic-related lockdowns probably caused the supply curve to shift inwards, prompting homebuilders to curb output for any given level of home prices. As Chart 8 illustrates, this meant that the increase in housing demand during the pandemic was largely absorbed through higher home prices rather than through increased output.   A Bittersweet Outcome Chart 9Unlike During The Great Recession, Prices For New And Existing Homes Should Fall In Tandem This Time Around Unlike During The Great Recession, Prices For New And Existing Homes Should Fall In Tandem This Time Around Unlike During The Great Recession, Prices For New And Existing Homes Should Fall In Tandem This Time Around The discussion above presents a good news/bad news story about the state of the US housing market. On the one hand, with seasonally-adjusted housing starts now below where they were in January 2020, construction activity is unlikely to fall significantly from current levels. On the other hand, as the supply curve for housing shifts back out, and the demand curve shifts back in towards pre-pandemic levels, home prices are bound to weaken. We expect US home prices to decline, almost certainly in real terms and probably in nominal terms as well. Unlike during the Great Recession, when a wave of foreclosures caused the prices of existing homes to fall more than new homes, the decline in prices across both categories is likely to be similar this time around (Chart 9).   The Impact of Falling Home Prices To what extent will lower home prices imperil the US economy? Beyond the adverse impact of lower prices on construction activity, falling home prices can depress aggregate demand through a negative wealth effect as well as by putting strain on the banking system. The good news is that both these channels are less operative today than they were prior to the GFC. Perhaps because home prices rose so rapidly over the past two years, homeowners did not get the chance to spend their windfall. The personal savings rate soared during the pandemic and has only recently fallen below its pre-pandemic average (Chart 10). Households are still sitting on about $2.2 trillion in excess savings, most of which is parked in highly liquid bank accounts. Outstanding balances on home equity lines of credit actually fell during the pandemic, sinking to a 21-year low of 1.3% of GDP in Q2 2022 (Chart 11). All this suggests that the coming decline in home prices will not suppress consumption as much as it did in the past. Chart 10Household Savings Surged During The Pandemic Household Savings Surged During The Pandemic Household Savings Surged During The Pandemic Chart 11Despite Higher Home Prices, Households Are Not Using Their Homes As ATMs Despite Higher Home Prices, Households Are Not Using Their Homes As ATMs Despite Higher Home Prices, Households Are Not Using Their Homes As ATMs The drop in home prices during the GFC generated a vicious circle where falling home prices led to more foreclosures and fire sales, leading to even lower home prices. Such a feedback loop is unlikely to emerge today. As judged by FICO scores, lenders have been quite prudent since the crisis (Chart 12). The aggregate loan-to-value ratio for US household real estate holdings stands near a low of 30%, down from 45% in the leadup to the GFC (Chart 13). Banks are also much better capitalized than they were in the past (Chart 14). Chart 12FICO Scores For Residential Mortgages Have Improved Considerably Since The Pre-GFC Housing Bubble The Risks From Housing The Risks From Housing Chart 13This Is Not 2007 This Is Not 2007 This Is Not 2007 Chart 14US Banks Are Better Capitalized Than Before The GFC US Banks Are Better Capitalized Than Before The GFC US Banks Are Better Capitalized Than Before The GFC The final thing to note is that home prices tend to fall fairly slowly. It took six years for prices to bottom following the housing bubble, and this was in the context of a severe recession. Thus, the negative wealth effect from falling home prices will probably not become pronounced until 2024 or later. A Grimmer Picture Abroad The housing outlook is more challenging in a number of economies outside of the US. While home prices have increased significantly in the US, they have risen much more in smaller developed economies such as Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Sweden (Chart 15). My colleague, Jonathan LaBerge, has also argued that overbuilding appears to be more of a problem outside the US (Chart 16). Chart 15Rising Rates Will Weigh On Developed Economies With Pricey Housing Markets Rising Rates Will Weigh On Developed Economies With Pricey Housing Markets Rising Rates Will Weigh On Developed Economies With Pricey Housing Markets Chart 16Canada And Several Other DM Countries Have Overbuilt Homes Since The Global Financial Crisis Canada And Several Other DM Countries Have Overbuilt Homes Since The Global Financial Crisis Canada And Several Other DM Countries Have Overbuilt Homes Since The Global Financial Crisis Chart 17Slightly More Than Half Of Canadians Opted For Variable Rate Mortgages Over The Past 12 Months Slightly More Than Half Of Canadians Opted For Variable Rate Mortgages Over The Past 12 Months Slightly More Than Half Of Canadians Opted For Variable Rate Mortgages Over The Past 12 Months The structure of some overseas mortgage markets heightens housing risks. In Canada, for example, more than half of homebuyers chose a variable-rate mortgage over the last 12 months (Chart 17). At present, about one-third of the total stock of mortgages are variable rate compared to less than 20% prior to the pandemic. Moreover, unlike in the US where 30-year mortgages are the norm, fixed-rate mortgages in Canada typically reset every five years. Thus, as the Bank of Canada hikes rates, mortgage payments will rise quite quickly.   China: Following Japan’s Path? In the EM space, China stands out as having the most vulnerable housing market. The five major cities with the lowest rental yields in the world are all in China (Chart 18). Home sales, starts, and completions have all tumbled in recent months (Chart 19). The bonds of Chinese property developers are trading at highly distressed levels (Chart 20). Chart 18Chinese Real Estate Shows Vulnerabilities… The Risks From Housing The Risks From Housing Chart 19...Activity And Prices Have Been Falling... ...Activity And Prices Have Been Falling... ...Activity And Prices Have Been Falling... Chart 20...And the Bonds of Property Developers Are Trading At Distressed Levels ...And the Bonds of Property Developers Are Trading At Distressed Levels ...And the Bonds of Property Developers Are Trading At Distressed Levels In many respects, the Chinese housing market resembles the Japanese market in the early 1990s. Just as was the case in Japan 30 years ago, Chinese household growth has turned negative (Chart 21). The collapse in the birth rate since the start of the pandemic will only exacerbate this problem. The number of births is poised to fall below 10 million this year, down more than 30% from 2019 (Chart 22). Chart 21China Faces A Structural Decline In The Demand For Housing China Faces A Structural Decline In The Demand For Housing China Faces A Structural Decline In The Demand For Housing Chart 22China's Baby Bust China's Baby Bust China's Baby Bust A few years ago, when inflation was subdued and talk of secular stagnation was all the rage, a downturn in the Chinese property sector would have been a major cause for concern. Things are different today. Global inflation is running high, and to the extent that investors are worried about a recession, it is because they think central banks will need to raise rates aggressively to curb inflation. A weaker Chinese property market would help restrain commodity prices, easing inflationary pressures in the process. As long as the Chinese banking system does not implode – which is highly unlikely given that the major banks are all state-owned – global investors might actually welcome a modest decline in Chinese property investment. Investment Conclusions The downturn in the US housing market suggests that we are in the late stages of the business-cycle expansion. However, given the long lags between when housing begins to weaken and when a recession ensues, it is probable that the US will only enter a recession in 2024. To the extent the stock market typically peaks six months before the outset of a recession, equities may still have further to run, at least in the near term. As we discussed last week, we recommend a neutral allocation on global stocks over a 12-month horizon but would overweight equities over a shorter-term 6-month horizon. In relative terms, the US housing market is more resilient than most other housing markets. We initiated a trade going long Canadian government bonds relative to US bonds on June 30, when the 10-year yield in Canada was 21 basis points above the comparable US yield. Today, the yield on both bonds is almost the same. We expect Canadian bonds to continue to outperform, given the more severe constraints the Bank of Canada faces in raising rates. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Follow me on     LinkedIn & Twitter Global Investment Strategy View Matrix The Risks From Housing The Risks From Housing Special Trade Recommendations Current MacroQuant Model Scores The Risks From Housing The Risks From Housing      

Listen to a short summary of this report.       Executive Summary A Tremendous Inflow Into US Government Bonds A Tremendous Inflow Into US Government Bonds A Tremendous Inflow Into US Government Bonds Multiple frameworks exist for managing currencies. These include forecasting growth differentials, watching central banks, gauging terms of trade and balance of payment dynamics or even assigning a probability to the occurrence of black swans. For us, the most useful tool has been to simply track portfolio flows. In today’s paradigm, portfolio flows into US equities are rapidly dwindling, while those flowing into fixed income have picked up meaningfully. Gauging what happens next will be critical for the dollar call (Feature chart). The Fed is being viewed as the most credible central bank to curb inflation. As a result, US rates have risen more than in other markets. This has also pushed valuation and sentiment of the dollar to very elevated levels. If inflation peaks and the world economy achieves a soft landing, downside in the dollar will be substantial. On sentiment, being a contrarian can make you a victim, but when the stars are aligned where valuation, sentiment and the appropriate macro analysis point towards a single direction, our framework proves extremely useful. In a nutshell, many currencies, especially the euro, are already pricing in a nasty recession into their respective economies. If a recession does occur, they could undershoot. If one does not, they are poised for a coiled spring rebound. Bottom Line: Tactical investors should be neutral to overweight the dollar in the near term, as the probability of a recession rises. Longer-term investors should be slowly accumulating assets in countries where fundamentals make sense, and their currencies are deeply undervalued. Feature The real neutral rate of interest in the US is difficult to estimate ex ante, but Chart 1 highlights that the real Fed Funds rate is well below many estimates of neutral. In a world where inflation has become a widespread problem, and a few economies (like the US) are overheating, markets have moved to test the credibility of their respective central banks. The consensus has been that the Federal Reserve will be the most credible in taming runaway inflation by being able to raise rates faster than other central banks (Chart 2). This is especially the case as many European economies remain at firing range from the Russia-Ukraine conflict and, as such, face more supply-side driven inflation. Chart 1The Fed Has Scope To Tighten Further The Fed Has Scope To Tighten Further The Fed Has Scope To Tighten Further Chart 2Interest Rates Have Moved In Favor Of The Dollar Interest Rates Have Moved In Favor Of The Dollar Interest Rates Have Moved In Favor Of The Dollar The typical pattern for the dollar is that it tends to rise when growth is falling and inflation is also subsiding, which triggers tremendous haven flows into US Treasurys. Right now, inflation remains strong but growth is rolling over, which has historically painted a mixed picture for the dollar (Chart 3). Chart 3The Dollar Rises On Falling Growth A Lens For Managing Currencies In Today’s Paradigm A Lens For Managing Currencies In Today’s Paradigm What happens next is critical. The dollar tends to rise 10%-15% during downturns. We are already there. The DXY index is up 8.8% this year, and up 16.3% from the trough last year. European currencies like the SEK and the EUR have already priced in a recession as deep as in 2020. If this indeed proves to be the case, commodity currencies will be next, which could push the DXY to fresh highs. But as we outline below, even in a pessimistic scenario, a systematic approach to looking at currencies warns against fresh bets in favor of the dollar. Inflation And Central Banks One of the key themes we outlined in our outlook for this year is that inflation is a global problem, and not centric to the US. So, while supply side factors have had an outsized effect on energy deficient countries like Germany, the UK, Sweden and, to an extent Japan, inflation is also well above target in Canada, Australia, Norway, New Zealand, and many other developed and emerging market countries. In fact, the inflation impulse is slowing in the US, relative to a basket of G10 countries (Chart 4). Related Report  Foreign Exchange StrategyLessons From Fed Interest Rate Hikes Falling inflation will be a welcome relief valve from the tension in markets over much tighter financial conditions. It will also lower the probability of a global recession. For currency markets however, the starting point is that the market has priced the Fed to continue leading the tightening cycle until something breaks. If inflation does subside, then hawkish expectations by the Fed will be heavily priced out of the curve, which will remove a key source of support for the greenback. From a chartist point of view, the dollar has already overshot the level of rates the markets expect from the Fed, relative to more dovish central banks (Chart 5). This suggests a hefty safety premium is already embedded in the dollar. Chart 4US Inflation Is Peaking, Relative To Other ##br##Economies US Inflation Is Peaking, Relative To Other Economies US Inflation Is Peaking, Relative To Other Economies Chart 5The Dollar Has Overshot The Path Implied By Interest Rates The Dollar Has Overshot The Path Implied By Interest Rates The Dollar Has Overshot The Path Implied By Interest Rates The Dollar And Global Growth If the Fed and other central banks tame the inflation genie, then we will have achieved a soft landing. The dollar has tended to track the path of the US yield curve, and a flattening usually underscores longer-term worries about a recession (Chart 6). A steepening curve will signal mission accomplished. In the view of the Foreign Exchange Strategy service, recession risks could be relatively balanced. While major central banks have been tightening policy (the US and most of the G10), China, a big whale in terms of its monetary policy impact, has been easing monetary conditions. Chart 7 highlights that most procyclical currencies have tracked the Chinese credit impulse tick for tick. Bond yields in China are near the lows for the year. Unless China enters another economic down-leg in growth that matches the 2015 slowdown, we might just witness a rotation in economic vigor from the US towards other economies, led by China, allowing the world to achieve a soft landing. Chart 6The Dollar Is Tracking The US Yield ##br##Curve The Dollar Is Tracking The US Yield Curve The Dollar Is Tracking The US Yield Curve Chart 7Commodity Currencies Are Tracking The Chinese Credit Impulse Commodity Currencies Are Tracking The Chinese Credit Impulse Commodity Currencies Are Tracking The Chinese Credit Impulse   In the currency world, typical recessionary indicators are not yet flashing red. Cross-currency basis swaps remain well contained, suggesting dollar funding pressures, or that the ability to service dollar debt abroad remains healthy. The Fed’s liquidity swap lines, which allow foreign central banks to obtain dollar funding, also remain untapped (Chart 8). That said, currency put-call ratios are rising, suggesting the cost of obtaining downside protection has increased. Chart 8The Fed"s Recession Models Are Still Sanguine The Fed"s Recession Models Are Still Sanguine The Fed"s Recession Models Are Still Sanguine The Dollar And Portfolio Flows Aside from hedging against downside protection for the EUR, the AUD or even the CAD, one driver of dollar strength has been huge portfolio inflows into US Treasurys (Chart 9). That has occurred while equity inflows have collapsed. Admittedly, this took us by surprise since by monitoring the big Treasury whales (Japan and China), holdings have been rolling over for quite some time (Chart 10). This has also occurred amidst an accumulation of speculative short positions on US Treasurys. Chart 9A Tremendous Inflow Into US Government Bonds A Tremendous Inflow Into US Government Bonds A Tremendous Inflow Into US Government Bonds Chart 10Japan And China Remain Treasury Sellers Japan And China Remain Treasury Sellers Japan And China Remain Treasury Sellers Historically, bond inflows are the driver of portfolio flows into the US, but the equity market has also dictated the trend in the dollar from time to time. Overall, the basic balance in the US, sum of all portfolio flows, has done a good job capturing turning points in the dollar. Our focus on equity flows this time around is due to the conundrum the US faces. Relative profits tend to drive the performance of relative stock prices, and US profits tend to be more defensive – rising on a relative basis when bond yields and commodity prices are collapsing and falling otherwise (Chart 11). As such, the rise in bond yields has already derated US equity multiples but profits have held up remarkably well. An underperformance in US equities during a downturn has been unprecedented with a strong dollar since the end of the Bretton Woods system. So should a market shakeout lead to a violent rotation out of US equities, the profile for the dollar could be a mirror image of what we witnessed in 2008 or even 2020. The conundrum for bond inflows is that according to traditional measures, real rates in the US remain deeply negative, but they have improved significantly under the lens of market-based measures (Chart 12). This partly explains the dollar overshoot. A scenario of faster growth outside the US could see real rates improve more quickly abroad. Chart 11US Profits Have Held Up Remarkably Well US Profits Have Held Up Remarkably Well US Profits Have Held Up Remarkably Well Chart 12Market-Based Real Yields In The US Have Improved A Lens For Managing Currencies In Today’s Paradigm A Lens For Managing Currencies In Today’s Paradigm A final point: managing currencies is about anticipating the next macroeconomic driver. In our view, this could be fears about balance of payments dynamics, especially as the world becomes marginally less globalized. Since the 1980s, we have never had a configuration where the dollar is very overvalued, US real rates are extremely low, and the trade deficit is near a record high (meaning it needs to be financed externally). A bet on US exceptionalism has a natural limit, as competitiveness abroad is improving tremendously vis-à-vis many of the goods and services the US exports. Currencies And Valuations Currencies should revert to fair value. The question then becomes "which fair value should they mean-revert to?" In our view, simple works best – purchasing power parity values. A simple chart shows that selling the dollar when it is expensive and buying it when cheap according to its purchasing power generates alpha over the long term (Chart 13). In A Simple Trading Rule For FX Valuation Enthusiasts, we showed that a shorter-term trading strategy also based on valuation adds value. Granted, the dollar started to become overvalued in 2015, but it is now sitting close to a historical extreme. A fair assessment is that currencies will revert to their fair value, but that takes time (3-5 years). As such, longer-term investors should be slowly accumulating assets in countries where fundamentals make sense, and their currencies are deeply undervalued. These include Japan, Australia, Sweden and even Mexico (Chart 14). Chart 13The Dollar Is Overvalued On a PPP Basis The Dollar Is Overvalued On a PPP Basis The Dollar Is Overvalued On a PPP Basis Chart 14The Real Effective Exchange Rate For The Dollar Is High A Lens For Managing Currencies In Today’s Paradigm A Lens For Managing Currencies In Today’s Paradigm The Dollar And Momentum There is quite simply a dearth of dollar bears. Internally at BCA, a lot of strategists who see more downside to US (and global) equities, simply cannot be negative on the dollar. Within the foreign exchange strategy, we have been short the DXY index since 104.8, and are sticking with that bet on a 12-18-month horizon. For risk management purposes, our stop loss is at 107. First, we are seeing record long positions by speculators (Chart 15). Fielding clients, or even the media, no one wants to be a dollar bear when the Fed is clearly an inflation vigilante. If inflation keeps surprising to the upside, then speculators will keep bidding up the dollar. But it is also fair to say that most investors who want to be long the greenback at this point already have that position on.  Our intermediate-term indicator, a combination of technical variables, also warns against initiating dollar-long positions at the current juncture (Chart 16). This series mean-reverts quite quickly, so it does not dictate the trend in the dollar, but warns of capitulation extremes. Chart 15Speculators Are Very Long The Dollar Speculators Are Very Long The Dollar Speculators Are Very Long The Dollar Chart 16Technical Dollar Indicators Are Overbought Technical Dollar Indicators Are Overbought Technical Dollar Indicators Are Overbought Finally, the dollar has been used as a bet on rising volatility. The dollar is well above levels that a correction in the S&P 500 index would dictate (Chart 17). It has also moved in tandem with bond volatility (Chart 18). This suggests much of equity downside risk has been priced into the dollar. Chart 17The Dollar Has More Than Compensated For The Drawdown In Equities The Dollar Has More Than Compensated For The Drawdown In Equities The Dollar Has More Than Compensated For The Drawdown In Equities Chart 18The Dollar Is Tracking ##br##Volatility The Dollar Is Tracking Volatility The Dollar Is Tracking Volatility Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary

Executive Summary Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc  Volatility in FX markets is likely to remain elevated, as witnessed by the reaction of a full circle of central bank meetings this week.Policy convergence remains a good bet for interest rate curves and currency pairs. The SNB surprised markets by raising interest rates by 50 bps, to -0.25%, the first hike since 2007.Higher volatility will continue to buoy the Swiss franc in the short run.Structural appreciation in the franc is also likely over the coming decades (Feature Chart). Swiss stocks often perform well during economic downturns, but they are not particularly cheap, and are vulnerable to higher interest rates. Investors should only overweight Swiss stocks if they expect more significant downside to global stocks.Valuation favors the franc versus the dollar. However, EUR/CHF and GBP/CHF are closer to fair value. CHF/JPY is expensive; hence, the yen is a better hedge for downside economic surprises. Go short CHF/JPY as a trade.BCA’s Foreign Exchange Strategy was short CHF/SEK at 10.2 with stop loss at 10.5. That stop was hit overnight, triggering a loss of -3.3%. Stand aside for now.Bottom Line: Favor the franc over the short term against other pro-cyclical currencies, with a view to downgrade CHF when it becomes evident that economic growth is bottoming. Any further bout of Swiss equity outperformance, prompted by global risk aversion, offers an attractive selling opportunity versus Eurozone stocks.Feature Chart 1The SNB Has Capitulated To Rising Inflation The SNB Has Capitulated To Rising Inflation The SNB Has Capitulated To Rising Inflation  Volatility in FX markets is likely to remain elevated. This week, the Fed delivered its first 75 bps interest rate hike since 1994. It also increased its expected year-end level for the Fed Funds rate to 3.4% from 1.9%, and to 3.8% from 3.4% at the end of 2023. The FX market had been warming up to a hawkish surprise, but the dollar surged on the news, hitting a fresh two-decade high of 105.5, before later reversing gains.Meanwhile, the European Central Bank (ECB) held an emergency meeting on Wednesday, to try to mitigate the rise in Italian yields, which hit as high as 4.2% on Tuesday, or 243 bps over German 10-year yields. The subsequent statement released by the Governing Council offered no concrete details. Yes, the reinvestments of the proceeds from maturing debt in the Pandemic Emergency Purchase Program (PEPP) will flow mostly to peripheral markets, but investors want clarity on the nature of the long-awaited policy plan to tackle fragmentation risk in the Euro Area. As a result, peripheral bond markets will remain fragile until a bold program comes to fruition.To cement currency volatility this week, SNB Governor Thomas Jordan surprised markets by raising interest rates by 50 bps in Switzerland, to -0.25%, the first hike since the Global Financial Crisis (Chart 1). The negative interest rate threshold for sight deposits was also lowered, a move encouraging banks to pack reserves at the SNB. The Bank of England also raised interest rates in line with market expectations. The move initially disappointed GBP bulls, but sterling is holding above our 1.20 floor.An environment of monetary policy uncertainty, rising recession risks in response to high inflation, and the potential for central bank policy mistakes bodes well for safe-haven assets. In Europe, the market with the strongest defensive profile is Switzerland. In this report, we address whether investors should bet on continued appreciation of the franc and an outperformance of Swiss stocks, especially now that the SNB has turned hawkish.Switzerland Versus The WorldGlobal economic growth is slowing and a small/open economy like Switzerland’s has not been spared. The KOF economic barometer, a key leading indicator for Swiss GDP growth, has collapsed over the past twelve months from 144 to 97 as global industrial activity decelerated (Chart 2). Despite softening growth, global inflation refuses to decline, forcing central banks worldwide to lean into the slowdown. This threatens to cut the post-pandemic business cycle expansion short. Chart 2The SNB Is Tightening Into A Slowing Economy The SNB Is Tightening Into A Slowing Economy The SNB Is Tightening Into A Slowing Economy  Surprisingly, the Swiss economy is generally performing better than the rest of Europe. Historically, Swiss economic performance is procyclical due to the large share of exports within its GDP. Hence, a slowdown in global manufacturing often creates a large threat to Swiss growth. Going forward, can the Swiss economy diverge from that of the rest of the world (Chart 3)? Such a divergence is not probable, but a few factors will protect the Swiss economy:Switzerland still has one of the lowest policy rates in the G10, even after today’s 50bps interest rate increase. This has tremendously helped ease monetary conditions. Our monetary gauge is at its most accommodative level in over two decades (Chart 4). Chart 3The Swiss Economy Is Procyclical The Swiss Economy Is Procyclical The Swiss Economy Is Procyclical   Chart 4Swiss Monetary Conditions Are Still Accommodative Swiss Monetary Conditions Are Still Accommodative Swiss Monetary Conditions Are Still Accommodative  Swiss inflation remains the lowest in the G10 outside Japan. In Switzerland, the main driver of price increases has been goods, while services inflation remains subdued. Consequently, the SNB has been tolerating an appreciating franc to temper imported inflation (Chart 5), while keeping domestic borrowing costs at very accommodative levels. In its updated forecasts, the SNB now expects a -0.25% interest rate to allow Swiss inflation to moderate to 1.9% in 2023 and 1.6% in 2024. Chart 5Swiss Inflation Is Surprising To The Upside Swiss Inflation Is Surprising To The Upside Swiss Inflation Is Surprising To The Upside  Part of the reason Switzerland has low inflation has been the tremendous productivity gains, especially relative to its trading partners (Chart 6). Swiss income-per-capita is elevated, but wage growth has lagged output gains, which limits the risk of a wage-inflation spiral. It is notable that part-time employment continues to dominate job gains, implying that the need for precautionary savings will remain high in Switzerland. Chart 6A Productivity Profile For Switzerland A Productivity Profile For Switzerland A Productivity Profile For Switzerland  Higher productivity growth and the elevated national savings leave their footprint on the trade data. The Swiss trade balance is hitting fresh highs, unlike Europe or Japan (Chart 7). This could potentially create a problem for the Swiss economy as it puts upward pressure on the CHF at a time when global manufacturing output is slowing. However, Switzerland specializes in high value-added exports with an elevated degree of complexity, that stand early in global supply chains. These type of goods are likely to remain in high demand in a global environment marked by supply-chain bottlenecks and high-capacity utilization.  Chart 7Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc  Finally, Switzerland does not import energy to fulfill its electricity production. Hydropower accounts for roughly 61.4% of electricity generation, followed by nuclear power at 28.5%. This has partially insulated Switzerland from the energy shock hurting economic activity and trade balances in the EU. For example, German electricity generation is 28.8% coal and 14.7% natural gas.Bottom Line: The Swiss economy is reopening and is relatively insulated from the Russia-Ukraine conflict. This limits to some degree how closely Switzerland will track the global and European economic slowdown. It creates a departure from the traditional pro-cyclicality of the Swiss economy.The SNB, The SARON Curve, And The Swiss FrancIf the Swiss economy surprises to the upside, the case for the SNB to tolerate a rising franc becomes even stronger. The pace of foreign exchange reserve accumulation is already decelerating (Chart 8). Governor Thomas Jordan has been very clear: as global prices rise, the fair value of the franc is also rising, which implies a willingness to tolerate currency strength. In a purchasing power parity framework, higher external inflation makes Swiss goods relatively cheaper. This allows foreigners to bid up the currency.Even with today’s updated pricing, the SNB is still expected to remain among the most dovish central banks in the G10 (Chart 9). If inflationary pressures prove sticky, the SNB will step up its hawkish rhetoric. If inflationary fears subside, then global rates will fall as well, which has usually been a boon for the franc. More specifically, this would be negative for the EUR/CHF cross (Chart 10). Chart 8Less Intervention By The SNB Less Intervention By The SNB Less Intervention By The SNB   Chart 9The SARON Curve Has Adjusted Higher The SARON Curve Has Adjusted Higher The SARON Curve Has Adjusted Higher   Chart 10EUR/CHF And Bund Yields Can Continue To Diverge EUR/CHF And Bund Yields Can Continue To Diverge EUR/CHF And Bund Yields Can Continue To Diverge  The Swiss economy can tolerate an appreciating CHF, but can it withstand higher interest rates? We believe so. Switzerland is a net creditor nation, but its domestic non-financial debt is also extremely elevated. Thus, the Swiss economy is vulnerable to higher rates, especially the housing market (Chart 11). Nonetheless, internal adjustments will soften the blow and increase affordability. Of note, property speculation in Switzerland has decreased in response to macroprudential measures. Growth in rental housing prices, which usually constitute the bulk of investment homes, has collapsed, but the price of owner-occupied homes has proven more robust (Chart 12). A cap on the percentage of secondary homes in any Canton as well as tighter lending standards have also helped. In a renewed update to its Financial Stability Report, Fritz Zurbrügg, Vice Chairman of the Governing Board, suggests that Swiss banks are well capitalized, especially given the recent reactivation of the countercyclical capital buffer. Chart 11Higher Rates Are A Risk For Swiss Real Estate Higher Rates Are A Risk For Swiss Real Estate Higher Rates Are A Risk For Swiss Real Estate   Chart 12Some Adjustment Already In Investment Home Prices Some Adjustment Already In Investment Home Prices Some Adjustment Already In Investment Home Prices  In the very near term, demographics might also be a tailwind. The pandemic limited immigration to Switzerland, but the working-age population is rebounding anew (Chart 13), which will create a cushion under housing and support domestic demand. Chart 13A Small Demographic Tailwind For Home Prices A Small Demographic Tailwind For Home Prices A Small Demographic Tailwind For Home Prices  Stronger aggregate demand in an inflationary world will justify the need for less monetary accommodation. In a nutshell, the SNB is likely to continue walking the path of “least regrets” like most central banks, by tightening monetary policy to meet its 2% inflation mandate, but pausing if economic conditions warrant.The currency has historically been used as a key tool for calibrating financial conditions. From a fundamental perspective, our PPP models suggest the franc is quite cheap versus the dollar but at fair value versus the euro and sterling. This is echoed by Governor Jordan, who no longer views the franc as expensive. Our models adjusts the consumption basket in Switzerland for an apples-to-apples comparison across both the UK and the eurozone (Chart 14). Chart 14AA CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP   Chart 14BA CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP  Finally, hedging costs for shorting the franc against the dollar have risen substantially (Chart 15). As such, any short bets on the franc are likely being placed naked. If the Fed ends up tempering its pace of rate hikes next year in response to weaker US activity, short-covering activity is likely to accentuate any pre-existing strength in the CHF. Chart 15Hedging Costs For USD/CHF Carry Trades Have Risen Hedging Costs Are Prohibitive Hedging Costs For USD/CHF Carry Trades Have Risen Hedging Costs Are Prohibitive Hedging Costs For USD/CHF Carry Trades Have Risen Hedging Costs Are Prohibitive  Bottom Line: The franc is undervalued against the dollar, and a good hedge against a rise in volatility versus other procyclical currencies. This places the franc in a good “heads I win, tails I don’t loose too much” bet. Swiss interest rates are also likely to climb higher. However, because the franc will do the bulk of the monetary tightening, the SNB is likely to lag the expectations now embedded in the SARON curve.What About Swiss Equities?Despite the cyclical nature of the Swiss economy, Swiss equities are extremely defensive. Swiss stocks have little to do with the domestic economy and are mostly a collection of large multinationals, dominated by the healthcare and consumer staples sectors, which together account for roughly 60% of the Swiss MSCI benchmark.This defensive attribute has created its own problem for Swiss equities. Relative to the Eurozone, the Swiss market has moved massively ahead of profitability, and it is now more expensive than at the apex of the European debt crisis in 2012 (Chart 16). Moreover, the jump in German yields is becoming increasingly problematic for Swiss stocks that historically perform poorly when global interest rates are rising (Chart 17). Chart 16Swiss Stocks Are Expensive Swiss Stocks Are Expensive Swiss Stocks Are Expensive   Chart 17A Lost Tailwind A Lost Tailwind A Lost Tailwind  In the near term, Swiss equities will only be able to defy the gravitational pull created by demanding valuations and higher yields if global risk aversion remains elevated. However, once global stocks find a floor and Italian spreads begin to narrow, Swiss stocks are likely to underperform massively (Chart 18). It could take a few more weeks before the BTP/Bund spreads narrow as the recent ECB announcement was rather tepid. However, the ECB holding an emergency meeting and issuing a formal statement addressing the problem facing peripheral bond markets suggests that a formal program designed to manage fragmentation risk will emerge before the end of the summer.Beyond their defensive attributes, Swiss stocks also correlate to the Quality Factor. The robust performance of this factor since the turn of the millennium, in Europe and globally, has allowed the Swiss market to greatly outperform Eurozone equities (Chart 19). However, the Quality Factor has begun to underperform, which indicates that the Swiss market is losing another of its underpinnings. Chart 18Near-term, Follow Risk Aversion Near-term, Follow Risk Aversion Near-term, Follow Risk Aversion   Chart 19Swiss Stocks Are About Quality Swiss Stocks Are About Quality Swiss Stocks Are About Quality  These observations imply that over the next 12 to 18 months, Swiss equities will underperform their Euro Area counterparts. Materials and consumer staples stand out as the two sectors with the most extended valuations relative to their Euro Area competitors, especially since their relative performances have become dissociated from relative profits (Chart 20). They should carry maximum underweights relative to their European counterparts. The healthcare sector is Switzerland’s largest market weight. It is not as expensive relative to the Eurozone as the materials and consumer staples sectors, but it carries enough of a premium that investors should still underweight this sector relative to its eurozone competitor (Chart 21). Chart 20Dangerous Setup For Swiss Materials and Staples Dangerous Setup For Swiss Materials and Staples Dangerous Setup For Swiss Materials and Staples   Chart 21The Swiss Heavyweight Is Becoming Pricey The Swiss Heavyweight Is Becoming Pricey The Swiss Heavyweight Is Becoming Pricey  Bottom Line: The defensive nature of the Swiss market has allowed for a large outperformance over European equities. However, the Swiss market is now very expensive on a relative basis, and it is vulnerable to higher interest rates. While global risk aversion can still buoy the Swiss market in the near term, conditions are falling into place for Swiss stocks to underperform their Eurozone counterpart over a 12-to-18 month window. Materials and consumer staples are the sectors mostly likely to experience a large underperformance relative to their Euro Area competitors, followed by the healthcare sector. Investment ConclusionsVolatility in FX markets is likely to remain elevated, as witnessed by the reaction of a full circle of central bank meetings this week.Policy convergence remains a good bet for interest rate curves and currency pairs. The SNB surprised markets by raising interest rates by 50 bps, to -0.25%, the first hike since 2007 (Chart 1).Higher volatility will continue to buoy the Swiss franc in the short run.Structural appreciation in the franc is also likely over the coming decades.Swiss stocks often perform well during economic downturns, but they are not particularly cheap, and vulnerable to higher interest rates. Investors should only overweight Swiss stocks if they expect more significant downside to global stocks.Valuation favors the franc versus the dollar. However, EUR/CHF and GBP/CHF are closer to fair value. CHF/JPY is expensive; hence the yen is a better hedge for downside economic surprises. Go short CHF/JPY as a trade.BCA’s Foreign Exchange Strategy was short CHF/SEK at 10.2 with stop loss at 10.5. That stop was hit overnight, triggering a loss of -3.3%. Stand aside for now. Chester NtoniforForeign Exchange Strategistchestern@bcaresearch.comMathieu Savary Chief European StrategistMathieu@bcaresearch.com

Executive Summary Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Volatility in FX markets is likely to remain elevated, as witnessed by the reaction of a full circle of central bank meetings this week. Policy convergence remains a good bet for interest rate curves and currency pairs. The SNB surprised markets by raising interest rates by 50 bps, to -0.25%, the first hike since 2007. Higher volatility will continue to buoy the Swiss franc in the short run. Structural appreciation in the franc is also likely over the coming decades (Feature Chart).  Swiss stocks often perform well during economic downturns, but they are not particularly cheap, and are vulnerable to higher interest rates. Investors should only overweight Swiss stocks if they expect more significant downside to global stocks. Valuation favors the franc versus the dollar. However, EUR/CHF and GBP/CHF are closer to fair value. CHF/JPY is expensive; hence, the yen is a better hedge for downside economic surprises. Go short CHF/JPY as a trade. BCA’s Foreign Exchange Strategy was short CHF/SEK at 10.2 with stop loss at 10.5. That stop was hit overnight, triggering a loss of -3.3%. Stand aside for now. Bottom Line: Favor the franc over the short term against other pro-cyclical currencies, with a view to downgrade CHF when it becomes evident that economic growth is bottoming. Any further bout of Swiss equity outperformance, prompted by global risk aversion, offers an attractive selling opportunity versus Eurozone stocks. Feature Chart 1The SNB Has Capitulated To Rising Inflation The SNB Has Capitulated To Rising Inflation The SNB Has Capitulated To Rising Inflation Volatility in FX markets is likely to remain elevated. This week, the Fed delivered its first 75 bps interest rate hike since 1994. It also increased its expected year-end level for the Fed Funds rate to 3.4% from 1.9%, and to 3.8% from 3.4% at the end of 2023. The FX market had been warming up to a hawkish surprise, but the dollar surged on the news, hitting a fresh two-decade high of 105.5, before later reversing gains. Meanwhile, the European Central Bank (ECB) held an emergency meeting on Wednesday, to try to mitigate the rise in Italian yields, which hit as high as 4.2% on Tuesday, or 243 bps over German 10-year yields. The subsequent statement released by the Governing Council offered no concrete details. Yes, the reinvestments of the proceeds from maturing debt in the Pandemic Emergency Purchase Program (PEPP) will flow mostly to peripheral markets, but investors want clarity on the nature of the long-awaited policy plan to tackle fragmentation risk in the Euro Area. As a result, peripheral bond markets will remain fragile until a bold program comes to fruition. To cement currency volatility this week, SNB Governor Thomas Jordan surprised markets by raising interest rates by 50 bps in Switzerland, to -0.25%, the first hike since the Global Financial Crisis (Chart 1). The negative interest rate threshold for sight deposits was also lowered, a move encouraging banks to pack reserves at the SNB. The Bank of England also raised interest rates in line with market expectations. The move initially disappointed GBP bulls, but sterling is holding above our 1.20 floor. An environment of monetary policy uncertainty, rising recession risks in response to high inflation, and the potential for central bank policy mistakes bodes well for safe-haven assets. In Europe, the market with the strongest defensive profile is Switzerland. In this report, we address whether investors should bet on continued appreciation of the franc and an outperformance of Swiss stocks, especially now that the SNB has turned hawkish. Switzerland Versus The World Global economic growth is slowing and a small/open economy like Switzerland’s has not been spared. The KOF economic barometer, a key leading indicator for Swiss GDP growth, has collapsed over the past twelve months from 144 to 97 as global industrial activity decelerated (Chart 2). Despite softening growth, global inflation refuses to decline, forcing central banks worldwide to lean into the slowdown. This threatens to cut the post-pandemic business cycle expansion short. Chart 2The SNB Is Tightening Into A Slowing Economy The SNB Is Tightening Into A Slowing Economy The SNB Is Tightening Into A Slowing Economy Surprisingly, the Swiss economy is generally performing better than the rest of Europe. Historically, Swiss economic performance is procyclical due to the large share of exports within its GDP. Hence, a slowdown in global manufacturing often creates a large threat to Swiss growth. Going forward, can the Swiss economy diverge from that of the rest of the world (Chart 3)? Such a divergence is not probable, but a few factors will protect the Swiss economy: Switzerland still has one of the lowest policy rates in the G10, even after today’s 50bps interest rate increase. This has tremendously helped ease monetary conditions. Our monetary gauge is at its most accommodative level in over two decades (Chart 4). Chart 3The Swiss Economy Is Procyclical The Swiss Economy Is Procyclical The Swiss Economy Is Procyclical Chart 4Swiss Monetary Conditions Are Still Accommodative Swiss Monetary Conditions Are Still Accommodative Swiss Monetary Conditions Are Still Accommodative Swiss inflation remains the lowest in the G10 outside Japan. In Switzerland, the main driver of price increases has been goods, while services inflation remains subdued. Consequently, the SNB has been tolerating an appreciating franc to temper imported inflation (Chart 5), while keeping domestic borrowing costs at very accommodative levels. In its updated forecasts, the SNB now expects a -0.25% interest rate to allow Swiss inflation to moderate to 1.9% in 2023 and 1.6% in 2024. Chart 5Swiss Inflation Is Surprising To The Upside Swiss Inflation Is Surprising To The Upside Swiss Inflation Is Surprising To The Upside Part of the reason Switzerland has low inflation has been the tremendous productivity gains, especially relative to its trading partners (Chart 6). Swiss income-per-capita is elevated, but wage growth has lagged output gains, which limits the risk of a wage-inflation spiral. It is notable that part-time employment continues to dominate job gains, implying that the need for precautionary savings will remain high in Switzerland. Chart 6A Productivity Profile For Switzerland A Productivity Profile For Switzerland A Productivity Profile For Switzerland Higher productivity growth and the elevated national savings leave their footprint on the trade data. The Swiss trade balance is hitting fresh highs, unlike Europe or Japan (Chart 7). This could potentially create a problem for the Swiss economy as it puts upward pressure on the CHF at a time when global manufacturing output is slowing. However, Switzerland specializes in high value-added exports with an elevated degree of complexity, that stand early in global supply chains. These type of goods are likely to remain in high demand in a global environment marked by supply-chain bottlenecks and high-capacity utilization.  Chart 7Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Structural Tailwinds For The Franc Finally, Switzerland does not import energy to fulfill its electricity production. Hydropower accounts for roughly 61.4% of electricity generation, followed by nuclear power at 28.5%. This has partially insulated Switzerland from the energy shock hurting economic activity and trade balances in the EU. For example, German electricity generation is 28.8% coal and 14.7% natural gas. Bottom Line: The Swiss economy is reopening and is relatively insulated from the Russia-Ukraine conflict. This limits to some degree how closely Switzerland will track the global and European economic slowdown. It creates a departure from the traditional pro-cyclicality of the Swiss economy. The SNB, The SARON Curve, And The Swiss Franc If the Swiss economy surprises to the upside, the case for the SNB to tolerate a rising franc becomes even stronger. The pace of foreign exchange reserve accumulation is already decelerating (Chart 8). Governor Thomas Jordan has been very clear: as global prices rise, the fair value of the franc is also rising, which implies a willingness to tolerate currency strength. In a purchasing power parity framework, higher external inflation makes Swiss goods relatively cheaper. This allows foreigners to bid up the currency. Even with today’s updated pricing, the SNB is still expected to remain among the most dovish central banks in the G10 (Chart 9). If inflationary pressures prove sticky, the SNB will step up its hawkish rhetoric. If inflationary fears subside, then global rates will fall as well, which has usually been a boon for the franc. More specifically, this would be negative for the EUR/CHF cross (Chart 10). Chart 8Less Intervention By The SNB Less Intervention By The SNB Less Intervention By The SNB Chart 9The SARON Curve Has Adjusted Higher The SARON Curve Has Adjusted Higher The SARON Curve Has Adjusted Higher Chart 10EUR/CHF And Bund Yields Can Continue To Diverge EUR/CHF And Bund Yields Can Continue To Diverge EUR/CHF And Bund Yields Can Continue To Diverge The Swiss economy can tolerate an appreciating CHF, but can it withstand higher interest rates? We believe so. Switzerland is a net creditor nation, but its domestic non-financial debt is also extremely elevated. Thus, the Swiss economy is vulnerable to higher rates, especially the housing market (Chart 11). Nonetheless, internal adjustments will soften the blow and increase affordability. Of note, property speculation in Switzerland has decreased in response to macroprudential measures. Growth in rental housing prices, which usually constitute the bulk of investment homes, has collapsed, but the price of owner-occupied homes has proven more robust (Chart 12). A cap on the percentage of secondary homes in any Canton as well as tighter lending standards have also helped. In a renewed update to its Financial Stability Report, Fritz Zurbrügg, Vice Chairman of the Governing Board, suggests that Swiss banks are well capitalized, especially given the recent reactivation of the countercyclical capital buffer. Chart 11Higher Rates Are A Risk For Swiss Real Estate Higher Rates Are A Risk For Swiss Real Estate Higher Rates Are A Risk For Swiss Real Estate Chart 12Some Adjustment Already In Investment Home Prices Some Adjustment Already In Investment Home Prices Some Adjustment Already In Investment Home Prices In the very near term, demographics might also be a tailwind. The pandemic limited immigration to Switzerland, but the working-age population is rebounding anew (Chart 13), which will create a cushion under housing and support domestic demand. Chart 13A Small Demographic Tailwind For Home Prices A Small Demographic Tailwind For Home Prices A Small Demographic Tailwind For Home Prices Stronger aggregate demand in an inflationary world will justify the need for less monetary accommodation. In a nutshell, the SNB is likely to continue walking the path of “least regrets” like most central banks, by tightening monetary policy to meet its 2% inflation mandate, but pausing if economic conditions warrant. The currency has historically been used as a key tool for calibrating financial conditions. From a fundamental perspective, our PPP models suggest the franc is quite cheap versus the dollar but at fair value versus the euro and sterling. This is echoed by Governor Jordan, who no longer views the franc as expensive. Our models adjusts the consumption basket in Switzerland for an apples-to-apples comparison across both the UK and the eurozone (Chart 14). Chart 14AA CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP Chart 14BA CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP A CHF Is At Fair Value Versus The EUR And GBP Finally, hedging costs for shorting the franc against the dollar have risen substantially (Chart 15). As such, any short bets on the franc are likely being placed naked. If the Fed ends up tempering its pace of rate hikes next year in response to weaker US activity, short-covering activity is likely to accentuate any pre-existing strength in the CHF. Chart 15Hedging Costs For USD/CHF Carry Trades Have Risen Hedging Costs Are Prohibitive Hedging Costs For USD/CHF Carry Trades Have Risen Hedging Costs Are Prohibitive Hedging Costs For USD/CHF Carry Trades Have Risen Hedging Costs Are Prohibitive Bottom Line: The franc is undervalued against the dollar, and a good hedge against a rise in volatility versus other procyclical currencies. This places the franc in a good “heads I win, tails I don’t loose too much” bet. Swiss interest rates are also likely to climb higher. However, because the franc will do the bulk of the monetary tightening, the SNB is likely to lag the expectations now embedded in the SARON curve. What About Swiss Equities? Despite the cyclical nature of the Swiss economy, Swiss equities are extremely defensive. Swiss stocks have little to do with the domestic economy and are mostly a collection of large multinationals, dominated by the healthcare and consumer staples sectors, which together account for roughly 60% of the Swiss MSCI benchmark. This defensive attribute has created its own problem for Swiss equities. Relative to the Eurozone, the Swiss market has moved massively ahead of profitability, and it is now more expensive than at the apex of the European debt crisis in 2012 (Chart 16). Moreover, the jump in German yields is becoming increasingly problematic for Swiss stocks that historically perform poorly when global interest rates are rising (Chart 17). Chart 16Swiss Stocks Are Expensive Swiss Stocks Are Expensive Swiss Stocks Are Expensive Chart 17A Lost Tailwind A Lost Tailwind A Lost Tailwind In the near term, Swiss equities will only be able to defy the gravitational pull created by demanding valuations and higher yields if global risk aversion remains elevated. However, once global stocks find a floor and Italian spreads begin to narrow, Swiss stocks are likely to underperform massively (Chart 18). It could take a few more weeks before the BTP/Bund spreads narrow as the recent ECB announcement was rather tepid. However, the ECB holding an emergency meeting and issuing a formal statement addressing the problem facing peripheral bond markets suggests that a formal program designed to manage fragmentation risk will emerge before the end of the summer. Beyond their defensive attributes, Swiss stocks also correlate to the Quality Factor. The robust performance of this factor since the turn of the millennium, in Europe and globally, has allowed the Swiss market to greatly outperform Eurozone equities (Chart 19). However, the Quality Factor has begun to underperform, which indicates that the Swiss market is losing another of its underpinnings. Chart 18Near-term, Follow Risk Aversion Near-term, Follow Risk Aversion Near-term, Follow Risk Aversion Chart 19Swiss Stocks Are About Quality Swiss Stocks Are About Quality Swiss Stocks Are About Quality These observations imply that over the next 12 to 18 months, Swiss equities will underperform their Euro Area counterparts. Materials and consumer staples stand out as the two sectors with the most extended valuations relative to their Euro Area competitors, especially since their relative performances have become dissociated from relative profits (Chart 20). They should carry maximum underweights relative to their European counterparts. The healthcare sector is Switzerland’s largest market weight. It is not as expensive relative to the Eurozone as the materials and consumer staples sectors, but it carries enough of a premium that investors should still underweight this sector relative to its eurozone competitor (Chart 21). Chart 20Dangerous Setup For Swiss Materials and Staples Dangerous Setup For Swiss Materials and Staples Dangerous Setup For Swiss Materials and Staples Chart 21The Swiss Heavyweight Is Becoming Pricey The Swiss Heavyweight Is Becoming Pricey The Swiss Heavyweight Is Becoming Pricey Bottom Line: The defensive nature of the Swiss market has allowed for a large outperformance over European equities. However, the Swiss market is now very expensive on a relative basis, and it is vulnerable to higher interest rates. While global risk aversion can still buoy the Swiss market in the near term, conditions are falling into place for Swiss stocks to underperform their Eurozone counterpart over a 12-to-18 month window. Materials and consumer staples are the sectors mostly likely to experience a large underperformance relative to their Euro Area competitors, followed by the healthcare sector.  Investment Conclusions Volatility in FX markets is likely to remain elevated, as witnessed by the reaction of a full circle of central bank meetings this week. Policy convergence remains a good bet for interest rate curves and currency pairs. The SNB surprised markets by raising interest rates by 50 bps, to -0.25%, the first hike since 2007 (Chart 1). Higher volatility will continue to buoy the Swiss franc in the short run. Structural appreciation in the franc is also likely over the coming decades. Swiss stocks often perform well during economic downturns, but they are not particularly cheap, and vulnerable to higher interest rates. Investors should only overweight Swiss stocks if they expect more significant downside to global stocks. Valuation favors the franc versus the dollar. However, EUR/CHF and GBP/CHF are closer to fair value. CHF/JPY is expensive; hence the yen is a better hedge for downside economic surprises. Go short CHF/JPY as a trade. BCA’s Foreign Exchange Strategy was short CHF/SEK at 10.2 with stop loss at 10.5. That stop was hit overnight, triggering a loss of -3.3%. Stand aside for now.   Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Mathieu Savary Chief European Strategist Mathieu@bcaresearch.com   Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Forecast Summary

Executive Summary The Market Has Priced An Aggressive Path For US Rate Hikes The Market Has Priced An Aggressive Path For US Rate Hikes The Market Has Priced An Aggressive Path For US Rate Hikes The Federal Reserve has joined other G10 central banks in increasing interest rates this week. However, this has been well priced by both the dollar and short rates in the US (Feature Chart). The key call for currencies therefore is whether the Fed delivers more or less hikes than is currently priced by markets over the course of the next few months. More aggressive rate hikes will boost US bond yields, and send the dollar higher. But it will also undermine US equity multiples, given the tight correlation between the price-to-earnings ratio in the US and the real bond yield. More importantly, US equity market leadership has been an important driver of portfolio inflows into the dollar. Should the Fed deliver less hikes than the aggressive path currently priced by markets, currency investors will also be caught offside. This conundrum puts the DXY at risk. The caveat is that if the US economy is genuinely stronger than the rest of the world, and more insulated from the Russo-Ukrainian conflict, this will warrant higher real US interest rates. We went short NOK/SEK last week given our bias that oil prices had overshot. Tighten stops to protect profits. Bottom Line: Being long the dollar is a consensus trade. While in the near term, this could prove to be the right call, the dollar is also expensive and overbought, which is bearish from a contrarian perspective. Feature The 25 basis point interest rate hike by the Federal Reserve this week has probably been one of the most telegraphed macro events. Interest rate expectations in the US have risen sharply compared to last year (Chart 1). More importantly, as Chart 2 shows, two-year bond yields (a proxy for short rates) have climbed in the US relative to pretty much every other G10 country. Correspondingly, rising interest rate expectations in the US have led to substantial speculative flows into the US dollar. Chart 2The Market Expects The Fed To Hike Faster Than Other Central Banks This Year The Market Expects The Fed To Hike Faster Than Other Central Banks This Year The Market Expects The Fed To Hike Faster Than Other Central Banks This Year Chart 1The Market Has Priced An Aggressive Path For US Rate Hikes The Market Has Priced An Aggressive Path For US Rate Hikes The Market Has Priced An Aggressive Path For US Rate Hikes On the flipside, the outperformance of the US equity market is being threatened by rising interest rates. If rates rise substantially, that could derate US equity multiples, as portfolio inflows are curtailed. US profits also tend to underperform when rates rise. However, if US rates rise by less than what the market expects, net long speculative positioning in the dollar will surely reverse. Non-US Markets Benefit More When Bond Yields Rise Profits tend to drive the equity market over the short run, with valuation starting to matter over longer horizons. When it comes to the US, it is also true that profits tend to underperform the rest of the world as bond yields rise. Why it matters for the dollar is because a better profit picture in the US helps drive portfolio flows into US equities, buffeting the exchange rate (Chart 3). Related Report  Global Investment StrategyA Two-Stage Fed Tightening Cycle Chart 4 shows that US profits lag the rest of the world when bond yields are in an uptrend. This is because of the composition of the US equity market. Specifically, the US equity market is underweight financials, energy, materials, and industrials, while overweight information technology, health care, and communication services. Rising inflation benefits commodity-linked sectors, the income statements of which are directly juiced by rising prices. Similarly, banks tend to do better as interest rates rise because net interest margins improve. In a nutshell, rising rates and inflation tend to be better for the profits of value stocks and cyclicals, sectors that are underrepresented in the US. Chart 3The Dollar And US Equities The Dollar And US Equities The Dollar And US Equities Chart 4Bond Yields And US Profits Bond Yields And US Profits Bond Yields And US Profits There is also a valuation angle to higher rates. Because the US market is more overweight sectors with cash flows that backwardated, higher rates will undermine the valuation premium currently commanded by these sectors. This is true both in absolute terms and relative to other markets (Chart 5A and 5B). Chart 5AThe S&P 500 P/E Ratio And Real ##br##Yields The S&P 500 P/E Ratio And Real Yields The S&P 500 P/E Ratio And Real Yields Chart 5BThe Valuation Premium In The US Is Inversely Correlated To Bond Yields The Valuation Premium In The US Is Inversely Correlated To Bond Yields The Valuation Premium In The US Is Inversely Correlated To Bond Yields The key point is that the US equity market is at risk relatively from higher global yields that could undermine relative profit growth and its valuation premium. The US trade deficit currently runs at $90 billion. In 2021, at least 45% of that was financed via foreign equity purchases. A reversal in these flows could undermine the dollar. The Dollar And Relative Interest Rates While portfolio flows into US equities have been reversing, bond inflows have improved (Chart 6). Over the long term, bond flows tend to be the key driver of the US dollar. As Chart 2 shows, most market participants expect the Fed to be among the most hawkish central banks in 2022 and beyond. In fact, December Eurodollar contracts are pricing the Fed to hike interest rates by 218 bps more than the ECB, and 235 bps more than the Bank of Japan (allowing for a small risk premium in this pricing) (Chart 7). Chart 7Investors Are Very Bullish On US Rate Expectations Investors Are Very Bullish On US Rate Expectations Investors Are Very Bullish On US Rate Expectations Chart 6Investors Have Been Aggressively Purchasing US Treasurys Investors Have Been Aggressively Purchasing US Treasurys Investors Have Been Aggressively Purchasing US Treasurys There are two key risks to a hawkish Fed view, relative to other central banks: First, the Fed is already behind the curve relative to its G10 counterparts. The BoE, RBNZ, BoC, and the Norges Bank have already increased rates. Even the rhetoric at the ECB is shifiting. Relative bond yields do not reflect this reality. Second, and related, rising inflation is a global phenomenon and not specific to the US. Almost every central bank is acknowledging that inflation is a key risk to their mandate, compared to the transitory narrative last year. Chart 8 plots headline inflation across G10 countries. On this basis, it becomes difficult to justify why two-year yields in the UK, for example, are much lower, compared to the US. Chart 8Rising Inflation Is Not A US-Centric Problem Rising Inflation Is Not A US-Centric Problem Rising Inflation Is Not A US-Centric Problem If inflation does indeed prove to be sticky, other central banks will have to keep hiking interest rates along with the Fed. If inflation subsides, the Fed might not be as aggressive in tightening policy as the market expects. On a relative basis, this suggests there is a mispricing of how the market views Fed action, relative to other central banks. The key risk to this view is that the US economy can actually withstand much higher rates compared to the rest of the world. While this could be the case, higher rates in Norway and New Zealand are not yet hurting domestic conditions. In fact, it can be argued that weakness in their currencies has unwound a lot of the tightening in financial conditions from higher interest rates. A commodity boom also suggests that these currencies will benefit from rising terms of trade. Conclusion Bond markets have priced higher relative rates in the US, but the Fed could actually lag market expectations, especially relative to commodity-linked currencies (Chart 9). Chart 9Commodity Currencies Have Been Tracking Rate Expectations With A Lag Commodity Currencies Have Been Tracking Rate Expectations With A Lag Commodity Currencies Have Been Tracking Rate Expectations With A Lag Specifically, higher rates than the market expects in the US will undermine US equity market leadership, reversing substantial portfolio inflows in recent years. This is already occurring at the margin. On the other hand, fewer rate hikes will severely unwind speculative inflows into the US dollar. Housekeeping We went short NOK/SEK on the expectation that oil prices had overshot, especially relative to forward markets (Chart 10). We are tightening the stop loss on this trade to 1.09. Finally, the Bank of England met this week and its transcript reinforced our stance that the BoE will be cornered as it attempts to raise rates amidst a slowing economy. Stay long EUR/GBP. Chart 10Stay Short NOK/SEK But Tighten Stops Stay Short NOK/SEK But Tighten Stops Stay Short NOK/SEK But Tighten Stops   Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary

Executive Summary Major EM’s Defense Spends Will Be Comparable To That Of Developed Countries Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​ Tectonic geopolitical trends are taking shape in Emerging Markets (EMs) today that will leave an indelible imprint on the next decade. First, EMs have gone on a relatively unnoticed public debt binge at a time when the economic prospects of the median EM citizen have deteriorated. This raises the spectre of sudden fiscal populism, aggressive foreign policy or social unrest in EMs. China, Brazil and Saudi Arabia appear most vulnerable to these risks. Second, the defense bill of major EMs could be comparable to that of the top developed countries of the world in a decade from now. Investors must brace for EMs to play a central role in the defense market and in wars, in the coming years. To profit from ascendant geopolitical risks in China, we reiterate shorting TWD-USD and the CNY against an equal-weighted basket of Euro and USD. To extract most from the theme of EM militarization, we suggest a Long on European Aerospace & Defense relative to European Tech stocks.   Trade Recommendation Inception Date Return LONG EUROPEAN AEROSPACE & DEFENSE / EUROPEAN TECH EQUITIES (STRATEGIC) 2022-03-18   Bottom Line: Even as EMs are set to emerge as protagonists on the world stage, investors must prepare for these countries to exhibit sudden fiscal expansions, bouts of social unrest or a newfound propensity to initiate wars. The only way to dodge these volatility-inducing events is to leverage geopolitics to foresee these shocks. Feature Only a few weeks before Russia’s war with Ukraine broke out, a client told us that he was having trouble seeing the importance of geopolitics in investing. “It seems like geopolitics was a lot more relevant a few years back, with the European debt crisis, Brexit, and Trump. Now it does not seem to drive markets at all”, said the client. To this we gave our frequent explanation which is, “Our strategic themes of Great Power Struggle, Hypo-Globalization, and Nationalism/Populism are now embedded in the international system and responsible for an observable rise in geopolitical risk that is reshaping markets”. In particular we highlighted our pessimistic view on both Russia and Iran, which have incidentally crystallized most clearly since we had this client conversation. Related Report  Geopolitical StrategyBrazil: The Road To Elections Won't Be Paved With Good Intentions Globally key geopolitical changes are afoot with Russia at war. In the coming weeks and months, we will write extensively about the dramatic changes we see taking shape in the realm of geopolitics and investing. We underscored the dramatic geopolitical realignment taking place as Russia severs ties with the West and throws itself into China’s arms in a report titled “From Nixon-Mao To Putin-Xi”. In this Special Report we highlight two key geopolitical themes that will affect emerging markets (EMs) over the coming decade. The aim is to help investors spot these trends early, so that they can profit from these tectonic changes that are sure to spawn a new generation of winners and losers in financial markets. (For BCA Research’s in-depth views on EMs, do refer to the Emerging Markets Strategy (EMS) webpage). Trend #1: Beware The Wrath Of EMs On A Debt Binge Chart 1The Pace Of Debt Accumulation Has Accelerated In Major EMs Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Investors are generally aware of the debt build-up that has taken place in the developed world since Covid-19. The gross public debt held by the six most developed countries of the world (spanning US, Japan, Germany, UK, France and Italy) now stands at an eye-watering $60 trillion or about 140% of GDP. This debt pile is enormous in both absolute and relative terms. But at the same time, the debt simultaneously being taken on by EMs has largely gone unnoticed. The cumulative public debt held by eight major EMs today (spanning China, Taiwan, Korea, India, Brazil, Russia, Saudi Arabia and Turkey) stands at $20tn i.e., about 70% of GDP. Whilst the absolute value of EM debt appears manageable, what is worrying is the pace of debt accumulation. The average public debt to GDP ratio of these EMs fell over the early 2000s but their public debt ratios have now doubled over the last decade (Chart 1). EMs have been accumulating public debt at such a rapid clip that the pace of debt expansion in EMs is substantially higher than that of the top six developed countries (Chart 1). These six DMs have a larger combined GDP than the eight EMs with which they are compared. Related Report  Geopolitical StrategyIndia's Politics: Know When To Hold 'Em, Know When To Fold 'Em (For in-depth views on China’s debt, do refer to China Investment Strategy (CIS) report here). Now developed countries taking on more debt makes logical sense for two reasons. Firstly, most developed countries are ageing, and their populations have stopped growing. So one way to prop up falling demand is to get governments to spend more using debt. Secondly, this practice seems manageable because developed country central banks have deep pockets (in the form of reserves) and their central banks are issuers of some of the safest currencies of the world. But EMs using the same formula and getting addicted to debt at an earlier stage of development is risky and could prove to be lethal in some cases. Also distinct from reasons of macroeconomics, the debt binge in EMs this time is problematic for geopolitical reasons. This Time Is Different EMs getting reliant on debt is problematic this time because their median citizen’s economic prospects have deteriorated. Growth is slowing, inflation is high, and job creation is stalling; thereby creating a problematic socio-political backdrop to the EM debt build-up. Growth Is Slowing: In the 2000s EMs could hope to grow out of their social or economic problems. The cumulative nominal GDP of eight major EMs more than quadrupled over the early 2000s but a decade later, these EMs haven not been able to grow their nominal GDP even at half the rate (Chart 2). Inflation Remains High: Despite poorer growth prospects, inflation is accelerating. Inflation was high in most major EMs in 2021 (Chart 3) i.e., even before the surge seen in 2022. Chart 2Major EM’s Growth Engine Is No Longer Humming Like A Well-Tuned Machine Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​ Chart 3Despite Slower Growth, Inflation In Major EMs Remains High Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​ Rising Unemployment: Employment levels have improved globally from the precipice they had fallen into in 2020. But unemployment today is a far bigger problem for major EMs as compared to developed markets (Chart 4). If the economic miseries of the median EM citizen are not addressed, then they can produce disruptive sociopolitical effects that will fan market volatility. This problem of rising economic misery alongside a rapid debt build-up, can also be seen for the next tier of EMs i.e. Mexico, Indonesia, Iran, Poland, Thailand, Nigeria, Argentina, Egypt, South Africa and Vietnam. While the average public debt to GDP ratios of these EMs fell over the early 2000s, the pace of debt accumulation has almost doubled over the last decade (Chart 5). Furthermore, the growth engine in these smaller EMs is no longer humming like a well-tuned machine and inflation remains at large (Chart 5). Chart 4Unemployment - A Bigger Problem In Major EMs Today Unemployment - A Bigger Problem In Major EMs Today Unemployment - A Bigger Problem In Major EMs Today ​​​​​ Chart 5Smaller EMs Must Also Deal With Rising Debt, Alongside Slowing Growth Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​ Chart 6The Debt Surge In EMs This Time, Poses Unique Challenges Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War History suggests that periods of economic tumult are frequently followed by social unrest. The eruption of the so-called Arab Spring after the Great Recession illustrated the power of this dynamic. Then following the outbreak of Covid-19 in 2020 we had highlighted that Turkey, Brazil, and South Africa are at the greatest risk of significant social unrest. We also showed that even EMs that looked stable on paper faced unrest in the post-Covid world, including China and Russia. In this report we take a decadal perspective which reveals that growth is slowing, and debt is growing in EMs. Given that EMs suffer from rising economic miseries alongside growing debt and lower political freedoms (Chart 6), it appears that some of these markets could be socio-political tinderboxes in the making. Policy Implications Of The EM Debt Surge “As it turns out, we don't 'all' have to pay our debts. Only some of us do.” – David Graeber, Debt: The First 5,000 Years (Melville House Publishing, 2011) The trifecta of fast-growing debt, slowing growth and/or low political freedoms in EMs can add to the volatility engendered by EMs as an asset class. Given the growing economic misery in EMs today, politicians will be wary of outbreaks of social unrest. To quell this unrest, they may resort broadly to fiscal expansion and/or aggressive foreign policy. Both of these policy choices can dampen market returns in EMs. Chart 7India's Performance Had Flatlined Post Mild Populist Tilt India's Performance Had Flatlined Post Mild Populist Tilt India's Performance Had Flatlined Post Mild Populist Tilt Policy Choice #1: More Fiscal Spending Despite High Debt Policymakers in some EMs may respond by de-prioritizing contentious structural reforms and prioritizing fiscal expansion. The Indian government’s decision to repeal progressive changes to farm laws in late 2021, launch a $7 billion home-building program in early 2022 and withholding hikes in retail prices of fuel, illustrates how policymakers are resorting to populism despite high public debt levels. As a result, it is no surprise that MSCI India had been underperforming MSCI EM even before the war in Ukraine broke out (Chart 7). Brazil is another EM which falls into this category, while China’s attempts to run tighter budgets have failed in the face of slowing growth. Policy Choice #2: Foreign Policy Aggression EMs may also adopt an aggressive foreign policy stance. Russia’s decision to invade Ukraine, Turkey’s interventions in several countries, and China’s increasing assertiveness in its neighboring seas and the Taiwan Strait provide examples. Wars by EMs are known to dampen returns as the experience of the Russian stock market shows. Russian stocks fell by 14% during its invasion of Georgia in 2008 and are down 40% from 24 February 2022 until March 9, 2022, i.e. when MSCI halted trading. If politicians fail to pursue either of these policies, then they run the risk of social unrest erupting due to tight fiscal policy or domestic political disputes. In fact, early signs of social discontent are already evident from large protests seen in major EMs over the last year (see Table 1). Table 1Social Unrest In Major EMs Is Already Ascendant Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Bottom Line: The last decade has seen major EMs go on a relatively unnoticed public debt binge. This is problematic because this debt surge has come at a time when economic prospects of the median EM citizen have deteriorated. Politicians will be keen to quell the resultant discontent. This raises the specter of excessive fiscal expansion, aggressive foreign policy, and/or social unrest. All three outcomes are negative from an EM volatility perspective. Trend #2: The Rise And Rise Of EM Defense Spends Great Power Rivalry is an outgrowth of the multipolar structure of international relations. This theme will drive higher defense spending globally. In this report we highlight that even after accounting for a historic rearmament in developed countries following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, a decade from now EMs will play a key role in driving global military spends. The defense bill of the six richest developed countries of the world (the US, Japan, Germany, UK, France and Italy) will increasingly be rivaled by that of the top eight EMs (China, Taiwan, Korea, India, Brazil, Russia, Saudi Arabia and Turkey). While key developed markets like Japan and Germany in specific (and Europe more broadly) are now embarking on increasing defense spends, the unstable global backdrop will force EMs to increase their military budgets as well. The combination of these forces could mean that the top eight EM’s defense spends could be comparable to that of the top six developed markets in a decade from now i.e., by 2032 (Chart 8). This is true even though the six DMs have a larger GDP. The assumptions made while arriving at the 2032 defense spend projections include: Substantially Higher Pace Of Defense Spends For Developed Countries: To reflect the fact that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine will trigger a historical wave of armament in developed markets we assume that: (a) NATO members France, Germany and Italy (who spent about 1.5% of GDP on an average on defense spends in 2019) will ramp up defense spending to 2% of GDP by 2032, (b) US and UK i.e. NATO members who already spend substantially more than 2% of GDP on defense spends will still ‘increase’ defense spends by another 0.4% of GDP each by 2032 and finally (c) Japan which spends less than 1% of GDP on defense spends today, in a structural break from the past will increase its spending which will rise to 1.5% of GDP by 2032. China And Hence Taiwan As Well As India Will Boost Spends: To capture China’s increasingly aggressive foreign policy stance and the fact that India as well as Taiwan will be forced to respond to the Chinese threat; we assume that China increases its stated defense spends from 1.7% of GDP in 2019 to 3% by 2032. Taiwan follows in lockstep and increases its defense spends from 1.8% of GDP in 2019 to 3% by 2032. India which is experiencing a pincer movement from China to its east and Pakistan to its west will have no choice but to respond to the high and rising geopolitical risks in South Asia. The coming decade is in fact likely to see India’s focus on its naval firepower increase meaningfully as it feels the need to fend off threats in the Indo-Pacific. India currently maintains high defense spends at 2.5% of GDP and will boost this by at least 100bps to 3.5% of GDP by 2032. Defense Spending Trends For Five EMs: For the rest of the EMs (namely Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Korea and Brazil), the pace of growth in defense spending seen over 2009-19 is extrapolated to 2032. For Turkey, we assume that defense spends as a share of GDP increases to 3% of GDP by 2032. Extrapolation Of Past GDP Growth For All Countries: For all 14 countries, we extrapolate the nominal GDP growth calculated by the IMF for 2022-26 as per its last full data update, to 2032. This tectonic change in defense spending patterns has important historical roots. Back in 1900, UK and Japan i.e., the two seafaring powers were top defense spenders (Chart 9). Developed countries of the world continued to lead defense spending league tables through the twentieth century as they fought expensive world wars. Chart 8Major EM’s Defense Spends Will Be Comparable To That Of Developed Countries Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​​ Chart 9Back In 1900, Developed Countries Like UK And Japan Were Top Military Spenders Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​​ Chart 10By 2000, EMs Had Begun Spending Generously On Armament Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War But things began changing after WWII. Jaded by the world wars, developed countries began lowering their defense spending. By the early 2000s EMs had now begun spending generously on armament (Chart 10). The turn of the century saw growth in developed markets fade while EMs like China and India’s geopolitical power began rising (Chart 11). Then a commodities boom ensued, resulting in petro-states like Saudi Arabia establishing their position as a high military spender. The confluence of these factors meant that by 2020 EMs had becomes major defense spenders in both relative and absolute terms too (Chart 12). Going forward, we expect the coming renaissance in DM defense spending in the face of Russian aggression, alongside rising geopolitical aspirations of China, to exacerbate this trend of rising EM militarization. Chart 11The 21st Century Saw Developed Countries’ Geopolitical Power Ebb Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Chart 12EMs Today Are Top Military Spenders, Even In Absolute Terms Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Why Does EM Weaponizing Matter? History suggests that wars are often preceded by an increase in defense spends: Well before WWI, a perceptible increase in defense spending could be seen in Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Italy (Chart 13). These three countries would go on to be known as the Triple Alliance in WWI. Correspondingly France, Britain and Russia (i.e., countries that would constitute the Triple Entente) also ramped up military spending before WWI (Chart 14). Chart 13Well Before WWI; Austria-Hungary, Germany, And Italy Had Begun Ramping Up Defense Spends Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​​ Chart 14The ‘Triple Entente’ Too Had Increased Defense Spends In The Run Up To WWI Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​​ History tragically repeated itself a few decades later. Besides Japan (which invaded China in 1937); Germany and Italy too ramped up defense spending well before WWII broke out (Chart 15). These three countries would come to be known as the Axis Powers and initiated WWII. Notably, Britain and Russia (who would go on to counter the Axis Powers) had also been weaponizing since the mid-1930s (Chart 16). Chart 15Axis Powers Had Been Increasing Defense Spends Well Before WWII Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​ Chart 16Allied Powers Too Had Been Increasing Defense Spends In The Run Up To WWII Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​ Chart 17Militarily Active States Have Been Ramping Up Defense Spends Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Russia, Ukraine, Turkey and Gulf Arab states like Iraq have been involved in wars in the recent past and noticeably increased their defense budgets in the lead-up to military activity (Chart 17). Given that a rise in military spending is often a leading indicator of war and given that EMs are set to spend more on defense, it appears that significant wars are becoming more rather than less likely, which Russia’s invasion of Ukraine obviously implies. A large number of “Black Swan Risks” are clustered in the spheres of influence of Russia, China, and Iran, which are the key powers attempting to revise the US-led global order today (Map 1). Map 1Black Swan Risks Are Clustered Around China, Russia & Iran Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Distinct from major EMs, eight small countries pose meaningful risks of being involved in wars over the next. These countries are small (in terms of their nominal GDPs) but spend large sums on defense both in absolute terms (>$4 billion) and in relative terms (>4% of GDP). Incidentally all these countries are located around the Eurasian rimland and include Israel, Pakistan, Algeria, Iran, Kuwait, Oman, Ukraine and Morocco (Map 2). In fact, the combined sum of spending undertaken by these countries is so meaningful that it exceeds the defense budgets of countries like Russia and UK (Chart 18). Map 2Eight Small Countries That Spend Generously On Defense Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Chart 188 Countries Located Near The Eurasian Rimland, Spend Large Sums On Defense Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​ Bottom Line: As EM geopolitical power and aspirations rise, the defense bill of top developed countries will be challenged by the defense spending undertaken by major EMs. On one hand this change will mean that certain EMs may be at the epicenter of wars and concomitant market volatility. On the other hand, this change could spawn a new generation of winners amongst defense suppliers. Investment Conclusions In this section we highlight strategic trades that can be launched to play the two trends highlighted above. Trend #1: Beware The Wrath Of EMs On A Debt Binge Investors must prepare for EMs to witness sudden fiscal expansions, unusually aggressive foreign policy stances, and/or bouts of social unrest over the next few years. The only way to dodge these volatility-inducing events in EMs is to leverage geopolitics to foresee socio-political shocks. Using a simple method called the “Tinderbox Framework” (Table 2), we highlight that: Table 2Tinderbox Framework: Identifying Countries Most Exposed To Socio-Political Risks Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Within the eight major EMs; China, Brazil, Russia and Saudi Arabia face elevated socio-political risks. Amongst the smaller ten EMs, these risks appear most elevated for Egypt, South Africa and Argentina. It is worth noting that Brazil, South Africa and Turkey appeared most vulnerable as per our Covid-19 Social Unrest Index that we launched in 2020. We used the tinderbox framework in the current context to fade out effects of Covid-19 and to add weight to the debt problem that is brewing in EMs. Client portfolios that are overweight on most countries that fare poorly on our “Tinderbox Framework” should consider actively hedging for volatility at the stock-specific level. To profit from ascendant geopolitical risks in China, we reiterate shorting TWD-USD and the CNY against an equal-weighted basket of Euro and USD. China’s public debt ratio is high and social pressures may be building with limited valves in place to release these pressures (Table 2). The renminbi has performed well amid the Russian war, which has weighed down the euro, but China faces a confluence of domestic and international risks that will ultimately drag on the currency, while the euro will benefit from the European Union’s awakening as a geopolitical entity in the face of the Russian military threat. Trend #2: EM’s Will Drive Wars In The 21st Century Wars are detrimental to market returns.1 Furthermore, as the history of world wars proves, even the aftermath of a war often yields poor investment outcomes as wars can be followed by recessions. It is in this context that investors must prepare for the rise of EMs as protagonists in the defense market, by leveraging geopolitics to identify EMs that are most likely to be engaged in wars. While we are not arguing that WWIII will erupt, investors must brace for proxy wars as an added source of volatility that could affect EMs as an asset class. To profit from these structural changes underway we highlight two strategic trades namely: 1.  Long Global Aerospace & Defense / Broad Market Thanks to the higher spending on defense being undertaken by major EMs, global defense spends will grow at a faster rate over the next decade as compared to the last. We hence reiterate our Buy on Global Aerospace & Defense relative to the broader market. 2.  Long European Aerospace & Defense / European Tech Up until Russia invaded Ukraine and was hit with economic sanctions, Russia was the second largest exporter of arms globally accounting for 20% global arms exports. With Russia’s ability to sell goods in the global market now impaired, the two other major suppliers of defense goods that appear best placed to tap into EM’s demand for defense goods are the US (37% share in the global defense exports market) and Europe (+25% share in the global defense exports market). Chart 19American Defense Stocks Have Outperformed, European Defense Stocks Have Underperformed Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​​ Chart 20Defense Market: Russia’s Loss Could Be Europe’s Gain Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War Beware EMs That Borrow Too Much Or Wage War ​​​​​ But given that (a) American aerospace & defense stocks have rallied (Chart 19) and given that (b) France, Germany, and Italy are major suppliers of defense equipment to countries that Russia used to supply defense goods to (Chart 20), we suggest a Buy on European Aerospace & Defense relative to European Tech stocks to extract more from this theme. In fact, this trade also stands to benefit from the pursuance of rearmament by major European democracies which so far have maintained lower defense spends as compared to America and UK. This view from a geopolitical perspective is echoed by our European Investment Strategy (EIS) team too who also recommend a Long on European defense stocks and a short on European tech stocks. Ritika Mankar, CFA Editor/Strategist ritika.mankar@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1      Please see: Andrew Leigh et al, “What do financial markets think of war in Iraq?”, NBER Working Paper No. 9587, March 2003, nber.org.  David Le Bris, “Wars, Inflation and Stock Market Returns in France, 1870-1945”, Financial History Review 19.3 pp. 337-361, December 2012, ssrn.com. Strategic Themes Open Tactical Positions (0-6 Months) Open Cyclical Recommendations (6-18 Months) Regional Geopolitical Risk Matrix