Emerging Markets

The factors that drove the recent rally - Fed dovishness, China reflation, and a pickup in economic data - are largely over. 

Corporate earnings rarely shrink outside of economic contractions, so investors can be forgiven for worrying that we are on the brink of a global recession. Earnings-per-share (EPS) for the MSCI all-country world index are estimated to have fallen by 7% in the year to March, the fourth quarter in a row of annual decline (top panel). This is by far the worst performance since the Great Recession. EPS growth in both the U.S. and the U.K. (local currency) is deep in negative territory. Profit growth is still positive, albeit decelerating, in the Eurozone and Japan in local currencies (bottom panel). How much more downside is there? When will EPS bottom and how strong will the recovery be? These are obviously key questions for the appropriate equity weighting within balanced portfolios, especially given that stocks are not cheap, downside global growth risks abound and the FOMC is biased to lift rates. It is difficult to justify being overweight equities without seeing some profit relief on the horizon. In yesterday's Special Report, we took a top-down approach to projecting EPS for the global index, the U.S., the Eurozone and Japan. The rebound in oil prices and some positive economic signs out of China have raised hopes that the profit recession is close to the end. Indeed, the good news is that world EPS annual growth should bottom in the third quarter. However, the bad news is that the climb back into positive growth territory will take time. Barring very strong (and unrealistic) growth assumptions for the rest of 2016, investors should not expect positive year-on-year global EPS growth until early in 2017. Bottom-up earnings estimates currently are too optimistic. On a regional basis, U.S. earnings growth will likely trail both Japan and the Eurozone over the next two years, although much depends on currency movements (see the next Insight).

Reflation continues to dictate short-term market moves. Behind this sugar-high, the global economic backdrop remains poor. Commodity currencies can rally for a few more weeks, but once markets refocus on Chinese and EM core weaknesses, commodity currencies will make new lows. Within the complex, favor the NOK and the CAD over the AUD and the NZD. Our portfolio remains positioned for additional yen strength.

The Fed's statement underscored its 'go slow' approach, with a June hike increasingly unlikely, but September and December still in play. The BoJ stood pat, reluctant to admit that NIRP was a flop soon after it was launched. Nevertheless, we expect fresh easing this summer. Chinese stimulus should last a few more months, but commodities will resume their structural downtrend thereafter. Remain tactically bullish risk assets; be prepared to turn more cautious in Q2.

Our sense is that the current reflation trade will extend into the summer, sending stock and commodity prices higher and the U.S. dollar down. Global government bond yields should rise during this phase. Beyond the near term, we expect these reflation trades to go into reverse. Stay defensive.

Special Report

Monetary policy at systematically important central banks will determine the winners and losers in global ag export markets going forward. The evolution of fundamentals - supply, demand, and inventories - will remain essential drivers. Mother Nature is the wild card.

Policy easing works with a time lag, and the previous easing measures should continue to feed through to business activity. The recent decline in the trade-weighted RMB should lead to continued improvement in the industrial sector's performance for at least the next two quarters.

The near-term (next month or two) market dynamics in EM risk assets remain a coin toss. Beyond that the outlook for EM risk assets remains downbeat. EM financial markets are complacent and there are many potential negative EM/China developments that could derail the current EM rally. A new trade: go long the KOSPI / short EM overall equity index.

Most financial assets are trading within the confines of the feedback loop between markets and Fed policy. Investors should avoid expensive assets such as spread product, and hold positions with attractive long-term value such as U.S. TIPS over nominal Treasuries and U.S. Treasuries over German bunds.