Precious Metals

Highlights Supply constraints and unstoppable demand growth – the result of stricter regulations requiring higher loadings in autocatalysts to treat toxic pollution in automobile-engine emissions – will continue to push palladium’s price higher, despite a near-vertical move higher that began in 2H19. South Africa’s power grid is in a state of near-collapse, which will add volatility to mining operations focused on platinum-group metals – chiefly palladium, platinum and rhodium. South Africa accounts for 36% of global palladium production and 73% of platinum production, which makes it difficult to make the case that platinum could be substituted for palladium as its price rises. Palladium stocks are at risk of being further depleted globally as demand from automobile manufacturers in China, the US and Europe remains robust. This will keep palladium forward curves backwardated for the foreseeable future. While pressure to find alternatives for palladium will grow as prices rise, in absolute terms the additional cost resulting from higher prices for the metal – ~ $400 per vehicle – is not yet enough to draw significant investment to this effort. Feature Palladium markets are fundamentally tight and unresponsive to macroeconomic uncertainty. Table 1Top 5 Best Performing Commodities Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues In 2019, for the third year in a row, palladium prices outperformed other major commodities, returning an impressive 54% over the year (Table 1). This is the result of a massive 13% increase in demand for the metal – powered by strong autocatalyst demand for gasoline-powered cars in China and Europe, even as collapsing auto production globally and elevated trade uncertainty continue to dog automobile sales (Chart 1). This apparent contradiction is explained by stricter vehicle emissions regulations in major consuming markets – chiefly the Euro 6d, China 6 and US Tier 3 regimes – and power shortages in South Africa, which are introducing considerable volatility on the supply side in the second-largest producing country for the metal. Chart of the WeekSurging Autocatalyst Palladium Demand Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues  Again this year, palladium markets are fundamentally tight and unresponsive to macroeconomic uncertainty. Palladium prices soared 39% YTD, its fastest 40-day increase since 2010. Unlike other commodity markets, palladium is completely disregarding the COVID-19 outbreak that originated in China late last year. Favorable supply-side fundamentals continue to drive the palladium rally: The metal’s decade-long physical supply deficit intensified in 2019 and we expect it to widen this year (Chart 2, panel 1). On the demand side, Chinese consumption is at risk. China is the world’s largest auto manufacturing market. Hubei Province – COVID-19’s epicenter – is a large car manufacturing hub, accounting for ~ 10% of the country’s annual automobile output. In the wake of COVID-19, the country’s car production is expected to fall 10% in 1Q20. In addition, the virus had infected more than 80,000 people globally, and has spread rapidly outside Hubei into Asia, Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and North America, raising the odds of a pandemic. Interestingly, speculative positioning and ETF investment demand is subdued, and is not inflating prices (Chart 2, panel 2). Chart 2Palladium Deficit To Widen This Year Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Palladium Demand Soars As Auto Production Collapses Strong global automobile catalyst demand drove the rally in palladium prices last year. This occurred as car production fell by 9%, 8%, and 15% in US, China, and India – an unusual divergence in fundamentals. The culprit: Technical changes to autocatalysts from stricter emissions regulations. In China, the latest phase of car emissions regulations – China 6 – was gradually introduced in high-population centers, which also suffer from high levels of pollution. These centers accounted for ~ 60% of annual Chinese car sales in 2019. China 6 represents a major shift in emissions regulations and will make the Chinese auto fleet compliant with Europe’s best practices. As a result, palladium loadings in conforming light-duty gasoline vehicles reportedly increased by ~20% in 2019. This pushed China’s autocatalyst consumption up by 570k oz despite the drop in annual car sales, which created the rare dislocation between the country’s car production and palladium prices (Chart 3). We expect this trend to continue this year: China 6 is on track to be enforced countrywide – i.e., the remaining 40% of car sales – by mid-year, providing an additional ~ 10% boost in loadings of the metal. Chart 3Stricter Regulations Support Prices Amid Falling Car Production Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues In Europe, the introduction of Euro 6c legislation in September 2018 and the extension to all new vehicles of Euro 6d-TEMP regulations in September 2019 – mainly the real driving emissions (RDE) testing procedure adopted in the wake of the Volkswagen “dieselgate” scandal in 2015 – pushed palladium loading in autocatalysts up by ~ 25% from 2017 to 2019.1 The regulations became stricter in January 2020, putting additional stress on manufacturers to comply with the new standards, which will continue to support higher palladium loadings. We expect the COVID-19 outbreak to delay the recovery in global gasoline-powered vehicle production and consumption to 2H20. Lastly, in the US – which remains an important market for autocatalyst palladium demand (Chart 4) – the ongoing implementation of the Tier 3 legislation will continue to gradually increase palladium content in autocatalysts until 2025. For 2020, we do not expect this to significantly boost loadings per vehicle and are factoring in 2% growth. These legislative changes in major automotive markets produced a structural break in our palladium demand model (Chart 5). After adjusting our estimates for greater palladium content in gasoline aftertreatment systems, our model suggests that demand provides strong support to palladium prices, but also suggests other factors – i.e. supply and inventory – are at play. Chart 4North America's Auto Sector Remains A Large Share Of Palladium Demand Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Chart 5Higher Palladium Loadings Largely Explains Last Year's Price Surge Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues In the US and Europe, consumers can absorb higher vehicle sales despite being close to saturated in terms of vehicle ownership. We expect the COVID-19 outbreak to delay the recovery in global gasoline-powered vehicle production and consumption to 2H20. In China, we expect the government will overstimulate its economy to meet its long-term goal of doubling its GDP and per capita income by 2020.2 Automobile ownership and vehicle sales there are low vs. DM economies, suggesting more upside for sales in China (Chart 6). In the US and Europe, consumers can absorb higher vehicle sales despite being close to saturated in terms of vehicle ownership. Car sales move in cycles around long-term demographic trends: The longer the current economic expansion, the further above-trend car sales can rise (Chart 7). Chart 6China: Structural Outlook For Autos Is Bright China Car Consumption Will Rebound In 2H20... Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Chart 7... Likewise For Europe And US Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Bottom Line: The combination of stricter environmental regulations in key gasoline-powered automobile markets and the post-coronavirus rebound in global auto consumption will push the palladium market further in deficit this year as it faces an inelastic supply, critically low inventories and low substitutability over the short-term (more on this below). Palladium Supply In 2020: Weak growth And Low Price-Elasticity Palladium supply is highly constrained. The largest supplies are concentrated in Russia (42%), South Africa (36%) and North America (14%). From 2015 to 2019, supply and capex grew by a very subdued 7% and 15.2% respectively, completely disregarding the 200% rise in prices (Chart 8, panel 1). This illustrates palladium supply’s extremely low price-elasticity.3 Palladium supply growth will remain muted for the foreseeable future, as Eskom begins long-delayed maintenance to refurbish its derelict generation fleet. Primary supplies declined by close to 2% last year on falling shipments from Russia and record electricity load-shedding – i.e. blackouts – in South Africa (Chart 8, panel 2).4 As tight as palladium markets are fundamentally, South Africa’s crippled power grid – long in need of upgrading and repair – has been, and remains, a key driver of short-term platinum-group metals (PGM) prices.5 Following the breakdown of close to 25% of the country’s generating capacity, Eskom – the nation’s utility monopoly responsible for ~ 90% of its electricity generation – has been forced to implement rolling blackouts to balance power supply and demand and prevent permanent damage to the country’s power grid. Palladium supply growth will remain muted for the foreseeable future, as Eskom begins long-delayed maintenance to refurbish its derelict generation fleet. Consequently, Stage 6 load-shedding events likely will become more frequent. These efforts are complicated by massive debt – ~ $30 billion – which has required government bailouts and forced the company to take loans from a Chinese industrial bank. Chart 8Top Palladium Producers' Capex Price-Elasticity Is Low Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues This is playing havoc with PGM supplies. During the unmatched Stage 6 load-shedding in December 2019 – cutting power to 37% of grid users – PGM supplies were reduced by 50%. Stockpiles covered the loss, but persistent blackouts lasting years could push markets into an actual shortage of palladium as inventories would rapidly be depleted. This is a significant risk: Eskom itself warned rolling blackouts will persist for the next 18 months.6 Elevated local currency PGM prices are postponing announced shafts closures, as miners seek to profit from the favorable pricing environment (Chart 9). But insufficient electricity capacity will weigh on mine supply growth over the next few years as companies hold-back on much-needed long-term investments. The final units of Eskom’s Medupi and Kusile projects are expected to be completed over the next two years – adding 4800MW to its installed capacity. This can partially alleviate South Africa’s electricity difficulties, but these units are not enough to support a rebound in economic and mine production growth. South Africa is in profound need of large-scale investments in its power sector. Close to 5000MW of power capacity is scheduled to shut down over the next five years (Chart 10). Chart 9Favorable Domestic Metal Prices For South African Miners Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Chart 10South Africa Needs Additional Power Generation Capacity Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues After years of pressure from mining companies, South Africa’s minister of Mineral Resources and Energy announced it would allow companies to generate unlimited electricity for their own activities. The current political and economic climate is not constructive for meeting this challenge. The World Bank recently slashed South Africa’s 2020 GDP growth forecast to 0.9% from 1.5% previously on the back of electricity and infrastructure constraints impeding domestic growth and weak external demand. Likewise, rating agency Moody's signaled – ahead of its review of South Africa’s Baa3 credit rating in March – it could downgrade the country to speculative grade, citing the detrimental impact of recurring power outages on manufacturing and mining output. After years of pressure from mining companies, South Africa’s minister of Mineral Resources and Energy announced it would allow companies to generate unlimited electricity for their own activities. This will provide much-needed help to the country’s power sector. According to the Minerals Council South Africa, mining companies could bring an additional ~ 1500MW capacity online in the next 9 to 36 months. But doubts remain with regard to the timeline for companies to obtain the necessary licenses and if these can easily be acquired. Johnson Matthey expects supply growth in Russia – the largest producer – will be capped this year as Nornickel’s processing of old mines' copper concentrate – which boosted the company’s palladium supply over the past few years – is finalized. Still, a paltry 1% gain is possible from expected efficiency gains at existing mines, according to Nornickel. The company also announced it will increase production at its Talnakh and South Cluster mines, but this additional supply will only reach markets gradually as processing capacity constraints won’t be resolved until 2023, according to Johnson Matthey. Bottom Line: Growth prospects in the top two palladium-producing countries are weak in 2020. This will not suffice to meet the soaring autocatalyst demand. Higher recycling and inventory releases – both incentivized by higher prices – will be needed to balance the market. Palladium Stockpiles Are Dangerously Low We expect palladium prices will move higher on the expanding deficit, and backwardation in the forward curve will persist to incentivize the release of inventories to market (Chart 11). Yet, global palladium stockpiles have been declining since 2014 and are now at critically low levels, raising the risk of a disrupting shortage of the metal:7 ETF and exchange inventories now stand at a paltry 600k oz (Chart 12). These are the most price-elastic stocks and will get close to zero as prices increase. Chart 10Expect Backwardation To Persist Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Chart 12Price-Sensitive Stockpiles Are Dangerously Low Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Exhaustion of inventory would spike prices until demand destruction or additional supply – both inelastic in the short-run – are able to balance the market. The Russian Ministry of Finance’s reserves – a state secret – are now almost exhausted, according to Russia’s Norilsk Nickel, the largest supplier of physical palladium in the world. Last year, Norilsk Nickel held an estimated 1mm oz of the metal in its Global Palladium Fund, and signaled it is increasingly using its reserves to balance markets and provide needed liquidity. Earlier this year, the company released 3 MT of palladium to the market from stocks. Complete exhaustion of inventory would spike prices until demand destruction or additional supply – both inelastic in the short-run – are able to balance the market. Don’t Count On Substitution, Yet Switching to platinum requires significant capital- and resource-intensive R&D and appears to be beyond the current capabilities of automakers. We expect platinum prices to rise in 2020 supported by improving fundamentals, growing safe-haven demand, and markets pricing in increasing anticipation of substitution from palladium to platinum. Unlike palladium, platinum is also affected by safe-haven demand and gets bid up with gold and silver prices in periods of high uncertainty (Chart 13). With gold prices now above $1,600/oz, platinum will benefit from safe-haven flows due to its relative price advantage (Chart 14). Chart 13Safe-Haven Flows Support Platinum Prices Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Chart 14Platinum Is Cheap Relative To Gold Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues We believe substitution will commence over the coming years, but this is a gradual process. Substitution from expensive palladium to low-priced platinum in industrial applications is the largest risk to our positive view on the palladium-to-platinum (Pd-to-Pt) ratio (Chart 15). This started in smaller and more price-elastic segments (e.g. dental, jewelry and diesel autocatalyst). However, to have a real impact on overall demand and thus the price ratio, substitution needs to take place in gasoline autocatalyst technology. The discount has been at a level consistent with substitution for more than a year, but the urgency to upgrade current designs to meet new environmental legislation and RDE regulations in China, Europe, and the US is the main focus of automakers this year. Switching to platinum requires significant capital- and resource-intensive R&D and appears to be beyond the current capabilities of automakers scrambling to meet the latest anti-pollution regulations globally. Moreover, large-scale substitution will take place only if automakers’ cost-benefit analysis points to significant long-term profits from switching. That said, platinum’s supply security remains a risk in the long-term: South Africa accounts for 73% of global production and our analysis suggests output growth there likely will remain weak over the next few years, especially as Eskom rebuilds its failing power grid. This lack of diversity increases sourcing risks for automakers, who, not without reason, would not want to switch over to platinum only to find that supply is also in doubt down the road. The overall platinum market is 26% smaller than that of palladium. Assuming a one-for-one substitution of Pd to Pt in gasoline catalyzers, a 1.2mm oz reduction in Pd demand – the amount required to reduce palladium’s deficit to zero – would send platinum markets to a 1.4mm oz deficit.8 Without substantial production growth, platinum prices would spike, reducing the profitability of investing in these new catalysts. Thus, substitution will eventually impact the price ratio, but will not be large enough to overturn absolute price level trends. In addition, the amount of PGMs in the typical autocatalyst – ~ 5 grams – adds $400 to the cost of the average automobile (Chart 15, lower panel). We do not believe this cost drives automakers' decisions, which is another reason the substitution of Pt for Pd likely will remain a topic of discussion more than action. Chart 15Palladium's Price Surge Adds ~0 Per Gasoline Car Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Bottom Line: We believe substitution will commence over the coming years, but this is a gradual process and it will not happen on a meaningful scale this year. Thus, we expect the continuation of relative demand and inventory trends will provide a favorable setting for the Pd-to-Pt ratio this year (Chart 16). Chart 16Pd-to-Pt Price Ratio Will Increase Again in 2020 Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues   Hugo Bélanger Associate Editor Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com   Commodities Round-Up Energy: Overweight Brent and WTI crude oil lost 5% and 4% this week, as fears of a global pandemic in the wake of the COVID-19 outbreak gripped markets. Reports of outbreaks in Asia ex-China, the Middle East and Europe fueled these concerns. Against this backdrop, OPEC 2.0 will be meeting in Vienna March 5 and 6 to consider cuts of 600k b/d recommended by its technical committee earlier this month. We continue to expect the full coalition to approve these cuts at the upcoming meetings. Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates reportedly are considering an additional 300k b/d of cuts to offset the global demand hit delivered by COVID-19. The IEA estimates the COVID-19 outbreak will reduce Chinese refining throughput by 1.1mm b/d, and will reduce the call on OPEC crude by 1.7mm b/d in 1Q20. Base Metals: Neutral Iron ore prices weakened, following global equities lower, as the COVID-19 outbreak spread around the world. However, traders continue to report lower stocks of iron ore, which should keep prices supported, according to MB Fastmarkets (Chart 17). We remain long December 2020 high-grade iron ore (65% Fe) vs. short the benchmark 62% Fe contract on the Singapore Commodity Exchange, which we initiated November 7, 2019. This recommendation was up 5.3% as of Tuesday’s close, when we mark to market. Precious Metals: Neutral After retreating slightly from its run toward $1,700/oz earlier this week, gold remains well supported by safe-haven demand (Chart 18).  In addition, actual and expected policy stimulus – e.g., Hong Kong's “helicopter money” drop of USD 1,200 to all permanent residents over the age of 18 – and expectations of additional central bank easing globally to offset the global spread of COVID0-19 will keep gold and precious metals generally supported.  Markets should start pricing in higher inflation expectations as additional stimulus starts to roll in.  Ags/Softs:  Underweight Global grain markets could be set to rally sharply, as unusually wet weather in the Middle East and East Africa spawned by higher-than-usual cyclone activity produces perfect breeding conditions for desert locusts in the region over the next two months.  According to National Geographic, by June the locusts could increase their populations “400-fold compared with today, triggering widespread devastation to crops and pastures in a region that’s already extremely vulnerable to famine.”  This could put more than 13mm people in East Africa at risk of “severe acute food insecurity,” and imperil millions more.  Chart 17China's Iron Ore Stocks Tight Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Chart 18Safe Havens Gold, USD Well Bid Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues   Footnotes 1     Please see New legislation planned in response to dieselgate, published by Autocar June 9, 2016. See also  Johnson Matthey’s February 2020 Pgm Market Report. 2     Our view of strong Chinese fiscal and monetary stimulus was discussed in detail in our February 13, 2020 weekly report titled Iron Ore, Steel Poised For Rally. 3    Historically produced as an inferior byproduct from nickel, gold, and platinum mines, the price incentive from palladium alone isn’t enough to generate the needed investments in new mine production. According to Nornickel, this is slowly changing, palladium is an increasingly large part of mining companies’ revenues, making the metal a valuable co-product. This could improve mines investments’ responsiveness to movement in palladium prices over the medium term. 4    According to Eskom, “Load shedding is aimed at removing load from the power system when there is an imbalance between the electricity available and the demand for electricity. If we did not shed load, then the whole national power system would switch off and no one would have electricity.” The company’s load-shedding program includes 8 stages, where each stage represents the removal of 1000MW of demand – e.g., stage 5 removes 5000MW. This is done by shutting down specific sections of the grid.  5    The PGMs are ruthenium, rhodium, palladium, osmium, iridium, and platinum. 6    Things got worse after the December load-shedding event.  Less than a month later, Reuters noted more than two times the power shed in December went “offline because of plant breakdowns. 7    This can be seen in the close to 12mm oz. decline in UK and Switzerland – home of the largest secured vaults of Palladium and Platinum – net imports. 8    Technological improvement in palladium catalysts has made the metal more efficient in for gasoline-powered engines vs. platinum. It has superior properties in terms of thermal durability and NOx reduction. Thus, the conversion could be greater than 1-to-1 and would imply a smaller share of palladium autocatalyst substitution could be absorbed by existing platinum supplies.   Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades TRADE RECOMMENDATION PERFORMANCE IN 2019 Q4 Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2020 Summary of Closed Trades Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues Epic Palladium Rally Likely Continues

Hunker Down Hunker Down Overweight Global bourses broke down yesterday, succumbing to immense pressure from the coronavirus epidemic gripping South Korea, Italy and Iran. Finally, lower profit growth expectations are weighing on extreme equity market optimism. We remain cautious on the prospects of the broad US equity market and reiterate our January 13 boost to overweight in the global gold mining index versus the MSCI All Country World Index. This portfolio position is already up 16% since the mid-January inception and more gains are in store on the back of the collapse in interest rates and increasing likelihood of fed funds rate cuts. Importantly, in order to gauge the relative attractiveness of this portfolio position at the current juncture, it is instructive to juxtapose global versus US policy uncertainty. Historically, this ratio has been closely correlated with relative share prices and signals that the path of least resistance is higher for gold miners compared with the broad market. Shinning global gold miners are impressive especially given the recent spike in the greenback. As a reminder, the US dollar also flexes its muscles when global uncertainty trumps US uncertainty (bottom panel). Finally, the recent hook up in US economic surprises versus the rest of the world also underpins relative share prices (middle panel). Bottom Line: Stay overweight the global gold mining index via the long GDX:US / short ACWI:US exchange traded funds. From a risk management perspective and in order to protect profits we are setting a trailing stop at the 10% return mark, since inception.  

Highlights Collective market signals suggest a low but non-negligible probability of a dollar spike due to the coronavirus. Stay long the yen as a portfolio hedge. Short CHF/JPY bets also make sense.  Our limit sell on the gold/silver ratio was triggered at 90. Place a stop at 95, with an initial target of 80. Feature Chart I-1Watching Market Signals Watching Market Signals Watching Market Signals Investors can generally be classified in two camps. There are those who are predisposed to being risk averse. As such, capital preservation trumps the desire for outsized returns. For such investors, defensive equities such as staples and utility stocks, fixed-income assets, or even gold tend to be the favored vehicles over time. At the opposite end of the spectrum are the investors who desire hopping on and riding the next growth unicorn. Their favored investment universe can include technology and biotech concerns, but can also span industries such as automotive and food. The key, however, is that their inherent disposition is to multiply returns rather than preserve capital. There is a crucial difference between this bias and a risk-on/risk-off environment. For example, in a risk-on environment, the more prudent investor might choose high-yielding government bonds, while the high flyer will be in the S&P 500 or private equity. In the currency world, the “preservationist” might choose the euro as an anti-dollar play despite negative yields, while the “high flyer” would rather be in the New Zealand dollar or the Norwegian krone. The oscillation between these two bipolar universes can be measured in various ways, but one that has been prescient in gauging the direction for currency markets is the ratio between the S&P 500 index and gold prices. In general, whenever the S&P 500 has been outperforming gold, the dollar has tended to soar, and vice versa (Chart I-1). As a closed economy, US markets are generally more defensive. So even in a risk-off environment, this ratio can capture the preference for capital preservation versus growth. The collective signals from financial markets suggest there is a low probability of a dollar spike. The SPX/Gold ratio hit a peak of 2.5 in the last quarter of 2018 and has since been exhibiting a bearish pattern of lower highs, with the latest rise peaking a nudge below 2.2. Our belief is that it is less a story of greed versus fear, and more an indication of a powerful underlying preference for investors being revealed in asset prices. Gauging FX Market Signals The coronavirus outbreak has been dominating market headlines in recent weeks. We are not infectious disease specialists, so cannot provide any insight on the potential impact on growth and/or the probability for the virus to become much more widespread. However, the collective signals from financial markets suggest there is a low probability of a dollar spike. The rise in the dollar has been relatively on par with the SARS experience of 2002 (Chart I-2A and Chart I-2B). Back then, the Chinese economy had a much smaller effect on global growth, and so far, the number of reported cases is outpacing the SARS experience. So, it is possible that given the dollar bull market of the last decade or so, there is a dearth of new buyers in the greenback. Chart I-2ARun Of The Mill Virus ? (1) Run Of The Mill Virus ? (1) Run Of The Mill Virus ? (1) Chart I-2BRun Of The Mill Virus ? (2) Run Of The Mill Virus ? (2) Run Of The Mill Virus ? (2) The most recent fall in the S&P 500 index versus gold is definitely a sign of risk aversion, but the much broader peak almost two years ago might be signaling an outright shift in the investment universe. In other words, capital preservation might now be best sought outside US bourses. If this is the case, cheap and unloved value stocks will provide better shelter compared to the growth champions of the last decade. It is interesting that emerging market cyclical stocks (where the epicenter of the crisis is) have not underperformed defensives in a meaningful way during the latest riot (Chart I-3). The typical narrative is that the dollar is now a high-yielding currency within the G10. That means it has now become the object of carry trades. Should the investment universe be shifting to one of prudence, it is plausible though not probable that the greenback will provide both functions. Chart I-3Mixed Message From Cyclicals Versus Defensives Mixed Message From Cyclicals Versus Defensives Mixed Message From Cyclicals Versus Defensives Chart I-4Correlation Break Down Or Unsustainable Gap? Correlation Break Down Or Unsustainable Gap? Correlation Break Down Or Unsustainable Gap? The absolute collapse in the gold-to-bond ratio further confirms that after almost a decade of underperformance, hard money might be coming back into favor versus yield plays (Chart I-4). Gold was a monetary aggregate for centuries, and continues to stand as a viable threat to dollar liabilities. This is not only visible in the rampant accumulation of gold by foreign central banks, notably Russia and China, but also by the breakout in gold in almost every currency, including safe-havens like the Swiss franc and the Japanese yen (Chart I-5). The absolute collapse in the gold-to-bond ratio further confirms that after almost a decade of underperformance, hard money might be coming back into favor. Data from the US Treasury confirms that foreign entities have been fleeing US bond markets at among the fastest pace in recent years. On a rolling 12-month total basis, the US saw an exodus of about US$250 billion in Treasurys from foreigners, one of the largest on record (Chart I-6). Foreign private investors are still net buyers of US Treasurys, but the downtrend in purchases in recent years is evident. In addition, this helps explain why gold has also outperformed Treasurys over this period. Chart I-5Soft Versus Hard ##br##Money Soft Versus Hard Money Soft Versus Hard Money Chart I-6Official Data Shows Less Preference For Treasurys Official Data Shows Less Preference For Treasurys Official Data Shows Less Preference For Treasurys The US dollar’s reserve status remains intact for now. But subtle shifts in this exorbitant privilege are worth monitoring. If balance-of-payment dynamics continue to head in the wrong direction, as  they are now, this will favor hard money and non-US assets, while accelerating divestment out of US Treasurys. This is irrespective of whether we enter a risk-on versus risk-off environment. A good proxy for whether the US government was prudent or profligate over the past four decades can be measured by the gap between unemployment relative to NAIRU (the so-called unemployment gap) and the corresponding budget deficit. In simple terms, full employment should be accompanied by balanced budgets, while governments can step in during recessions to put a floor under aggregate demand. Not surprisingly, using this simple rule, sound fiscal policies in the US were usually accompanied by a strong dollar, and vice versa. Chart I-7The Risk To Long Dollar Positions The Risk To Long Dollar Positions The Risk To Long Dollar Positions Over the next five years, the US Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that the US budget deficit will swell to 4.6% of GDP. Assuming the current account deficit remains stable, this will pin the twin deficits at 7.2% of GDP. This assumes no recession, which would have the potential to boost the deficit even further. In the last forty years, there has not been any prolonged period where twin deficits in the US have been expanding while the dollar has been in a bull market (Chart I-7).  In a nutshell, even though the coronavirus is dominating headlines, the lack of a more pronounced greenback strength can be pinpointed to a rising number of negative market signals. Our bias is that when this eventually rolls over and global growth picks up in earnest, dollar bulls may be forced to capitulate. Bottom Line: We are not downplaying the potential impact of the coronavirus, but are skeptical of its ability to catapult the dollar higher. We are short the DXY index, with a target of 90 and a stop at 100. Stick with it. Bullish Both Gold And Silver, But Go Short The GSR If we are right, then both gold and silver will tend to rise in an environment where the dollar is falling. That said, the gold/silver ratio (GSR) hit a three-decade high of 93.3 last summer, opening up an arbitrage opportunity. The history of these reversals is that they tend to be powerful, quick, and extremely volatile (Chart I-8). This not only paves the way for an excellent entry point to short gold versus silver, but provides important information on the battleground between easing financial conditions and a pick-up in economic (or manufacturing) activity. The ratio of the velocity of money between the US and China has tended to track both the gold/silver ratio and the dollar closely.  Just like gold, silver benefits from low interest rates, plentiful liquidity, and the incentive for fiat money debasement. However, the gold/silver ratio is sitting near two standard deviations above its mean. Meanwhile, over the past century, the peak in GSR has been around 100. The gold/silver ratio tends to rally ahead of an economic slowdown, but then peaks when growth is still weak but liquidity conditions are plentiful enough to affect the outlook for future growth. This appears to be the case today. The simple reason is that silver has more industrial uses than gold (Chart I-9). Chart I-8GSR At A Speculative Extreme GSR At A Speculative Extreme GSR At A Speculative Extreme Chart I-9No Recession = Buy Silver No Recession = Buy Silver No Recession = Buy Silver The ratio of the velocity of money between the US and China has tended to track both the gold/silver ratio and the dollar closely (Chart I-10). A falling ratio signifies that the number of times money is changing hands in China is outpacing that number in the US. This also tends to coincide with a preference for US versus non-US assets, since animal spirits (as measured by money velocity) tend to be pronounced in places where returns on capital are higher.  Silver is a more volatile metal than gold. Part of the reason is that the silver market is thinner, with future open interest that is about one-third that of gold. As such, silver tends to rise faster than gold during precious metal bull markets (Chart I-11). Chart I-10Falling GSR = Rising Manufacturing Activity Falling GSR = Rising Manufacturing Activity Falling GSR = Rising Manufacturing Activity Chart I-11Silver Is More Volatile Than Gold Silver Is More Volatile Than Gold Silver Is More Volatile Than Gold This brings us to the sweet spot for silver. Even if global growth remains tepid over the next few months, due to a rise in infections from the coronavirus, a lot of the bad news is already reflected in a high GSR. This means the potential for upside will have to be nothing short of a deep recession. Relative speculative positioning favors gold, which is positive from a contrarian standpoint. Ditto for relative sentiment. More often than not, a positive signal from both these indicators has been a good timing tool for a selloff in the GSR. If global growth bottoms, then the rise in silver prices could be explosive. Silver fabrication demand benefits from new industries such as solar and a flourishing “cloud” industry that are capturing the new manufacturing landscape. Meanwhile, we are also entering a window where any pickup in demand could lead to a sizeable increase in the physical silver deficit. Bottom Line: A falling GSR provides important information about the battleground between easing financial conditions and a pickup in economic activity. We remain bullish on both gold and silver, but a trading opportunity has opened up for a short GSR position. Housekeeping Chart I-12AUD Will Follow Asian Currencies AUD Will Follow Asian Currencies AUD Will Follow Asian Currencies Our limit buy on the Australian dollar was triggered at 68 cents. We discussed the Aussie at length in our report dated  January 17.1 Place an initial target at 0.75 cents and a tight stop at 0.66. The near-term risk to this trade is any escalation in virus infections that will collectively send Asian currencies into a tailspin (Chart I-12).     Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "On AUD And CNY," dated January 17, 2020, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar   Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 USD Technicals 2 USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been positive: The Markit manufacturing PMI fell to 51.7 while the services component increased to 53.2 in January. The Dallas Fed manufacturing index improved from -3.2 to -0.2 in January. Moreover, the Richmond Fed manufacturing index soared to 20 in January. Durable goods orders increased by 2.4% month-on-month in December. The trade deficit widened further to $68.3 billion from $63 billion in December. Annualized GDP growth was unchanged at 2.1% year-on-year in Q4. Initial jobless claims fell to 216K from 223K for the week ended January 24th. The DXY index appreciated by 0.1% this week. While the coronavirus spurred worries about a further slowdown in the global economy, the impact on the US remains to be seen. On Wednesday, the Fed committee voted unanimously to keep interest rates on hold at 1.75% and concluded that the current rate is appropriate to support sustained expansion of the US economy. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 EUR Technicals 2 EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been mostly positive: The Markit manufacturing PMI jumped to 47.8 in January while the services PMI fell slightly to 52.2. The German IFO current assessment index increased to 99.1 from 98.8 in January, while expectations component fell to 92.9. The economic sentiment indicator increased to 102.8 from 101.3 in January. The unemployment rate fell further to 7.4% in December from 7.5% the prior month. The euro has been flat against the US dollar this week. Though the German IFO expectations component disappointed, the overall assessment has shown tentative signs of recovery. More importantly, changes in the manufacturing PMI indices, especially in Germany, are staging the V-shaped recovery we have been expecting. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 On Money Velocity, EUR/USD And Silver - October 11, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 JPY Technicals 2 JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been positive: Consumer confidence was unchanged at 39.1 in January. Services PPI increased by 2.1% year-on-year in December. Headline inflation increased to 0.8% year-on-year from 0.5% in December. Both manufacturing and services PMIs increased to 49.3 and 52.1, respectively in January. The Japanese yen appreciated by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. The flare up in risk aversion was a very potent catalyst, given the yen had become unloved and under owned. Persistent global risks, including Mid East tensions, and more recently, the spread of coronavirus, all warrant holding the Japanese yen as a portfolio hedge. Our last weekly report discussed why we prefer the Japanese yen to the Swiss franc as portfolio insurance. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Signposts For A Reversal In The Dollar Bull Market - November 1, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 GBP Technicals 2 GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the UK have been solid: Both Markit manufacturing and services PMIs soared to 49.8 and 52.9 respectively in January. Nationwide housing prices increased by 1.9% year-on-year in January, compared with 1.4% the previous month. The saucer-shaped bottom in home prices is becoming more and more evident. The British pound has been flat against the US dollar this week. On Thursday, the BoE decided to leave interest rates unchanged at 0.75%. The fact that there were only two dissenters, in line with the previous month, suggests that rising bets for a rate cut were misplaced. The UK is due to leave the EU as of January 31st and enter a transition period that is supposed to last until December 31st 2020. The immediate aftermath of the exit will be business as usual. Trading strategy on the pound should be a buy on dips. We will continue to explore opportunities in GBP in upcoming reports. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 United Kingdom: Cyclical Slowdown Or Structural Malaise? - Sept. 20, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 AUD Technicals 2 AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been mixed: The NAB business conditions index fell to 3 from 4 in December. Moreover, the business confidence index decreased to -2 from 0. Headline inflation increased to 1.8% year-on-year from 1.7% in the fourth quarter. Import prices increased by 0.7% quarter-on-quarter, while export prices plunged by 5.2% quarter-on-quarter in Q4. The Australian dollar fell by 2.1% against the US dollar this week, triggering our limit buy position at AUD/USD 0.68. Despite temporary challenges from the bushfires and the coronavirus, we continue to hold our base case view that global growth is likely to rebound in the next 12-to-18 months, which is bullish for the Aussie dollar. Report Links: On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 NZD Technicals 2 NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been positive: Headline inflation increased to 1.9% year-on-year in Q4, compared with 1.5% the previous quarter. It also beat expectations of 1.8%. The trade balance shifted to a surplus of NZ$547 million in December. Goods exports rose by 4.8% year-on-year to NZ$5.5 billion, while imports fell by 5.4% year-on-year to NZ$5 billion. Shortly after the rise along with inflation data, the New Zealand dollar fell by more than 2% this week, amid growing risk aversion. New Zealand, as a chief exporter of agricultural products, bore a good brunt of speculative selling. Assuming infections peak in the coming weeks, we remain positive on the kiwi as the Chinese government is likely to inject more stimulus into the economy. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 CAD Technicals 2 CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been mostly positive: Retail sales increased by 0.9% month-on-month in November. The Bloomberg Nanos confidence index rose to 56.5 from 56.1 for the week ended January 24th. The Canadian dollar fell by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. As a petrocurrency, the risk of much reduced travel hit the loonie. We have written at length in various reports about the loonie, but the bottom line is that Canada benefits less than other petrocurrencies in oil bull markets. Ergo, the underperformance of short CAD/NOK and long AUD/CAD positions this week is expected. In other news, Trump has signed the new USMCA bill into law this week, leaving Canada the only member of the trilateral deal that has yet to ratify the agreement. Report Links: The Loonie: Upside Versus The Dollar, But Downside At The Crosses Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Making Money With Petrocurrencies - November 8, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 CHF Technicals 2 CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been mixed: The trade surplus narrowed for a fourth consecutive month in December, falling to CHF 2 billion. Real exports decreased by 3.4% month-on-month while real imports grew by 0.2% month-on-month. The ZEW expectations index fell to 8.3 from 12.5 in January. The KOF leading indicator jumped to 100.1 from 96.2 in January. The Swiss franc has been more or less flat against the US dollar this week. The fall in exports of chemical and pharmaceutical production was the main driver behind the decrease in the Swiss trade balance in December. The SNB is walking a fine line. The improvement in the KOF leading indicator, along with rising inflation and PMI data is definitely a source of comfort, but the surge in EUR/CHF will hurt competitiveness and warrant stealth intervention. Buy EUR/CHF at 1.06. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Notes On The SNB - October 4, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 NOK Technicals 2 NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been negative: Retail sales fell by 2% month-on-month in December. The Norwegian krone fell by 1.9% against the US dollar this week. The WTI crude oil price plunged by 20% since the peak earlier this month, due to a combination of falling global travel demand, eased Iran tensions and a bearish EIA inventory report. That being said, our Commodity & Energy strategists continue to be bullish energy prices and expect the WTI crude oil price to reach $63/bbl in 2020, based on recovering global demand and supply constraints. This should eventually lift the Norwegian krone. OPEC is scheduled to meet early March, and plunging prices could be a catalyst for the cartel to cut production. Report Links: On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Making Money With Petrocurrencies - November 8, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 SEK Technicals 2 SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been mixed: Producer prices increased by 1.3% year-on-year in December. The trade surplus shrank to SEK 0.3 billion from SEK 2.7 billion in December. Retail sales grew by 3.4% year-on-year in December. Consumer confidence marginally fell to 92.6 from 94.7 in January, while business confidence jumped to 97.4 in January, the highest in seven months. The Swedish krona fell by 1.3% against the US dollar this week. Recent Swedish data has been disappointing given the steep decline during the trade war, but we are beginning to see second-derivative improvements. The trade surplus is rising on a year-on-year basis. Particularly noteworthy was the improvement in business confidence, which has historically led the Swedbank PMI index tick for tick. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

In Gold We Trust In Gold We Trust Overweight This week we reintroduced a modest portfolio hedge via augmenting exposure to global gold miners to overweight. Global gold miners have a lot going for them. Rising global policy uncertainty plays to their strength as investors seek the refuge of safe haven assets especially when geopolitical risks flare up (top panel). Importantly, real US bond yields have also taken a beating recently underpinning gold prices and gold mining equities. This is significant, as bullion yields nothing and gold miners next to nothing so from an opportunity cost perspective it pays to hold a zero yielding asset when competing yields fall and vice versa (middle panel). Worrisomely, this fall in real US yields is de facto pushing global real yields lower, which might indicate that investors worry that the global economy has more downside. In fact, economists’ estimates for GDP growth (as compiled by Bloomberg, bottom panel) continue to decelerate globally, and they forecast below-trend real output growth in the US for 2020. Bottom Line: Boost global gold miners to an above benchmark allocation via the long GDX/short ACWI exchange traded funds.