Gold
Highlights Currency markets continue to fight a tug-of-war between deteriorating global growth and easing global financial conditions. Such an environment is typically fertile ground for a dollar bull market, yet the trade-weighted dollar is up only 2.3% this year. The lack of more-pronounced strength in the greenback suggests that other powerful underlying forces are preventing the dollar from gapping higher. The breakdown in the bond-to-gold ratio is an important distress signal for dollar bulls. As both political and economic uncertainty remain elevated, likely winners in the interim remain safe-haven currencies such as the yen and the Swiss franc. For the remainder of the year, portfolio managers should focus on relative value trades at the crosses, rather than outright dollar bets. Stand aside on the pound for now. Aggressive investors can place a buy stop at 1.25 and sell stop at 1.20. The Riksbank’s hawkish surprise was a welcome development for the krona. Remain long SEK/NZD. The SEK might be the best-performing G10 currency over the next five years. Feature Yearly performance is an important benchmark for most portfolio managers. As most CIOs return to their desks from a summer break, they will be looking at a few barometers to help them navigate the rest of 2019. On the currency front, here is what the report card looks like so far: The dollar has been a strong currency, but the magnitude of the increase has been underwhelming, given market developments. The Federal Reserve’s trade-weighted dollar is up only 2.3% this year. In contrast, the yen is up 3.6% and the Canadian dollar 2.3%. Meanwhile, the best shorts have been the Swedish krona (down 9.7%) and the kiwi. Through the lens of the currency market, the dollar has been in a run-of-the-mill bull market, rather than in a panic buying frenzy (Chart I-1). Chart I-1A Report Card On Currency Performance
Preserving Capital During Riot Points
Preserving Capital During Riot Points
Gold has broken out in every major currency. This carries a lot of weight because it has occurred amid dollar strength, a historical rarity. Importantly, the breakout culminates the seven-or-so-year pattern where gold was stable versus many major currencies (Chart I-2). We are no technical analysts, but ever since gold peaked in 2011, all subsequent rallies have seen diminishing amplitude, which by definition were bull traps. This appeared to have changed since 2015-2016, which could be a signal that the dollar bull market is nearing an end. Commodities have been a mixed bag. Precious metals have surged alongside gold. Despite the recent correction, oil is still up 13.8% for the year. Meanwhile, natural gas is in a bear market. Among metals, nickel has surged 70%, while Doctor Copper is down 5.1%. The only semblance of agreement is among soft commodities, which have been mostly deflating (Chart I-3). In short, there has been no coherent theme for commodity currencies. All the talk of a Sino-U.S. trade war, Chinese A-shares are up 18.7% for the year. This more than makes up for any CNY depreciation. Equities have performed well across the board, mostly up double digits. The only notable laggards have been in Asia, specifically Japan, Hong Kong and Korea. That said, of all the talk of a Sino-U.S. trade war, Chinese A-shares are up 18.7% for the year. This more than makes up for any CNY depreciation. This also suggests that capital flows into equities have not been a major driver of currencies this year. Chart I-2Gold Has Been The Ultimate Currency
Gold Has Been The Ultimate Currency
Gold Has Been The Ultimate Currency
Chart I-3Commodities Are A Mixed Bag
Commodities Are A Mixed Bag
Commodities Are A Mixed Bag
Yields have collapsed, with higher-beta markets seeing bigger drops. Differentials have mostly moved against the dollar in recent weeks as the U.S. 10-year yield plays catch-up to the downside. One important question is that with Swiss 10-year yields now at -0.96% and German yields at -0.67%, is there a theoretical floor to how low bond yields can fall (Chart I-4)? Chart I-4Yields Have Melted
Yields Have Melted
Yields Have Melted
Heading back to his office, the CIO is now pondering how to deploy fresh capital. On one hand, the typical narrative that we have been operating in the quadrant of a deflationary bust, given the trade war, manufacturing recession, political unrest and rapidly rising probability of recession is not clearly visible in financial data. This would have been historically dollar bullish, and negative for other asset classes. However, the plunge in bond yields begs the question of whether this is a prelude to worse things to come. A more sanguine assessment is that we might be at a crossroads of sorts. If economic data continues to deteriorate due to much larger endogenous factors, a defensive strategy is clearly warranted. One way to tell will be an emerging divergence between our leading indicators and actual underlying data. On the flip side, any specter of positive news could light a fire under sectors, currencies and countries that have borne the brunt of the slowdown. Time is of the essence, and strategy will be dependent on horizons. A review of the leading indicators for the major economic blocks is in order. Are We At The Cusp Of A Recession? Centripetal systems tend to stay in equilibrium, while centrifugal forces can explode in spectacular fashion. In the currency world, this means that the tug of war between deteriorating global growth and easing liquidity conditions cannot last forever. Either the dollar breakout morphs into a panic buying frenzy or proves to be a bull trap. Are we at the cusp of a bottom in global growth, or approaching a riot point? Let us start with the economic front: U.S.: Plunging U.S. bond yields have historically been bullish for growth. More importantly, the recent decline in the ISM Manufacturing Index is approaching 2008 recessionary levels. Either easing in financial conditions revive the index, or the decoupling persists for a while longer. The tone on the political front appears reconciliatory, which means September and October data will be critical. In 2008, the divergence between deteriorating economic conditions and falling yields was an important signpost for a riot point (Chart I-5). Eurozone: The Swedish manufacturing PMI ticked up to 52.4 in August. Most importantly, the new orders-to-inventories ratio is suggesting that the German (and European) manufacturing recession is reversing (Chart I-6). For all the debate about whether China is stimulating enough or not, the beauty about this indicator is that there are no Chinese variables in it (the euro zone and Sweden export a lot of goods and services to China). Any surge higher in this indicator will categorically conclude the euro zone manufacturing recession is over, lighting a fire under the euro in the process. Whatever the number is, if it can stabilize Chinese growth, a powerful deflationary force that dictated markets in 2018-2019 will dissipate. China: Chinese bond yields have melted alongside global yields. This is reflationary, given the liberalization in the bond market over the past few years. Policy makers are currently discussing the quota for next year’s fiscal spending. Whatever the number is, if it can stabilize Chinese growth, a powerful deflationary force that dictated markets in 2018-2019 will dissipate. Chart I-5Is U.S. Manufacturing Close ##br##To A Bottom?
Is U.S. Manufacturing Close To A Bottom?
Is U.S. Manufacturing Close To A Bottom?
Chart I-6Is Eurozone Manufacturing Close To A Bottom?
Is Eurozone Manufacturing Close To A Bottom?
Is Eurozone Manufacturing Close To A Bottom?
Discussions among industry specialists suggest some anecdotal evidence that many manufacturers have been engaged in re-routing channels and parallel manufacturing chains to avoid the U.S.-China tariffs. This is welcome news, since global exports and global trade are still in a downtrend. A key barometer to watch on whether the global slowdown is infecting domestic demand will be Chinese imports (Chart I-7). So far, the message is that traditional correlations have not yet broken down. As a contrarian, this is positive. Manufacturing slowdowns have tended to last 18 months peak-to-trough, the final months of which are characterized by fatigue and capitulation. However, unless major imbalances exist (our contention is that so far they do not), mid-cycle slowdowns sow the seeds of their own recovery via accumulated savings and pent-up demand. In the currency world, the dollar has tended to be an excellent counter-cyclical barometer. On the dollar, the bond-to-gold ratio is breaking down, in contrast to the rise in the DXY. This is not a sustainable divergence (Chart I-8). The last time the bond-to-gold ratio diverged from the DXY was in 2017, and that proved extremely short-lived. As global growth rebounded and U.S. repatriation flows eased, dollar support was quickly toppled over. Chart I-7Chinese Imports Could Soon Rebound
Chinese Imports Could Soon Rebound
Chinese Imports Could Soon Rebound
Chart I-8Mind The Gap
Mind The Gap
Mind The Gap
Ever since the end of the Bretton Woods agreement broke the gold/dollar anchor in the early 1970s, bullion has stood as a viable threat to dollar liabilities, capturing the ebbs and flows of investor confidence in the greenback tick-for-tick. While U.S. yields remain attractive, portfolio outflows and a deteriorating balance-of-payments backdrop will keep longer-term investors on the sidelines. Chart I-9Dollar Bulls Need A More Hawkish Fed
Dollar Bulls Need A More Hawkish Fed
Dollar Bulls Need A More Hawkish Fed
Capital tends to gravitate towards higher returns, and the U.S. tax break in 2017 was a one-off that is now ebbing. Meanwhile, despite wanting to resist the appearance of influence from President Trump, the Fed realises that the neutral rate of interest in the U.S. is now below its target rate, which should keep them on an easing path. A dovish Fed has historically been bearish for the dollar (Chart I-9). Bottom Line: In terms of strategy, heightened uncertainty can keep the greenback bid in the coming weeks, but we will be sellers on strength. Our favorite plays remain the Swedish krona, the Norwegian krone, and, for insurance purposes, the Japanese yen. Outright dollar shorts await confirmation from more economic data. What To Do About CAD? The Bank of Canada (BoC) decided to stay on hold at its latest policy meeting. This was highly anticipated, but the silver lining is that the BoC might later reflect on this move as a policy mistake, given the arms race by other central banks to ease policy. The three most important variables for the Canadian economy are a:) what is happening to the U.S. economy, b:) what is happening to crude oil prices and c:) what is happening to consumer leverage and the housing market. On all three fronts, there has been scant good news in recent weeks. Heightened uncertainty can keep the greenback bid in the coming weeks, but we will be sellers on strength. The Nanos Investor Confidence Index suggests Canadian GDP might be at the cusp of a slowdown after an excellent run of a few quarters (Chart I-10). One of the key drivers for the CAD/USD exchange rate is interest rate differentials with the U.S., and the compression in rates could run further (Chart I-11). Unless the BoC adopts a looser monetary stance, a rising exchange rate is likely to tighten financial conditions. Rising energy prices will be a tailwind, but the Western Canadian Select discount, and persistent infrastructure problems are headwinds. As such, we think domestic conditions will continue to knock down whatever benefit comes from rising oil prices. Chart I-10Canadian Data Has##br## Been Firm
Canadian Data Has Been Firm
Canadian Data Has Been Firm
Chart I-11A Firm Exchange Rate Could Tighten Financial Conditions
A Firm Exchange Rate Could Tighten Financial Conditions
A Firm Exchange Rate Could Tighten Financial Conditions
On the consumer side, real retail sales are deflating at the worst pace since the financial crisis, but consumer confidence remains elevated given the robust labor market data (Chart I-12). However, if house prices continue to roll over, confidence is likely to crater (Chart I-13). Chart I-12Canada: Consumer Spending Is Weak
Canada: Consumer Spending Is Weak
Canada: Consumer Spending Is Weak
Chart I-13Canada: The Housing Market Is Softening
Canada: The Housing Market Is Softening
Canada: The Housing Market Is Softening
On the corporate side of the equation, the latest Canadian Business Outlook Survey suggests there has been no meaningful revival in capital spending. This is a big headwind, since Canada finances itself externally rather than via domestic savings. For external investors, the large stock of debt in the Canadian private sector and overvaluation in the housing market are likely to continue leading to equity outflows (from bank shares) on a rate-of-change basis (Chart I-14). Chart I-14Foreign Investors Are Fleeing Canadian Securities
Foreign Investors Are Fleeing Canadian Securities
Foreign Investors Are Fleeing Canadian Securities
Technically, the USD/CAD failed to break below the upward sloping trend line drawn from its 2012 lows, and the series of lower highs since the 2016 peak is forcing the cross into the apex of a tight wedge. The next resistance zone on the downside is the 1.30-1.32 level. Our bias is that this zone will prove to be formidable resistance. We continue to recommend investors short the CAD, mainly via the euro. Housekeeping We were stopped out of our short XAU/JPY position amid fervent buying in gold. Even though we are gold bulls, the rationale behind the trade was that the ratio of the two safe havens was at a speculative extreme. We will stand aside for now and look to re-establish the position in the near future. The Risksbank left rates on hold this week. This was welcome news for our long SEK/NZD position. The weakness in the SEK this year was expected given the surge in summer volatility, but the magnitude of the fall took us by surprise. In general, as soon as President Trump ramped up the trade-war rhetoric and China started devaluing the RMB, the environment became precarious for all pro-cyclical currencies. In terms of strategy going forward, the SEK probably has some additional downside, but not a lot. It is currently the cheapest currency in the G10. Should the Riksbank be actively trying to weaken the currency ahead of ECB policy stimulus this month, the final announcement, depending on what it entails, might be the bottom for the SEK and top for the EUR/SEK. Finally, as the Brexit drama unfolds, the outlook for the pound is highly binary. Aggressive investors can place a buy stop at 1.25 and a sell stop at 1.20. Anything in between should be regarded as noise. Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1
USD Technicals 1
USD Technicals 1
Chart II-2USD Technicals 2
USD Technicals 2
USD Technicals 2
Recent data in the U.S. have been firm: PCE deflator nudged up from 1.3% to 1.4% year-on-year in July. Core PCE was unchanged at 1.6% year-on-year. Michigan consumer sentiment index fell from 92.1 to 89.8 in August. Trade deficit narrowed marginally by $1.5 billion to $54 billion in July. Notably, the trade deficit with China increased by 9.4% to $32.8 billion in July. Initial jobless claims was little changed at 217 thousand for the past week. Unit labor cost increased by 2.6% in Q2. Nonfarm productivity remained unchanged at 2.3%. Factory orders increased by 1.4% month-on-month in July. More importantly on the PMI front, Markit manufacturing PMI was down from 50.4 in July to 50.3 in August. ISM manufacturing PMI deteriorated to 49.1 in August, while ISM non-manufacturing PMI increased to 56.4, up from the previous 53.7 and well above estimates. DXY index fell by 0.5% this week. The recent worries about a near-term recession since the 10/2 yield curve inverted last month has been supporting the dollar, together with possible additional tariffs against China and the Chinese yuan devaluation. Going forward, we believe the dollar strength will ebb, given fading interest rate differentials. Report Links: Has The Currency Landscape Shifted? - August 16, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Focusing On the Trees But Missing The Forest - August 2, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1
EUR Technicals 1
EUR Technicals 1
Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2
EUR Technicals 2
EUR Technicals 2
Recent data in the euro area have been firm: Unemployment rate was unchanged at 7.5% in July. Both headline and core preliminary inflation were unchanged at 1% and 0.9% year-on-year respectively in August. PPI fell from 0.7% to 0.2% year-on-year in July. On the PMI front, Markit composite PMI was little changed at 51.9 in August. Manufacturing component was unchanged at 47, while services component nudged up slightly to 53.5. Retail sales growth fell from upwardly-revised 2.8% to 2.2% year-on-year in July, still better than the estimated 2%. EUR/USD appreciated by 0.5% this week. While the manufacturing sector across Europe remain depressed, the services sector seems to be alive and well. The ECB monetary policy meeting next Thursday will be key for the path of the euro. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1
JPY Technicals 1
JPY Technicals 1
Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2
JPY Technicals 2
JPY Technicals 2
Recent data in Japan have been mixed: Housing starts fell by 4.1% year-on-year in July. Construction orders increased by 26.9% year-on-year in July, a positive shift from 4.2% contraction in the previous month. Capital spending growth slowed to 1.9% in Q2. Manufacturing PMI fell slightly to 49.3 in August, while services PMI jumped from 51.8 to 53.3. USD/JPY increased by 0.5% this week. The consumption tax hike in Japan is scheduled for October 1. The tax rate will rise from 8% to 10%, with possible exemption on several goods such as food and non-alcoholic beverages, which could be a drag on domestic spending. That being said, we continue to favor the Japanese yen due to the risk of a recession amid the escalating global trade war. Report Links: Has The Currency Landscape Shifted? - August 16, 2019 Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1
GBP Technicals 1
GBP Technicals 1
Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2
GBP Technicals 2
GBP Technicals 2
Recent data in the U.K. continued to deteriorate: Nationwide house price index was unchanged in August. Markit composite PMI fell to 50.2 in August: Manufacturing component slowed to 47.4; Construction PMI fell to 45; Services component decreased to 50.6. Retail sales contracted by 0.5% year-on-year in August. GBP/USD increased by 1.2% this week. Brexit remains the biggest driver behind the pound. British PM Boris Johnson’s brother resigned this week, citing tension between “family loyalty” and “national interest”. Our Geopolitical Strategy upgraded a no-deal Brexit probability to about 33%, maintaining that it is not the base case since nobody wants an imminent recession. From a valuation perspective, the pound is quite cheap and currently trading far below its fair value. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1
AUD Technicals 1
AUD Technicals 1
Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2
AUD Technicals 2
AUD Technicals 2
Recent data in Australia have been mixed: Building approvals keep contracting by 28.5% year-on-year in July. Australian Industry Group (AiG) manufacturing index increased to 53.1 in August. The services index soared to 51.4 in August from a previous reading of 43.9. Current account balance shifted to A$5.9 billion in Q2, the first surplus since 1975. Retail sales contracted by 0.1% month-on-month in July. GDP growth slowed down to 1.4% year-on-year in Q2, the lowest rate in over a decade. Exports and imports both grew by 1% and 3% month-on-month respectively. Trade surplus narrowed marginally to A$7.3 million. AUD/USD increased by 1.4% this week. While Q2 GDP growth rate continued to soften, the current account and PMI data are showing tentative signs of a recovery. On Monday, the RBA kept interest rates unchanged at 1%. In the press release, the Bank acknowledged that low income growth and falling house prices limited household consumption in the first half of the year. Going forward, the tax cuts, infrastructure spending, housing market stabilization, and a healthy resources sector should all support the Australian economy, and put a floor under the Aussie dollar. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns- April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1
NZD Technicals 1
NZD Technicals 1
Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2
NZD Technicals 2
NZD Technicals 2
Recent data in New Zealand have been negative: Consumer confidence improved slightly to 118.2 in August. Building permits continued to contract by 1.3% month-on-month in July. Terms of trade increased to 1.6% in Q2. NZD/USD increased by 1.2% this week. In a Bloomberg interview earlier this week, the New Zealand finance minister Grant Robertson expressed his confidence on the fundamentals of the domestic economy, especially the low unemployment rate and sound wage growth. The largest downside risk remains the global trade and manufacturing slowdown. As a small open economy, New Zealand is ultimately vulnerable to exogenous factors, especially those related to its large trading partners including U.S., China, and Australia. On the policy side, the finance minister believes that there is “still room to move” in terms of monetary policy. Report Links: USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1
CAD Technicals 1
CAD Technicals 1
Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2
CAD Technicals 2
CAD Technicals 2
Recent data in Canada have been mostly negative: Annualized Q2 GDP growth jumped from 0.5% to 3.7% quarter-on-quarter, well above estimates. Bloomberg Nanos confidence fell slightly from 57 to 56.4. Markit manufacturing PMI fell to 49.1 in August, right after a small rebound in July to 50.2. Trade deficit widened to C$1.12 billion in July. USD/CAD fell by 0.5% this week. On Wednesday, BoC held its interest rate unchanged at 1.75%, as widely expected. In its monetary policy statement, the BoC sounded cautiously dovish, and expects economic activity to slow in the second half of the year amid global growth worries. The strong Q2 rebound was mostly driven by cyclical energy production and robust export growth, which could be temporary given the current market volatility. The rate cut probability next month is currently at 40%. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1
CHF Technicals 1
CHF Technicals 1
Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2
CHF Technicals 2
CHF Technicals 2
Recent data in Switzerland have been positive: KOF leading indicator was unchanged at 97 in August. Real retail sales grew by 1.4% year-on-year in July, up from the previous 0.7%. Manufacturing PMI increased to 47.2 in August, up from 44.7 in the previous month. Headline inflation remained muted at 0.3% year-on-year in July. GDP yearly growth slowed to 0.2% in Q2, from a downwardly-revised 1% in Q1. USD/CHF fell by 0.2% this week. We remain positive on the Swiss franc. The global economic slowdown and increasing worries about a near-term recession remain tailwind for the safe-haven franc. Report Links: What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1
NOK Technicals 1
NOK Technicals 1
Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2
NOK Technicals 2
NOK Technicals 2
Recent data in Norway have been mostly negative: Retail sales increased by 0.9% year-on-year in July. Current account surplus plunged by 60% from NOK 73.1 billion to NOK 30.6 billion in Q2, the lowest since Q4 2017. USD/NOK fell by 1.3% this week. The rebound in oil prices this week has supported petrocurrencies. On the supply side, the production discipline is likely to be maintained. On the demand side, fiscal stimulus globally should revive overall demand. A potential weaker USD should also support oil prices in the second half of the year, which will be bullish for the Norwegian krone. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1
SEK Technicals 1
SEK Technicals 1
Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2
SEK Technicals 2
SEK Technicals 2
Recent data in Sweden have been mixed: Manufacturing PMI increased slightly to 52.4 in August, from 52 in the previous month. Current account surplus narrowed from SEK 63 billion to SEK 37 billion in Q2. Industrial production increased by 3.2% year-on-year in July. Manufacturing new orders increased by 0.4% in July compared with last month. However, on a year-on-year basis, it fell by 2.2%. The Swedish krona rallied this week, appreciating by 1.4% against USD. The Riksbank held its interest rate unchanged at -0.25% this Thursday, and stated that they still plan to raise interest rates this year or early next, but at a slower pace than the previous forecast. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades
Highlights While a self-fulfilling crisis of confidence that plunges the global economy into recession cannot be excluded, it is far from our base case. Provided the trade war does not spiral out of control, it is highly likely that global equities will outperform bonds over the next 12 months. The auto sector has been the main driver of the global manufacturing slowdown. As automobile output begins to recover later this year, so too will global manufacturing. Go long auto stocks. As a countercyclical currency, the U.S. dollar will weaken once global growth picks up. We expect to upgrade EM and European equities later this year along with cyclical equity sectors such as industrials, energy, and materials. Financials should also benefit from steeper yield curves. We still like gold as a long-term investment. However, the combination of higher bond yields and diminished trade tensions could cause bullion to sell off in the near term. As such, we are closing our tactical long gold trade for a gain of 20.5%. Feature “The Democrats are trying to 'will' the Economy to be bad for purposes of the 2020 Election. Very Selfish!” – @realDonaldTrump, 19 August 2019 8:26 am “The Fake News Media is doing everything they can to crash the economy because they think that will be bad for me and my re-election” – @realDonaldTrump, 15 August 2019 9:52 am Bad Juju Chart 1Spike In Google Searches For The Word Recession
A Psychological Recession?
A Psychological Recession?
President Trump’s remarks, made just a few days after the U.S. yield curve inverted, were no doubt meant to deflect attention away from the trade war, while providing cover for any economic weakness that might occur on his watch. But does the larger point still stand? Google searches for the word “recession” have spiked recently, even though underlying U.S. growth has remained robust (Chart 1). Could rising angst induce an actual recession? Theoretically, the answer is yes. A sudden drop in confidence can generate a self-fulfilling cycle where rising pessimism leads to less private-sector spending, higher unemployment, lower corporate profits, weaker stock prices, and ultimately, even deeper pessimism. Two things make such a vicious cycle more probable in the current environment. First, the value of risk assets is quite high in relation to GDP in many economies (Chart 2). This means that any pullback in equity prices or jump in credit spreads will have an outsized impact on financial conditions. Chart 2The Total Market Value Of Risk Assets Is Elevated
The Total Market Value Of Risk Assets Is Elevated
The Total Market Value Of Risk Assets Is Elevated
Chart 3Not Much Scope To Cut Rates
Not Much Scope To Cut Rates
Not Much Scope To Cut Rates
Second, policymakers are currently more constrained in their ability to react to adverse shocks, such as an intensification of the trade war, than in the past. Interest rates in Europe and Japan are already at zero or in negative territory (Chart 3). Even in the U.S., the zero-lower bound constraint – though squishier than once believed – remains a formidable obstacle. Chart 4 shows that the Federal Reserve has cut rates by over five percentage points, on average, during past recessions. It would be impossible to cut rates by that much this time around if the U.S. economy were to experience a major downturn. Chart 4The Fed Is Worried About The Zero Bound
The Fed Is Worried About The Zero Bound
The Fed Is Worried About The Zero Bound
Fiscal stimulus could help buttress growth. However, both political and economic considerations are likely to limit the policy response. While China is stimulating its economy, concerns about excessively high debt levels have caused the authorities to adopt a reactive, tentative approach. Japan is set to raise the consumption tax on October 1st. Although a variety of offsetting measures will mitigate the impact on the Japanese economy, the net effect will still be a tightening of fiscal policy. Germany has mused over launching its own Green New Deal, but so far there has been a lot more talk than action. President Trump floated the idea of cutting payroll taxes, only to abandon it once it became clear that the Democrats were unwilling to go along. On The Positive Side Despite these clear risks, we are inclined to maintain our fairly sanguine 12-to-18 month global macro view. There are a number of reasons for this: First, the weakness in global manufacturing over the past 18 months has not infected the much larger service sector (Chart 5). Even in Germany, with its large manufacturing base, the service sector PMI remains above 50, and is actually higher than it was late last year. This suggests that the latest global slowdown is more akin to the 2015-16 episode than the 2007-08 or 2000-01 downturns. Chart 5AThe Service Sector Has Softened Much Less Than Manufacturing (I)
The Service Sector Has Softened Much Less Than Manufacturing (I)
The Service Sector Has Softened Much Less Than Manufacturing (I)
Chart 5BThe Service Sector Has Softened Much Less Than Manufacturing (II)
The Service Sector Has Softened Much Less Than Manufacturing (II)
The Service Sector Has Softened Much Less Than Manufacturing (II)
Second, manufacturing activity should benefit from a turn in the inventory cycle over the remainder of the year. A slower pace of inventory accumulation shaved 90 basis points off of U.S. growth in the second quarter and is set to knock another 40 basis points from growth in the third quarter, according to the Atlanta Fed GDPNow model. Excluding inventories, U.S. GDP growth would have been 3% in Q2 and is tracking at 2.7% in Q3 – a fairly healthy pace given the weak global backdrop (Chart 6). Chart 6The U.S. Economy Is Still Holding Up Well
A Psychological Recession?
A Psychological Recession?
Outside the U.S., inventories are making a negative contribution to growth (Chart 7). In addition to the official data, this can be seen in the commentary accompanying the Markit manufacturing surveys, which suggest that many firms are liquidating inventories (Box 1). Falling inventory levels imply that sales are outstripping production, a state of affairs that cannot persist indefinitely. Third, and related to the point above, the automobile sector has been the key driver of the global manufacturing slowdown. This is in contrast to 2015-16, when the main culprit was declining energy capex. According to Wards, global vehicle production is down about 10% from year-ago levels, by far the biggest drop since the Great Recession (Chart 8). The drop in automobile production helps explain why the German economy has taken it on the chin recently. Chart 7Inventories Are Making A Negative Contribution To Growth
Inventories Are Making A Negative Contribution To Growth
Inventories Are Making A Negative Contribution To Growth
Chart 8Auto Sector: The Culprit Behind The Manufacturing Slowdown
Auto Sector: The Culprit Behind The Manufacturing Slowdown
Auto Sector: The Culprit Behind The Manufacturing Slowdown
Importantly, motor vehicle production growth has fallen more than sales growth, implying that inventory levels are coming down. Despite secular shifts in automobile ownership preferences, there is still plenty of upside to automobile usage. Per capita automobile ownership in China is only one-fifth of what it is in the United States, and one-fourth of what it is in Japan (Chart 9). This suggests that the recent drop in Chinese auto sales will be reversed. As automobile output begins to recover later this year, so too will global manufacturing. Investors should consider going long automobile makers. Chart 10 shows that the All-Country World MSCI automobiles index is trading near its lows on both a forward P/E and price-to-book basis, and sports a juicy dividend yield of nearly 4%.1 Chart 9The Automobile Ownership Rate Is Still Quite Low In China
The Automobile Ownership Rate Is Still Quite Low In China
The Automobile Ownership Rate Is Still Quite Low In China
Chart 10Auto Stocks Are A Compelling Buy
A Psychological Recession?
A Psychological Recession?
Fourth, our research has shown that globally, the neutral rate of interest is generally higher than widely believed. This means that monetary policy is currently stimulative, and will become even more accommodative as the Fed and a number of other central banks continue to cut rates. Remember that unemployment rates have been trending lower since the Great Recession and have continued falling even during the latest slowdown, implying that GDP growth has remained above trend (Chart 11). As diminished labor market slack causes inflation to rebound from today’s depressed levels, real policy rates will decline, leading to more spending through the economy. Chart 11Unemployment Rates Keep Trending Lower
Unemployment Rates Keep Trending Lower
Unemployment Rates Keep Trending Lower
The Trade War Remains The Biggest Risk The points discussed above will not matter much if the trade war spirals out of control. It is impossible to know what will happen for sure, but we can deduce the likely course of action based on the incentives that both sides face. President Trump has shown a clear tendency in recent weeks to try to de-escalate trade tensions whenever the stock market drops. This is not surprising: Despite his efforts to deflect blame for any selloff on others, he knows full well that many voters will blame him for losses in their 401(k) accounts and for slower domestic growth and rising unemployment. What about the Chinese? An increasing number of pundits have warmed up to the idea that China is more than willing to let the global economy crash if this means that Trump won’t be re-elected. If this is China’s true intention, the Chinese will resist making any deal, and could even try to escalate tensions as the U.S. election approaches. It is an intriguing thesis. However, it is not particularly plausible. U.S. goods exports to China account for 0.5% of U.S. GDP, while Chinese exports to the U.S. account for 3.4% of Chinese GDP. Total manufacturing value-added represents 29% of Chinese GDP, compared to 11% for the United States. There is no way that China could torpedo the U.S. economy without greatly hurting itself first. Any effort by China to undermine Trump’s re-election prospects would invite extreme retaliatory actions, including the invocation of the War Powers Act, which would make it onerous for U.S. companies to continue operating in China. Even if Trump loses the election, he could still wreak a lot of havoc on China during the time he has left in office. Moreover, as Matt Gertken, BCA’s Chief Geopolitical Strategist, has stressed, if Trump were to feel that he could not run for re-election on a strong economy, he would try to position himself as a “War President,” hoping that Americans rally around the flag. That would be a dangerous outcome for China. Chart 12Would China Really Be Better Off Negotiating With A Democrat As President?
Would China Really Be Better Off Negotiating With A Democrat As President?
Would China Really Be Better Off Negotiating With A Democrat As President?
In any case, it is not clear whether China would be better off with a Democrat as president. The popular betting site PredictIt currently gives Elizabeth Warren a 34% chance of winning, followed by Joe Biden with 26%, and Bernie Sanders with 15% (Chart 12). This means that two far-left candidates with protectionist leanings, who would stress environmental protection and human rights in their negotiations with China, have nearly twice as much support as the former Vice President. All this suggests that China has an incentive to de-escalate the trade war. Given that Trump also has an incentive to put the trade war on hiatus, some sort of détente between the U.S. and China, as well as between the U.S. and other players such as the EU, is more likely than not. Investment Conclusions Provided the trade war does not spiral out of control, it is very likely that global equities will outperform bonds over the next 12 months. Since it might take a few more months for the data on global growth to improve, equities will remain in a choppy range in the near term, before moving higher later this year. As we discussed last week, the equity risk premium is quite high in the U.S., and even higher abroad, where valuations are generally cheaper and interest rates are lower (Chart 13).2 Chart 13AEquity Risk Premia Remain Quite High (I)
Equity Risk Premia Remain Quite High (I)
Equity Risk Premia Remain Quite High (I)
Chart 13BEquity Risk Premia Remain Quite High (II)
Equity Risk Premia Remain Quite High (II)
Equity Risk Premia Remain Quite High (II)
The U.S. dollar is a countercyclical currency (Chart 14). If global growth picks up later this year, the greenback should begin to weaken. European and emerging market stocks have typically outperformed the global benchmark in an environment of rising global growth and a weakening dollar (Chart 15). We expect to upgrade EM and European equities – along with more cyclical sectors of the stock market such as industrials, materials, and energy – later this year. Chart 14The U.S. Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency
The U.S. Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency
The U.S. Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency
Chart 15EM And Euro Area Equities Usually Outperform When Global Growth Improves
EM And Euro Area Equities Usually Outperform When Global Growth Improves
EM And Euro Area Equities Usually Outperform When Global Growth Improves
Thanks to the dovish shift by central banks around the world, government bond yields are unlikely to return to their 2018 highs anytime soon. Nevertheless, stronger economic growth should lift long-term yields at the margin, causing yield curves to steepen (Chart 16). Steeper yield curves will benefit beleaguered bank stocks. Chart 16Stronger Economic Growth Should Lift Long-Term Bond Yields, Causing Yield Curves To Steepen
Stronger Economic Growth Should Lift Long-Term Bond Yields, Causing Yield Curves To Steepen
Stronger Economic Growth Should Lift Long-Term Bond Yields, Causing Yield Curves To Steepen
Finally, a word on gold: We still like gold as a long-term investment. However, the combination of higher bond yields and diminished trade tensions could cause bullion to sell off in the near term. As such, we are closing our tactical long gold trade for a gain of 20.5%. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com Box 1 Evidence of Inventory Liquidation In The Manufacturing Sector
A Psychological Recession?
A Psychological Recession?
Footnotes 1 The top ten constituents of the MSCI ACWI Automobiles Index are Toyota (22.6%), General Motors (7.8%), Daimler (7.3%), Honda Motor (6.2%), Ford Motor (5.7%), Tesla (4.8%), Volkswagen (4.8%), BMW (3.8%), Ferrari (3.0%), Hyundai Motor (2.4%). 2 Please see Global Investment Strategy Special Report, “TINA To The Rescue?” dated August 23, 2019. Strategy & Market Trends MacroQuant Model And Current Subjective Scores
A Psychological Recession?
A Psychological Recession?
Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
Escalating Sino-U.S. trade tensions. The effect on gold prices from an escalation in Sino-U.S. trade tensions are difficult to model. On the one hand, such an escalation would positively impact gold prices, because it increases the probability of more rate…
BCA's Foreign Exchange Strategy and Commodity & Energy Strategy services have collaborated to analyze how gold performs better than most alternative safe-haven assets – i.e. U.S., Japanese and Swiss bonds and currencies. Importantly, gold is unique…
Highlights From time immemorial, gold has been a medium of exchange, a store of value, and a safe haven to hedge portfolios. In modern times, the market in which it trades has evolved into an important filter of information and expectations re monetary policy, inflation expectations, and geopolitical risk. At any moment in time, one or all of these factors can drive gold prices. At present, we believe the precious metal is pricing to all three of them. However, as we show below, one group of factors – monetary and financial aggregates – holds sway over the evolution of gold prices at present (Chart of the Week).
Chart 1
Feature We view gold primarily as a financial asset – almost a currency, but not quite, since it has non-monetary value as well as being a medium of exchange (e.g., in electronics applications). We separate the factors to which gold prices are responsive into three groups of fundamentals: Demand for inflation hedges; Monetary and financial aggregates; and, Demand for portfolio-diversification assets, including safe-haven demand. In modeling gold prices, we also pay attention to a group of tactical indicators that complements our fundamental analysis using sentiment, positioning and technical indicators (Table 1).1 Table 1Fundamental And Technical Gold-Price Drivers
All That Glitters ... And Then Some
All That Glitters ... And Then Some
As important as real rates are to the evolution of gold prices, technical factors – chiefly sentiment and positioning – also played a large role in gold’s recent breakout (Chart 2). Our tactical composite indicator moved from oversold to overbought territory. Sentiment often is a thin reed on which to place too much conviction, and, over the near term, this could weigh on prices, as market participants try to anticipate when sentiment will change.2 Tracking these variables allows us to generate a “fair value” for gold, which represents the equilibrium at which all of these diverse forces meet (Chart 3). Chart 2Technical Indicators Play A Role In Price Formation
Technical Indicators Play A Role In Price Formation
Technical Indicators Play A Role In Price Formation
Chart 3Gold Fair Value Model Captures Upward Trajectory For Gold
Gold Fair Value Model Captures Upward Trajectory For Gold
Gold Fair Value Model Captures Upward Trajectory For Gold
Below, we discuss each group of fundamentals driving gold prices, using this analysis to draw investment conclusions. Inflation Hedging Demand Hedging against inflation historically has been one of the key drivers of gold demand. For most of the 21st century, inflationary pressures in the U.S. have remained subdued (Chart 4). For the most part, the recent fall in realized inflation is due to transitory factors like the sharp decline in financial-services costs inflation following last December’s market sell-off (Chart 5). However, it also reflects a larger-than-expected slowdown in the U.S. and global economy, as well as falling inflation expectations (Chart 6). Low realized and expected inflation will, we believe, make it easier for the Fed to cut rates at its upcoming end-July meeting. Chart 4Inflation Pressures Remain Subdued
Inflation Pressures Remain Subdued
Inflation Pressures Remain Subdued
Our research shows inflation-hedging demand for gold only supports the metal’s price in periods of “high” inflation – i.e., realized and expected inflation rates running above 4.5% p.a. Chart 5Transitory Factors Push Realized Inflation Lower
Transitory Factors Push Realized Inflation Lower
Transitory Factors Push Realized Inflation Lower
Chart 6Inflation Expectations Also Are Subdued
Inflation Expectations Also Are Subdued
Inflation Expectations Also Are Subdued
Over the short term – i.e., the next 3 months or so – this means demand for an inflation hedge will not be the primary driver of gold prices. All the same, markets might be getting out ahead of themselves on this score: The Fed’s recent dovish turn signals inflation could surprise to the upside, and likely will move above target next year. As our U.S. Bond strategists note, the Fed’s new battleground is between inflation expectations and financial conditions.3 Indeed, the upcoming “insurance cut” from the Fed at its end-July meeting largely reflects the Fed’s goal of reviving inflation expectations.4 Our research shows inflation-hedging demand for gold only supports the metal’s price in periods of “high” inflation – i.e., realized and expected inflation rates running above 4.5% p.a. We expect inflation to trend higher later in 2020.5 Ordinarily, during inflationary periods, store-of-value assets like gold are bid up as demand exceeds relatively inelastic supply.6 Bottom Line: For now, even though realized and expected inflation remains subdued, it can exceed the Fed’s and other systematically important central banks’ policy rates. This produces low inflation-adjusted interest rates – real rates, in the vernacular – which are bullish for gold prices. We explore this further below. Monetary And Financial Aggregates In the current low-interest-rate environment, inflation rates do not have to rise far above central-bank targets to trigger a flight to gold. Indeed, real rates can quickly turn negative as inflation rises, which diminishes the real return of holding bonds. Since 2014, gold’s price has correlated well with negative yields in global debt markets (Chart 7). The recent dovish turn by systematically important central banks will reinforce this tendency. At present, the monetary and financial aggregates we follow are the most important determinants of gold prices. From an explanatory perspective – vis-à-vis modeling gold prices – these are the most robust group of variables in our analytical framework, as shown in the price decomposition in Chart 1. These variables are important because they focus on the opportunity cost of holding gold, which, in and of itself, generates no yield, and the impact of the U.S. dollar on gold demand, via its price and wealth effects on consumers ex U.S. Chart 7Gold Correlations Rise With Negative-Yielding Debt
Gold Correlations Rise With Negative-Yielding Debt
Gold Correlations Rise With Negative-Yielding Debt
Chart 8Gold Correlations Also Higher Versus Real Rates
Gold Correlations Also Higher Versus Real Rates
Gold Correlations Also Higher Versus Real Rates
U.S. real rates: As a non-yielding asset, gold’s opportunity cost increases with real interest rates. This makes investment demand for gold negatively correlated with real rates (Chart 8). As mentioned previously, the recent dovish turn by major central banks – notably the Fed – supported gold’s 10.8% return YTD, and will continue to do so as we approach the July FOMC meeting. Nonetheless, the positive effect of monetary easing could diminish going into 2H19. Our U.S. Bond strategists’ recent research shows yields rise, on average, following a mid-cycle “insurance rate” cut (Chart 9).7 A second “insurance cut” in 2H19 would delay a rise in yields further into 2H19 or 2020. Because of this, markets will be focused on the Fed’s forward guidance, following it FOMC’s end-July meeting. U.S. Dollar: One of the most stable and powerful relationships with gold prices is its inverse correlation to the U.S. dollar (USD). Chart 10 illustrates this relationship, which has held since the 1990s and before, and has been even more profound than that of oil and copper with the greenback. For one, gold, like oil and copper, is quoted in U.S. dollars, so a drop in the greenback is manifested through higher gold prices because of the numeraire effect. But the powerful relationship between the dollar and gold is at the heart of the function of gold as a medium of exchange, from time immemorial.
Chart 9
Chart 10Gold's Relationship With USD Is Long-Standing
Gold's Relationship With USD Is Long-Standing
Gold's Relationship With USD Is Long-Standing
Gold continues to outperform Treasurys today, which has historically been an ominous sign for the U.S. dollar. Ever since the end of the Bretton Woods agreement broke the gold/dollar link in the early ‘70s, bullion has stood as a viable barometer of dollar liabilities, capturing the ebbs and flows of investor confidence in the greenback tick for tick. With the Federal Reserve’s dovish shift, we may just have triggered one of the necessary catalysts for a selloff in the U.S. dollar. A pick-up in global and Chinese growth amidst ample liquidity conditions will be supportive of gold. The rationale is pretty simple. Investors who are worried about U.S. twin deficits – fiscal and trade – and the crowded trade of being long Treasurys will shift into gold, since pretty much every other major bond market (Germany, Switzerland, Japan) has negative yields. That favors gold at the expense of the dollar. The reverse is true if investors consider Treasurys more of a safe haven. The bond-to-gold ratio and dollar tend to move tick for tick, so a breakout in one can be a signal for what will happen to the other (Chart 11). Given interest rates, portfolio flows, balance-of-payments dynamics and growth differentials are moving against the U.S. dollar, a breakdown will be a powerful catalyst for higher gold prices. Meanwhile, a fall in the dollar improves the purchasing power of many emerging-market countries as their currencies appreciate. These countries, especially China, Russia and India tend to be the marginal buyers of gold. Chart 12 shows that there is a pretty strong and consistent relationship between the performance of EM relative to DM equities and the gold price. The important takeaway is that the rise in the gold price has not yet been supported by the normal wealth-effect channels from emerging markets, suggesting we are just in the early stages of the rally. Chart 11As Is The USD's Relationship With The Bond/Gold Ratio
As Is The USD's Relationship With The Bond/Gold Ratio
As Is The USD's Relationship With The Bond/Gold Ratio
Chart 12Gold's Second Leg Up Likely Comes From EM Demand
Gold's Second Leg Up Likely Comes From EM Demand
Gold's Second Leg Up Likely Comes From EM Demand
Gold tends to be a “Giffen Good,” meaning physical demand increases as prices rise. Ever since the gold bubble burst in 2011, both financial and jewelry demand have evaporated. The reality is that both China and India went on a buying binge of coins and jewelry during gold’s last bull market, and there is no reason to expect this time to be different, if, as we expect, incomes continue to rise in these markets (Chart 13). This is especially important since less than 28% of gold demand is investment related, with the balance being consumer and industrial. Ergo, a pick-up in global and Chinese growth amidst ample liquidity conditions will be supportive of gold.
Chart 13
Consumer and industrial demand for gold is vividly captured in our GIA index (Chart 14). As a weighted average of select country trade data, currencies, industrial production and a few Chinese manufacturing sector variables, it captures the ebb and flow of the global production cycle. More important for the gold price is the trend in this index rather that the amplitude. The upturn remains tentative, but will be another catalyst that cements the gold bull market. Bottom Line: Given interest rates, portfolio flows, balance-of-payment dynamics and growth differentials are moving against the U.S. dollar, a breakdown will be a powerful catalyst for higher gold prices. Higher EM income growth will also be supportive. Chart 14Rebound in EM Industrial Activity Will Boost EM Wealth, Gold Demand
Rebound in EM Industrial Activity Will Boost EM Wealth, Gold Demand
Rebound in EM Industrial Activity Will Boost EM Wealth, Gold Demand
Gold As A Portfolio-Diversification Asset Safe-haven assets provide an essential source of returns for investors in times of crisis. Gold remains one of the best safe-haven assets to protect portfolios against drawdowns arising from financial, geopolitical and political crises. Our analysis shows gold performs better than most alternative safe-haven assets – i.e. U.S., Japanese and Swiss bonds and currencies (Chart 15, Top Panel). Importantly, gold is unique because of the non-linearity in its hedging ability: In times of crisis, gold beats most other safe-havens, while also being the top performer among the group in periods of economic and equity market expansion (Chart 16).8 This makes gold a less risky safe-haven asset to own defensively in late cycles.
Chart 15
Chart 16
Critically, gold’s performance during periods of heightened geopolitical risk is formidable. Not to put too fine a point on it, but we believe geopolitical risks will remain elevated in 2H19. Three ongoing developments remain important to monitor: Iran-U.S. conflict and the heightened probability of an oil shock. We believe markets are underestimating the likelihood of a military conflict between Iran and the U.S. in the Persian Gulf. While both sides to this standoff in the Gulf have professed their desire to avoid war, the real risk is an inadvertent escalation in hostilities arising from routine operations, as has happened in the past. An escalation of hostilities in the Gulf almost surely would rally oil and gold prices, as Chart 15, Middle Panel – Performance During Geopolitical Crises – shows.9 EM central banks’ de-dollarization. Data from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) shows that the global allocation of foreign exchange reserves towards the U.S. dollar peaked at about 72% in the early 2000s and has been in a downtrend since. At the same time, foreign central banks have been amassing gold reserves, notably Russia and China, almost to the tune of the total annual output of the yellow metal (Chart 17, Bottom Panel). The U.S. dollar remains the reserve currency of the world today, but that exorbitant privilege is fading. Escalating Sino-U.S. trade tensions. The effects on gold prices from an escalation in Sino-U.S. trade tensions are difficult to model. On the one hand, such an escalation would positively impact gold prices, because it increases the probability of more rate cuts from central banks – including the Fed and PBOC – and likely would lead to an increase in equity volatility. It also could impact gold prices negatively, because it likely would diminish EM GDP growth more than U.S. growth, which, over the short-to-medium term, would be negative for gold and commodities generally. This likely also would rally the dollar, which is negative for gold, and commodities generally. About the only thing we can venture at this point is such an escalation would increase the safe-haven demand for gold, as investors rush for cover. Chart 17Central Banks Are Absorbing Most Gold Production
Central Banks Are Absorbing Most Gold Production
Central Banks Are Absorbing Most Gold Production
Chart 18Gold Becomes More Appealing As Recession Fears Grow
Gold Becomes More Appealing As Recession Fears Grow
Gold Becomes More Appealing As Recession Fears Grow
Each factor influencing gold is time-varying. The safe-haven component of gold’s price is a modest driver of its price in ordinary times. However, as an economic expansion reaches its limit, gold benefits from mounting recession fears, as these worries usually are exacerbated by the Fed‘s tightening cycles (Chart 18). In these periods, gold’s correlation with real rates diminishes and the inflation and recession/equity-correction risks dominate. This contributed to gold’s outperformance since 4Q18. We continue to recommend gold as a portfolio hedge, given its performance during periods of financial, monetary and geopolitical stress. For the present, however, the dovish turn by systematically important central banks – combined with fiscal stimulus earlier this year, and monetary stimulus later this year in China – implies the expansion will last longer than previously expected, pushing portfolio-diversification demand lower in the ranking of gold’s drivers until the hiking cycle restarts some time in the future.10 Bottom Line: We continue to recommend gold as a portfolio hedge, given its performance during periods of financial, monetary and geopolitical stress, as shown above. Risks remain elevated in all of these dimensions, which will keep gold well supported over the short and medium terms. Hugo Bélanger, Senior Analyst Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Robert P. Ryan, Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 The supply of gold is relatively fixed over the short and long term – every ounce of gold ever produced still is in circulation in one form or another (e.g., as jewelry or as an electronic component).Please see the World Gold Council’s Supply and Demand Statistics, which show these data to 1Q19. 2 Please see The Gold Trifecta published June 27, 2019, by BCA Research’s Commodity & Energy Strategy. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see The New Battleground For Monetary Policy, published by BCA Research’s U.S. Bond Strategy March 26, 2019.It is available at usbs.bcaresearch.com. 4 This expression was used by Fed Chair Jay Powell in his March congressional testimony: “In our thinking, inflation expectations are now the most important driver of actual inflation.”Please see Fed Puts Inflation Expectations at Heart of Major Policy Review, published by Bloomberg.com March 15, 2019. 5 For more details on gold – and other assets – performance during different inflation regimes, please see BCA Research’s Global Asset Allocation’s Investors’ Guide To Inflation Hedging: How To Invest When Inflation Rises, published May 22, 2019.It is available at gaa.bcaresearch.com. 6 Gold’s inelastic supply is important. Gold is regularly treated as a currency; however, it lacks a central bank that can increase its supply via turning up the printing press. This makes the precious metal a so-called "hard currency," and endows it with the ability to maintain its purchasing power during periods of inflation. In addition, it is an asset that is accepted as collateral to support bank lending and margining by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), and numerous commercial and private banks. 7 Please see The Long Awkward Middle Phase published by BCA Research’s U.S. Bond Strategy July 2, 2019.It is available at usbs.bcaresearch.com. 8 Gold’s performance across the spectrum of bear-to-bull equity markets shows it is, in some respects, similar to a long option position with puts protecting the downside and calls protecting the upside. Its value increases as equities and other asset classes are falling, and it also appreciates as these other assets are rising, albeit not as much at times. 9 Please see Supply – Demand Balances Consistent With Higher Oil Prices, published by BCA Research’s Commodity & Energy Strategy June 20, 2019, for further discussion.See also The Emerging Crisis in the Persian Gulf by Richard Nephew, published by Columbia University's Center on Global Energy Policy July 19, 2019. 10 Please see “Third Quarter 2019 Strategy Outlook: The Long Hurrah” published by BCA Research’s Global Investment Strategy June 28, 2019, for a discussion of U.S. and Chinese stimulus.It is available at gis.bcaresearch.com. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades TRADE RECOMMENDATION PERFORMANCE IN 2019 Q2
Image
Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2019 Summary of Closed Trades
Image
Housekeeping
Housekeeping
Last Thursday we were stopped out from our tactical S&P semi equipment underweight position as it hit our -7% stop loss (bottom panel). We are obeying the stop loss and are returning this index to a neutral weighting as better than expected profits from both ASML and TSMC lifted all chip-related equities. In marked contrast, our long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas exploration & production trade initiated just last week has gone parabolic, spiking to 17% (top panel). While our thesis has not changed in this high beta tactical pair trade, from a risk management perspective, we are moving our stop loss from -10% to +12% in order to protect profits. Bottom Line: Stick with the counter-cyclical long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas exploration & production trade via the long GDX:US/short XOP:US exchange traded funds. For additional details on the rationale behind this trade, please refer to last Monday’s Weekly Report.
Dear Clients, In addition to this Weekly Report, you will also be getting a Special Report authored by some of our top strategists on global growth. The manufacturing recession that began in early 2018 has lasted longer than most expected. The risk is that this is an additional end-of-cycle indicator, with important ramifications for the U.S. dollar. The dollar tends to stage meaningful rallies in recessions. In this week’s publication, we highlight some of the key indicators we are watching for justification on maintaining a pro-cyclical stance, but the internal debate from the Special Report highlights how delicate the balance of forces for this stance are. A fortnight ago we suggested a few portfolio hedges, and recommend maintaining tight stops on all positions until September. Next week, we will be sending you a Special Report on gold, from our colleagues in the Commodity & Energy Strategy team. In the interim, I will be learning from our clients in Latin America about some of the forces currently shaping global FX markets. I will report back with my findings in a few weeks. Kind Regards, Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist Highlights There is very scant evidence that global growth is bottoming. That said, it is usually darkest before dawn. A few key indicators are beginning to flash amber, which we will continue to closely monitor. The deceleration phase this cycle has been as prolonged as others, warning that the rebound could also be V-shaped. The AUD/JPY cross will be a very useful barometer. Stay long a basket of petrocurrencies versus the euro and short USD/JPY. Feature One of the most cyclical developed-market indices is the Japanese Nikkei (Table I-1).1 Almost 60% of all sectors are concentrated in just three: consumer discretionary, information technology and industrials. Boasting a wide spectrum of global robotic, automotive and construction machinery giants, Japanese companies sit at the epicenter of the global manufacturing supply chain. As such, it is very telling when Japanese share prices – which track global bond yields very closely – appear to be making a tentative bottom (Chart I-1).
Chart I-
On the currency front, a lower greenback has also tended to be a very useful confirmation signal that we are entering a reflationary window. A slowing global economy on the back of deteriorating trade is positive for the greenback. As a reserve and counter-cyclical currency, the dollar has tended to rise during times of capital flight. On the other hand, a dovish Federal Reserve knocks down U.S. interest rate expectations relative to the rest of the world. This has historically been bearish for the dollar, and positive for global growth (Chart I-2). More importantly, even if the Fed does not proceed to cut rates as much as the market expects, it will be because global growth has bottomed, which will also favor non-U.S. rates. Chart I-1Japanese Share Prices Usually Bottom Before Bond Yields
Japanese Share Prices Usually Bottom Before Bond Yields
Japanese Share Prices Usually Bottom Before Bond Yields
Chart I-2A Dovish Fed Will Be Dollar Bearish
A Dovish Fed Will Be Dollar Bearish
A Dovish Fed Will Be Dollar Bearish
The commodity and export channel also helps explain why rising global growth is negative for the dollar. In theory, rising commodity prices (or rising terms of trade) allow for increased government spending in export-driven economies, making room for the resident central bank to tighten monetary policy. This is usually bullish for the currency. Rising terms of trade also further increases the fair value of the exchange rate. Balance-of-payments dynamics also tend to improve when exports are booming. Altogether, these forces combine to be powerful undercurrents for pro-cyclical currencies. Both political and domestic pressure for central banks to ease policy is the highest it has ever been. Chart I-3Both Economic And Political Pressure For Central Banks To Alter Policy
Both Economic And Political Pressure For Central Banks To Alter Policy
Both Economic And Political Pressure For Central Banks To Alter Policy
Both political and domestic pressure for central banks to ease policy is the highest it has ever been.2 This suggests that either they have already done so or the conditions warranting stimulus have hit climactic pressure. Going forward, such a synchronized move by global central banks is usually accompanied by a synchronized recovery, for the simple reason that central banks are usually behind the curve (Chart I-3). Finally, the starting point for long dollar positions is one of an overcrowded trade, along with U.S. Treasury bonds. The latest downdraft in global manufacturing has nudged U.S. net speculative long positions to a point where they typically experience exhaustion (Chart I-4). This suggests there may be a scarcity in fresh dollar bulls. 2018 was particularly favorable for the dollar, as a liquidity crunch (the Fed’s balance sheet runoff) underpinned a sizeable rally. The big surge in cryptocurrencies this year (and gold) could suggest that the liquidity environment is once again becoming favorable. Chart I-4Dollar Positioning Is Stretched
Dollar Positioning Is Stretched
Dollar Positioning Is Stretched
Chart I-5Carry Trades Are Usually Consistent With Higher Yields
Carry Trades Are Usually Consistent With Higher Yields
Carry Trades Are Usually Consistent With Higher Yields
An improving liquidity environment will be especially favorable for carry trades. High-beta currencies such as the RUB/USD, ZAR/USD and BRL/USD have stopped falling and are off their lows of the year. These currencies are usually good at sniffing out a change in the investment landscape. The message so far is that the drop in U.S. bond yields may have been sufficient to make these currencies attractive again (Chart I-5). Bottom Line: There is very scant evidence that global growth is bottoming. That said, it is usually darkest before dawn. A few key indicators are beginning to flash amber, which we will continue to monitor closely. A Few Growth Barometers A key difference from last year is that U.S. growth leadership is set to give way to the rest of the world. The U.S. ISM manufacturing Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) peaked last August and has been steadily rolling over relative to its trading partners. Historically, the relative growth differential between the U.S. and elsewhere has had a pretty good track record of dictating trends in the dollar. The message is that the manufacturing PMI should pick up from 47.6 currently to the 50 boom/bust level in the coming months. Meanwhile, there is some evidence that there are tentative signs of a bottom in global growth: Chart I-6Euro Area Might Be Close To A Bottom
Euro Area Might Be Close To A Bottom
Euro Area Might Be Close To A Bottom
Europe: The Swedish new orders to inventory ratio has a long and pretty accurate track record of calling bottoms in European growth, and the message is that the manufacturing PMI should pick up from 47.6 currently to the 50 boom/bust level in the coming months. Importantly, the recoveries have tended to be V-shaped pretty much throughout the past two decades. Any further decline in the PMI will pin it at levels consistent with the last European debt crisis (Chart I-6). Japan: Japan is closely impacted by the industrial cycle, especially demand from China. And while overall machinery orders remain weak, machine tool orders from China have bottomed. China: The Chinese credit impulse has bottomed. This suggests the contraction in imports, along with Korean and Taiwanese exports, is near its nadir (Chart I-7). The domestic bond market in China is becoming pretty good at signaling reflationary conditions for domestic demand (Chart I-8). Singapore exports this week were deeply negative, but this could be the bottom if all credit-injection so far in China starts flowing. Shipping indices are already recovering very strongly, and global machinery stocks are re-rating. Chart I-7A Modest Recovery For Exports
A Modest Recovery For Exports
A Modest Recovery For Exports
Chart I-8Chinese Imports Should Bounce
Chinese Imports Should Bounce
Chinese Imports Should Bounce
A pickup in Chinese growth should begin to benefit commodity currencies, especially the Australian dollar. A lot of the bad news already appears to be priced into the Aussie, which is down 14% from its 2018 peak and 37% from its 2011 peak. This suggests outright short AUD bets are susceptible to either upside surprises in global growth or simply forces of mean reversion. Importantly, the AUD/JPY cross is sitting at an important technical level. Ever since the financial crisis, the 72-74 cent zone has proven to be formidable resistance, with the cross failing to break below both during the euro area debt crisis in 2011-2012 and the China slowdown of 2015-2016. Speculators are now massively short the cross, suggesting that any upward move could be powerful and significant (Chart I-9). A rally in the Swedish krona will be another confirmation that global growth may have bottomed. A rally in the Swedish krona will be another confirmation that global growth may have bottomed. On a relative basis, the Swedish economy appears to have troughed relative to that of the U.S., making the USD/SEK an attractive way to play USD downside. From a technical perspective, USD/SEK failed to break decisively above 9.60, and is now trading below a major resistance at 9.40 (Chart I-10). Aggressive investors can slowly begin accumulating short positions, while being cognizant of the negative carry. Chart I-9AUD/JPY Near A Critical Zone
AUD/JPY Near A Critical Zone
AUD/JPY Near A Critical Zone
Chart I-10The Swedish Krona Is Attractive
The Swedish Krona Is Attractive
The Swedish Krona Is Attractive
Bottom Line: We are already long the SEK versus NZD, and the thesis remains intact from our June 7th recommendation. The AUD/JPY cross is very close to a bottom. Hold EUR/CAD For A Trade Chart I-11EUR/CAD Technicals: Limited Downside
EUR/CAD Technicals: Limited Downside
EUR/CAD Technicals: Limited Downside
The EUR/CAD has reached an important technical level, and what will follow is either a major breakdown or a powerful bounce (Chart I-11). With Canadian data firing on all cylinders and the euro area in the depths of a manufacturing recession, the cross has rightly responded to growth divergences. On the downside, the EUR/CAD is at the bottom of the upward trending channel that has existed since 2012, in the vicinity of 1.45-1.46. A bounce here will not meet initial upside resistance until the triple top, a nudge above 1.6. The biggest catalyst for this cross going forward will likely be interest rate differentials, since any improvement in euro area data will continue to reduce the scope by which the European Central Bank stays dovish relative to the Bank of Canada. European rates are further below equilibrium, and the ECB’s dovish shift will help lift the growth potential of the euro area. Meanwhile, the Canadian neutral rate will be heavily weighed down by the large stock of debt in the Canadian private sector, exacerbated by overvaluation in the housing market. Valuations and balance-of-payment dynamics also favor the euro versus the CAD on a long-term basis. Bottom Line: Hold the EUR/CAD for a trade with a stop at 1.45. Chart I-12Gold/Silver Ratio Near Speculative Extreme
Gold/Silver Ratio Near Speculative Extreme
Gold/Silver Ratio Near Speculative Extreme
Trade Idea: Buy Silver, Sell Gold The gold/silver ratio is reaching a speculative extreme. Usually, reflationary cycles benefit silver more than gold, with 100 usually the upper bound of the gold/silver ratio. We are very close to such a tipping point. Stay tuned (Chart I-12). Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1
USD Technicals 1
USD Technicals 1
Chart II-2USD Technicals 2
USD Technicals 2
USD Technicals 2
Recent data in the U.S. have continued to soften: Headline PPI fell to 1.7% year-on-year in June. Core PPI was unchanged at 2.3% year-on-year in June. NY Empire State manufacturing index increased to 4.3 in July. Retail sales increased by 0.4% month-on-month in June. Import and export prices contracted by 0.9% and 2% year-on-year respectively in June. Building permits contracted by 6.1% month-on-month in June. Housing starts softened by 0.9% month-on-month. Philadelphia Fed manufacturing index rose to 21.8 in July from 0.3 in June. Continuing jobless claims fell to 1.686 million this week, while initial jobless claims increased to 216 thousand. DXY increased by 0.4% this week. On Tuesday, Fed Chair Powell gave a short speech in Paris, regarding the current developments in the U.S. economy, and some post-crisis structural shifts. While U.S. economy has been on the 11th consecutive year of expansion, Powell highlighted concerns towards softer growth this year, in the manufacturing sector in particular, weighed down by weaker consumer spending, sluggish business investment, and trade war uncertainties. Report Links: On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1
EUR Technicals 1
EUR Technicals 1
Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2
EUR Technicals 2
EUR Technicals 2
Recent data in the euro area have been weak: Industrial production contracted by 0.5% year-on-year in May. Trade balance widened to €20.2 billion in May. Headline and core inflation increased by 1.3% and 1.1% year-on-year respectively in June. EUR/USD fell by 0.36% this week. ZEW data continue to soften in July: The sentiment index in the euro area fell to -20.3, and the sentiment in Germany decreased to -24.5. Moreover, the European Commission’s summer forecast released last week cut the 2020 euro area GDP projection from 1.5% (spring forecast) to 1.4%, and lowered inflation to 1.3% for both this year and next year. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1
JPY Technicals 1
JPY Technicals 1
Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2
JPY Technicals 2
JPY Technicals 2
Recent data in Japan have been negative: Industrial production contracted by 2.1% year-on-year in May. Capacity utilization increased by 1.7% in May. Exports contracted by 6.7% year-on-year in June. Imports also fell by 5.2% year-on-year. Total trade balance increased to ¥589.5 billion. USD/JPY fell by 0.2% this week. The weak Q2 data worldwide, driven by a significant slowdown in the manufacturing sector have raised concerns for a possible near-term recession. This has been exacerbated by a trade war, U.S.-Iranian tensions and Brexit uncertainties. We continue to favor the yen as a safe-haven currency. Hold to the short USD/JPY and short XAU/JPY positions. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 Short USD/JPY: Heads I Win, Tails I Don’t Lose Too Much - May 31, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1
GBP Technicals 1
GBP Technicals 1
Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2
GBP Technicals 2
GBP Technicals 2
Recent data in the U.K. have been mixed: Rightmove house price index contracted by 0.2% year-on-year in July. On the labor market front, ILO unemployment rate was unchanged at 3.8% in May. Average earnings including bonus increased by 3.4% in May. Headline inflation was unchanged at 2% year-on-year in June. Core inflation increased to 1.8% year-on-year. Retail sales increased by 3.8% year-on-year in June. GBP/USD fell by 0.5% this week, now trading around 1.2486. The Brexit uncertainties still loom over the U.K. Boris Johnson and Jeremy Hunt are fighting to take over from Theresa May as the leader of the Conservative Party and the UK’s next Prime Minister. In addition, the Q2 credit conditions survey released this Thursday indicates that default rates on loans to corporates increased for small and large businesses in Q2. Meanwhile, these are expected to increase for businesses of all sizes in Q3. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1
AUD Technicals 1
AUD Technicals 1
Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2
AUD Technicals 2
AUD Technicals 2
Recent data in Australia have been mixed: Westpac leading index fell by 0.08% month-on-month in June. On the labor market front, unemployment rate was unchanged at 5.2% in June. Participation rate was steady at 66%. 500 new jobs were created in June, including 21.1 thousand new full-time positions, and a loss of 20.6 thousand part-time positions. AUD/USD increased by 0.3% this week. The RBA minutes released this week reiterated that the central bank is ready to adjust interest rates if required, in order to support sustainable growth and achieve the inflation target overtime. The easing financial conditions and rising terms of trade all underpin the Aussie dollar in the long term. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns- April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1
NZD Technicals 1
NZD Technicals 1
Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2
NZD Technicals 2
NZD Technicals 2
Recent data in New Zealand have been mostly positive: House sales keep contracting by 3.8% year-on-year in June. Business manufacturing PMI increased to 51.3 in June. Headline inflation increased to 1.7% year-on-year in Q2. NZD/USD rose by 0.6% this week. Solid incoming data have lifted the New Zealand dollar for the past few weeks. However, the kiwi might lag the Aussie given the RBNZ is behind the RBA. The market is currently pricing in an 84% probability of a rate cut at the beginning of next month, but more cuts could be needed down the road. Hold to our long AUD/NZD and SEK/NZD positions. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1
CAD Technicals 1
CAD Technicals 1
Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2
CAD Technicals 2
CAD Technicals 2
Recent data in Canada have been mostly positive: Headline and core inflation both fell to 2% year-on-year in June. ADP employment shows an increase of 30.4 thousand new jobs in June. USD/CAD increased by 0.3% this week. Just last week, the BoC kept its interest rate on hold. With a more dovish Fed, this might narrow the interest rate differentials between the Fed and the BoC. We favor the loonie in the near-term based on the interest rate differentials, crude oil prices, and relatively more positive data incoming from Canada. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1
CHF Technicals 1
CHF Technicals 1
Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2
CHF Technicals 2
CHF Technicals 2
Recent data in Switzerland have been mixed: Producer and import prices contracted by 1.4% year-on-year in June. Exports increased to CHF 20,328 million, while imports fell to CHF 17,131 million in June. This lifted the trade balance up to 3,251 million. USD/CHF increased by 0.35% this week. We continue to favor the Swiss franc in the long term. The rising market volatility has increased the appetite for the Swiss franc. Moreover, the Swiss franc is still cheap compared to its fair value. Report Links: What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1
NOK Technicals 1
NOK Technicals 1
Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2
NOK Technicals 2
NOK Technicals 2
Recent data in Norway have been negative: Trade balance narrowed to NOK 5.2 billion in June. USD/NOK increased by 0.8% this week. The recent energy price volatility, mostly due to the uncertainties of oil demand has knocked down the Norwegian krone. In the long term, we continue to believe that the OPEC 2.0’s production strategy of reducing global oil inventories, and U.S. – Iran tension will drive oil prices higher, thus bullish for petrocurrencies including the Norwegian krone. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1
SEK Technicals 1
SEK Technicals 1
Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2
SEK Technicals 2
SEK Technicals 2
Recent data in Sweden have been positive. Industrial orders increased by 3.2% year-on-year in May. Budget balance came in at SEK -24.8 billion in June. USD/SEK fell by 0.28% this week. Recent data shows that the Swedish government debt is sliding below 35% of GDP. This is triggering political pressure on the government to expand fiscal support. More fiscal expenditure will allow for a more hawkish Risksbank, supporting the Swedish Krona. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Footnotes 1 The Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) classification does not really apply for euro zone companies, so we used the Industry Classification Benchmark (ICB) for the euro area, the U.S., and Japan. The difference between GICS and ICB is that the new GICS standard (which took effect last year) splits Telecom into an additional Communication Services sector. ICB may also apply this later this year. 2 Carola Binder, “Political Pressure on Central Banks,” SSRN, December 16, 2018. Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades
Add Shiny Metal Exposure
Add Shiny Metal Exposure
One way to benefit from the global growth soft-patch is to go long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas E&P stocks on a tactical three-to-six month basis. Since our Monday inception three days ago, this pair trade is already up 9%. The relative moves in the underlying commodities that serve as pricing power proxies are the key drivers of this share price ratio (top panel). Given the massive currency debasement potential that has gripped Central Banks the world over, such a flush liquidity backdrop will boost the allure of the shiny metal more so than crude oil. Meanwhile, global manufacturing PMIs are foreshadowing recession and our diffusion index has plummeted to the lowest level since 2011 (diffusion shown inverted, middle panel). In the U.S. specifically there is a growth-to-liquidity handoff and the ISM manufacturing survey’s new order versus prices paid subcomponents confirms that global gold miners have the upper hand compared with E&P equities (bottom panel). Bottom Line: We initiated a tactical long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas E&P pair trade on a three-to-six month time horizon with a stop at the -10% mark. The ticker symbols for the stocks in these indexes are: GDX:US and BLBG – S5OILP – COP, EOG, APC, PXD, CXO, FANG, HES, DVN, MRO, NBL, COG, APA, XEC, respectively. Please refer to this Monday’s Weekly Report for additional details.
Highlights Portfolio Strategy Recession odds continue to tick higher, according to the NY Fed’s probability of recession model, at a time when global growth is waning, U.S. profit growth is contracting and the non-financial ex-tech corporate balance sheet is degrading rapidly. On a cyclical 3-12 month time horizon we remain cautious on the broad equity market. This is U.S. Equity Strategy’s view, which stands in contrast to the more sanguine equity BCA House View. The souring macro backdrop coupled with a firming industry demand outlook signal that more gains are in store for hypermarket stocks. The global growth slowdown, declining real bond yields, missing inflation, rising policy uncertainty and a favorable relative demand backdrop suggest that there is an exploitable tactical trading opportunity in a long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas E&P pair trade. Recent Changes Upgrade the S&P hypermarkets index to overweight, today. Initiate a long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas exploration & production (E&P) pair trade, today Table 1
Divorced From Reality
Divorced From Reality
Feature Obsession with the Fed easing continues to trump all else, with the SPX piercing through the 3,000 mark to fresh all-time highs last week. However, it is unrealistic for the Fed to do all the heavy lifting for the equity market as we have argued recently (see Chart 3 from June 24),1 at a time when profit cracks are spreading rapidly. This should be cause for some trepidation. Since the Christmas Eve lows essentially all of the 26% return in equities is explained by valuation expansion. The forward P/E has recovered from 13.5 to nearly 17.2 (Chart 1). There is limited scope for further expansion as four interest rate cuts in the coming 12 months are already priced in lofty valuations. Now profits will have to do the heavy lifting. But on the eve of earnings season, more than half of the S&P 500 GICS1 sectors are forecast to have contracted profits last quarter, and three sectors could not lift revenue versus year ago comps, according to I/B/E/S data. Looking further out, there is a plethora of indicators that we highlighted last week that suggest that a profit recession is looming.2 Our sense is that once the euphoria around the looming Fed easing cycle settles, there will be a massive clash between perception and reality (Chart 2) that will likely propagate as a surge in volatility. Chart 1Multiple Expansion Explains All Of The SPX’s Return
Multiple Expansion Explains All Of The SPX’s Return
Multiple Expansion Explains All Of The SPX’s Return
Chart 2Unsustainable Divergence
Unsustainable Divergence
Unsustainable Divergence
This addiction to low rates has come at a great cost to the non-financial corporate sector. As a reminder, this segment of the economy is where the excesses are in the current cycle as we have been highlighting in recent research.3 Using stock market related data for the non-financial ex-tech universe, net debt has increased by 70% to $4.2tn over the past five years, but cash flow has only grown 18% to $1.7tn. As a result, net debt-to-EBITDA has spiked from 1.7 to 2.5, an all-time high (Chart 3). While stocks are at all-time highs (top panel, Chart 3), the debt-saddled non-financials ex-tech universe will likely exert substantial downward pressure to these equities in the coming months (Chart 4). Chart 3Balance Sheet Degrading
Balance Sheet Degrading
Balance Sheet Degrading
Chart 4Something’s Got To Give
Something’s Got To Give
Something’s Got To Give
Moving on to the labor market, we recently noticed an interesting behavior between the unemployment rate and wage inflation since the early-1990s recession: a repulsive magnet-type property exists where like magnetic poles repel each other (middle panel, Chart 5). In other words, every time the falling unemployment rate has kissed off accelerating wage growth, a steep reversal ensued at the onset of recession during the previous three cycles. A repeat may be already taking place, as average hourly earnings (AHE) growth has been stuck in the mud since peaking in December 2018. Importantly, the AHE impulse is quickly losing steam and every time the Fed embarks on an aggressive easing cycle it typically marks the end of wage inflation (bottom panel, Chart 5). Chart 5Beware Of Repulsion
Beware Of Repulsion
Beware Of Repulsion
Chart 6Waiting For Growth
Waiting For Growth
Waiting For Growth
Meanwhile, BCA’s global manufacturing PMI diffusion index has cratered to below 40% (middle panel, Chart 6). Neither the G7 nor the EM aggregate PMIs are above the boom/bust line (top panel, Chart 6). Our breakdown of the Leading Economic Indicators into G7 and EM14 also signals that global growth is hard to come by, albeit EMs are showing some early signs of a trough (bottom panel, Chart 6). As the early-May announced increase in Chinese tariffs begin to take a toll, we doubt global growth can have a sustainable recovery for the rest of 2019, despite Chinese credit growth picking up. Now, even Japan and Korea are fighting it out and are erecting barriers to trade, dealing a further blow to these economically hyper-sensitive export-oriented economies. Netting it all out, the odds of recession by mid-2020 continue to tick higher according to the NY Fed’s model (NY Fed’s probability of recession shown inverted, top panel, Chart 5) at a time when global growth is waning, U.S. profit growth is contracting and the non-financial ex-tech corporate balance sheet is degrading rapidly. On a cyclical 3-12 month time horizon we remain cautious on the broad equity market. This is U.S. Equity Strategy’s view, which stands in contrast to the more sanguine equity BCA House View. This week we are upgrading a consumer staples subgroup to overweight and initiating an intra-commodity market neutral trade. Time To Buy The Hype The tide is shifting and we are upgrading the S&P hypermarkets index to an above benchmark allocation. While valuations are stretched, trading at a 50% premium to the overall market on a 12-month forward P/E basis (not shown), our thesis is that these Big Box retailers will grow into their pricey valuations in the coming months. The macro landscape is aligned perfectly with these defensive retailers. Consumer confidence has been falling all year long and now cracks are spreading to the labor market (confidence shown inverted, top panel, Chart 7). ADP small business payrolls declined for the second month in a row. Similarly, the NFIB survey shows that small business hiring plans are cooling (hiring plans shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 7). As a reminder, 2/3 of all new hiring typically occurs in the small and medium enterprise space. In the residential real estate market, the drop in interest rates that is now in its eighth month has yet to be felt, and house price inflation has ground to a halt. Historically, Costco membership growth has been inversely correlated with house prices (house price inflation shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 7). Chart 7Deteriorating Macro Backdrop …
Deteriorating Macro Backdrop …
Deteriorating Macro Backdrop …
Chart 8…Is A Boon To Hypermarkets…
…Is A Boon To Hypermarkets…
…Is A Boon To Hypermarkets…
Chart 8 shows three additional macro variables that signal brighter times ahead for the relative share price ratio. The drubbing in the 10-year U.S. treasury yield reflects a souring macro backdrop, melting inflation and a steep fall in U.S. economic data surprises. The ISM manufacturing index that continues to decelerate and is now closing in on the boom/bust line corroborates the bond market’s grim message. Tack on the Fed’s expected four cuts in the coming 12 months, and factors are falling into place for a durable rally in relative share prices. This disinflationary backdrop along with the Fed’s looming easing interest rate cycle have put a solid bid under gold prices. Hypermarket equities and bullion traditionally move in lockstep, and the current message is to expect more gains in the former (top panel, Chart 9). On the trade front specifically, these Big Box retailers do source consumer goods from China, but up to now these imports have been nearly immune to the U.S./China trade dispute as prices have been deflating (import prices shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 9). However, this does pose a risk going forward and we will be closely monitoring it for two reasons: First, because downward pressures may intensify on the greenback and second, President Trump may impose additional tariffs, both of which are negative for industry pricing power. Chart 9Profit Margins…
Profit Margins…
Profit Margins…
Chart 10…Will Likely Expand
…Will Likely Expand
…Will Likely Expand
Meanwhile, industry demand is on the rise and will likely offset the potential trade and U.S. dollar induced margin pressures. Hypermarket retail sales are climbing at a healthy clip outpacing overall retail sales (bottom panel, Chart 10). Already non-discretionary retail sales are outshining discretionary ones, which is a precursor to recession at a time when overall consumer outlays have sunk below 1% (real PCE growth shown inverted, top panel, Chart 10). The implication is that hypermarkets will continue to garner a larger slice of consumer outlays as the going gets tough. In sum, the souring macro backdrop coupled with a firming industry demand outlook signal that more gains are in store for hypermarket stocks. Bottom Line: Boost the S&P hypermarkets index to overweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG – S5HYPC – WMT, COST. Initiate A Long Global Gold Miners/Short S&P Oil & Gas E&P Pair Trade One way to benefit from the global growth soft-patch and looming global liquidity injection is to go long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas E&P stocks on a tactical three-to-six month basis. While this market neutral and intra-commodity pair trade has already enjoyed an impressive run, there is more upside owing to a favorable macro backdrop. The key determinant of this share price ratio is the relative move in the underlying commodities that serve as pricing power proxies (top panel, Chart 11). Given the massive currency debasement potential that has gripped Central Banks the world over, such a flush liquidity backdrop will boost the allure of the shiny metal more so than crude oil. Global manufacturing PMIs are foreshadowing recession and our diffusion index has plummeted to the lowest level since 2011 (diffusion shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 11). In the U.S. specifically there is a growth-to-liquidity handoff and the ISM manufacturing survey’s new order versus prices paid subcomponents confirms that global gold miners have the upper hand compared with E&P equities (bottom panel, Chart 11). Chart 11Global Soft-Patch…
Global Soft-Patch…
Global Soft-Patch…
Chart 12…Disinflation…
…Disinflation…
…Disinflation…
As a result of this growth scare that can easily morph into recession especially if the U.S./China trade war continues into next year, inflation is nowhere to be found. Unit labor costs are slumping (top panel, Chart 12), the NY Fed’s Underlying Inflation Gauge has rolled over decisively (not shown),4 and the GDP deflator is slipping (middle panel, Chart 12). Parts of the yield curve first inverted in early-December and the 10-year/fed funds rate slope is still inverted, signaling that gold miners will continue to outperform oil producers (yield curve shown on inverted scale, bottom panel, Chart 13). The near 100bps dive in real interest rates since late-December ties everything together and is a boon to bullion (and gold producers) that yields nothing (TIPS yield shown inverted, top panel, Chart 13). Meanwhile, bond volatility has spiked of late and the bottom panel of Chart 14 shows that historically the MOVE index has been joined at the hip with relative share prices. Chart 13…Melting Real Yields And…
…Melting Real Yields And…
…Melting Real Yields And…
Chart 14…The Spike In Bond Vol, All Favor Gold Miners Over Oil Producers
…The Spike In Bond Vol, All Favor Gold Miners Over Oil Producers
…The Spike In Bond Vol, All Favor Gold Miners Over Oil Producers
On the relative demand front, we peer over to China to take a pulse of the marginal moves in these commodity markets. China (and Russia) has been aggressively shifting their currency reserves into gold, and bullion holdings are rising both in volume terms and as a percentage of total FX reserves. In marked contrast, oil demand is feeble and Chinese apparent diesel consumption that is closely correlated with infrastructure and manufacturing activity has tumbled. Taken together, the message is to expect additional gain in relative share prices (middle & bottom panels, Chart 15). Adding it all up, the global growth slowdown, declining real bond yields, missing inflation, rising policy uncertainty and a favorable relative demand backdrop suggest that there is an exploitable tactical trading opportunity in a long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas E&P pair trade. Bottom Line: Initiate a tactical long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas E&P pair trade on a three-to-six month time horizon with a stop at the -10% mark. The ticker symbols for the stocks in these indexes are: GDX:US and BLBG – S5OILP – COP, EOG, APC, PXD, CXO, FANG, HES, DVN, MRO, NBL, COG, APA, XEC, respectively. Chart 15Upbeat Relative Demand Backdrop
Upbeat Relative Demand Backdrop
Upbeat Relative Demand Backdrop
Anastasios Avgeriou, U.S. Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Cracks Forming” dated June 24, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Beware Profit Recession” dated July 8, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “A Recession Thought Experiment” dated June 10, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 4 https://www.newyorkfed.org/research/policy/underlying-inflation-gauge Current Recommendations Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps
Highlights The breakout in financial asset prices stands at odds with a deteriorating profit outlook. This suggests a high probability of a coiled-spring reversal in one of the two variables as we enter the thin summer trading months. We are maintaining a pro-cyclical currency stance, but are making a few portfolio tweaks in case we are caught offside during what could be a volatile summer. Maintain very tight stops on cable at 1.25, but look to sell EUR/GBP between 0.92 and 0.94. Our top pick for long positions are petrocurrencies, as geopolitical support is unlikely to ebb anytime soon. Buy a speculative basket of the Norwegian krone, Russian ruble, Mexican peso, and Colombian peso versus the euro. The latest RBA interest rate cut might be the ultimate insurance backstop needed to jumpstart the Australian economy. Remain long the Aussie dollar versus both the greenback and the kiwi, but with tight stops on the former. Any “flash crashes” are likely to favor the currencies of countries where tradeable bonds are in short supply. Remain short USD/JPY. Also, tactically sell gold bullion versus the yen. Feature Chart I-1The Markets And Data Diverge
The Markets And Data Diverge
The Markets And Data Diverge
Financial markets are at an important crossroads as we head into the thin summer trading months. Asset prices have been reflated by plunging bond yields, with the S&P 500 hitting fresh highs this week. On the other hand, incoming manufacturing data across the major economies continue to deteriorate, suggesting the profit cycle remains in a downtrend. Either markets get better visibility into an improving profit outlook, or stock prices will succumb to the pressure of incoming data weakness (Chart I-1). For currency strategy, this means fundamentals could be temporarily put to the wayside, as markets flip the switch towards risk aversion. Our recommendations this week are threefold. First, maintain tight stops on tactical positions, especially those susceptible to summer volatility. Topping this list is our long position in the British pound. Second, our top pick for long positions are petrocurrencies, as geopolitical support is unlikely to ebb anytime soon. Finally, maintain portfolio insurance by being short the USD/JPY. Also, sell gold against the yen, given that relative sentiment has shifted in extreme favor of the former. A Summer Attack On The Pound? The episodes leading to the collapse of the pound in 1992 have important lessons for today.1 Britain entered the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) in October of 1990 in an attempt to find a stable nominal anchor. In the years preceding entry into the ERM, inflation in the U.K. had been high and rising, leading to an appreciation in the real exchange rate. The rationale was that by adopting German interest rates, inflation would finally be tempered, and the real exchange rate would eventually be realigned. Most of the adjustment in the pound happened quickly, but a key difference from today is that exit from the ERM was unanticipated, unlike Brexit. During the ensuing years, pressure on the pound was relatively short-lived and could be quickly reversed by foreign exchange interventions or modest increases in interest rates. Meanwhile, the prospect of a European Monetary Union (EMU) also provided an anchor for expectations, since it would allow for more sound domestic policies. Problems began to surface in June 1992, when the Danes voted no in a referendum on the Maastricht Treaty that included a chapter on the EMU. This led to severe doubts about the progress made towards a union, especially as the outcome of the French referendum in September was expected to be close. Investors began to question where the shadow exchange rate for ERM currencies lay, especially where the Italian lira or the Spanish peseta were concerned. In August of that year, Britain began to massively step up interventions in the foreign exchange market, having to borrow excessively through the Very Short Term Financing facility (VSTF) to increase reserves. It also promised to raise interest rates from 10% to 12%, and later to 15%. But as an overvalued exchange rate had generated extremely sluggish GDP growth going into the 1990s, markets were not convinced the U.K. would tap into its unlimited borrowing facility or raise interest rates sufficiently to defend the pound. On black Wednesday in September 1992, Britain suspended membership to the ERM. There are a few important lessons that stand in stark contrast to a hard Brexit: Most of the adjustment in the pound happened quickly, but a key difference from today is that exit from the ERM was unanticipated, unlike Brexit. Foreign exchange markets are extremely fluid and adjust to expectations quite quickly, usually with overshoots or undershoots. From its peak, GBP/USD depreciated by 24% by the end of October 1992. It subsequently fell to a low of 1.418 in February 1993 (Chart I-2). Peak to trough, cable has already fallen by 28%. Judging from the real effective exchange rate adjusted for consumer prices, the pound was overvalued as the U.K. entered the ERM. A persistent inflation differential between the U.K. and Germany had led to significant appreciation in the real rate. That gap is much narrower today (Chart I-3). Chart I-2The Pound Drop During ERM Was Quick And Violent
The Pound Drop During ERM Was Quick And Violent
The Pound Drop During ERM Was Quick And Violent
Chart I-3Not Much Misalignment In##br## U.K. Prices Today
Not Much Misalignment In U.K. Prices Today
Not Much Misalignment In U.K. Prices Today
The overvaluation of the pound meant that domestic growth was under tremendous pressure. Growth was already at recessionary levels entering into the ERM. Meanwhile, a bursting real estate bubble necessitated lower, not higher interest rates. This put to test the credibility of the peg. Today, U.K. growth is outpacing that of Germany, and will only improve if the pound drops further (Chart I-4). Productivity in the U.K. has kept pace with that of Germany over the last several years, suggesting the fall in the pound has been unwarranted. The Tory government runs a balanced budget and the Bank of England has much foreign exchange reserves to intervene in the market should confidence in the pound collapse. More importantly, the British currency is freely floating meaning there are less “hidden sins” compared to the fixed exchange rate period when it had to use the VSTF facility to boost reserves (Chart I-5). Chart I-4The U.K. Is Growing Faster Than The Eurozone's Engine
The U.K. Is Growing Faster Than The Eurozone's Engine
The U.K. Is Growing Faster Than The Eurozone's Engine
Chart I-5Britain Has Lots Of ##br##FX Reserves
Britain Has Lots Of FX Reserves
Britain Has Lots Of FX Reserves
A new conservative leadership is, at the margin, more negative for the pound (the assessment of our geopolitical strategists is that the odds of a hard Brexit have risen to 21% from 14%). However, our simple observation is that the pound is below where it was after the 2016 referendum results, yet more people are now in favor of staying in the union (Chart I-6). The pound is below where it was after the 2016 referendum results, yet more people are now in favor of staying in the union. This dichotomy might be the reason why in a speech this week, BoE Governor Mark Carney continued to highlight the growing divergence between market interest rate expectations (almost a 50% probability of a cut this year) and the central bank’s more hawkish bias. The experience of the ERM suggests it will be extremely destabilizing for the pound if the BoE is unable to anchor market interest rate expectations. This is especially true since the second quarter is likely to be a very weak one, leaving little time for data improvement until the October 31st Brexit deadline. Chart I-6More People In Favour Of The Union
More People In Favour Of The Union
More People In Favour Of The Union
Chart I-7Cable Valuation Reflects Brexit Risk
Cable Valuation Reflects Brexit Risk
Cable Valuation Reflects Brexit Risk
Putting it all together, our bias is that if there is a hard Brexit, the pound could easily drop to the 1.10-1.15 zone. Part of this move will be an undershoot. The real effective exchange rate of the pound is now lower than where it was after the U.K. exited the ERM in 1992, with a drawdown that has been of similar magnitude (24% in both episodes) (Chart I-7). In the case of a soft Brexit (or no Brexit), the pound should converge toward the mid-point of its (or above) historical real effective exchange rate range, which will pin it 15-20% higher, or at around 1.50. As for EUR/GBP, U.K. gilt yields stand at 108-basis-point over German bunds, an attractive spread should carry trades return in favor. Historically, such a spread has usually pinned the EUR/GBP much lower (Chart I-8). Yes, incoming data in the U.K. has softened, but employment growth has been holding up, wages are inflecting higher and the average U.K. consumer appears in decent shape. Investment and construction have been the weak spot in the U.K. economy, but may marginally improve on lower rates. Meanwhile, from a technical perspective, the pound is also oversold versus the euro (Chart I-9). Chart I-8EUR/GBP Is A Sell Long-Term
EUR/GBP Is A Sell Long-Term
EUR/GBP Is A Sell Long-Term
Chart I-9EUR/GBP Is Overbought
EUR/GBP Is Oversold
EUR/GBP Is Oversold
Bottom Line: Stay long the pound as we enter volatile summer trading, but maintain tight stops at 1.25. Sell EUR/GBP if 0.94 is touched. Buy A Speculative Basket Of Petrocurrencies Rising geopolitical tensions between the U.S. and Iran continue to support oil prices. Meanwhile, at its latest meeting, OPEC agreed to extend its production cuts to the first half of 2020. This will put upward pressure on forward curves, nudging oil near our Commodity & Energy Strategy service’s target of $75 per barrel.2 Should demand pick up later this year, it will supercharge the uptrend. More importantly, the risk of escalation between Iran and the U.S. is high, given that the former has been backed up into a corner on falling oil exports. Together with a weakening U.S. dollar, this will be categorically bullish for petrocurrencies. In our currency portfolio, we are long the NOK versus both the SEK and CAD as exposure to both crude oil prices and the Brent premium. This week, we are adding a speculative basket of the Colombian peso, Mexican peso and Russian ruble to benefit from any surge in the oil geopolitical risk premium. This basket is attractive for two reasons. First, the currencies are trading at a discount to what is implied by the oil price (Chart I-10). This discount could rapidly close if it becomes evident that oil supplies are at major risk. It is also beneficial that the shipping routes these supplies take categorically avoids the Straits of Hormuz, or the epicenter of the conflict. Second, the carry from the trade is attractive at 5%, which provides some cushion against downside risks. The risk of escalation between Iran and the U.S. is high. Together with a weakening U.S. dollar, this will be categorically bullish for petrocurrencies. The positive correlation between petrocurrencies and oil has been gradually eroded as the U.S. economy has become less and less of an oil importer. Meanwhile, Norwegian production has been falling for a few years. This is why it may be increasingly more profitable to be long a basket of petrocurrencies versus oil-consuming nations rather than the U.S. Going long versus the euro is also a cushion against a knee-jerk rally in the dollar. Also going long a basket of higher-yielding EM petrocurrencies versus DM ones is a good bet (Chart I-11). Chart I-10Petrocurrencies Are Attractive
Petrocurrencies Are Attractive
Petrocurrencies Are Attractive
Chart I-11EM Versus DM Oil Basket
EM Versus DM Oil Basket
EM Versus DM Oil Basket
Bottom Line: Buy a speculative basket of the Norwegian krone, Russian ruble, Mexican peso and Colombian peso versus the euro. Investors should also consider a basket of EM petrocurrencies versus DM ones. A Final Note On Gold The short-term technical picture for gold has become unfavorable. This suggests that investors could be caught offside in the interim holding gold as a hedge. We recommend swapping some gold bullion for yen to insure against this risk for three reasons: As both are safe-haven proxies, yen in gold terms has tended to mean revert since 2012, so as to maintain a stable ratio of 138,000 JPY per ounce of gold. Today, the yen is sitting at two standard deviations below this range (Chart I-12). Open interest for gold is surging towards new highs, while that of the yen is making fresh lows. In the case of a rush towards safe havens, the liquidity squeeze is likely to favor appreciation in the yen (Chart I-13). Chart I-12Sell Some Bullion For Yen Paper
Sell Some Bullion For Yen Paper
Sell Some Bullion For Yen Paper
Chart I-13A Liquidity Squeeze Could Favor The Yen
A Liquidity Squeeze Could Favor The Yen
A Liquidity Squeeze Could Favor The Yen
Speculators are long gold but short the yen, which is attractive from a contrarian standpoint (Chart I-14). Chart I-14Speculators Are Long Gold And Short Yen
Speculators Are Long Gold And Short Yen
Speculators Are Long Gold And Short Yen
Bottom Line: Remain short USD/JPY and sell a basket of gold versus some yen. Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Mathias Zurlinden, “The Vulnerability of Pegged Exchange Rates: The British Pound in the ERM,” Economic Research, Vol. 75, No. 5 (September/October 1993). 2 Please see Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report, titled “Oil Volatility Will Abate As Financial Conditions Ease,” dated July 4, 2019, available at ces.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1
USD Technicals 1
USD Technicals 1
Chart II-2USD Technicals 2
USD Technicals 2
USD Technicals 2
Recent data in the U.S. have been soft: Headline PCE fell to 1.5% year-on-year in May. Core PCE was unchanged at 1.6% year-on-year. Personal income growth was unchanged at 0.5% month-on-month in May, while personal spending fell to 0.4% month-on-month. Markit composite and manufacturing PMI both increased to 51.5 and 50.6 in June. However, ISM manufacturing and non-manufacturing PMI both decreased to 51.7 and 55.1 in June. Chicago purchasing managers’ index fell to 49.7 in June. Trade deficit widened to $55.5 billion in May. Factory orders contracted by 0.7% month-on-month in May. Also, durable goods orders fell by 1.3% month-on-month in May. DXY index increased by 0.4% this week. Our bond-to-gold indicator continues to point towards a weaker dollar. We believe that the combination of Chinese stimulus and the lagged effects from easing financial conditions should lift the global growth later this year, which would be a headwind for the dollar. Report Links: On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1
EUR Technicals 1
EUR Technicals 1
Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2
EUR Technicals 2
EUR Technicals 2
Recent data in the euro area have been mixed: Headline inflation was unchanged at 1.2% year-on-year in June, while core inflation increased to 1.1% year-on-year in June. Money supply (M3) grew by 4.8% year-on-year in May. Markit composite PMI increased to 52.2 in June. Manufacturing PMI fell to 47.6, while services PMI increased to 53.6. Unemployment rate fell to 7.5% in May. Producer price inflation fell to 1.6% year-on-year in May. Retail sales growth fell to 1.3% year-on-year in May. EUR/USD fell by 0.8% this week. IMF managing director Christine Lagarde was nominated to replace Mario Draghi as European Central Bank president this week. Analysts believe that she will likely maintain the ECB’s accommodative stance. This was confirmed by the plunge in 10-year bund yields to -40bps. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1
JPY Technicals 1
JPY Technicals 1
Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2
JPY Technicals 2
JPY Technicals 2
Recent data in Japan have been mixed: The Tankan survey for Q2 was a mixed bag. The index for large manufacturers fell from 12 to 7. That for non-manufacturers increased from 21 to 23. Importantly, capex intentions rose from 1.2% to 7.4%. Housing starts contracted by 8.7% year-on-year in May. Construction orders continue to fall by 16.9% year-on-year in May. Nikkei composite PMI increased to 50.8 in June. Manufacturing PMI fell to 49.3, while services PMI increased to 51.9. Consumer confidence fell to 38.7 in June. USD/JPY has been flat this week. While Trump and Xi agreed to delay the trade talks during the G20 summit last weekend, there is no real progress toward a final trade agreement that could alleviate the tariffs. We continue to recommend the yen as a safe-haven hedge. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 Short USD/JPY: Heads I Win, Tails I Don’t Lose Too Much - May 31, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1
GBP Technicals 1
GBP Technicals 1
Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2
GBP Technicals 2
GBP Technicals 2
Recent data in the U.K. have been negative: GDP growth was unchanged at 1.8% year-on-year in Q1. Current account deficit widened to £30 billion in Q1. Markit composite PMI fell to 49.7 in June. Manufacturing PMI decreased to 48; Construction PMI fell to 43.1; Services PMI fell to 50.2. Mortgage approvals fell to 65.4 thousand in May, while the Nationwide house price index was up 0.5% year-on-year. GBP/USD fell by 1% this week. BoE governor Carney warned in a speech this week that “a global trade war and a no deal Brexit remain growing possibilities not certainties.” Moreover, he stated that monetary policy must address the consequences of such uncertainty for the behavior of business, household, and financial markets. The probability of a BoE rate cut by the end of this year has thus increased from 21% to 46% following his speech. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1
AUD Technicals 1
AUD Technicals 1
Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2
AUD Technicals 2
AUD Technicals 2
Recent data in Australia have been mostly positive: The Markit manufacturing PMI increased from 51.7 to 52.0 Terms of trade remain in a powerful uptrend. HIA new home sales increased by 28.8% month-on-month in May. This is beginning to put a floor under building approvals. Trade surplus increased to A$5.8 billion in May, the highest on record. Retail sales increased by 0.1% month-on-month in May. AUD/USD increased by 0.3% this week. Following the rate cut last month, the RBA again cut interest rates by another 25 basis points to a historical low of 1% this week. During the policy statement, Governor Philip Lowe stated that this should support employment growth and provide greater confidence to achieve the inflation target. We continue to favor the Australian dollar from a contrarian perspective. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns- April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1
NZD Technicals 1
NZD Technicals 1
Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2
NZD Technicals 2
NZD Technicals 2
Recent data in New Zealand have been positive: Consumer confidence increased by 2.8% month-on-month in June. Building permits increased by 13.2% month-on-month in May. NZD/USD fell by 0.3% this week. With its policy rate 50 basis points higher than its antipodean counterpart, the RBNZ is now under pressure to cut rates in the coming weeks. The market is currently pricing an 84% probability of a rate cut for the next policy meeting in August, and 94% chance rates will be cut before year-end. Should data disappoint in the interim, additional cuts could be priced in. Hold on to our long AUD/NZD and SEK/NZD positions. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1
CAD Technicals 1
CAD Technicals 1
Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2
CAD Technicals 2
CAD Technicals 2
Recent data in Canada have been positive: GDP growth increased to 1.5% year-on-year in Q1. Bloomberg Nanos confidence continues to rise to 58.3 last week. This tends to lead GDP growth by a quarter or two. Markit manufacturing PMI increased to 49.2 in June. Exports and imports both increased to C$53.1 billion and C$52.3 billion in May. The trade balance turned positive to C$0.8 billion on surging exports to the U.S. USD/CAD fell by 0.5% this week. The BoC Business Outlook Survey published last Friday highlighted that business sentiment has slightly improved, and that hiring intentions continue to be healthy. This should underpin the loonie in the near-term. Report Links: On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 A Shifting Landscape For Petrocurrencies - March 22, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1
CHF Technicals 1
CHF Technicals 1
Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2
CHF Technicals 2
CHF Technicals 2
Recent data in Switzerland have been negative: KOF leading indicator fell to 93.6 in June. Real retail sales contracted by 1.7% year-on-year in May. Manufacturing PMI fell to 47.7 in June. Headline inflation was unchanged at 0.6% year-on-year in June, while core inflation increased to 0.7% year-on-year in June. USD/CHF increased by 0.4% this week. The CHF/NZD cross has been correcting in recent weeks, and could eventually trigger our limit buy order at 1.45. Stay tuned. Report Links: What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1
NOK Technicals 1
NOK Technicals 1
Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2
NOK Technicals 2
NOK Technicals 2
Recent data in Norway have been mixed: Manufacturing PMI fell from 54.1 to 51.9 in June. Registered unemployment was unchanged at 2.1% in June. House prices are inflecting higher, to the tune of 2.6% year-on-year in June. USD/NOK fell by 0.5% this week. This week’s OPEC meeting extended the production cuts into 1Q20. Easing global financial conditions and Chinese stimulus should help revive oil demand. Our Commodity & Energy Strategy team continues to expect Brent to average $75/bbl by the end of this year. Stay long NOK/SEK and short CAD/NOK. Report Links: On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 A Shifting Landscape For Petrocurrencies - March 22, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1
SEK Technicals 1
SEK Technicals 1
Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2
SEK Technicals 2
SEK Technicals 2
Recent data in Sweden have been negative: Retail sales fell by 0.5% year-on-year in May. Composite PMI fell to 50.5 in June. Manufacturing and services PMI both fell to 52 and 49.9. USD/SEK increased by 0.4% this week. The Riksbank held its interest rate unchanged at -0.25% this week as widely expected. However, the tone in the communique was hawkish. That said, the trade disputes between U.S. and China, and the Brexit chaos remain downside risks to the European economy, and the Riksbank might push the planned rate hike further down the road. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades