Japanese Yen
Listen to a short summary of this report Executive Summary GIS Projection For The EUR/USD
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
We went long the euro early last week, as EUR/USD hit our buy limit price of $0.99. Despite a near cut-off of Russian gas imports, European gas inventories have reached 84% of capacity – above the 80% target that the EU set for November 1st. The latest meteorological forecasts suggest that Europe will experience a warmer-than-normal winter. This will cut heating usage, likely making gas rationing unnecessary. Currencies fare best in loose fiscal/tight monetary environments. This is what Europe faces over the coming months, as governments boost income support for households and businesses, while ramping up spending on energy infrastructure and defense. For its part, the ECB has started hiking rates. Since mid-August, interest rate differentials have moved in favor of the euro at both the short and long end. Rising inflation expectations make it less likely that the ECB will be able to back off from its tightening campaign as it did in past cycles. A hawkish Fed is the biggest risk to our bullish EUR/USD view. We expect US inflation to trend lower over the coming months, before reaccelerating in the second half of 2023. However, as the August CPI report highlights, the danger is that any dip in inflation proves to be shallower and shorter-lived than previously anticipated. Bottom Line: Although significant uncertainty remains, the risk-reward trade-off favors being long EUR/USD. Our end-2022 target is $1.06. Dear Client, I will be meeting clients in Asia next week while also working on our Fourth Quarter Strategy Outlook, which will be published at the end of the month. In lieu of our regular report next Friday, you will receive a Special Report from my colleague, Ritika Mankar, discussing the sources of US equity outperformance over the past 14 years and the likely path ahead. Best Regards, Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist It’s Just a Clown Chart 1Investors Are Bullish The Dollar, Not The Euro
Investors Are Bullish The Dollar, Not The Euro
Investors Are Bullish The Dollar, Not The Euro
The scariest part of a horror movie is usually the one before the monster is revealed. No matter how good the special effects, the human brain can always conjure up something more frightening than anything Hollywood can dream up. Investors have been conjuring up all sorts of cataclysmic scenarios for the upcoming European winter. In financial markets, the impact has been most visible in the value of the euro, which has tumbled to parity against the US dollar. Only 23% of investors are bullish the euro at present, down from a peak of 78% in January 2021 (Chart 1). Conversely, 75% of investors are bullish the US dollar. More than half of fund managers cited “long US dollar” as the most crowded trade in the latest BofA Global Fund Manager Survey (“long commodities” was a distant second at 10%). As we discuss below, the outlook for the euro may be a lot better than most investors realize. While my colleagues, Chester Ntonifor, BCA’s chief FX strategist, and Mathieu Savary, BCA’s chief European strategist, are not quite ready to buy the euro just yet, we all agree that EUR/USD will rise over the long haul. Cutting Putin Loose Natural gas accounts for about a quarter of Europe’s energy supply. Prior to the Ukraine war, about 40% of that gas came from Russia (Chart 2). With the closure of the NordStream 1 pipeline, that number has fallen to 9% (some Russian gas continues to enter Europe via Ukraine and the TurkStream supply route). Yet, despite the deep drop in Russian natural gas imports, European natural gas inventories are up to 84% of capacity – roughly in line with past years and above the EU’s November 1st target of 80% (Chart 3). Chart 2Despite A Sharp Drop In Imports Of Russian Natural Gas…
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Chart 3...Europeans Managed To Stock Up On Natural Gas For The Winter Season
...Europeans Managed To Stock Up On Natural Gas For The Winter Season
...Europeans Managed To Stock Up On Natural Gas For The Winter Season
Europe has been able to achieve this feat by aggressively buying natural gas on the open market. While this has caused gas prices to soar, it sets the stage for a retreat in prices in the months ahead. European spot natural gas prices have already fallen from over €300/Mwh in late August to €214/Mwh, and the futures market is discounting a further decline in prices over the next two years (Chart 4). Chart 4The Futures Market Is Discounting A Further Decline In Natural Gas Prices
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Chart 5Futures Prices Of Energy Commodities Provide Some Limited Information On Where Spot Prices Are Heading
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Follow the Futures? Futures prices are not a foolproof guide to where spot prices are heading. As Chart 5 illustrates, the correlation between the slope of the futures curve and subsequent changes in spot prices in energy markets is quite low. Nevertheless, future spot returns do tend to be negative when the curve is backwardated, as it is now, especially when assessed over horizons of around 12-to-18 months (Table 1). Table 1Energy Commodity Spot Price Returns Tend To Be Negative When The Futures Curve Is Backwardated
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Our guess is that European natural gas prices will indeed fall further from current levels. The latest meteorological forecasts suggest that Europe will experience a milder-than-normal winter (Chart 6). This is critical considering that natural gas accounts for over 40% of EU residential heating use once electricity and heat generated in gas-fired plants are included (Chart 7). Chart 6Meteorological Models Suggest Above-Normal Temperatures In Europe This Winter
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Chart 7Natural Gas Is An Important Source Of Energy For Heating Homes In The EU
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
A warm winter would bolster the euro area’s trade balance, which has fallen into deficit this year as the energy import bill has soared (Chart 8). An improving balance of payments would help the euro. Europe is moving quickly to secure new sources of energy supply. In less than one year, Europe has become America’s biggest overseas market for LNG (Chart 9). A new gas pipeline linking Spain with the rest of Europe should be operational by next spring. Chart 8Soaring Energy Costs Have Pushed The Euro Area Trade Balance Into Deficit
Soaring Energy Costs Have Pushed The Euro Area Trade Balance Into Deficit
Soaring Energy Costs Have Pushed The Euro Area Trade Balance Into Deficit
Chart 9Europe Is America's Largest LNG Customer
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
In the meantime, Germany is building two “floating” LNG terminals. It has also postponed plans to mothball its nuclear power plants and has restarted its coal-fired power plants, a decision that even the German Green Party has supported. France is aiming to boost nuclear capacity, which had fallen below 50% earlier this summer. Électricité de France has pledged to nearly double daily production by December. For its part, the Dutch government has indicated it will raise output from the massive Groningen natural gas field if the energy crisis intensifies. Fiscal Policy to the Rescue On the policy front, European governments are taking steps to buttress household balance sheets during the energy crisis, with nearly €400 billion in support measures announced so far (and surely more to come). Although these support measures will be offset with roughly €140 billion of windfall profit taxes on the energy sector, the net effect will be to raise budget deficits across the region. However, following the old adage that one should “finance temporary shocks but adjust to permanent ones,” a temporary spike in fiscal support may be just what the doctor ordered. The last thing Europe needs is a situation where energy prices fall next year, but the region remains mired in recession as households seek to rebuild their savings. Such an outcome would depress tax revenues, likely leading to higher government debt-to-GDP ratios. Get Ready For a V-Shaped Recovery Stronger growth in the rest of the world should give the euro area a helping hand. That would be good news for the euro, given its cyclical characteristics (Chart 10). The European economy is especially leveraged to Chinese growth. It is likely that the authorities will loosen the zero-Covid policy once the Twentieth Party Congress concludes next month, and new anti-viral drugs and possibly an Omicron-specific booster shot become widely available later this year. That should help jumpstart China’s economy. More stimulus will also help. Chart 11 shows that EUR/USD is highly correlated with the Chinese credit/fiscal impulse. Chart 10The Euro Is A Cyclical Currency
The Euro Is A Cyclical Currency
The Euro Is A Cyclical Currency
Chart 11EUR/USD Is Highly Correlated With The Chinese Credit & Fiscal Impulse
EUR/USD Is Highly Correlated With The Chinese Credit & Fiscal Impulse
EUR/USD Is Highly Correlated With The Chinese Credit & Fiscal Impulse
All this suggests that the prevailing view on European growth is too pessimistic. Even if Europe does succumb to a technical recession in the months ahead, it is likely to experience a V-shaped recovery. That will provide a nice tailwind for the euro. Loose Fiscal/Tight Monetary Policies: The Winning Combo for Currencies Chart 12Fiscal Policy Has Eased Structurally In The Euro Area More Than In Other Advanced Economies
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
A tight monetary and loose fiscal policy has historically been the most bullish combination for currencies. Recall that the US dollar soared in the early 1980s on the back of Paul Volcker’s restrictive monetary policy and Ronald Reagan’s expansionary fiscal policy, the latter consisting of huge tax cuts and increased military spending. While not nearly on the same scale, the euro area’s current configuration of loose fiscal/tight monetary policies bears some resemblance to the US in the early 1980s. Even before the war in Ukraine began, the IMF was forecasting a much bigger swing towards expansionary fiscal policy in the euro area than in the rest of the world (Chart 12). The war has only intensified this trend, triggering a flurry of spending on energy and defense – spending that is likely to persist for most of this decade. The ECB’s Reaction Function After biding its time, the ECB has joined the growing list of central banks that are hiking rates. On September 8th, the ECB jacked up the deposit rate by 75 bps. Investors expect a further 185 bps in hikes through to September 2023. While US rate expectations have widened relative to euro area expectations since the August US CPI report (more on that later), the gap is still narrower than it was on August 15th. Back then, investors expected euro area 3-month rates to be 233 bps below comparable US rates in June 2023. Today, they expect the gap to be only 177 bps (Chart 13). Real long-term bond spreads, which conceptually at least should be the more important driver of currency movements, have also moved in the euro’s favor. In the past, ECB rate hikes were swiftly followed by cuts as the region was unable to tolerate even moderately higher rates. While this very well could happen again, the odds are lower than they once were, at least over the next 12 months. Chart 13Interest Rate Differentials Have Moved In Favor Of The Euro Since Mid-August
Interest Rate Differentials Have Moved In Favor Of The Euro Since Mid-August
Interest Rate Differentials Have Moved In Favor Of The Euro Since Mid-August
Chart 14Euro Area: Inflation Expectations Have Risen Briskly
Euro Area: Inflation Expectations Have Risen Briskly
Euro Area: Inflation Expectations Have Risen Briskly
For one thing, median inflation expectations three years ahead in the ECB’s monthly survey have risen briskly (Chart 14). The Bundesbank’s own survey paints an even more alarming picture, with median expected inflation over the next five years having risen to 5% from 3% in mid-2021 (Chart 15). Expected German inflation over the next ten years stands at a still-elevated 4%. Whether this reflects Germans’ heightened historical sensitivity to inflation risks is unclear, but it is something the ECB cannot ignore. Structurally looser fiscal policy has raised the neutral rate of interest in the euro area, giving the ECB more leeway to lift rates. A narrowing in competitiveness gaps across the currency bloc has also mitigated the need for the ECB to set rates based on the needs of the weakest economies in the region. Chart 16 shows that collectively, unit labor costs among the countries most afflicted by the sovereign debt crisis a decade ago have completely converged with Germany. Chart 15German Inflation Expectations Are Elevated
German Inflation Expectations Are Elevated
German Inflation Expectations Are Elevated
Chart 16Europe's Periphery Has Closed The Competitiveness Gap With Germany
Europe's Periphery Has Closed The Competitiveness Gap With Germany
Europe's Periphery Has Closed The Competitiveness Gap With Germany
While Italy is still a laggard in the competitiveness rankings, the ECB’s new Transmission Protection Instrument (TPI) – which allows the central bank to buy sovereign debt with less stringent conditionality than under the Outright Monetary Transactions (OMT) program – should keep a lid on sovereign spreads. This, in turn, will allow the ECB to raise rates more than it otherwise could. Hawkish Fed is the Biggest Risk to Our Bullish EUR/USD View Chart 17Supplier Delivery Times Have Fallen Sharply
Supplier Delivery Times Have Fallen Sharply
Supplier Delivery Times Have Fallen Sharply
Tuesday’s hotter-than-expected August US CPI report pulled the rug from under the euro’s incipient rally, pushing EUR/USD back to parity. We have been flagging the risks of high inflation for several years (see, for example, our February 19, 2021 report, 1970s-Style Inflation: Yes, It Could Happen Again). Our thesis is that inflation will follow a “two steps up, one step down” pattern. We are probably near the top of those two steps now, with the next leg for inflation likely to be to the downside, driven by ebbing pandemic-related supply side-dislocations. Perhaps most notably, supplier delivery times have fallen sharply in recent months (Chart 17). These pandemic-related dislocations extend to the housing rental market. Rent inflation dropped after rent moratoriums were put in place, only to rebound forcefully once the moratoriums were lifted and the labor market tightened. Although official measures of rent inflation will remain elevated for some time, owing to lags in how they are constructed, timelier data on new rental units coming to market already point to a sharp decline in rent inflation (Chart 18). This is something that the Fed is sure to notice. Ironically, falling inflation could sow the seeds of its own demise. Nominal wage growth is currently very elevated, yet because of high inflation, real wages are still shrinking. As inflation comes down, real wage growth will turn positive. This will lift consumer sentiment, helping to buoy consumption (Chart 19). A pickup in consumer spending will cause the economy to overheat again, leading to a second wave of inflation in the back half of 2023. Chart 18Timelier Measures Of Rent Inflation Have Rolled Over
Timelier Measures Of Rent Inflation Have Rolled Over
Timelier Measures Of Rent Inflation Have Rolled Over
Chart 19Falling Inflation Will Boost Real Wages And Consumer Confidence
Falling Inflation Will Boost Real Wages And Consumer Confidence
Falling Inflation Will Boost Real Wages And Consumer Confidence
As we discussed in our August 18th Special Report Dispatches From The Future: From Goldilocks To President DeSantis, the Fed will respond to this second inflationary wave by hiking the Fed funds rate to 5%. This will temporarily push up the value of the dollar, a process that will only stop once the US falls into recession in 2024 and the Fed is forced to cut rates again. Our projected rollercoaster ride for EUR/USD is depicted in Chart 20. We see the euro rising to $1.06 by year-end, peaking at $1.11 in the spring of 2023, falling back to $1.05 by late 2023, and then beginning a prolonged rally in 2024. Chart 20GIS Projection For The EUR/USD
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Chart 21The Dollar Is Very Overvalued Against The Euro Based On PPP
The Dollar Is Very Overvalued Against The Euro Based On PPP
The Dollar Is Very Overvalued Against The Euro Based On PPP
Chart 21 shows that the dollar is 30% overvalued against the euro based on its Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) exchange rate. Thus, there is significant long-term upside to EUR/USD. Implications for Other Currencies and Regional Equity Allocation Chart 22Stock Markets Outside The US Tend To Fare Best When The Dollar Is Weakening
Stock Markets Outside The US Tend To Fare Best When The Dollar Is Weakening
Stock Markets Outside The US Tend To Fare Best When The Dollar Is Weakening
The strengthening in the euro that we envision over the next six months or so will be part of a broad-based dollar decline. While BCA’s Foreign Exchange Strategy service sees more upside for the euro than the pound, GBP/USD will likely follow the same trajectory as EUR/USD. The yen is one of the cheapest currencies in the world and should finally gain some traction. If China abandons its zero-Covid policy and increases fiscal support for its economy, the RMB and other EM currencies should strengthen. Stock markets outside the US tend to fare best when the dollar is weakening. This includes Europe. As Chart 22 illustrates, there is a close correlation between EUR/USD and the relative performance of European versus US stocks. Thus, an above-benchmark exposure to international markets is appropriate during the coming months. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Follow me on LinkedIn & Twitter Global Investment Strategy View Matrix
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
Special Trade Recommendations Current MacroQuant Model Scores
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
It’s Time To Buy The Euro
A message for Foreign Exchange Strategy clients, There will be no report next week, as we take a summer break. We will be joining our clients and colleagues for our annual investment conference to be held in New York, on September 7 & 8. We will resume our publication the following week, with a Special Report on the Hong Kong dollar, together with our China Investment Strategy colleagues. Looking forward to seeing many of you in person. Kind regards, Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist Executive Summary No Urgency To Tighten Policy
No Urgency To Tighten Policy
No Urgency To Tighten Policy
The biggest medium-term threat for Japan remains deflation, rather than inflation. This suggests that the BoJ will be loathe to abandon yield curve control anytime soon. That said, inflation is still accelerating globally, and has meaningfully picked up in Japan. Betting on a hawkish BoJ policy shift could therefore be a significant macro trade. We have identified five conditions that need to be met for the BoJ to begin removing accommodation. None are currently indicating an imminent need to alter monetary policy settings, particularly with the Japanese economy softening alongside subdued inflation expectations. The yen will soar on any hawkish BoJ policy shift. Currently, BCA Foreign Exchange Strategy is short EUR/JPY. That said, the historical evidence suggests waiting for an exhaustion in yen selling pressure, before placing fresh bets on selling USD/JPY. Longer-term bond yields in Japan, for maturities beyond the BoJ yield target, are already moving higher, while speculative interest in shorting JGBs has increased. We recommend fading these trends for now – shorting JGBs outright will remain a “widowmaker trade”. Bottom Line: The yen has undershot and longer-term investors should buy it - our preferred way to express that view in the near-term is to be short EUR/JPY. Bond investors should be underweight “low-beta” JGBs in fixed-income portfolios on a tactical basis, not as a hawkish BoJ bet, but because global bond yields are more likely to stay in broad trading ranges than break to new highs. Feature Chart 1The BoJ Is A Lonesome Dove
When Will The BoJ Abandon Yield Curve Control?
When Will The BoJ Abandon Yield Curve Control?
Almost every G10 central bank has raised rates over the last 12 months, even the perennially dovish banks like the ECB and Swiss National Bank, in response to soaring inflation. The one exception has been the Bank of Japan (BoJ). The BoJ has kept policy rates unchanged throughout the year (Chart 1), while also maintaining its Yield Curve Control policy of capping 10-year Japanese government bond (JGB) yields at 0.25%. There has been interest from the macro investor community on Japan in recent months, betting on the BoJ eventually succumbing to the global monetary tightening trend. If the BoJ were to shift gears and turn less accommodative, then the yen would surely soar, while JGBs will go on a fire sale. In this report, jointly published by BCA Research Foreign Exchange Strategy and Global Fixed Income Strategy, we explore the necessary conditions that need to be in place for the BoJ to meaningfully shift policy, most likely starting with the end of Yield Curve Control before interest rate hikes. We see five such conditions, which will form a “checklist” to be monitored in the months ahead. Condition 1: Overshooting Inflation Expectations The BoJ has a policy mandate on inflation and most measures of underlying Japanese inflation are still well below its 2% target. For example, the weighted median and mode CPI inflation rates are only at 0.5%, even as headline CPI inflation has climbed to 2.6% on the back of two primarily non-domestic factors – rapidly rising prices for energy and goods (Chart 2). With such low baseline inflation, it has been hard to lift market-based Japanese inflation expectations like CPI swap rates above 1%, even as far out as ten years (Chart 3). CPI swaps have tended to provide a more realistic assessment of underlying Japanese inflation, adhering more closely to trends in realized core CPI inflation, and thus deserve the most attention from the BoJ. This is in stark contrast to the BoJ’s own consumer survey of inflation expectations, that has consistently overestimated inflation over the years, which is currently showing both 1-year-ahead and 5-year-ahead inflation expectations at a startling, yet highly inaccurate, 5%. Chart 2Low Underlying Inflation In Japan
Low Underlying Inflation In Japan
Low Underlying Inflation In Japan
Chart 3No Unmooring Of Inflation Expectations In Japan
No Unmooring Of Inflation Expectations In Japan
No Unmooring Of Inflation Expectations In Japan
The BoJ is likely to side with the more subdued read on market-based inflation expectations in determining if monetary policy needs to turn less dovish – especially with the BoJ’s own estimate of the output gap now at -1.2%, indicating spare capacity in the economy and a lack of underlying inflation pressures (Chart 4). Chart 4Japan Still Suffers From Excess Capacity
Japan Still Suffers From Excess Capacity
Japan Still Suffers From Excess Capacity
Condition 2: Excessive Yen Weakness Our more comprehensive measure of determining the pressure to change monetary policy is captured in our central bank monitor for Japan, a.k.a. the BoJ Monitor. The Monitor includes economic, inflation and financial variables. This measure suggests that the BoJ should not be tightening monetary policy today (Chart 5). One of the variables that goes into our BoJ Monitor is the yen. The yen impacts monetary conditions through two ways. First, import prices tend to rise as the yen weakens, feeding into domestic inflation. In short, it eases monetary conditions. That has been the story over the last year with the yen falling -15% on a trade-weighted basis (Chart 6). The second impact is through profit translation effects. Overseas earnings for Japanese exporters are buffeted in yen terms as the currency depreciates. Both impacts would tend to put more pressure to tighten monetary policy, on the margin. Chart 5No Urgency To Tighten Policy
No Urgency To Tighten Policy
No Urgency To Tighten Policy
Chart 6Yen Weakness Only Generates Temporary Inflation
Yen Weakness Only Generates Temporary Inflation
Yen Weakness Only Generates Temporary Inflation
However, the impact of yen weakness in boosting profit translation costs for Japanese concerns has eased over the years. As many Japanese companies have offshored production, lower wages in Japan have been offset by higher costs abroad. As a result, profit margins for multinational Japanese corporations are not rising meaningfully relative to their G10 peers, despite yen weakness (Chart 7). That puts the central bank in a quandary regarding how to interpret yen weakness vis-à-vis future policy moves. On the one hand, soaring global inflation and a weak yen should be allowing the BoJ to declare victory on rising inflation expectations in Japan. On the other hand, domestic wage growth will not reach “escape velocity” (Chart 8), and inflation will fail to overshoot on a sustainable basis, if corporate profit margins are not rising meaningfully. Chart 7No Widespread Signs Of Increased Profitability From Yen Weakness
No Widespread Signs Of Increased Profitability From Yen Weakness
No Widespread Signs Of Increased Profitability From Yen Weakness
Chart 8No Escape Velocity Yet In Japanese ##br##Wages
No Escape Velocity Yet In Japanese Wages
No Escape Velocity Yet In Japanese Wages
Of course, Japanese authorities care about excessive moves in the yen, but they also understand their limited ability to alter the path of the currency. The Ministry of Finance last intervened to support the currency in 1998. That helped the yen temporarily, but global factors dictated its longer-term trend. A BoJ monetary tightening designed solely to stabilize the yen, before inflation expectations stabilize at the BoJ target, is a recipe for failure on both fronts. The bottom line is that yen weakness is giving a lift to inflation, but this is unlikely to be sticky. The yen needs to fall 10% every year just to generate a one percentage point increase in Japanese inflation. As such, the current bout of yen weakness is unlikely to alter the longer-term goals of BoJ policy, unless a wave of selling undermines financial stability. Condition 3: Continually Rising Energy Costs Chart 9Japan Is More Energy Dependent Than Many Other Countries
Japan Is More Energy Dependent Than Many Other Countries
Japan Is More Energy Dependent Than Many Other Countries
Policy makers in the eurozone have told us that even in the face of a recession, a threat to their credibility on price stability – like the energy-fueled overshoot of European inflation - is worth defending through monetary tightening. Thus, a continued external energy shock could also cause the BoJ to shift. Our Chief Commodity Strategist, Robert Ryan, expects the geopolitical risk premium on oil to increase in the near term. Japan imports almost all its energy and has structurally been more dependent on fossil fuels than Europe (Chart 9). A rise in energy costs that unanchors inflation expectations is a threat worth monitoring for the BoJ, one that could drag it into monetary tightening as has been the case in Europe. That said, adjustments are already underway. Japanese and European LNG imports from the US are rising. As a result, the price arbitrage between US Henry Hub prices and the Dutch TTF equivalent is likely to soften, assuaging energy import costs (Chart 10). Japan is also ramping up nuclear power production, which can help provide alternative sources to imported energy (Chart 11). Chart 10An Unprecedented Arbitrage
An Unprecedented Arbitrage
An Unprecedented Arbitrage
Chart 11Nuclear Power Could Help?
Nuclear Power Could Help?
Nuclear Power Could Help?
The BoJ would likely not consider an early exit from accommodative monetary policy based solely on energy-fueled inflation. After all, the current surge in global energy prices, compounded by yen weakness, has barely pushed headline inflation above the BoJ 2% target – with little follow-through into core inflation or wage growth. Condition 4: An Economic Revival In Japan A burst in Japanese growth that absorbs excess capacity and tightens labor market conditions could convince the BoJ that a policy adjustment is due. This could result in higher Japanese interest rates and bond yields. The yen also tends to appreciate when the Japanese economy is improving (Chart 12). Unfortunately, Japanese growth momentum is going in the wrong direction for that outcome. Chart 12The Yen And the Japanese Economy
The Yen And the Japanese Economy
The Yen And the Japanese Economy
Domestic demand has been under siege from the lingering effects of the pandemic, including an unprecedented collapse in tourism. As the pandemic effects have faded, however, Japan’s economy faces new threats from slowing global growth, waning export demand, and declining consumer confidence (Chart 13). It is notable that while goods spending has been picking up around the world, the personal consumption component of GDP in Japan remains nearly three percentage points below the level implied by its pre-pandemic trend. While Japan’s unemployment rate is 2.6% and falling, it remains above the low reached just before the start of the pandemic. Chart 13A Broad-Based Slowing Of Japanese Growth
A Broad-Based Slowing Of Japanese Growth
A Broad-Based Slowing Of Japanese Growth
What Japan needs now is more fiscal spending. For a low-growth economy, with ultra-loose monetary settings, the fiscal multiplier tends to be much larger. Stronger fiscal spending could lift animal spirits in Japan and cause the BoJ to shift. Yet even on that front, the evidence does not point to a direct link from fiscal stimulus to rising inflation expectations – a necessary catalyst for the BoJ to turn more hawkish. A recent study by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco concluded that there was no boost to depressed Japanese inflation expectations from the massive Japanese government fiscal programs during the worst of the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic shock. Waning Japanese economic momentum is not putting any pressure on the BoJ to begin considering a shift to less accommodative monetary settings. Condition 5: More Hawkish Members At The BoJ There are important transitions occurring within the BoJ’s nine-member board that could change the policy bias in a less dovish direction. In July, two new board members – Hajime Takata and Naoki Tamura – were appointed to the BoJ board. Both brought up the notion of the need for an “exit strategy” from current easy monetary policies at their introductory press conference, although both were also careful to state that they did not think the conditions were in place yet for that to occur. Related Report Foreign Exchange StrategyWhat To Do About The Yen? Nonetheless, the two new appointees represent a marginally hawkish shift in the policy bias of the BoJ board, especially Takata who replaced one of the more vocal advocates for maintaining aggressive monetary easing, economist Goushi Kataoka. Of course, the big change at the top of the BoJ will come next April when Governor Haruhiko Kuroda’s current term ends. This will follow the departures of the two deputy governors, Masayoshi Amamiya and Masazumi Wakatabe in March. That means five of nine board members would be changed in less than one year, including the most senior leadership. That would be a huge change for any central bank, but especially for the BoJ where Governor Kuroda has overseen the introduction of all the current aggressive monetary policies, from negative interest rates to massive quantitative easing to Yield Curve Control. A growing constraint for the future of Yield Curve Control As outlined earlier, underlying inflation and growth trends in Japan are nowhere close to justifying an end to Yield Curve Control or even a mere upward tweak of the current 0.25% yield target on 10-year JGBs. However, there are negative spillover effects from the BoJ’s bond market manipulation that could make the current policies less sustainable over the medium term for the new incoming BoJ leadership. We addressed one of those issues earlier with the extreme yen weakness, which is largely a product of the BoJ keeping a lid on Japanese interest rates while almost the entire rest of the world is in a monetary tightening cycle. But another issue to be addressed is the impaired liquidity of the JGB market. After years of steady, aggressive bond buying, the BoJ has essentially “cornered” the JGB market. The central bank now owns roughly 50% of all outstanding JGBs, doubling its ownership share since Yield Curve Control started in 2016 (Chart 14). The numbers are even more extreme when focusing on the specific maturity targeted by the BoJ under Yield Curve Control, with the central bank now owning nearly 80% of all 10-year JGBs (Chart 15). Chart 14The BoJ Has Cornered The JGB Market
The BoJ Has Cornered The JGB Market
The BoJ Has Cornered The JGB Market
Chart 15BoJ Now Owns 80% Of 10yr JGBs
When Will The BoJ Abandon Yield Curve Control?
When Will The BoJ Abandon Yield Curve Control?
By absorbing so much supply of the main risk-free asset in the Japanese financial system, the BoJ has made life more difficult for Japanese commercial banks, insurance companies and pension funds that require JGBs for regulatory and risk management purposes. In the most recent BoJ survey of bond market participants, 68 of 69 firms surveyed described the JGB market as having poor liquidity conditions, with an equal amount stating that JGB trading conditions were as bad or worse than three months earlier. The change in BoJ leadership could also bring about a change in policymakers’ desire to continue manipulating the JGB market via Yield Curve Control. Although the BoJ would have to be very careful in how it signals and executes any change to Yield Curve Control. There is currently a very wide gap between a 10-year JGB yield at 0.25% and a 30-year JGB yield at 1.25% (Chart 16). If the BoJ completely ended Yield Curve Control, the 10-year yield would converge rapidly towards that 30-year yield, likely reaching 1%. That would create a major negative total return shock to the Japanese banks and institutional investors that still own nearly 40% of JGBs. Chart 1610yr JGB Yields Will Surge Without Yield Curve Control
10yr JGB Yields Will Surge Without Yield Curve Control
10yr JGB Yields Will Surge Without Yield Curve Control
A more likely outcome would be the BoJ raising the yield target on the 10-year to something like 0.50%, or perhaps shifting to a different maturity target where the BoJ owns a smaller share of outstanding JGBs like the 5-year sector. Yet without an actual trigger for such a move coming from faster economic growth or core inflation hitting the 2% BoJ target, it is highly unlikely that the BoJ would dare tinker with its yield curve policy, and risk a JGB market blowup, solely over concerns about bond market liquidity. Investment Conclusions None of the items in our newly constructed “BoJ Checklist” are currently indicating that a shift in Japanese monetary policy is imminent. We therefore see it as being too early to put on the legendary “widowmaker trade” of shorting JGBs, although a case can be made to go long the yen based on longer-term valuation considerations. Japanese yen The carnage in the yen is in an apocalyptic phase, but the BoJ is unlikely to rescue the yen in the near term. As such, short-term traders should be on the sidelines. For longer-term investors, being contrarian could pay off handsomely. The 1-year drawdown in the yen is within the scope of historical capitulation phases (Chart 17). Meanwhile, according to our PPP models (and a wide variety of others), the Japanese yen is the cheapest G10 currency, undervalued by around -41% (Chart 18). BCA Foreign Exchange Strategy is currently long the yen versus the euro and the Swiss franc. Chart 17The Yen Is On Sale
The Yen Is On Sale
The Yen Is On Sale
Chart 18The Yen Is Very Cheap
The Yen Is Very Cheap
The Yen Is Very Cheap
JGBs Chart 19Stay Tactically Underweight JGBs
Stay Tactically Underweight JGBs
Stay Tactically Underweight JGBs
In the absence of a bearish domestic monetary policy trigger, JGBs should be treated by global bond investors as a risk management tool as much as anything else. The relative return performance of JGBs versus the Bloomberg Global Treasury Index of government bonds is highly correlated to the momentum of global bond yields (Chart 19). Thus, increasing the exposure to JGBs in a global bond portfolio is akin to reducing the interest rate duration of a bond portfolio – both positions will help a portfolio outperform its benchmark when global bond yields rise. On a tactical basis (3-6 month time horizon), an underweight allocation to JGBs in government bond portfolios seems appropriate, even with JGBs offering relatively attractive yields on a currency-hedged basis, most notably for USD-based investors. Global bond yields are more likely to stay in broad trading ranges, capped by slowing global growth and decelerating goods inflation but floored by stickier non-goods inflation and hawkish central banks. Thus, the defensive properties of JGBs as a “duration hedge” in global bond portfolios are less necessary in the near-term. Beyond the tactical time horizon, the uncertainty over the potential makeup of new BoJ leadership in 2023, along with some easing of global inflation pressures from the commodity space, could justify lower JGB exposure on a more structural basis - if it appears that a new wave of more hawkish policymakers is set to take over in Tokyo. Stay tuned. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
Listen to a short summary of this report. Executive Summary Chart 1The Dollar Has Broken Below The First Line Of Support
The Dollar Has Broken Before The First Line Of Support
The Dollar Has Broken Before The First Line Of Support
The softer CPI print in the US boosted growth plays and pushed the DXY index below its 50-day moving average (Feature Chart). This suggests CPI numbers will remain the most important print for currency markets in the coming weeks and months. If US inflation has peaked, then the market will price a less aggressive path for Fed interest rates, which will loosen support for the dollar. At the same time, other G10 central banks are still seeing accelerating inflation. This will keep them on a tightening path. This puts the DXY in a tug of war. On the downside, the Fed could turn less hawkish. On the other hand, currencies such as the EUR, GBP and even SEK face high inflation but deteriorating growth. This will depress real rates. Within this context, the most attractive currencies are those with relatively higher real rates, and a real prospect of a turnaround in growth. NOK and AUD stand out as potential candidates. Our short EUR/JPY trade has been performing well in this context. Stick with it. RECOMMENDATIONS INCEPTION LEVEL inception date RETURN Short EUR/JPY 141.20 2022-07-21 3.29 Bottom Line: Our recommended strategy is a neutral dollar view over the next three months, until it becomes clear inflation has peaked and global growth has bottomed. Feature The DXY index peaked at 108.64 on July 14 and has dropped to 105.1 as we go to press. There have been two critical drivers of this move. First, the 10-year US Treasury yield has fallen from 3.5% to 2.8%. With this week’s all important CPI release, which showed a sharp deceleration in the headline measure, bond yields may well stabilize at current levels for a while. Second, the drop in energy prices has boosted the JPY, SEK and EUR, which are heavily dependent on imported energy. Related Report Foreign Exchange StrategyA Montreal Conversation On FX Markets Another development has been happening in parallel – as US inflation upside surprises have crested, so has the US price impulse relative to its G10 counterparts (Chart 1). To the extent that this eases market pricing of a hawkish Fed (relative to other G10 central banks), it will continue to diminish upward pressure on the dollar. Much will depend on the incoming inflation prints both in the US, and abroad. With the DXY having broken below its 50-day moving average, the next support level is at 103.6. This is where the 100-day moving average lies, which the dollar tested twice this year before eventually bouncing higher (Chart 2). The next few sections cover the important data releases over the last month in our universe of G10 countries, and implications for currency strategy. What is clear is that most foreign central banks are committed to their tightening campaign, which argues for a neutral stance towards the DXY for now. Chart 1US Inflation Momentum Has Rolled Over
US Inflation Momentum Has Rolled Over
US Inflation Momentum Has Rolled Over
Chart 2The Dollar Has Broken Below The First Line Of Support
The Dollar Has Broken Below The First Line Of Support
The Dollar Has Broken Below The First Line Of Support
US Dollar: Consolidation Chart 3The Conditions For A Fed Hike Remain In Place
The Conditions For A Fed Hike Remain In Place
The Conditions For A Fed Hike Remain In Place
The dollar DXY index is up 10% year to date. Over the last month, the DXY index is down 2.1% (panel 1). Incoming data continues to make the case for a strong dollar. Job gains are robust. In June, the US added 372K jobs. The July release was even stronger at 528K jobs. This pushed the unemployment rate to a low of 3.5% (panel 2). Wages continue to soar. Average hourly earnings came in at 5.2% year-on-year in July. The Atlanta Fed wage growth tracker continues to edge higher across all income cohorts (panel 3). The June CPI print was above expectations at 9.1% for headline, with core at 5.9%. The July print for headline that came out this week was 8.5%, below expectations of 8.7%. At 5.9%, the core measure is still well above the Fed’s target (panel 4). June retail sales remained firm, but consumer sentiment continues to weaken. While the University of Michigan current conditions index increase from 53.8 to 58.1 in June, this is well below the January 2020 level of 115. Correspondingly, the Conference Board consumer confidence index fell from 98.7 to 95.7 in July. On June 17, the Fed increased interest rates by 75bps, as expected. The US entered a second consecutive quarter of GDP growth contraction in Q2, falling by an annualized 0.9%. The ISM manufacturing index was flat in July suggesting Q3 GDP is not starting on a particularly strong foot. The Atlanta Fed Q3 GDP growth tracker is, however, printing 2.5%. Unit labor costs are soaring, rising 10.8% in Q2. This is sapping productivity growth, which fell 4.6% in Q2. The key for the dollar’s outlook is the evolution of US inflation and the labor market. For now, inflation remains sticky, and wages are rising. Meanwhile, labor market conditions remain robust. This will keep the Fed on a tightening path in the near term. We initially went short the DXY index but were stopped out. We remain neutral in the short term, though valuation keeps us bearish over a long-term horizon. The Euro: A European Hard Landing Chart 4The Euro Is At Recession Lows
The Euro Is At Recession Lows
The Euro Is At Recession Lows
The euro is down 9.2% year to date. Over the last month, the euro is up 2.7%, having faced support a nudge below parity. Incoming data continues to suggest weak economic conditions, with a stagflationary undertone: The ZEW Expectations Survey for July was at -51.1, the lowest reading since 2011 (panel 1). The current account remains in a deficit, at -€4.5bn in May. Consumer confidence continues to plunge. The July reading of -27 is the worst since the 2020 Covid-19 crisis (panel 2). Despite the above data releases, the ECB surprised markets by raising rates 50bps. CPI continues to surprise to the upside. The preliminary CPI print for July came in at 8.9%, well above the previous 8.6% print. PPI in the euro area was at 35.8% in June, a slight decline from the May reading (panel 3). The German Ifo business expectations index fell to 80.3 in July. Historically, that has been consistent with a manufacturing PMI reading of 45 (panel 4). The Sentix confidence index stabilized in August but remains very weak at -25.2. This series tends to be trending, having peaked in July last year. We will see if the next few months continue to show stabilization. The ECB mandate dictates that it will continue to fight soaring inflation. As such, it may have no choice but to generate a Eurozone-wide recession. This is the key risk for the euro since it could push EUR/USD below parity again. We continue to sell the EUR/JPY cross. In a risk-off environment, EUR/JPY will collapse. In a risk-on environment, like this week, the yen can still benefit since it is oversold. Meanwhile, investors remain overwhelmingly bearish (panel 5). The Japanese Yen: Quite A Hefty Rally Chart 5Some Green Shoots In Japan
Some Green Shoots In Japan
Some Green Shoots In Japan
The Japanese yen is down 13.4% year-to-date, the worst performing G10 currency (panel 1). Over the last month, the yen is up 3.3%. Incoming data in Japan has been worsening as the rising number of Covid-19 cases is hitting mobility and economic data. According to the Eco Watcher’s survey, sentiment among small and medium-sized Japanese firms deteriorated in July. Current conditions fell from 52.9 to 43.8. The outlook component also declined from 47.6 to 42.8. Machine tool order momentum, one of our favorite measures of external demand, continues to slow. Peak growth was at 141.9% year-on-year in May last year. The preliminary reading from July was at 5.5% (panel 2). Labor cash earnings came in at 2.2% year-on-year, a positive sign. Household spending also rose 3.5%. Rising wages could keep inflation momentum rising in Japan (panel 3). On that note, the Tokyo CPI report for July was also encouraging, with an increase in the core-core measure from 1% to 1.2%. The Tokyo CPI tends to lead nationwide measures. The labor market remains robust. Labor demand exceeds supply by 27%. The Bank of Japan kept monetary policy on hold on July 20th, a policy move that makes sense given incoming data. The BoJ still views a large chunk of inflation in Japan as transitory. For inflation to pick up, wages need to rise. While they are rising, inflation expectations remain well anchored, suggesting little rationale for the BoJ to shift (panel 4). That said, the yen is extremely cheap after being the best short this year (panel 5). British Pound: Coiled Spring Below 1.20? Chart 6Cable Is Vulnerable
Cable Is Vulnerable
Cable Is Vulnerable
The pound is down 9.8% year to date. Over the last month, the pound is up by 2.5%. Sterling broke below a soft floor of 1.20, but quickly bounced back and is now sitting at 1.22, as sentiment picked up (panel 1). We find the UK to have an even bigger stagflation problem than the eurozone. CPI came in at 9.4% in June. The RPI came in at 11.8%. PPI was at 24%. All showed an acceleration from the month of May (panel 2). Nationwide house price inflation has barely rolled over unlike other markets, increasing from 10.7% in June to 11% in July. The Rightmove national asking price was 9.3% higher year-on-year in July, compared to 9.7% in June (panel 3). Meanwhile, mortgage approvals have been in steady decline over the last two years, which points toward stagflation. Retail sales excluding auto and fuel fell 5.9% year-on-year in June, the weakest reading since the Covid-19 crisis. Consumer confidence is lower than in 2020 (panel 4). Trade data continues to be weak, which has dipped the current account towards decade lows (panel 5). The external balance is the biggest driver of the pound, given the huge deficit. The above environment has put the BoE in a stagflationary quagmire. Last week, they raised rates by 50 bps suggesting inflation is a much more important battle than growth. Politically, the resignation of Prime Minister Boris Johnson, and broader difficulties for the Conservative Party, is fueling sterling volatility. We are maintaining our long EUR/GBP trade as a bet that at 1.03, the euro has priced in a recession (well below the 2020 lows), but sterling has not. On cable, 1.20 will prove to be a long-term floor but it will be volatile in the short term. Australian Dollar: A Contrarian Play Chart 7Relatively Solid Domestic Conditions In Australia
Relatively Solid Domestic Conditions In Australia
Relatively Solid Domestic Conditions In Australia
The AUD is down 2.3% year-to-date. Over the last month, the AUD is up 5.3%. AUD is fast approaching its 200-day moving average. If that is breached, it could signal that the highs of this year, above 76 cents, are within striking distance (panel 1). Inflation is accelerating in Australia. In Q2, the inflation reading was 6.1%, while the trimmed-mean and weighted-median measures were above the central bank’s 1-3% band (panel 2). As a result, the RBA stated the benchmark rate was “well below” the neutral rate. It increased rates by an additional 50bps in August, lifting the official cash rate to 1.85%. Further rate increases are likely. There are a few reasons for this. First, labor market conditions are the most favorable in decades. In June, unemployment reached 3.5%, its lowest level in 50 years, against a consensus of 3.8% (panel 3). The participation rate also increased to 66.8% in June from 66.7%, which has pushed the underutilization rate to multi-decade lows (panel 4). Despite this, consumer confidence continued its decline in August, dropping to 81.2 from 83.8. A pickup in Covid-19 cases and high consumer prices are the usual suspects. Beyond the labor market, monetary policy seems to be having the desired effect. Demand appears to be slowing as retail sales grew 0.2% month-on-month in June from 0.9%. Home loan issuance declined by 4.4% in June, driven by a 6.3% decline in investment lending. House price growth continued to decline in July, particularly in densely populated regions like Sydney and Melbourne. The manufacturing sector remains strong, with July PMI coming in at 55.7, suggesting the RBA might just be achieving a soft landing in Australia. The external environment was largely favorable for the AUD in June, as the trade balance increased substantially by A$17.7bn with commodities rallying early in the month. However, commodity prices are rolling over. The price of iron for example, is down 24% from its peak in June. This will likely weigh on the trade balance going forward (panel 5). A weakening external environment are near-term headwinds for the AUD, but we will be buyers on weakness (panel 6). New Zealand Dollar: Least Preferred G10 Currency Chart 8Near-Term Risks To NZD
Near-Term Risks To NZD
Near-Term Risks To NZD
The NZD is down 6.1% this year. Over the last month, it is up 5% (panel 1). The Reserve Bank of New Zealand raised its official cash rate (OCR) in July by 50bps to 2.5%, in line with market expectations. Policymakers maintained their hawkish stance and guided towards increased tightening until monetary conditions can bring inflation within its target range of 1-3%. Inflation rose in Q2 to 7.3% from a 7.1% forecast, largely driven by rising construction and energy prices (panel 2). As of the latest data, monetary policy appears to be continuing to have the desired effect on interest rate sensitive parts of the economy. REINZ home sales declined 38.1% year-on-year in June. Home price growth continues to roll over (panel 3). The external sector continues to slow. Dairy prices, circa 20% of exports, saw a 12% drop in early August after remaining flat in July. The 12-month trailing trade balance remains in deficit. This is most likely due to a substantial slowdown in Chinese economic activity, given that China is an important trade partner with New Zealand. What is important is that the RBNZ’s “least regrets” approach seems to be working. Despite a cooling economy, sentiment seems to be stabilizing. ANZ consumer confidence improved to 81.9 in July from 80.5. Business confidence also improved to -56.7 from -62.6 (panel 4). Ultimately, the NZD is driven by terms of trade, as well as domestic conditions (panels 1 and 5). Thus, short-term headwinds from a deteriorating external sector do not make us buyers of the currency for now, though a rollover in the dollar will help the kiwi. Canadian Dollar: Lower Oil, Hawkish BoC Chart 9The BoC Will Stay On A Hawkish Path
The BoC Will Stay On A Hawkish Path
The BoC Will Stay On A Hawkish Path
The CAD is down 1.2% year to date. Over the last month, it is up 1.8%. The Canadian dollar did not fully catch up to oil prices on the upside. Now that crude is rolling over, CAD remains vulnerable, unless the dollar continues to stage a meaningful decline (panel 1). Canadian data has been rather mixed over the last month. For example: There have been two consecutive months of job losses. This is after a string of positive job reports. In July, Canada lost 31K jobs. In June, it lost 43K. The reasons have been mixed, from women dropping out of the labor force, to lower youth participation (the participation rate fell), but this is a trend worth monitoring (panel 2). CPI growth remains elevated and is accelerating both on headline and core measures(panel 3). Building permits and housing starts have started to roll over, as house price inflation continues to lose momentum. June housing starts were at 274K from 287.3K. June building permits also fell 1.5% month-on-month though annual inflation is still outpacing house price growth (panel 4). The Canadian trade balance is improving, hitting a multi-year high of C$5.05 bn in June. This has eased the need for foreign capital inflows. The BoC raised rates 100bps in July, the biggest interest rate increase in one meeting among the G10. Unless the labor market continues to soften, the BoC will continue to focus on inflation, which means more rate hikes are forthcoming. The OIS curve is pricing a peak BoC rate of 3.6% in 9 months (panel 5). Two-year real rates are still higher in the US compared to Canada. And the loonie has lost the tailwind from strong WCS oil prices. As such, unless the dollar softens further, the loonie will remain in a choppy trading pattern like most of this year. Swiss Franc: A Safe Haven Chart 10The Franc Will Remain Strong Against The Euro For Now
The Franc Will Remain Strong Against The Euro For Now
The Franc Will Remain Strong Against The Euro For Now
CHF is down 3.2% year-to-date and up 4.3% in the past month. The Swiss franc has been particular strong against the euro, with EUR/CHF breaching parity (panel 1). Switzerland remains an island of relative economic stability in the G10. Although slowing, the manufacturing PMI was a healthy 58 in July. The trade surplus was up to CHF 2.6bn in June, despite a strong franc. While most European countries are preparing for a tough winter with energy rationing, prospects for Switzerland, which derives only 13% of its electricity from natural gas, look more favorable. Still, as a small open economy, Switzerland is feeling the impact of global growth uncertainty. The KOF leading indicator dropped to 90.1 in August with a sharp decline in the manufacturing component. This broader measure suggests the relative resilience of the manufacturing sector might not last long (panel 2). Consumer confidence also fell to the lowest level since the onset of the pandemic. Swiss headline inflation stabilized at 3.4% in July. The core measure rose slightly to the SNB’s 2% target (panel 3). The UBS real estate bubble index rose sharply in Q2, suggesting inflation is not only an imported problem. Labor market conditions also remain tight, with the unemployment rate at 2%, a two-decade low. The SNB will continue to embrace currency strength while inflation risks persist (panel 4), as can be seen by the decline in sight deposits and FX reserves (panel 5). The market is still pricing in another 50 bps hike in September although August inflation data that comes out before the meeting will likely be critical for that decision. CHF is one of the most attractive currencies in our ranking. Despite the recent outperformance, CHF is still down year-to-date against the dollar. A rise in safe-haven demand, and a possible energy crunch in winter will be supportive, especially against the euro. Norwegian Krone: Oil Fields Are A Jewel Chart 11NOK Will Reap Dividends From Energy Exports
NOK Will Reap Dividends From Energy Exports
NOK Will Reap Dividends From Energy Exports
NOK is down 7.4% year-to-date and up 7.1% over the last month. It is also up 4.2% versus the euro, despite softer oil prices (panel 1). Inflation in Norway continues to accelerate. In July, CPI grew 6.8% year-on-year, above the market consensus and the Norges Bank’s forecast. Underlying inflation jumped sharply to an all-time high of 4.5%, compared to the Bank’s 3.2% forecast made just over a month ago (panel 2). These figures are adding pressure on the central bank to increase the pace of interest rate hikes, with 50bps looking increasingly likely at the meetings in August and September. NOK jumped on the inflation news. The housing market is starting to show signs of slowing with prices down 0.2% on the month in July, the first decrease since December. This, together with household indebtedness (panel 3), makes the task of policy calibration challenging. Our bias is that a persistently tight labor market and strong wage growth (panel 4) will allow the bank to focus on inflation. Economic activity remains robust in Norway but is softening. The manufacturing PMI fell to 54.6 in July, while industrial production was down 1.7% month-over-month in June. Consumer demand remains frail with retail sales and household consumption flat in June from the previous month. On a more positive note, trade surplus remains near record levels and is likely to stay elevated as high European demand for Norwegian energy is likely to last at least through the winter (panel 5). As global risk sentiment picked up, the krone became the best performing G10 currency over the past month. If the risk appetite reverses, the currency is likely to feel some turbulence. Swedish Krona: Cheap, But No Catalysts Yet Chart 12SEK = EUR On Steroids
SEK = EUR On Steroids
SEK = EUR On Steroids
SEK is down 10% year-to-date and up 5.6% over the past month. The vigorous rebound highlights just how oversold the Swedish krona is (panel 1). The Swedish economy grew 1.4% in Q2 from the previous three months, rebounding from a 0.8% contraction in the first quarter. This is impressive, given high energy prices and a slowdown in global economic activity. Going forward, growth is likely to slow. In July, the services and manufacturing PMIs declined, and consumer confidence fell sharply to the lowest reading in almost 30 years. Retail sales were down 1.2% month-on-month in June. The housing market is also feeling the pain of rising borrowing costs (panel 2). The Riksbank’s latest estimate sees a 16% decline in prices by the end of next year. For now, inflation is still accelerating in Sweden. CPIF, the Riksbank’s preferred measure, increased from 7.2% to 8.5% in June. Headline inflation rose from 7.3% to 8.7% (panel 3). Headline inflation is likely to decline in July, given the drop in the price component of the PMIs, but inflation will remain well above target. This will keep real rates weak (panel 4). This suggests that the Riksbank is facing the same conundrum as the ECB: accelerate policy tightening and tip the economy towards recession or remain accommodative and risk inflation becoming more entrenched. Our bias is that the Riksbank is likely to frontload rate hikes as currently priced in the OIS curve, with a 50 bps hike in September, ahead of major labor union wage negotiations (panel 5). Much like the NOK, the Swedish krona rebounded strongly in the past month on global risk-on sentiment. Fundamentally, the krona remains more vulnerable to external shocks due to higher energy dependency and a strong dollar. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Artem Sakhbiev Research Associate artem.sakhbiev@bcaresearch.com Thierry Matin Research Associate thierry.matin@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
Listen to a short summary of this report. Executive Summary The Euro And The Chinese Credit Impulse
The Euro And The Chinese Credit Impulse
The Euro And The Chinese Credit Impulse
The US dollar has bounced off its 50-day moving average. In the recent past, that had led to a period of cyclical strength. The yen rally can be explained by the decline in Treasury yields and the fall in energy prices. Where next for the yen will depend on the time horizon. For investors trying to time the bottom, the euro is not yet a buy, but the common currency is incredibly cheap. Much depends on global/Chinese growth (Feature Chart). One of the key drivers of the dollar is volatility, and the correlation with the MOVE index. Less uncertainty will ease safe-haven demand. Stay short EUR/JPY and CHF/JPY. Remain long EUR/GBP. Maintain a limit sell on CHF/SEK at 10.76. RECOMMENDATIONS inception date RETURN Short EUR/JPY 2022-07-21 3.68 Bottom Line: We are tactically neutral the dollar but will be sellers on strength. Questions And Answers Chart 1Currencies And Yield Differentials
Currencies And Yield Differentials
Currencies And Yield Differentials
It is rare that we receive clients in our Montreal office. This has obviously been doubly the case due to the pandemic and the general hassle of travel nowadays. But when we do, it is a delight. In this week’s report, we got asked a few difficult questions on a tea date. The most important was not surprisingly the dollar view, but also our highest conviction trades in FX markets. We enjoyed the conversation and the intellectual debate, so we thought we would share this with our clients. Hopefully, this answers some of the most pressing questions. We have sliced this into as brief and concise a conversation as we could. Question: It is hard not to notice the steep decline in the dollar over the last few weeks. Should we fade this decline or lean into it? That is a tough question, but our educated guess is to fade it for now. That said, longer-term asset allocators should really be looking at buying extremely cheap G10 currencies on any declines. The drivers of dollar downside have been clear. First, long-term interest rates in the US have fallen substantially. The US 10-year Treasury yield has fallen from 3.5% to 2.7%. In real terms, they have also declined. The 10-year TIPS yield has fallen from 0.85% to 0.23%. On a relative basis, the market is also pricing in that the Fed will cut interest rates next year much faster than other central banks. More simply put, 2-year real bond yields in the US are rolling over, relative to the euro area and Japan, the biggest components of the DXY index (Chart 1). Related Report Foreign Exchange StrategyHow Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In? Specific to Japan and the euro area, there has also been another critical factor – the decline in energy import costs. Germany’s trade balance improved markedly in June (Chart 2). This has been the first genuine improvement in a year. There is also discussion to extend the life of existing nuclear power plants, which will help assuage energy import costs. In Japan, trade balance data comes out on Monday next week, so we will see what it reveals. But what has been clear is a political drive to restart nuclear power and wean the Japanese economy off its dependence on oil and gas (Chart 3). Japanese prime minister Fumio Kishida has been very vocal about this in recent speeches. Chart 2Euro Area And Japanese Trade Balances Are Improving
Euro Area And Japanese Trade Balances Are Improving
Euro Area And Japanese Trade Balances Are Improving
Chart 3A Nuclear Renaissance In Japan?
A Nuclear Renaissance In Japan?
A Nuclear Renaissance In Japan?
Turning to the more important part of your question, should we fade the decline or lean into it? We are of two minds on this to be honest, and here is why. The DXY has bounced off its 50-day moving average, which has been a sign in the past that the rally is not over (Chart 4). Our Geopolitical and Commodity & Energy colleagues are telling us not to trust the decline in oil prices. Our bond strategists think US yields are heading higher, with a whisper floor of 2.5%. Chart 4The DXY Has Support At The 50-Day Moving Average
The DXY Has Support At The 50-Day Moving Average
The DXY Has Support At The 50-Day Moving Average
Given these crosscurrents, there are many better opportunities that exist in FX at the crosses, rather than playing the dollar outright. But of course, the dollar call is critical. We would be neutral over the next three-to-six months but be incremental sellers of the dollar on strength. Question: Okay, neutral dollar for now, but bearish long term. We tend to consider longer-term investments as well, and we are confused about the euro, but even more so about the yen. Would you buy the yen today? If so, why? Our starting point for many currencies is valuation. On this basis, the yen is incredibly cheap. So, if you have a five-to-ten-year horizon, you can unlock incredible value in Japan, simply on a buy-and-hold basis. Our in-house curated model shows that the yen is at a multi-general low in value terms (Chart 5). Currencies mean-revert. Consider this for a minute – we are not equity experts, but Toyota trades at a P/E of 10.75, while Tesla trades at a P/E of 109.15. And yes, Toyota has electric cars. Chart 5The Japense Yen Is Incredibly Cheap
The Japense Yen Is Incredibly Cheap
The Japense Yen Is Incredibly Cheap
Chart 6The Yen Is A Favorite Short
The Yen Is A Favorite Short
The Yen Is A Favorite Short
It is true that a winner-takes-all mantra can be attributed to Tesla’s valuation over Toyota, but our colleagues in the Global Investment Strategy are telling us this era is over. As such, at a 40% discount, the yen is a long-term buy in our books. Interestingly, nobody likes the yen, at least by our preferred measure – net speculative positions. It is one of the most shorted G10 currencies (Chart 6). A cheap currency that is the most shorted ranks quite well in our evaluation of bargains in currency markets. Given my discussion above about the dollar, we have played the yen at the crosses. We are short EUR/JPY and CHF/JPY. On the euro, Japanese car manufacturers are simply becoming more competitive than their eurozone or US counterparts. This is not only related to the car industry, but according to the OECD, EUR/JPY is expensive on a purchasing power parity basis (Chart 7). Meanwhile, a short EUR/JPY trade is a perfect hedge for a pro-cyclical portfolio. The DXY index has historically traded in perfect inverse correlation to the euro-yen exchange rate (Chart 8). This suggests the collapse in the yen, relative to the euro, is very much overdone. In a risk-off environment, EUR/JPY will sell off. Meanwhile, there are also fundamental reasons to suggest that the yen should trade higher vis-à-vis the euro. Chart 7Remain Short ##br##EUR/JPY
Remain Short EUR/JPY
Remain Short EUR/JPY
Chart 8The DXY And EUR/JPY Usually Track Each Other
The DXY And EUR/JPY Track Each Other EUR/JPY And The DXY: Unsustainable Gap
The DXY And EUR/JPY Track Each Other EUR/JPY And The DXY: Unsustainable Gap
Question: Okay, let’s switch to the euro. I know you are short EUR/JPY, which has been working out well in the last few days. But the euro touched parity and I get a sense that it has bottomed. You have often mentioned that the euro has priced in one of the deepest recessions in the eurozone. I am surprised you are not trumpeting this currency and a once-in-a-lifetime buying opportunity. We agree somewhat with your conclusion but not the premise. Let’s consider the narrative over the last few months in the media. The first was that eurozone inflation will never catch up to the US, because the economy was structurally weak. Well, it did, albeit due to an exogenous shock. So, among a ranking of stagflationary candidates, the euro area is a top contender. If you believe in the idea that currencies are driven by real interest rates, rising inflation, and falling growth are an anathema for the exchange rate. When we typically have doubts about the euro area economy, and the outlook for its financial markets, we consult with our European Investment Strategy colleagues. We did just that and Mathieu Savary, who heads the service, mentioned two things: one – Chinese import volumes are imploding. For net creditor nations, this is a negative as their source of income is waning. The euro area falls into that category. The second thing to consider is that the dollar is a momentum currency. So is the euro. We mentioned earlier that the dollar bounced off its 50-day moving average, which explains euro weakness in recent trading days. In the end, Mathieu and the FX team did not really disagree, but I highlighted two charts to track. The euro tracks the Chinese credit impulse due to the importance of Chinese import demand for the euro area. It looks like our measure of that impulse has bottomed (Chart 9). If it has, you buy the euro on a long-term view. Relatedly, financial conditions are easing in China. As the Chinese bond market becomes more open and liberalized, bond yields become a financial conditions valve. That has been the case and has perfectly tracked the propensity for imports in the last few years (Chart 10). Chart 9The Euro And The Chinese Credit Impulse
The Euro And The Chinese Credit Impulse
The Euro And The Chinese Credit Impulse
Chart 10Financial Conditions Are Easing In China
Financial Conditions Are Easing In China
Financial Conditions Are Easing In China
In short, we will buy the euro if it touches parity, and even more so below parity with a 5–10-year view, but we think EUR/USD could touch 0.95 in the near term. I guess what we are saying is that a 5%-7% move is big in FX markets, but a 26% move (the undervaluation of the euro) is a whale. We do not see the catalyst for a whale in our current compass. Question: We have talked about the yen and the euro. I do not want to get into the pound, Australian dollar, and other currencies as you have told me your team has upcoming reports on those. But the Chinese yuan is very important in my investment portfolio. Any ideas on its next move? USD/CNY topped out near 6.8 in May. Since then, it has been in a trading range despite the DXY breaking to multi-decade highs (Chart 11). When a pattern like this emerges, it is always useful to revisit fundamentals. Those fundamentals are real interest rate differentials. We care about the yuan because China is a big trading partner of the US. As such, it is also a huge weight in the broad trade-weighted dollar index. China has huge problems, especially related to the property market, which need to be resolved. Bond yields have also collapsed. But the real interest rate in China is very attractive (Chart 12). It is also important to consider that if the dollar is the global safe haven, that means that the yuan could be becoming the haven in Asia. So, yuan downside is not a big risk for our long-term dollar bearish call. That said, we will be short CNY versus the yen, but not the dollar. Chart 11The RMB Has Been Relatively Resilient
The RMB Has Been Relatively Resilient
The RMB Has Been Relatively Resilient
Chart 12The RMB Has Undershot Real Rate Differentials
The RMB Has Undershot Real Rate Differentials
The RMB Has Undershot Real Rate Differentials
Question: I think I could sit with you all morning to discuss other aspects of FX, but I respect you have a tight stop due to the BLU meeting. Any concluding thoughts? I have one. Very often, we debate with our colleagues about capital flows. The dollar rises (in general), as capital inflows accelerate into the US and vice versa. It is often said that getting the dollar call right gets everything else right. So, if you can predict the path of the dollar, the performance of, say, US versus non-US equities becomes easy. Chart 13The Dollar And Earnings Revisions
The Dollar And Earnings Revisions
The Dollar And Earnings Revisions
We agree that the dollar is a real-time indicator of relative fundamentals. But here is one important observation: relative earnings revisions are deteriorating in the US vis-à-vis other countries (Chart 13). That has historically had an impact on exchange rates, as it affects equity capital flows. If the Federal Reserve also cut rates next year as the market is predicting, that will also be a negative for bond inflows. We think the global economy will avoid a deep recession, and that will allow growth to pick up outside the US. When the euro area and China bottom, then the dollar will truly peak, as capital flows to these economies will accelerate. So we are watching relative earnings and bond yield differentials closely. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
Listen to a short summary of this report. Executive Summary The Dollar Rises During Recessions
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
At 106.5, the dollar DXY index is certainly pricing in a recession deeper than during the Covid-19 crisis. The dollar tends to rise during recessions and only peaks when a global economic recovery is in sight (Feature Chart). One caveat: contrary to conventional wisdom, US economic data is deteriorating relative to the rest of the world. Historically, that has been a negative for the greenback. The key question facing investors is if markets are entering a riot point. That is a high probability. Historically, high volatility supports the dollar. As such, our recommended stance on the dollar is neutral over the next few months. Our highest conviction bets are short EUR/JPY and long Swiss franc trades. Valuations tend to matter when most investors least expect them to. On this basis, we are negative the dollar on a 12-to-18 month time horizon. Place a limit sell on CHF/SEK at 10.76. TRADES* INITIATION DATE PERCENT RETURNS Short EUR/JPY 2022-07-21 2.73% Bottom Line: Stand aside on the dollar for now. Continue to opportunistically play trades at the crosses. Short EUR/JPY bets make sense as a volatility hedge. Chart 1Any Dollar Bears Left?
Any Dollar Bears Left?
Any Dollar Bears Left?
In our conversations with clients, it is rare to find a dollar bear these days. One barometer is price action – the dollar DXY index is up 18% from its 2021 lows. More instructively, net long speculative positions are near a multi-decade high (Chart 1). In our meetings, we sense a specter of capitulation among fundamental dollar bears, as the macroeconomic environment becomes more uncertain. For chart enthusiasts, the DXY index staged a classic breakout, and the next technical level is closer to the 2002 highs near 120. We doubt the DXY index will hit this level, as significant headwinds are building. It is true that as markets increasingly price in the probability of a recession, especially in Europe, the dollar will be bought. But as we argue below, the dollar has already priced in a recession, deeper than was the case in 2020 (or admittedly, at any time since the end of the Bretton Woods system). This suggests that investors with a relatively benign economic backdrop should be fading any strength in the dollar. In other words, if your bet on a recession is low odds, fade dollar strength relatively to your colleagues. As such, our recommended stance on the dollar is neutral over the next few months, but bearish for investors with a longer-term horizon. For today, our highest conviction bets are short EUR/JPY and long Swiss franc trades. The US Dollar And Global Growth Chart 2The Dollar Tracks Global Growth
The Dollar Tracks Global Growth
The Dollar Tracks Global Growth
There are many important drivers of the US dollar. One is the path for global growth. If global activity is going to slow meaningfully, then as a countercyclical currency, the dollar tends to rise in that environment. The dollar has been closely correlated (inversely) to the trend in global PMIs, industrial production, and other measures of global growth (Chart 2). Across the world, global growth is slowing (Chart 3). Most manufacturing PMIs in the developed world peaked in the middle of last year. In the developing world, China’s zero Covid-19 policy has nudged many PMIs close to the 50 boom/bust level. As a rule of thumb, you do not want to be short the greenback when global industrial activity is slowing. That is the bull case. Chart 3AGlobal Growth Is Slowing In Developed Markets
Global Growth Is Slowing In Developed Markets
Global Growth Is Slowing In Developed Markets
Chart 3BGrowth Is Also Soft In Emerging Markets
Growth Is Also Soft In Emerging Markets
Growth Is Also Soft In Emerging Markets
The good news for dollar bears is that most of this information is already priced in. Looking back at recessions since the 1970s, the dollar is pricing in one of the most anticipated slowdowns in history (Chart 4). This alone is not a reason to turn bearish on the greenback, but it is a red flag towards the consensus view. In general, currencies are a relative game. The dollar tends to rise 10%-to-15% during recessions. We are already there, with the DXY index up 18% since the 2021 lows. It is also important to gauge how the US is faring relative to the rest of the world. Quite simply, US economy economic activity is deteriorating vis-à-vis its trading partners. This is visible in the Citigroup economic surprise indices, but also via a simple chart of relative PMIs (Chart 5). Historically, that has been a negative for the greenback outside of recessions. Chart 4The Dollar Overshoots During Recessions
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
Chart 5US Economic Momentum Is Deteriorating
US Economic Momentum Is Deteriorating
US Economic Momentum Is Deteriorating
The US Dollar And Interest Rates The Fed hiked interest rates by 75bps this week. This was as expected but given what the Bank of Canada delivered on July 13th, a 100bps hike was a whisper number in our books. More importantly, interest rate differentials (real and nominal) are increasingly moving against the US. As we go to press, 10-year bond yields are 2.67% in the US, but 2.62% in Canada, 3.41% in New Zealand, and even 3.1% in Australia. Chart 6The Euro And Relative Interest Rates
The Euro And Relative Interest Rates
The Euro And Relative Interest Rates
The key point is that the market consensus is centered around the Fed being the most hawkish central bank. That will face a critical test in the next few months, if the world enters a recession. This is especially true in the euro area. The market is pricing that interest rates in the eurozone will be 200bps lower next year, relative to the US (Chart 6). The historical spread between US and German 2-year yields has been 83 bps. If Europe indeed enters a deep recession, then that is already priced in the euro. If we get any green shoots in economic growth, then the euro is poised for a coiled-spring rebound. The market is also pricing in that US interest rates will peak next year, relative to other G10 economies (Chart 7). This could happen in one of two ways: The Fed turns more dovish and/or non-US growth loses steam, leading to lower interest rates outside the US. It is difficult to forecast how the economic scenario will evolve, but from an investor’s standpoint, the dollar has already overshot the level implied by relative interest rates (Chart 8). Chart 7US Short Real Yields Are Attractive
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
Chart 8The Dollar Has Overshot Rate Fundamentals
The Dollar Has Overshot Rate Fundamentals
The Dollar Has Overshot Rate Fundamentals
A Short Note On USD Valuations Valuations usually get little respect, especially over the last few years. The bull market in the dollar from 2011 to 2022 coincided with higher real interest rates in the US relative to the rest of the developed world. That said, a rising trade deficit (imports > exports) requires a lower exchange rate to boost competitiveness in the manufacturing sector, or less spending to reduce the trade deficit. Therefore, the natural adjustment mechanism for countries running wide trade deficits will have to be the exchange rate. Quite simply, rising deficits are a symptom of an overvalued exchange rate. Within a broad spectrum of developed and emerging market currencies, the US dollar is overvalued on a real effective exchange rate basis (Chart 9 and 10). While valuations tend to matter less until they trigger a tipping point, such inflections usually occur with a shift in animal spirits, especially when investors start to worry about huge external imbalances. Chart 9The Dollar Is Overvalued
The Dollar Is Overvalued
The Dollar Is Overvalued
Chart 10The Dollar Is One Of The Most Expensive Currencies
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
How Deep A Recession Is The Dollar Pricing In?
In the US, these imbalances are already starting to spark a shift. The US trade deficit has deteriorated. The basic balance in the US (the sum of the current account and foreign direct investment) is deteriorating. The dollar tends to decline on a multi-year basis when the basic balance peaks and starts deteriorating. It is remarkable that at a time when real rates are quite negative in the US, the dollar is the most overvalued in decades on a simple PPP model basis. This is a perfect mirror image of the dollar configuration at the start of the bull market in 2010, where the dollar was cheap and real rates were more supportive. According to economic theory, a currency should adjust to equalize returns across countries. In the early 80s, an expensive dollar was supported by very positive real rates. The subsequent dollar declines thereafter also coincided with falling real interest rates. If global growth shifts from relative strength in the US to overseas, interest rate differentials will tilt in favor of non-US markets. That will be solace for dollar bears. Conclusions In financial markets, it pays to be humble but also to be bold. Our recommended stance on the DXY (and by association, the euro and cable) is to stay on the sidelines. Our highest conviction trade is to short EUR/JPY. With the drop in commodity prices, resource-related currencies are becoming interesting, a topic we will discuss in upcoming bulletins. But momentum is your friend for now, which suggests prudence. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
Executive Summary The Dollar And Volatility
The Dollar And Volatility
The Dollar And Volatility
The dollar continues to be bid, as volatility rises. The MOVE volatility index is making fresh cycle highs and has pushed the DXY index above our stop level of 107 (Feature Chart). The move in the dollar suggests that we are experiencing a classic breakout pattern. Historically, this means that flows into the USD will continue, until it becomes clear that drivers of USD strength have abated. These include inflation peaking and global growth bottoming. We are moving our recommended stance on USD to neutral. It is becoming clear that the market sees the risk of a nasty recession in Europe to be high. The euro could break below parity, as speculators short the currency en masse. The yen is becoming a winner in the current context. We are reopening our short EUR/JPY trade this week, in addition to our short CHF/JPY position initiated last week. Our long AUD/USD position was stopped out at 68 cents this week. Given our shift to a neutral view on the dollar, we recommend investors stand aside for now. Bottom Line: We were stopped out of our short DXY position at 107, for a loss of 2.34%. We are moving to a neutral stance on the greenback. While valuation and sentiment are at contrarian extremes, the current environment dictates that further gains in the greenback are likely in the near term. Feature The DXY index has staged a classic breakout and the next technical level is closer to the 2002 highs near 120. Year-to-date, the DXY has been one of the best performing currencies (Chart 1). In last week’s report, we presented a framework for managing currencies, suggesting that while the path of least resistance for the dollar was up, significant headwinds were also building. One of the closest correlations we have seen in recent trading days is with volatility. As Chart 2 shows, the dollar and the MOVE index have been the same line. As markets increasingly price in the probability of a recession, especially in Europe, the dollar will be bought. This puts central banks in a quandary: focusing on growth or inflation? As such bond volatility is shooting up and the dollar is commanding a hefty safety premium. In the next few sections, we go over the important data releases from our universe of G10 countries, and implications for currency strategy. Chart 1The Dollar Remains King
Month In Review: The Euro At Parity, What Next?
Month In Review: The Euro At Parity, What Next?
Chart 2The Dollar And Volatility
The Dollar And Volatility
The Dollar And Volatility
US Dollar: A Classic Breakout Chart 3A Clean Breakout In The DXY
A Clean Breakout In The DXY
A Clean Breakout In The DXY
The dollar DXY index is up 11.3% year-to-date. Over the last month, the DXY index is up 4.7%. Technical forces are still in favor of the greenback as a momentum currency, given the classic breakout pattern. Looking at incoming data from the US, the case for dollar strength remains in place in the near term. The May CPI print came in well above expectations, at 8.6% for headline, versus 8.3% expected. A few days later, the PPI print was also strong at 10.8% year on year. This is happening at a time when consumer confidence is rolling over. The University of Michigan current conditions index fell from 63.3 to 53.8 in May. The expectations component dropped from 55.2 to 47.5. The conference board measure fell from 103.2 to 98.7 in June. After this print, the Fed met on June 15 and increased interest rates by 75bps, a surprise to the market. The current account deficit widened to $291.4bn US, a record low since the end of the Bretton Woods system . Retail sales disappointed in May. Excluding automobile and gasoline, sales were up 0.1% month on month, versus a consensus expectation of a 0.4% rise. It was also flat for the control group, suggesting basket changes were not responsible for the deterioration. The numbers are on a nominal basis, which suggests that retail sales volumes are contracting meaningfully. The rise in interest rates is filtering into the housing market. Mortgage applications fell 5.4% during the week of July 1. Housing starts declined from 1,810K to 1,724K in May, a 14.4% drop. Building permits also fell 7% month on month, in line with the 3.4% drop in existing home sales. The ISM manufacturing index fell from 56.1 to 53 in June. US economic data is softening, which raises the odds that the US joins Europe and China in a classic slowdown. In such a configuration, the market is pricing in that the dollar will ultimately be the haven asset, as has been the case in recent history. We went short the DXY index at 104.8, with a stop-loss at 107, that was triggered overnight. We are moving to a neutral stance today and will revisit this position once global economic uncertainty subsides. The Euro: A European Hard Landing Chart 4The Euro Is Pricing In A Deep Recession
The Euro Is Pricing In A Deep Recession
The Euro Is Pricing In A Deep Recession
The euro is down 10.5% year-to-date. Over the last month, the euro is down 4.7%, and recent trading suggests we will probably breach parity versus the dollar in the coming weeks. Recent data from the eurozone continues to suggest it is trapped in stagflation. The preliminary CPI print for June came in at 8.6%, well above the previous 8.1% print. PPI in the euro area is at 36.3%. Meanwhile, consumer confidence (the European Commission’s measure) is approaching a record low. The Sentix investor confidence index peaked in July last year and has been falling ever since. With a mandate of bringing down inflation, the ECB may have no choice but to knock the eurozone economy to its knees. The proximate expression of this view has been via shorting the euro. Most of the incoming data for the euro area have been deteriorating. For example, on a seasonally adjusted basis, the trade deficit widened to -€31.7bn. This is a record since the creation of the euro. This has completely wiped the eurozone current account, meaning the euro is now becoming a borrower nation. The critical question for Europe lies in the adjustment mechanism towards a possible shut-off in natural gas supplies for the winter. European natural gas prices are soaring anew, though well below the peak this year. A cut-off of Russian supplies is becoming a very real possibility. The question then becomes how deep of a European recession the euro is pricing in. Back in 2020, the euro bottomed at 1.06. At the time, quarterly real GDP in the euro area fell 11.9% in the second quarter. That was worse than both during the global financial crisis, and anytime since the creation of the euro. This means that fundamentally, the euro has already priced in a nasty recession in Europe. If it occurs, the euro could undershoot but if it does not, the potential for a coiled spring rebound is immense. A hedged bet on the euro is to sell the EUR/JPY cross. In a risk-off environment, EUR/JPY will collapse. In a Goldilocks scenario, the yen has sold off much more that the euro, that the cross could move sideways. The Japanese Yen: Now A Safe Haven Chart 5The Yen Is Becoming An Attractive Safe Haven
The Yen Is Becoming An Attractive Safe Haven
The Yen Is Becoming An Attractive Safe Haven
The Japanese yen is down 15.4% year-to-date, the worst performing G10 currency. Over the last month, the yen is down 2.4%. Incoming data in Japan has been mixed with the domestic economy still showing some signs of weakness, while the external sector is faring relatively better. The Bank of Japan kept monetary policy on hold last month, despite a widely held view in markets that it would pivot, following the surprise hike by the Swiss National Bank. Inflation in Japan has been modest, with nationwide CPI at 2.5% in May. The Tokyo CPI release for June showed that inflation remains sticky around this level. Yet the BoJ views a large chunk of inflation in Japan to be transitory, due to rising energy costs, and base effects from the sharp drop in mobile phone prices last year. For inflation to pick up, ultimately wages need to rise. Labor cash earnings for May came in at 1%. For Japan, this is a healthy print compared to recent history, but still pins real cash earnings at -1.8%, suggesting little risk of a wage inflation spiral. The Tankan survey for the second quarter provided a glimmer of hope. While large manufacturers (mainly exporters) sensed a deterioration in the outlook, domestic concerns were more upbeat. The large non-manufacturing index improved from 9 to 13 in the second quarter. The small non-manufacturing index improved from -6 to -1. Notably, capex intentions rose 18.6%, the highest level since the late 80s. The drivers of the yen remain clear and absolute. First, rising global interest rates put selling pressure on the yen and vice versa. Second, energy prices sap the trade balance, which is also negative. Should these factors abate (as they are currently), the yen will benefit. This week, we are reopening our short EUR/JPY trade, in addition to being short CHF/JPY. From a contrarian perspective, the yen is the cheapest G10 currency according to our PPP models. It also happens to be one of the most heavily shorted currencies, according to CFTC data. British Pound: Sterling Breaks Below 1.20 Chart 6Politics Will Keep Cable Volatile
Politics Will Keep Cable Volatile
Politics Will Keep Cable Volatile
The pound is down 11.1% year-to-date. Over the last month, the pound is down by 4.5% as a combination of economic and political headwinds hit sterling. Politically, the resignation of Prime Minister Boris Johnson is fueling sterling volatility. According to our geopolitical strategists, investors’ focus should be on whether UK national policy will change. This will require an election that replaces the Conservative Party-led government, or at least removes its single-party majority. Boris Johnson’s approval rating had been collapsing in recent days on the back of a series of scandals, so a less unloved leader under the same party will at least assuage public opinion, while keeping existing policies largely the same. The next milestones to watch for are an early election (unlikely since the Conservative Party still has an interest in prolonging until 2025) and a Scottish referendum for independence next year. Labor will also continue to benefit from a tailwind of high inflation and the mishandling of the pandemic by the Tories that has left voters largely frustrated. Economically, data in the UK continues its whiff of stagflation. CPI came out at 9.1% in May, the RPI accelerated to 11.7%, and nationwide housing prices came in at 10.7% in June, while retail sales are tanking, falling 4.7% year on year in June, excluding auto and fuel costs. The GFK Consumer confidence indicator hit a record low of -41 in June. Our report on sterling suggested that headwinds remain likely in the near term, but the pound is becoming more and more attractive for longer-term investors. We are currently long EUR/GBP. This cross still heavily underprices the risks to the UK economy in the near term. However, if recession fears ease, our suspicion is that cable is poised for a coiled-spring rebound. Canadian Dollar: The BoC Will Stay Hawkish Chart 7The CAD Has Decoupled From Oil Prices
The CAD Has Decoupled From Oil Prices
The CAD Has Decoupled From Oil Prices
The CAD is down 2.5% year-to-date. Over the last month, it is down 3.4%. Incoming data continues to suggest there is little reason for the BoC to change course in tightening monetary policy. The employment market remains strong. In May, 40K new jobs were added, and the details below the surface were notable. 135K full time jobs were swapped for 96K part time roles. Hourly wages rose 4.5% and the unemployment rate dipped to 5.1%. This sort of data is carte blanche for the BoC to keep hiking, since it signals a soft landing in the economy. Housing has been a point of contention for higher rates in Canada (given indebted households), but the Teranet national house price index shows that home prices are still rising 18.3% year-on-year in Canada as of May. This is occurring within the context of widespread price gains. Headline CPI came in at 7.7% in May, with all measures of the BoC’s trimmed estimates (core-common, core-median, core-trim), well above target and expectations. It will be interesting to watch how the BoC calibrates monetary policy given that the closely watched Business Outlook Survey showed a large deterioration in participants’ outlook for the future. In a world where USD strength persists, CAD will trade on the weaker side, but we remain buyers of the CAD once recession fears ebb. Australian Dollar: A Contrarian Play Chart 8A Jumbo Hike By The RBA
A Jumbo Hike By The RBA
A Jumbo Hike By The RBA
The Australian dollar is down 5.8% year- to-date. Over the last month, the AUD is down 5.3% as the price of iron ore declined by over 10% and the Chinese economy remained on lockdown. The RBA raised its interest rate by 50bps for a second month in a row this week. This aggressively shifted market expectations for further rate increases, with pricing in the OIS curve one year out rising from 3.35 to 3.51% today. While the RBA admitted global supply chain issues have contributed to inflation, capacity constraints in certain sectors and a tight labor market are also helping fuel domestic inflation. Particularly, the May employment report was robust, with 69.4K full-time jobs added, and a healthy jump in the participation rate to 66.7%. Job vacancies continued to grow at 13.8%. Rising rates in Australia are having the desired effect. Home price inflation is cooling, especially in places like Sydney. Demand for housing and construction remains robust, suggesting the RBA is achieving a soft landing in the economy. For example, home loan values are growing 1.7% and building approvals are growing by 9.9%. Demand also appears strong as manufacturing PMI came out at 56.2 in June. We are bullish the AUD against the dollar; however, short-term headwinds from Chinese lockdowns do not currently make us buyers of the currency. We are exiting our long AUD/USD position after being stopped out at 0.68 for a loss of -5.67%. New Zealand Dollar: Least Preferred G10 Currency Chart 9Terms Of Trade Are Waning For NZD
Terms Of Trade Are Waning For NZD
Terms Of Trade Are Waning For NZD
The NZD is down 9.7% this year. Over the last month, it is down 4.7%. New Zealand has the highest policy rate in the G10, and that is beginning to take a toll on interest-rate sensitive parts of the economy. REINZ house sales fell 28.4% year on year in May. House price inflation is also rapidly cooling. In June, the ANZ consumer confidence index fell from 82.3 to 80.5. Business confidence deteriorated from -55.6 to -62.6. The external sector is no longer a tailwind for the NZ economy, as grain and meat prices cool off. The price of dairy, approximately 20% of New Zealand’s exports, continues to decline with a 10% drop in June. The 12-month trailing trade balance continues to plummet, hitting -9.5bn NZD in May. The current account for May came in at -6.14 billion NZD versus a consensus -5.5 billion NZD. China is an important economic partner for New Zealand, with circa 27% of Kiwi exports China bound. Restrictions seem to be easing as the latest non-manufacturing PMI from China data came in at 54.7 against a previous 48.4 reading. The number of days required to quarantine on arrival also dropped to 10 days from 21 days in June. If this trend continues, it will be positive for the NZD; however, China does not appear to have an exit strategy for their zero-case COVID-19 policy. Within the G10 currency space, many other currencies appear more attractive than the kiwi, though our view is that NZD will benefit when US dollar momentum rolls over. Swiss Franc: A Safe Haven Chart 10A U-Turn From The SNB
A U-Turn From The SNB
A U-Turn From The SNB
CHF is down 6.4% year-to-date and flat over the past month versus the dollar. Against the euro, the franc is up 4.7% year-to-date and 5.2% over the past month. Our special report on the franc was timely, given the surprise rate hike announcement from the SNB last month. Amidst currency market volatility, EUR/CHF broke below parity. The SNB views currency strength as a virtue in today’s paradigm. As such, it has halted currency interventions, evident through the decline in sight deposits. Markets are pricing in another 50bps hike in September. Inflation continued to accelerate above projections in June. Headline and core CPI were up 3.4% and 1.9% year on year respectively, lower than other G10 countries but high enough to keep the SNB on alert. Inflation remains largely driven by the prices of imported goods which strengthens the case for a strong franc. The labor market is also tight, with unemployment at 2.2% in May. The outlook for the Swiss economy remains positive for the rest of the year, albeit with some signs of slowing activity emerging. The manufacturing PMI at 59.1 and the KOF leading indicator at 96.8 were both down to multi-month lows in June. The trade surplus in May was down to CHF 2bn. The franc is undervalued against the dollar and can serve as a good hedge for spikes in global volatility. Norwegian Krone: Improving The Current Account Chart 11NOK Has Decoupled From Oil Prices
NOK Has Decoupled From Oil Prices
NOK Has Decoupled From Oil Prices
The NOK is down 13.2% YTD and down 6.2% over the last month. Against the euro, the NOK is down 2.4% YTD and 1.3% in over the past month. In June, the Norges Bank raised the policy rate from 0.75% to 1.25%, 25bps higher than broadly anticipated. The rate path was also revised sharply higher and now corresponds to a 25bps hike at each meeting until the rate steadies at around 3% next summer. Governor Ida Wolden Bache left the door open for more half-point hikes but also highlighted the potential risk of overtightening, suggesting a balanced approach. Inflation in Norway is surprising to the upside. In May, CPI came in at 5.7% and 3.4% for core, signaling that price increases are becoming more broad-based. The labor market remains tight. The unemployment rate dipped to 1.7% in June, the lowest reading since 2008. Wages are projected to grow 3.9% this year. Together with a positive output gap, and a weak currency, both domestic and imported inflation could remain sticky for a while. Economic activity remains healthy in Norway. The manufacturing PMI went up to 56.4 in June, private consumption is robust, and business investment is expected to increase around 8% this year. Petroleum investments are also expected to pick up markedly in the years ahead, spurred by elevated energy prices and tax incentives. Recent natural gas production hikes, approved by the government, will further contribute to the healthy trade surplus. The strike started by union workers this week threatened to halt a significant portion of Norway’s oil and natural gas output. However, a resolution was found rather quickly. Despite record energy prices, the krone is one of the worst-performing majors this year. Pronounced global risk-off sentiment in the first half weighed on the currency. Despite potential challenges in the near term, Norway’s trade balance will remain a major tailwind this year. Shorting EUR/NOK on rallies looks attractive. Swedish Krona: Tracking The Euro Lower Chart 12The SEK Is At Capitulation Lows
The SEK Is At Capitulation Lows
The SEK Is At Capitulation Lows
The SEK is down 14.2% year-to-date and 7.1% over the last month. Inflation is becoming a problem in Sweden. In May, the CPIF increased 7.2% year on year, while the core measure was up 5.4%. In response, the Riksbank raised the policy rate by 50bps to 0.75% at its June meeting. The Riksbank sees the policy rate at around 1.75% by year-end, implying 50bps hikes at the remaining two meetings this year. The bank also announced a faster run-off in its balance sheet. We had anticipated the hawkish pivot by the Riksbank in early June, but that has not helped the Swedish krona much. Like Europe, the Swedish economy is being held hostage by external shocks, the global slowdown and an energy crisis. Signs of economic slowdown are becoming more pronounced. The Riksbank’s GDP forecast for 2022 was revised down by 1% to 1.8% and cut in half to 0.7% for 2023. Industrial production and new order data also point to a cooling in economic activity. Manufacturing and services PMIs remain expansionary zone but are falling rapidly. Notably, export orders have been hovering around the 50 boom/bust line over the last few months. Housing market is also vulnerable, with the Riksbank projecting a more-than-10% decline in prices by next year. That said, the SEK is below the 2020 lows suggesting these risks are well priced in. We are buyers of SEK on weakness. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Artem Sakhbiev Research Associate artem.sakhbiev@bcaresearch.com Thierry Matin Research Associate thierry.matin@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
In this <i>Strategy Outlook</i>, we present the major investment themes and views we see playing out for the rest of the year and beyond.
Executive Summary Is Relative Inflation Peaking In The US?
Is Relative Inflation Peaking In The US
Is Relative Inflation Peaking In The US
The dollar has likely peaked in the near term. An unwinding of speculative bets, based on structurally higher inflation in the US, is the key driver (Feature Chart). Our theme of central bank convergence continues to play out. Rates in the euro area are headed higher. The next bet for higher rates is in Japan. The key for picking currency winners will be global growth barometers. The US dollar embeds a huge safety premium that will be eroded as we get more clarity on global growth and inflation. RECOMMENDATIONS INCEPTION LEVEL inception date RETURN Short DXY 104.80 2022-05-13 2.22 Bottom Line: We are short the DXY index as of 104.8. We recommend sticking with this position. Feature The dollar very much remains well bid (Chart 1). But the macroeconomic environment that has helped the dollar is likely to reverse. As inflation in the US cools, especially relative to other DM economies, the policy divergence between the US and other economies will move in the opposite direction (Chart 2 and Chart 3). Chart 1Long Dollar Positions Still Profitable
Month In Review: Recession Risk
Month In Review: Recession Risk
Chart 2Is Relative Inflation Peaking In The US
Is Relative Inflation Peaking In The US
Is Relative Inflation Peaking In The US
Chart 3The Dollar And Interest Rates
The Dollar And Interest Rates
The Dollar And Interest Rates
Last month, we posited that interest rate differentials played a key role in pushing the dollar higher but have not been the sole factor. The safe-haven premium in the DXY is around 8-10%. That premium will remain if growth concerns are at the forefront of investors’ minds but will evaporate otherwise. Over the last few weeks, we have had a few surprises from central banks, notably the ECB and the RBA. In this Month-In-Review, we go over our current currency thinking, and implications for portfolio strategy. US Dollar: Peak Hawkishness? Chart 4Is Inflation Peaking In The US
Is Inflation Peaking In The US
Is Inflation Peaking In The US
The dollar DXY index is up 7.4% year to date. However, over the last month, there has been a big reversal in the dollar, down 1.5% month-to-date. As a momentum currency, technical forces are moving against the greenback. Incoming data for the US remains robust, but a peak in inflation expectations, that will temper the pace of Fed interest rate hikes, has been driving dollar momentum. Headline CPI is expected to come in at 8.3% in May, while the core measure should decelerate to 5.9%. It is possible that these numbers surprise to the downside. For example, used car prices, an important contribution to US CPI, are rolling over sharply (panel 2). Overall, supply-side price pressures appear to be easing (panel 3). The US added 390K jobs in May, so the employment report remains robust. Encouragingly, the participation rate is also picking up. This suggests the US can absorb more willing workers before we see additional upward pressure in wage growth. We are closely watching the Atlanta Fed wage growth tracker (panel 4). The ISM manufacturing index had a solid print of 56.1 in May, but the prices paid index dipped from 84.6 to 82.2. As we highlighted above, these developments have sapped market expectations for aggressive interest rate increases in the US relative to other G10 countries. Speculative froth in the dollar is also unwinding (panel 5). We went short the DXY index at 104.8, with a stop loss at 107. We recommend sticking with this position. The Euro: A European Soft Landing? Chart 5The Euro Has Priced A Recession
The Euro Has Priced A Recession
The Euro Has Priced A Recession
The euro is down 6.6% year-to-date. Over the last month, the euro is up 0.7%. The ECB cemented the fact that interest rates are headed higher this week. With a mandate of taming inflation, the central bank faces a tough job of reigning in price pressures, while engineering a soft landing in the economy. From the perspective of the euro, it is our view that most of the downside risks to this scenario have been priced in, while upside surprises have not (panel 1). Incoming data from the euro area has been improving. The Sentix Investor Confidence index ticked up in June. Energy prices remain high, but momentum has been softening. The ZEW expectations survey also delivered an upside surprise in May. The key point from an FX perspective is that the euro has already priced a recession in the European economy, but no prospect of a soft landing. That is positive from a contrarian perspective. With HICP inflation at 8.1% (panel 2), emergency monetary settings are no longer required, and the ECB should lift rates. As we suggested last month, a “least regrets” approach will gently nudge rates higher to address inflationary pressures but pay attention to cyclical sectors of the economy (panel 3). It is important to remember that interest rates in the eurozone are still at -0.5%. Related Report Foreign Exchange StrategyMonth In-Review: A Hefty Safe-Haven Premium In The Dollar We remain long EUR/GBP on the prospect that the ECB could better engineer a soft landing, compared to the BoE. We also remain sellers of the EUR/JPY cross. In a risk-off environment, EUR/JPY will collapse. In a Goldilocks scenario, the cross has already priced in a much stronger global economy (panel 4). This is also a perfect hedge for a pro-cyclical currency positioning. The Japanese Yen: Back To Carry Trades Chart 6The Yen Will Soon Bottom
The Yen Will Soon Bottom
The Yen Will Soon Bottom
The Japanese yen is down 14.3% year-to-date, the worst performing G10 currency this year. Over the last month, the yen is down 2.9%. The yen is a classic case of the risks of fighting the trend in currency markets (panel 1). That said we remain buyers, rather than sellers, on weakness. The drivers of the yen have been very clear and absolute. First, rising interest rates abroad, as we saw this week, have put selling pressure on the JPY (panel 2), given the BoJ will maintain yield curve control. Second, the pickup in energy prices continues to deflate the Japanese trade balance. These are negative shocks that are likely to continue inflicting pain on yen long positions in the near term. From a contrarian perspective, there is solace for yen bulls. First, it is the cheapest G10 currency according to our PPP models. It also happens to be one of the most heavily shorted currencies, according to CFTC data (panel 4). In terms of data, there have also been positive surprises over the last month. The Eco Watcher’s Survey surprised to the upside. PMIs have rebounded above 50. Inflation is above the 2% target and should keep rising. Machinery orders are picking up. The Bank of Japan is likely to stay dovish next week but that is largely priced in. Meanwhile, the BoJ will have no choice but to pivot if inflationary pressures prove stronger than they anticipate, and/or the output gap in Japan closes much faster as demand recovers. We have no active position on the yen right now but will be buyers on weakness. British Pound: Sterling And A Policy Mistake Chart 7Cable Is At Risk Near Term
Cable Is At Risk Near Term
Cable Is At Risk Near Term
The pound is down 7.6% year to date. Over the last month, the pound is up by 1.3%. We wrote a report on sterling last week. In our view, sterling faces headwinds in the near term but is likely to be a profitable long position for investors with a more structural view. First, the deterioration in the UK’s trade balance is cyclical and not structural. Fuels constitute 11% of UK imports so higher energy prices are affecting the balance of trade. This will soon reverse. Second, goods imports have picked up, but it is encouraging that a huge share has been machinery and transport equipment. Inflation remains a problem in England, with CPI at 9%. In our view, while sterling is pricing in a policy mistake by the BoE – tightening too fast into a slowing economy, our bias is that the BoE can engineer a soft landing for the economy. Only one-third of the rise in UK inflation has been driven by demand-side pull, with the balance related to supply-side factors. The latter have been the usual suspects – rising energy costs, supply shortages, and even legacies of the Brexit shock (Chart 10). These could ease going forward. We are currently long EUR/GBP. This cross still heavily underprices the risks to the UK economy in the near term. However, if recession fears ease, our suspicion is that cable is poised for a coiled spring rebound. Canadian Dollar: The BoC Will Stay Hawkish Chart 8CAD Should Benefit From Terms Of Trade
CAD Should Benefit From Terms Of Trade
CAD Should Benefit From Terms Of Trade
The CAD is down 0.6% year to date. Over the last month, it is up 2.4%. The CAD has been the best performing G10 currency this year after the DXY, and the key drivers of loonie strength will persist. First, the CAD will benefit from a terms-of-trade boost, given it is trading at a discount to prevailing oil prices. Second, the BoC will stay hawkish, having hiked interest rates by 50 bps last month, and telegraphing more tightening going forward. Economic data out of Canada suggests tighter monetary policy is warranted. Both headline and core inflation remain strong, with headline inflation at 6.8% in April. The common, trim, and median inflation prints were at 3.2%, 5.1%, and 4.4%, respectively, well above the BoC’s target. This continues to suggest inflationary pressures in Canada are broad based (panel 2). House prices are rolling over so the wealth effect could temper hawkishness from the BoC. However, recent speeches from policy officials have highlighted a need to tame housing price pressures in Canada (panel 4). We remain buyers of the CAD on a lower dollar but are monitoring risks from a tightening in financial conditions. New Zealand Dollar: Will Weaken At The Crosses Chart 9The RBNZ Is Trying To Engineer A Soft Landing
The RBNZ Is Trying To Engineer A Soft Landing
The RBNZ Is Trying To Engineer A Soft Landing
The NZD is down 6.6% this year. Over the last month, the kiwi is down 1.0%. The RBNZ hiked interest rates by 50 bps in May, taking the overnight rate to 2%. This seems to be having the intended effect, with house price inflation rolling over as mortgage rates adjust higher. This “least regrets” approach is likely to continue in the short term. The labor market is extremely tight, with a shortage of high skilled labor given immigration has slowed. This is leading to substantial wage increases. As such, the RBNZ has been increasing guidance for annual CPI inflation, and therefore, interest rates, raising its overnight projection for June 2023 to 3.9% from 2.8%. There is reason to believe the RBNZ will tone down its hawkish rhetoric. For one, terms of trade are softening. Dairy prices, circa 20% of exports, are down 1% this month after reaching a 10-year high in May. A domestic slowdown is also likely to nudge the RBNZ toward more accommodation. In a nutshell, the kiwi has upside versus the dollar, but will underperform at the crosses. Australian Dollar: Our Top Pick Against The Dollar Chart 10The RBA Will Continue To Hike
The RBA Will Continue To Hike
The RBA Will Continue To Hike
The Australian dollar is down 2.3% year to date. Over the last month, the AUD is up 2%. The Reserve Bank of Australia raised interest rates by 50 bps this week, a surprise to markets, but in line with the hawkish tone telegraphed in prior meetings. Inflation in Australia is surprising to the upside. Meanwhile, unemployment remains well below NAIRU. As a result, an exit from emergency monetary settings makes sense. The key will be whether the RBA can engineer a soft landing in the Aussie economy. Job gains remain robust, and both the unemployment rate and the participation rate are at healthy levels. Terms of trade are holding up, and wage gains are improving. Home prices are rolling over, but it is a welcome development as the RBA is trying to calibrate financial conditions. We are long the AUD as of 72 cents. The big concern for this trade is China, and the potential for renewed lockdowns that will hurt the external balance. As such, we expect this trade to be volatile near-term, but pay off over a longer horizon. Swiss Franc: A Safe Haven Chart 11The SNB Will Stay Constructive On The Franc
The SNB Will Stay Constructive On The Franc
The SNB Will Stay Constructive On The Franc
The Swiss franc is down 7% year-to-date, but up versus the dollar over the last month. Swiss economic conditions have been rather resilient. GDP expanded by 0.5% in Q1, slightly above expectations, while industrial production also rose 2.4% in the same period. In April, Switzerland’s trade surplus widened to CHF 3.8bn, boosted by demand for machinery and chemicals. In May, the KOF leading indicator clocked 96.8 and the manufacturing PMI stood at 60, a slowdown month-on-month but still a very healthy reading. Inflation is surprising to the upside in Switzerland. Headline and core CPI growth came in at 2.9% and 1.7% year-on-year in May, respectively. Recently, several SNB board members have voiced the primacy of price stability and preparedness to hike rates if inflation becomes broad based. This has helped support the franc. The market now expects SNB to follow the ECB in removing the NIRP starting in September. But it is always good to remember that the Swiss franc is a defensive currency, so a path to policy normalization still presents upside for EUR/CHF. In our trading book, we are short CHF/SEK, but will take profits if Thomas Jordan proves to be more of an inflationary hawk. Norwegian Krone: Bullish On A 12-to-18 Month Horizon Chart 12The Norges Bank Will Stay Hawkish
Month In Review: Recession Risk
Month In Review: Recession Risk
NOK is down 8.1% year to date and up 1.5% over the last month. In the three months through March, Norway’s GDP contracted by 1% quarter on quarter, led by drops in private consumption (1.5%), government spending (1.4%), and exports (3.5%). The decline largely reflects restriction measures imposed at the start of the year. That said, economic growth is rebounding and GDP growth will be around 3% in the next 12 months. Meanwhile, the trade surplus remains very healthy at 92.6bn NOK. As a result, the current account surplus hit at an all-time high of 341bn NOK in Q1. From a broader perspective, incoming numbers in Norway reflect a slowdown in global growth. Consumer confidence dropped to the lowest levels since 2016. The manufacturing PMI fell sharply to 54.9 in May, the lowest reading in over a year. Industrial production also decreased by 0.5% month-on-month in April. That said, the labor market continues to tighten. The unemployment rate fell to 1.7% in May, significantly below Norge Bank’s 2% projection. Renewed immigration might help alleviate some of the labor market tightness, but the strength in employment trends is very evident. As a result, our bias is that the committee will stick to its quarterly 25bps hikes, but upside surprises to this baseline are non-trivial. Terms of trade are a tailwind for Norway. In particular, NOK/SEK can be an attractive bet on a 12-month horizon, should oil prices remain firm. Swedish Krona: Into A Capitulation Phase Chart 13More Hawkish Surprises From The Riksbank
More Hawkish Surprises From The Riksbank
More Hawkish Surprises From The Riksbank
The SEK is down 8.7% year to date and up 1.6% over the last month. Sweden sits right at the crosshairs of the Russia-Ukraine conflict. As a result, inflation remains a problem with CPIF at 6.4%, year-over-year in April, above updated projections from Riksbank. The issue is that there are rising risks that inflation will not be transitory, raising the prospect of a policy surprise from the Riksbank. The OIS curve is now pricing in a 1.75% policy rate by year-end. In our view, this will be a baseline scenario. The critical point is whether the Riksbank is on the verge of making a policy mistake. Economic growth is slowing. Swedish GDP contracted by 0.8% in Q1 from the previous quarter. However, if policymakers are overly fixated on inflation, the prospect of grinding the Swedish economy to a halt becomes a rising risk. Major rounds of collective wage negotiations early next year, affecting as much of as 40% of total labor force, is a risk to monitor. There is already some evidence of a slowdown in economic activity. Consumers reported the lowest level of confidence since the Global Financial Crisis. PMIs remain resilient, well above 50 but the risk is to the downside. Should the Chinese credit impulse bottom and supply constraints ease, economic activity will pick up in the second half of the year, but the risk of downside surprises are worth monitoring. The bottom line is that SEK has already priced in much of the negative news and remains undervalued in our models. We are short CHF/SEK on these grounds, a position 1.5% in the money. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
Listen to a short summary of this report. Executive Summary The Dollar Likes Volatility
The Dollar Likes Volatility
The Dollar Likes Volatility
Uncertainty about Fed policy has supercharged volatility in bond markets, and correspondingly, USD demand (Feature chart). A well-telegraphed path of interest rates will deflate the volatility “bubble” in Treasury markets and erode the USD safety premium. The dollar has also already priced in a very aggressive path for US interest rates. The onus is on the Fed to deliver on these expectations. Our theme of playing central bank convergence – by fading excessive hawkishness or dovishness by any one central bank – continues to play out. Our latest candidate: short EUR/JPY. The Russia-Ukraine conflict, and ensuing volatility in oil markets, is providing some trading opportunities. One of those is that “good” oil will continue to trade at a premium to “bad” oil. Go long a basket of CAD and NOK versus the RUB. TRADES* INITIATION DATE INCEPTION LEVEL TARGET RATE STOP LOSS PERCENT RETURNS SPOT CARRY** TOTAL Short DXY 2022-05-12 104.8 95 107 Short EUR/JPY 2022-05-12 133.278 120 137 Bottom Line: We recommended shorting the DXY index on April 8th at 102, with a tight stop at 104. That stop-loss was triggered this week. We are reinitiating this trade this week at 104.8, in line with our cyclical view that the dollar faces downside on a 12–18 month horizon. Multiple factors tend to drive the dollar: Real interest rate differentials, growth divergences, portfolio flows into both public and private capital markets, or even safe-haven demand. Across both developed and emerging market currency pairs, the dollar has been strong (Chart 1), but what has been the key driver of these inflows? For most of this year, interest rate differentials have played a key role in pushing the dollar higher. That said, they have not been the complete story. Chart 2 shows that the dollar has very much overshot market expectations of Fed interest rate policy, relative to other central banks. That premium has been around 8%-10% in the DXY index. In real terms, the overshoot has been even higher. Chart 1The Dollar Has Been King
Month In-Review: A Hefty Safe-Haven Premium In The Dollar
Month In-Review: A Hefty Safe-Haven Premium In The Dollar
Chart 2The Fed And The Dollar
The Fed And The Dollar
The Fed And The Dollar
Chart 3The Dollar Likes Volatility
The Dollar Likes Volatility
The Dollar Likes Volatility
A key source of this safe-haven premium has been rising volatility, specifically in the bond market. For most of the last two years, the dollar has tracked the MOVE index, a volatility measure of US Treasurys (Chart 3). Uncertainty about the path of US interest rates, and the corresponding rise in dollar hedging costs, have ushered in a wave of “naked” foreign buyers – owning USTs without a corresponding dollar hedge. Foreign purchases of US Treasurys are surging. Speculators have also expressed bearish bets on the euro, yen, and even sterling via the dollar. There is a case to be made that some of these bullish dollar bets will be unwound in the next few months, even if marginally. For example, the market expects rates to be 248 bps and 313 bps higher in the US by year end, respectively, compared to the euro area and Japan (Chart 4). This might be exaggerated. The real GDP growth and inflation differential between the eurozone and the US is 0.1% and 0.8%, respectively, for 2022. The difference in the neutral rate could be as low as 1.25%. This suggests that a simplified Taylor-rule framework will prescribe a policy rate differential of only 1.7% (1.25 + 0.5(0.8+0.1)). In a global growth slowdown, US inflation will come in much lower, which will allow the Fed to ratchet back interest rate expectations. Should growth accelerate, however, then growth differentials between open economies and the US will widen, narrowing the policy divergence we have been experiencing. The safe-haven premium in the dollar has also been visible in the equity market. One striking feature of the correction has been the inability for US equities to outperform, as they usually do, during a market riot point. The carnage in technology stocks has been absolute, and the tech-heavy US equity market continues to struggle against its global peers. As such, there has been a break in the historically strong relationship between the dollar and the outperformance of the US equity market (Chart 5). Chart 4Pricing In The Euro And Yen In Line With Rates
Pricing In The Euro And Yen In Line With Rates
Pricing In The Euro And Yen In Line With Rates
Chart 5The Dollar Has Overshot The Relative Performance Of US Equities
The Dollar Has Overshot The Relative Performance Of US Equities
The Dollar Has Overshot The Relative Performance Of US Equities
As US equity markets were surging throughout 2021, investors started accumulating dollars as a hedge against equity market capitulation, which explained the tight correlation between the put/call ratio and the USD (Chart 6). As the carry on the dollar has risen, and puts have become more expensive, our suspicion is that the greenback has become a preferred hedge. Chart 6Dollar Hedges Against A Drawdown In The S&P
Dollar Hedges Against A Drawdown In The S&P
Dollar Hedges Against A Drawdown In The S&P
As we have highlighted in past reports, the dollar continues to face a tug of war. Higher interest rates undermine the US equity market leadership, while lower rates will reverse the record high speculative positioning in the dollar. Given recent market action, the path of US bond yields will be critical for the dollar outlook. Cresting inflation could pressure bond yields lower. As a strategy, we recommended shorting the DXY index on April 8th at 102, with a tight stop 104. That stop-loss was triggered this week. We are reinitiating this trade at 104.8, in line with our cyclical view that the dollar faces downside on a 12–18-month horizon. As usual, this week’s Month In Review report goes over our take on the latest G10 data releases and the implications for currency strategy both in the near term and longer term. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com US Dollar: Inflation Will Be Key Chart 7How Sustainable Is The Breakout?
How Sustainable Is The Breakout
How Sustainable Is The Breakout
The dollar DXY index is up 9% year-to-date, hitting multi-year highs (panel 1). The Fed increased interest rates by 50bps this month. In our view, the Fed will continue to calibrate monetary policy based on data, and the key releases continue to surprise to the upside. Headline CPI came in at 8.3% in April, while the core measure was at 6.2%. Both were higher than expected. Importantly, the month-on-month rate for core was 0.6%, much higher than a run rate of 0.2% that will be consistent with the Fed’s target of inflation (panel 2). It is important to note that used car prices have had an important contribution to US CPI. Airfares had an abnormally large contribution to US CPI for the month of April. As these prices crest, along with other supply-driven costs, inflation could meaningfully roll over in the coming months (panel 3). The job’s report was robust, but there was disappointment in the participation rate that fell from 62.4% to 62.2%. This suggests there might be more labor slack in the US than a 3.6% unemployment rate suggests. Wages continue to inflect higher. The Atlanta Fed Wage Growth Tracker currently sits at 6% (panel 4). These developments continue to underpin market expectations for aggressive interest rate increases. The market now expects the Fed to raise rates to 2.5% by December 2022. Speculators are also very long the dollar. Three factors could unhinge market expectations. First, inflation could come crashing back down to earth which will unwind some of the rate hikes priced in the very near term. That would hurt the dollar. Second, growth could pick up outside the US, especially in economies with lots of pent-up demand like Japan. Third, financial conditions could ease, which will help revive animal spirits. In conclusion, our 3-month view on the dollar remains neutral, but our 12-18-month assessment is to sell the dollar. We are reinitiating our short DXY position today with a stop-loss at 106. Euro: A Recession Is Priced Chart 8Go Short EUR/JPY
Go Short EUR/JPY
Go Short EUR/JPY
The euro has broken below 1.05 and the whisper circulating in markets is that parity is within striking distance. EUR/USD is down 8.7% year-to-date. We have avoided trading the euro against the dollar and have mostly focused on the crosses – long EUR/GBP, and this week, we are selling EUR/JPY. The euro is in a perfect tug of war: Rising inflation is threatening the credibility of the ECB while there is the risk of slowing growth tipping the euro area into a recession. In our view, the euro has already priced in the latter, much more than potentially higher rates in the eurozone. The ZEW sentiment index, a gauge of European growth prospects, is at COVID-19 lows, along with EUR/USD (panel 1). My colleague, Mathieu Savary, constructed a stagflation index for Europe which perfectly encapsulates the ECB’s quandary. A growing cohort of ECB members are supporting a July rate hike. On the surface, the ECB has the lowest rate in the G10 (outside of Switzerland). With HICP inflation at 7.5% (panel 2), emergency monetary settings are no longer required. A “least regrets” approach suggests gently nudging rates higher to address inflationary pressures. House prices in Germany and Italy are rising at their fastest pace in over a decade, much more than wage inflation (panel 3). The key for the ECB will be to telegraph that policy remains extremely accommodative. It is hard to envision that hiking rates from -0.5% to -0.25% will trigger a European recession, but the ECB will need to balance that outcome with the possibility that inflation crests and real rates rise in Europe. In our trading books, we are long EUR/GBP as a play on policy convergence between the ECB and the BoE. This week, we are playing the same theme via shorting EUR/JPY. In a risk-off environment, EUR/JPY should fall. In an economic boom, the cross has already priced in a stronger euro, relative to the yen (panel 4). We are neutral on the euro over a 3-month horizon but are buyers over 12-18 months. Japanese Yen: A Mean-Reversion Play Chart 9A Capitulation In The Yen?
A Capitulation In The Yen?
A Capitulation In The Yen?
The Japanese yen is down 10.5% year-to-date, one of the worst performing G10 currency this year. In retrospect, a chart formation since 1990 suggests that we witnessed a classic liquidation phase that could only be arrested by an exhaustion in selling pressure, or a shift in fundamentals (panel 1). The two key drivers of yen weakness are the rise in US yields (panel 2) and the higher cost of energy imports. As today’s price move suggests, any reversal in these key variables will lead to a selloff in USD/JPY – falling bond yields and/or lower energy prices. We have been timidly long the yen, via a short CHF position. Today we are introducing a short EUR/JPY trade as well. What has been remarkable in the last month is the improvement in Japanese economic fundamentals, as the country slowly emergences from the latest COVID-19 wave: Both the outlook and current situation components of the Eco Watchers Survey improved in April. This is a survey of small and medium-sized businesses, very sensitive to domestic conditions. PMIs in Japan are improving on both the manufacturing and service fronts. The Tokyo CPI surprised to the upside, with the headline figure at 2.5%. Historically, the earlier release of the Tokyo CPI has been a reliable gauge for nationwide inflation. Importantly, the release was much below BoJ forecasts. Inflation in Japan could surprise to the upside (panel 3). Employment numbers remain robust. The unemployment rate fell to 2.6% in March, and the jobs-to-applicants ratio rose to 1.22. The Bank of Japan has stayed dovish, reinforcing yield curve control in its April 27 meeting, with strong forward guidance. That said, the BoJ will have no choice but to pivot if inflationary pressures prove stronger than they anticipate, and/or the output gap in Japan closes much faster as demand recovers. Related Report Foreign Exchange StrategyWhat To Do About The Yen? We were stopped out of our short USD/JPY position at 128. In retrospect, USD/JPY rallied above 131 and is finally falling back down to earth. We are already in the money on our short CHF/JPY position, from our last in-depth report on the yen. This week, we recommend shorting EUR/JPY. British Pound: A Volte-Face By The BoE Chart 10The Pound Is Being Traded As High Beta
The Pound Is Being Traded As High Beta
The Pound Is Being Traded As High Beta
The pound is down 9.8% year-to-date. While the Bank of England raised rates to 1% this month, they also expect the economy to temporarily dip into recession this year. This week’s disappointing GDP release confirmed the BoE’s fears. In short, pricing in the SONIA curve for BoE rate hikes remains aggressive. The Bank of England has been one of the more proactive central banks, yet the currency has been performing akin to an inflation crisis in emerging markets (panel 1). Inflation continues to soar in the UK with headline CPI now at 6.2% (panel 2). According to the BoE’s projections, inflation will rise to around 10% this year before peaking, well above previous forecasts of 8%. Together with tighter fiscal policy, the combination will be a hit to consumer sentiment. While the BOE must contain inflationary pressures (in accordance with their mandate), the risks of a policy mistake have risen, akin to the eurozone. Labor market conditions appear tight on the surface (panel 3), but our prognosis is that the UK needs less labor regulation, especially towards areas in the economy where labor shortages are acute and are pressuring wages higher. That is unlikely to change in the near term. As such, the current stance of tight monetary and fiscal policy will stomp out any budding economic green shoots. We are currently short sterling, via a long EUR position. In our view, the EUR/GBP cross still heavily underprices the risks to the UK economy in the near term. Given that the pound is very sensitive to global financial conditions (panel 1), it could rebound if recession fears ease, but our suspicion is that it will still underperform the euro. Canadian Dollar: The BoC Will Stay Hawkish Chart 11The CAD Will Stay Resilient
The CAD Will Stay Resilient
The CAD Will Stay Resilient
The CAD is down 3% year-to-date. The key driver of the CAD remains the outlook for monetary policy and the path of energy prices (panel 1). In the near term, oil prices will stay volatile, but the CAD has not priced in the fact that the BoC is matching the Fed during this interest rate cycle, and/or the rise in energy prices. Together with the NOK, we are going long the CAD versus the RUB today. As we expected, the Bank of Canada raised interest rates by 50bps to 1% at the April 13 meeting. Since then, all the measures the BoC looks at to calibrate monetary policy are continuing to suggest more tightening in monetary policy. Both headline and core inflation came in strong, with headline inflation at 6.7% in March. The common, trim, and median inflation prints were at 2.8%, 4.7%, and 3.8%, respectively, well above the BoC’s target. This continues to suggest inflationary pressures in Canada are broad- based (panel 2). The employment report in April disappointed market consensus, but employment in Canada is back above pre-pandemic levels, and the unemployment rate fell to 5.2%, close to estimates of NAIRU. This suggests the BoC’s path for monetary policy will not be altered (panel 3). House price inflation seems to be moderating across many cities, which argues that monetary policy is having the intended effect, but price increases remain well above nominal income growth (panel 4). Speculators are slightly long the CAD, a risky stance over the next three months. That said, we are buyers of CAD over a 12-to-18-month horizon. New Zealand Dollar: Positive Catalysts, But Fairly Valued Chart 12Real NZ Rates Need To Stabilize
Real NZ Rates Need To Stabilize
Real NZ Rates Need To Stabilize
The NZD is down 8.7% year-to-date. The RBNZ remains the most hawkish central bank in the G10. They further raised interest rates to 1.5% on April 13. Given a strict mandate on inflation, together with house price considerations, long bond yields have accepted that the RBNZ will be steadfast in tightening policy and hit 3.8% this month. This will help stabilize real yields are rising (panel 1). Underlying data suggests that the “least regrets” approach by the RBNZ makes sense – in a nutshell, tighten policy as fast as economically possible, to get ahead of the inflation curve. CPI continues to accelerate, hitting 6.9% year-on-year in Q1, from 5.9% the previous quarter (panel 2). House price inflation is rolling over from very elevated levels (panel 3). This suggests that monetary policy is having the intended effect of dampening demand. A weak NZD could sustain imported inflation, but a hawkish central bank cushions this risk. The RBNZ is forecasting a 2.8% overnight rate for June 2023. The OIS curve suggests that market expectations are much higher. This fits with our view that the market had been overpricing higher interest rates in New Zealand, especially relative to other countries. We already took profits on our long AUD/NZD trade and continue to expect the NZD to underperform at the crosses, even if it rises versus the dollar. Australian Dollar: Our Top Pick Against The Dollar Chart 13The AUD Has A Terms Of Trade Tailwind
The AUD Has A Terms Of Trade Tailwind
The AUD Has A Terms Of Trade Tailwind
The Australian dollar is down 5.5% year-to-date. The Reserve Bank of Australia raised interest rates by 15bps on its May 3rd meeting, in line with the hawkish tone telegraphed at the prior meeting. The two critical measures that the RBA is focusing on, inflation and wages, have been improving. That said, we had expected the RBA to wait for fresh wage data, out next week, before calibrating monetary policy. The key point is that emergency monetary settings are no longer required in Australia. Home prices remain robust, the unemployment rate has fallen to a cycle low of 4% in and inflationary pressures remain persistent. Headline CPI was at 5.1% year-on-year in Q1. The trimmed-mean and weighted- median CPI print came in at 3.7% and 3.2%, respectively, above the upper bound of the RBA’s 2%-3% target range. The external environment is one area of concern for the AUD. The trade balance continues to soar, but China’s zero COVID-19 policy is a risk to Australian exports. On the flip side, many speculators are now short the Aussie, which is bullish from a contrarian perspective. We are long the AUD as of 72 cents, expecting this trade to be volatile in the near term, but to pay off over a longer horizon. Swiss Franc: The Yen Is A Better Hedge Chart 14Swiss Inflation Will Fall
Swiss Inflation Will Fall
Swiss Inflation Will Fall
Year-to-date, CHF is down 9% against USD and flat against the EUR. The Swiss economy continues to perform well and remains relatively insulated from the inflation dynamics taking place in the rest of the G10. In April, headline CPI inched higher to 2.5% and core CPI to 1.5% year-over-year (panel 2), while the unemployment rate was down to 2.3%. The KOF indicator was also above expectations at 101.7. At 62.5, the manufacturing PMI is still well in the expansionary zone. In other data, retail sales were up 0.8% month-on-month in March and the trade surplus was down to CHF 1.8bn, likely due to the elevated exchange rate versus the euro. Since then, the franc has given up all its gains against the euro. Several SNB board members have recently spoken about the beneficial role of a strong franc in helping to control inflation (panel 4). That said, it is unclear whether the SNB, known for rampant currency interventions, will be as welcoming to a highly valued franc should inflation roll over. Switzerland’s trade surplus as a share of GDP has been persistently increasing since the early 2000s. An expensive currency would not be positive for economic growth. In fact, SNB sight deposits, have been on the rise recently. Last week, these deposits posted the largest one-week increase in two years. In a world where inflation starts to roll over, the SNB will be more dovish. In this environment, EUR/CHF can see more upside. Norwegian Krone: Bullish On A 12-to-18 Month Horizon Chart 15NOK Has Upside
Month In-Review: A Hefty Safe-Haven Premium In The Dollar
Month In-Review: A Hefty Safe-Haven Premium In The Dollar
The NOK is down 10.7% against the USD this year. This is a remarkable development amidst higher real rates in Norway (panel 1). The Norges Bank is one of the most predictable central banks. It is set to deliver quarterly 25bps hikes through the end of 2023 to a total of 2.5%. In April, headline CPI rose 5.4% and the measure excluding energy was up 2.6% (panel 2). Although slightly above the latest projections, these figures are unlikely to make the bank deviate from its projected rate path. Economic activity is recovering steadily since the removal of pandemic-related restrictions in February. Household consumption and retail sales grew 4.3% and 3.3% month-over-month, respectively, in March. The manufacturing PMI broke above the 60 level in April, while industrial production was up 2.2% on the month in March. Registered unemployment fell under 2% in April, below pre-pandemic levels. This is helping boost wages (panel 3). Norway’s trade balance continued to break all-time highs with a NOK 138bn surplus in March. Elevated energy prices and the transition away from Russian energy should be a significant tailwind for the Norwegian economy. Oil companies planned to increase investment even before the invasion, and recent developments will likely induce more capex. NOK has significantly underperformed in the last month largely due to broad risk-off sentiment. Once markets stabilize, the krone should strengthen over the next 12–18 months. Given the relatively “safer” nature of Norwegian oil, we are initiating a long NOK/RUB trade today, along with a long CAD leg. Swedish Krona: Into A Capitulation Phase Chart 16SEK Has Upside
SEK Has Upside
SEK Has Upside
The SEK is down 10.8% versus the dollar this year. In a major policy U-turn, the Riksbank raised rates by 25bps during its last meeting, after inflation came in above expectations at 6.1% on the year in March. The Bank also announced a faster pace of balance-sheet reduction, as well as expecting two-to-three more hikes before the end of the year. Just like the euro area, Sweden is within firing range of tensions between Russia and Ukraine (panel 1). Swedish GDP contracted 0.4% from the previous quarter. Global uncertainty and rising prices are weighing on consumer confidence, reflected in subdued retail sales and household consumption in March. The manufacturing PMI remains robust at 55 but is falling quite rapidly, as are real rates (panel 2). As a small open economy, Sweden needs external demand to recover. On a positive note, orders remain very strong and an easing of lockdowns in China should contribute to growth in manufacturing and goods exports later this year. It is also encouraging that Sweden’s trade surplus rose to 4.7bn SEK in March. The krona remains vulnerable to both a growth contraction in Europe as well as geopolitical risk, especially as Finland might join NATO, sparring retaliation from Russia. That said, the negative news is likely already priced in. SEK should benefit from growth normalization and a pick-up in the Chinese credit impulse in the second half of the year. As a way to benefit from this dynamic, we are short CHF/SEK, but short USD/SEK positions will be warranted later this year. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Artem Sakhbiev Research Associate artem.sakhbiev@bcaresearch.com Footnotes Strategic View Cyclical Holdings (6-18 months) Tactical Holdings (0-6 months) Limit Orders Forecast Summary
Executive Summary A True Bond Bear Market, USD-Hedged Or Unhedged
A True Bond Bear Market, USD-Hedged Or Unhedged
A True Bond Bear Market, USD-Hedged Or Unhedged
The US dollar has appreciated in 2022, most notably against the euro and Japanese yen. The rally has been more muted against the currencies of major US trading partners like the Canadian dollar and Chinese yuan. The dollar strength to date has had minimal impact on US inflation and will not force any adjustment in the Fed’s hawkish path on interest rates. The weakness of the euro and yen versus the USD will not turn the ECB or Bank of Japan more hawkish, given the lack of visible pass-through from currency depreciation to domestic inflation in Europe and Japan. The two largest owners of US Treasuries, China and Japan, have not increased Treasury purchases in response to higher US yields and a firmer US dollar. Geopolitical tensions and a desire to diversify out of US assets will continue to limit China buying of US Treasuries. Even higher US yields will be needed to compensate Japanese investors for higher bond and currency volatility at a time when the cost to hedge USD exposure is high and rising. Bottom Line: An appreciating US dollar is not yet a reason to expect a peak in US inflation or Treasury yields, or a change in ECB/BoJ policy. Maintain a neutral global duration stance and continue to underweight US Treasuries versus German Bunds and JGBs. Feature The strengthening US dollar (USD) has gotten the attention of investors, with the DXY index up +8.1% since the start of 2022 and threatening a major breakout from the range that has prevailed since 2016 (Chart 1). There have been notable moves in the major currencies that are in the DXY index, especially the euro (EUR) and Japanese yen (JPY). EUR/USD now sits at 1.05 and is threatening a move towards the parity level last seen in 2002. USD/JPY has seen a stunningly rapid increase to the current 130 level, rising 15 big figures in just two months. On a broader basis, the USD rally has been less impressive. The Federal Reserve’s nominal broad trade-weighted dollar index is up a more modest +3.7% year-to-date (Chart 2). Currencies of the major US trading partners have seen less impressive moves versus the dollar compared to the euro and yen. The Canadian dollar is down -1.9%, while the Mexican peso is flat, versus the dollar so far in 2022. Even the tightly managed Chinese currency (CNY) has belatedly joined the depreciation party, with USD/CNY up +4% since mid-April. Chart 1USD Breaking Out Against The Majors
USD Breaking Out Against The Majors
USD Breaking Out Against The Majors
Chart 2Smaller FX Moves From The Larger US Trade Partners
Smaller FX Moves From The Larger US Trade Partners
Smaller FX Moves From The Larger US Trade Partners
For bond markets, the move towards a stronger US dollar is relevant if a) it is sustainable; b) it helps cool off the overheating US economy; and c) it induces capital flows into US Treasuries. On all three counts, the current bout of dollar strength has not been enough to reverse the upward trajectory of US Treasury yields, in absolute terms and relative to government bonds in Europe and Japan. Multiple Drivers Of The USD Rally First and foremost, the latest appreciation of the USD has been about rising US interest rate expectations. The Fed’s increasingly hawkish rhetoric in response to surging inflation has forced a sharp upward adjustment of both the near-term and medium-term path for US bond yields. This has been most evident in the real yield component of yields, with the yield on the 10-year inflation-protected TIPS now in positive territory at +0.15% - a big increase from the -0.5 to -1% range that has prevailed during the past two years of the COVID pandemic. Related Report Global Fixed Income StrategyWe’re All Yield Chasers Now The momentum of the USD rally, with a +13.6% year-over-year gain in the DXY index, has been robust compared to the outright level of US bond yield spreads versus the major developed markets, especially after adjusting for realized inflation differentials (Chart 3). This reflects other USD-bullish factors beyond US interest rate expectations. The US dollar typically behaves as a defensive currency, appreciating during periods of slowing global growth and/or rising investor risk aversion. Both are happening at the same time right now, boosting the safe haven appeal of the US dollar. Global growth expectations are depressed, with the ZEW survey of investment professionals back down to the pandemic lows of 2020 (Chart 4, top panel).1 Worries about slowing growth and high inflation, and the rapid tightening of global monetary policies needed to combat that inflation, are also weighing on investor confidence. US equity market volatility has picked up and investors are paying up to protect their portfolios via options - the VIX index is back above 30 and the CBOE put/call ratio is at a two-year high (middle panel). Chart 3A Big USD Rally Fueled By Wider Real Yield Differentials
A Big USD Rally Fueled By Wider Real Yield Differentials
A Big USD Rally Fueled By Wider Real Yield Differentials
Chart 4Slowing Global Growth & Rising Risk Aversion Weighing On USD
Slowing Global Growth & Rising Risk Aversion Weighing On USD
Slowing Global Growth & Rising Risk Aversion Weighing On USD
This “perfect storm” of USD-bullish factors – rising US interest rate expectations, slowing global growth expectations and increased investor nervousness – has pushed to USD to a level that now appears stretched. BCA Research’s US Dollar Composite Technical Indicator, which combines measures of breadth, momentum, sentiment and trader positioning, is now at an overbought extreme that has heralded past US dollar reversals (bottom panel). Bottom Line: The rising US dollar now discounts a lot of Fed tightening, growth pessimism and investor fear. Conditions for a reversal are in place if any of those USD-bullish factors lose influence, most notably Fed expectations. USD Strength Does Not Impact The Outlook For The Fed, ECB Or BoJ Chart 5A True Bond Bear Market, USD-Hedged Or Unhedged
A True Bond Bear Market, USD-Hedged Or Unhedged
A True Bond Bear Market, USD-Hedged Or Unhedged
USD strength has made life even more difficult of bond investors, at a time when returns across the fixed income universe have suffered because of the duration-related losses from rising bond yields. The Bloomberg Global Treasury index is down -12.2% so far in 2022, and down -18% from the 2020 peak, on a currency-unhedged basis (Chart 5). The returns are not much better this year on a USD-hedged basis, down -6.8% since the start of the year. The latter is suffering from both duration losses and the rising cost to hedge the US dollar. An investor hedging USD exposure into JPY must pay an annualized 165bps (using 3-month currency forwards), while hedging USD exposure into EUR costs 200bps. Those hedging costs primarily reflect higher US interest rate expectations versus Europe and Japan. They will only come down when markets believe that the Fed will stop raising interest rates and begin to easy policy. It is not clear that the current bout of USD strength, on its own, is enough to change the Fed’s plans. Typically, a substantially stronger US dollar would lead the Fed along a less hawkish path, as it would act to slow imported inflation pressures. However, this is not a typical Fed cycle with US headline CPI inflation at a 41-year high of 8.5%. A huge part of that US inflation overshoot is due to global supply squeezes that have impacted the prices of traded goods and commodities. On a rate-of-change basis, the appreciating US dollar is coinciding with some slowing of commodity price momentum, but less so for goods prices. The index of world export prices compiled by the CPB Research Bureau in the Netherlands is up +12.2% on a year-over-year basis, a rapid pace that typically exists during periods of US dollar depreciation (Chart 6, top panel). The annual growth of the CRB commodity index is +17.2%, down from the peak of +54.4% in June 2021, and has roughly tracked the acceleration of the US dollar (middle panel). Yet even with the moderation of commodity inflation, the US dollar strength seen to date has not been enough to slow overshooting global goods price inflation – a necessary condition for central banks like the Fed to turn less hawkish (bottom panel). We do expect global goods price inflation to moderate over the rest of 2022, especially in the US, as post-pandemic consumer spending patterns shift away from goods back towards services. This will be a demand-related story, however, not a USD-strength-related story. Until there is more decisive evidence that goods inflation is slowing meaningfully, the Fed will be forced to deliver on its latest hawkish rhetoric. This includes shifting to a path of hiking rates by 50bps per meeting and moving towards a faster reduction of the Fed’s balance sheet. Right now, there is not much evidence suggesting that the stronger dollar should derail that trajectory (Chart 7): Chart 6USD Strength Not Helping To Slow Global Inflation
USD Strength Not Helping To Slow Global Inflation
USD Strength Not Helping To Slow Global Inflation
Chart 7The Fed Will Remain Hawkish, Despite A Firmer USD
The Fed Will Remain Hawkish, Despite A Firmer USD
The Fed Will Remain Hawkish, Despite A Firmer USD
Non-oil import prices are expanding at a +7.5% pace and accelerating in the face of a firmer US dollar that would normally coincide with slowing import price growth (top panel) The overall level of US financial conditions – which includes not only the currency but other variables like equity prices and corporate bond yields - remains stimulative, both in absolute terms and relative to the level of the trade-weighted US dollar (middle panel). One area of concern is the widening US trade deficit, now nearly -5% of GDP in nominal terms (bottom panel). That wider deficit is primarily related to the combination of strong import demand (and soaring import prices) and soft export demand given slowing global growth. A stronger US dollar does not help reverse either of those trends. However, it is difficult for the Fed to isolate the impact of the currency on the trade deficit given the other non-currency-related factors weighing on US export and import demand (i.e. weaker exports because of the Ukraine war and China COVID lockdowns). In sum, the US dollar strength seen so far does not change our expectations on the path of US inflation, and the pace of Fed tightening, over the next 6-12 months. We still see the Fed delivering multiple rate hikes, but less than the 298bps discounted in the US overnight index swap (OIS) curve over the next year. Conversely, the weakness of the euro and yen versus the US dollar does not change our outlook for the ECB and Bank of Japan. We see both central banks not delivering anything close to the rate hikes discounted in OIS curves. Chart 8Not Much Inflation From A Weaker Euro & Yen
Not Much Inflation From A Weaker Euro & Yen
Not Much Inflation From A Weaker Euro & Yen
On a trade-weighted basis, the euro is only down -5% over the past year - a modest move in comparison to soaring euro area inflation, which hit +7.5% on a headline basis and +3.5% on a core basis in April (Chart 8, middle panel). The ECB is under pressure to end its asset purchases very quickly and begin raising rates, but the euro does not appear to be a reason to accelerate the ECB’s timetable. In Japan, the very rapid weakening of the yen has generated shockingly little inflation, especially in the current environment of strong global goods/commodities inflation. The trade-weighted yen is down -12.7% on a year-over-year basis, yet Japan’s “core-core” CPI index that excludes food and energy prices remains in deflation hitting -0.7% in March – a move exaggerated by plunging mobile phone prices, but still very weak compared to the path of the yen and global goods prices. OIS curves are currently discounting 183bps of ECB rate hikes and 9bps of Bank of Japan rate hikes over the next year. We recommend fading that pricing by staying overweight core Europe and Japan in global bond portfolios, especially versus the US where the Fed is far more likely to follow through on discounted rate hikes. Bottom Line: The dollar strength to date has had minimal impact on US inflation and will not force any adjustment in the Fed’s hawkish path on interest rates. At the same time, the weakness of the euro and yen versus the USD will not turn the ECB or Bank of Japan more hawkish, given the lack of visible pass-through from currency depreciation to domestic inflation in Europe and Japan. Can Foreign Investors Replace Fed Treasury Buying? Chart 9UST Demand Shifting To More Price-Sensitive Buyers
UST Demand Shifting To More Price-Sensitive Buyers
UST Demand Shifting To More Price-Sensitive Buyers
For bond investors, the role of non-US demand for US Treasuries has always been a source of mystery that is often used to explain yield movements. Rumors of flows from major emerging market currency reserve managers or large Asian pension funds has often been used to justify a bullish or bearish view on Treasuries – even when hard data that could prove the existence of such flows is published with long lags that make it useless for timely analysis. The impact of potential foreign bond buying on US Treasury yields has been less influential over the past couple of years. Fed buying via quantitative easing (QE) has swamped all other sources of demand for Treasuries. With the Fed now in a rate hiking cycle that will also lead to a rapid start of quantitative tightening (QT) this summer, the question of who will replace the Fed’s demand for US Treasuries becomes once again relevant for the future path of US bond yields beyond the expected path of the fed funds rate. Already, there has been an adjustment in the term premium for longer-term US Treasury yields – the component of bond yield valuation that would be most impacted by large flows - as the Fed has slowed its pace of bond buying (Chart 9). The New York Fed’s estimates of the term premium on the 10-year Treasury yield reached deeply depressed levels – around -100bps - at the peak of the Fed’s pandemic QE program in 2020. As the US economy has recovered from the 2020 COVID recession, US interest rate expectations have increased but so have estimates of the term premium, which are now back to zero or even slightly positive. The Fed’s QE bond buying has been purely volume driven, with the size and timing of the purchases announced well in advance. The Fed is often called a “price insensitive” buyer since its buying is done without any consideration of yield levels. Other Treasury investors, including foreign buyers, are more price sensitive, with demand influenced by the level of yields. According to the TIC database on US capital flows produced by the US Treasury Department, net foreign buying of Treasuries has picked up, totaling +$346 billion over the 12 months to the most recently available data from February 2022 (Chart 10). That increase has entirely come from private investors, as so-called “official” flows have been flat. Chart 10China Remains On A UST Buyer's Strike
China Remains On A UST Buyer's Strike
China Remains On A UST Buyer's Strike
Chart 11European Buying Of USTs Set To Peak?
European Buying Of USTs Set To Peak?
European Buying Of USTs Set To Peak?
The latter is a continuation of the trend seen over the past few years where China, the nation with the second largest holdings of US Treasuries, has stopped buying them. This is a decision rooted in both geopolitics and economics. Smaller trade surpluses mean China has fewer new currency reserves to invest, while worsening Sino-US tensions have led Chinese authorities to diversify existing reserve holdings away from US Treasuries into gold and other assets. Looking ahead, China is unlikely to significantly ramp up its Treasury purchases despite more attractive US yields and Chinese policymakers tolerating some mild currency weakness versus the US dollar. Beyond China, demand for Treasuries from Europe and Japan has picked up but remains moderate by historical standards. For European investors, there has been a major swing in the TIC data, moving from a net outflow (on a 12-month running total basis) of -$194 billion in December 2020 to a net inflow of +$24 billion in February 2022 (Chart 11, top panel). Typically, net inflows into Treasuries are linked to the FX-hedged spread between US and German government debt. Specifically, when the hedged 10-year Treasury-Bund spread widens to a level between 100-150bps, the flows from Europe into Treasuries begin to improve (middle panel) When that hedged spread narrows to zero or lower, the flows turn the other way and European demand for Treasuries begins to wane. That is typically followed by a widening of the unhedged Treasury-Bund spread (bottom panel). With the current FX-hedged Treasury-Bund spread now at zero, a result of the high cost of hedging US dollars into euros given elevated US rate expectations, we expect European demand for Treasuries to diminish over the rest of 2022. This will help support a wider Treasury-Bund spread as the Fed delivers far more rate hikes than the ECB. For Japan, the largest holder of Treasuries, there has only been a stabilization of outflows over the 12 months to February 2022 (Chart 12, top panel). Past periods of large net inflows from Japan into US Treasuries have occurred when the hedged 10-year US Treasury-JGB spread has approached 200bps (middle panel). With the current spread at only 112bps, Japanese investor demand for Treasuries is unlikely to return without a significant increase in US yields. Chart 12UST Yields Not Attractive Enough To Induce More Japanese Demand
UST Yields Not Attractive Enough To Induce More Japanese Demand
UST Yields Not Attractive Enough To Induce More Japanese Demand
Chart 13Foreign Bond Investing Is Too Volatile For Japanese Investors Right Now
Foreign Bond Investing Is Too Volatile For Japanese Investors Right Now
Foreign Bond Investing Is Too Volatile For Japanese Investors Right Now
More timely weekly capital flow data from Japan shows that Japanese investors have been reluctant to move money into foreign bonds (Chart 13). Elevated levels of bond/rate volatility, and currency volatility given the huge rally in USD/JPY, have made large Japanese bond investors more cautious on increasing foreign bond allocations, even on a currency-hedged basis. If bond/FX volatility subsides, Japanese investors will become “better buyers” of foreign bonds once again. However, Japanese investors may opt to increase allocations to European bonds rather than US Treasuries, with European yields at comparable levels to US Treasuries in JPY-hedged terms (Tables 1-4). For example, a 30-year German Bund hedged into yen now yields 1.46%, compared to a JPY-hedged 30-year US Treasury yield of 1.33%. Table 12-Year Developed Market Government Bond Yields, Hedged Into USD, EUR & JPY
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Table 25-Year Developed Market Government Bond Yields, Hedged Into USD, EUR & JPY
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Table 310-Year Developed Market Government Bond Yields, Hedged Into USD, EUR & JPY
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Table 430-Year Developed Market Government Bond Yields, Hedged Into USD, EUR & JPY
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Bottom Line: Foreign demand for US Treasuries is unlikely to accelerate enough to replace diminished Fed QE purchases over the next 6-12 months, given high USD-hedging costs and elevated Treasury yield volatility. Non-US investors will not help bring an end to the US bond bear market. Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 The Global ZEW expectations series shown in Chart 4 is an equal-weighted average of the individual expectations series for the US and euro area. GFIS Model Bond Portfolio Recommended Positioning Active Duration Contribution: GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. Custom Performance Benchmark
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Global Fixed Income - Strategic Recommendations* Cyclical Recommendations (6-18 Months)
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Recent USD Strength Is Not Bond Bullish
Tactical Overlay Trades